Pan Australia Shipping Pty Ltd v The Ship ‘Comandate'

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Pan Australia Shipping Pty Ltd v The Ship ‘Comandate’
[2006] FCA 881

JURISDICTION – stay of action – anti-anti-suit injunction – quia timet relief - application for injunction to restrain defendant obtaining injunction in a foreign court which would prevent plaintiff filing statement of claim in personam pursuant to r 22 of the Admiralty Rules so as to invoke Australian jurisdiction under Trade Practices Act1974 (Cth) – where defendant threatening to take steps in English High Court of Justice to restrain proceedings in the Federal Court of Australia

ADMIRALTY & MARITIME – arrest of vessel – in personam claim

Held – interim injunction granted to restrain defendant from taking any steps in any court seeking to restrain the continuation of the current proceeding, pending filing of a statement of claim in personam pursuant to r 22 of the Admiralty Rules.

Admiralty Act 1988 (Cth)
International Arbitration Act 1974 (Cth) s 7
Trade Practices Act1974 (Cth)
Admiralty Rules r 22

Akai Pty Ltd v Peoples Insurance Co Limited [1998] 1 Lloyd’s Rep 90 discussed
Akai Pty Ltd v Peoples Insurance Co Ltd (1996) 188 CLR 418 discussed
Batistatos v Roads and Traffic Authority of New South Wales [2006] HCA 27 followed
CSR Limited v Cigna Insurance Australia Limited (1997) 189 CLR 345 followed
Hi-Fert Pty Ltd v Kiukiang Maritime Carriers Inc(No 5) (1998) 90 FCR 1 referred to
Queensland v JL Holdings Pty Ltd (1997) 189 CLR 146 referred to
Raymond v Honey [1983] 1 AC 1 applied
Re Wakim; Ex parte McNally (1999) 198 CLR 511 referred to
Walter Rau Neusser Oel und Fett AG v Cross Pacific Trading Limited [2005] FCA 1102 referred to

PAN AUSTRALIA SHIPPING PTY LTD v THE SHIP ‘COMANDATE’
NSD 1130 OF 2006

RARES J
22 JUNE 2006
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 1130 OF 2006

BETWEEN:

PAN AUSTRALIA SHIPPING PTY LTD
PLAINTIFF

AND:

THE SHIP ‘COMANDATE’
DEFENDANT

JUDGE:

RARES J

DATE OF ORDER:

22 JUNE 2006

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Leave be granted to the defendant to file in Court an amended appearance.

2.Leave be granted to file the affidavit of Danella Ann Wimshurst sworn 22 June 2006 in Court.

3.Leave be granted to the defendant to file its Notice of Motion in Court.

4.Paragraph 1 of that Notice of Motion be returnable instanter.

5.The hearing of paragraphs 2-5 of that Notice of Motion be deferred to a date to be determined at a later stage.

6.Subject to Order 2, up to and including 13 July 2006, Comandate Marine Corporation, by itself, its servants and agents, be restrained from taking any step, either directly or indirectly, in the English High Court of Justice or any other court seeking to restrain the continuation of proceedings NSD 1130 of 2006 of this Court, or seeking to restrain the plaintiff in this proceeding from taking any step in this proceeding, including the filing of an in personam claim in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pan Australia Shipping Pty Ltd v The Ship ‘Comandate' and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] FCA 881
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Pan Australia Shipping Pty Ltd sought to extend an ex parte injunction against the owners of the vessel Comandate, restraining them from seeking relief in the English High Court of Justice or any other court to restrain the continuation of these proceedings. The writ for arrest of the vessel was issued on 9 June 2006, claiming $2.5 million in damages, interest, arrest of the ship and an order for the return or cancellation of a standby letter of credit. The writ was supported by an affidavit from Ms Wilmshurst, who provided evidence of various breaches of the charter party between the owners of the ship and the plaintiff. The parties had agreed to the release of the ship upon the provision of a letter of guarantee. The owners had elected to appear unconditionally in the proceedings, acknowledging the court's jurisdiction under the Admiralty Act 1988 (Cth). Ms Wilmshurst supported the application for an extension of the injunction, citing the owners' intention to seek relief in the English High Court of Justice based on a clause in the charter party.

The court was required to determine whether to extend the ex parte injunction, preventing the owners from taking any steps in the English High Court of Justice or any other court to restrain the continuation of these proceedings. The court considered the evidence provided by Ms Wilmshurst and the potential consequences of allowing the Australian proceedings to proceed. The court also referenced the judgment of Thomas J in Akai Pty Ltd v Peoples Insurance Co Limited, where his Lordship concluded that parties should not be deprived of the results of their freely bargained choice of law and jurisdiction clauses. The court needed to balance the need to protect the plaintiff's rights with the potential impact on the owners' rights under the charter party.

The court granted the application to extend the injunction, subject to certain conditions. The owners were restrained from taking any steps in the English High Court of Justice or any other court to restrain the continuation of these proceedings or seeking to restrain the plaintiff in these proceedings from taking any step in them, including the filing of an in personam claim. The court also extended the time for filing any statement of claim and provided for the hearing of the defendant's amended notice of motion. The costs of the hearing were reserved.

ORDERS:
1. Leave be granted to the defendant to file an amended appearance.
2. Leave be granted to file the affidavit of Danella Ann Wimshurst sworn 22 June 2006 in Court.
3. Leave be granted to the defendant to file its Notice of Motion in Court.
4. Paragraph 1 of that Notice of Motion be returnable instanter.
5. The hearing of paragraphs 2-5 of that Notice of Motion be deferred to a date to be determined at a later stage.
6. Subject to Order 2, up to and including 13 July 2006, Comandate Marine Corporation, by itself, its servants and agents, be restrained from taking any step, either directly or indirectly, in the English High Court of Justice or any other court seeking to restrain the continuation of proceedings NSD 1130 of 2006 of this Court, or seeking to restrain the plaintiff in this proceeding from taking any step in this proceeding, including the filing of an in personam claim in accordance with the Admiralty Rules 1988 (Cth).
7. Leave be granted to the defendant to file and serve on or before 5 pm 23 June 2006 an amended notice of motion seeking, as it may be advised, a stay under s 7 of the International Arbitration Act 1974 (Cth).
8. The time for filing of any statement of claim under Order 22 of the Admiralty Rules 1988 (Cth) be extended to 12 noon on 5 July 2006.
9. The matter be stood over for directions at 9.30 am on 7 July 2006.
10. The hearing of the amended notice of motion of the defendant to be filed pursuant to Order 2 be provisionally fixed before Rares J at 10.15 am on 13 July 2006.
11. The costs of today be reserved.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Leave be granted to the defendant to file in Court an amended appearance.

2. Leave be granted to file the affidavit of Danella Ann Wimshurst sworn 22 June 2006 in Court.

3. Leave be granted to the defendant to file its Notice of Motion in Court.

4. Paragraph 1 of that Notice of Motion be returnable instanter.

5. The hearing of paragraphs 2-5 of that Notice of Motion be deferred to a date to be determined at a later stage.

6. Subject to Order 2, up to and including 13 July 2006, Comandate Marine Corporation, by itself, its servants and agents, be restrained from taking any step, either directly or indirectly, in the English High Court of Justice or any other court seeking to restrain the continuation of proceedings NSD 1130 of 2006 of this Court, or seeking to restrain the plaintiff in this proceeding from taking any step in this proceeding, including the filing of an in personam claim in accordance with the Admiralty Rules 1988 (Cth).

7. Leave be granted to the defendant to file and serve on or before 5 pm 23 June 2006 an amended notice of motion seeking, as it may be advised, a stay under s 7 of the International Arbitration Act 1974 (Cth).

8. The time for filing of any statement of claim under Order 22 of the Admiralty Rules 1988 (Cth) be extended to 12 noon on 5 July 2006.

9. The matter be stood over for directions at 9.30 am on 7 July 2006.

10. The hearing of the amended notice of motion of the defendant to be filed pursuant to Order 2 be provisionally fixed before Rares J at 10.15 am on 13 July 2006.

11. The costs of today be reserved.

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an application to extend an ex parte injunction granted by Emmett J on 20 June 2006 restraining the defendant from taking any steps in the English High Court of Justice or any other court seeking to restrain the continuation of these proceedings or seeking to restrain the plaintiff in these proceedings from taking any step in them including the filing of in personam claim in accordance with r 22 of the Admiralty Rules.BACKGROUND The parties were in a relationship involving the vessel the MV Comandate, a Liberian flagged vessel. The writ pursuant to which the vessel was arrested was issued by the court on 9 June 2006. It claimed $2.5 million as damages, interest, the arrest of the ship and an order for the return or cancellation of a standby letter of credit delivered by the plaintiff to the owners of the ship. The particulars of claim were pleaded as:‘The plaintiff's claim is for damages arising from the breach of the charter party between owners of the Comandate and the plaintiff. The Federal Court's jurisdiction in respect of this claim arises under section 10 and section 17 and 4(3)(d), (f), (o), (r) and (w) of the Admiralty Act 1988 (Cth).’ The solicitor for the plaintiff, Ms Wilmshurst, swore an affidavit in support of the issue of the arrest warrant, on 9 June 2006 in which she said, relevantly, that the claim concerned various breaches of the time charter between the owners of the ship and the plaintiff. She exhibited a copy of what was said to be a charter party dated 19 April 2006 and a Liberian Permanent Certificate of Registry and a Certificate of Delivery of the Vessel. The ship was arrested and the parties then agreed to its release on the provision by the owners of a letter of guarantee for $US3,500,000 issued by the Royal Bank of Scotland. Originally, the ship itself, by a notice of appearance filed on 14 June 2006 appeared conditionally. I granted leave to the corporate defendant to file an amended notice of appearance which provided that it appeared conditionally this morning. During the course of argument the defendant elected to appear unconditionally, having made the concession that the court was clearly seized of jurisdiction under the Admiralty Act1988 (Cth). Ms Wilmshurst supported the present application which is for, in effect, quia timet relief to protect the ability of the plaintiff to file its statement of claim in personam so as to invoke rights under Australian law, with affidavits sworn 20 and 22 June 2006. In her affidavit of 20 June 2006, Ms Wilmshurst exhibited a number of items of correspondence which had passed between solicitors acting for the owners and the charterers. The evidence establishes quite clearly that unless restrained, the owners will seek to move the High Court of Justice in England on the basis of cl 45 of the charter party to the intent that the plaintiff will be enjoined from pursuing these proceedings in this court. Exhibit A before me is the judgment of Thomas J in Akai Pty Ltd v Peoples Insurance Co Limited [1998] 1 Lloyd’s Rep 90. In that case his Lordship concluded that Peoples Insurance had not submitted to the jurisdiction of the courts of New South Wales. He held that the judgment of the High Court of Australia (Akai Pty Ltd v Peoples Insurance Co Ltd (1996) 188 CLR 418) was not one that was recognised as giving rise to a decision binding on Peoples Insurance in accordance with the rules of private international law operative in England. He concluded that because the parties had freely bargained for the English choice of law and jurisdiction clauses, that bargain should be upheld, unless there were strong reasons for not doing so and should not as a matter of comity give effect to the decision of the High Court of Australia which overrode that bargain and that choice ([1998] 1 Lloyd’s Rep at 100). The effect of allowing the Australian proceedings to proceed, his Lordship held, would deprive Peoples Insurance of the results of that bargain by imposing a set of statutory provisions which made the contract much less favourable to the insurer than English law provided.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

RARES J

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: RARES J

Full text does not contain this section.