Y
CATCHWORIjS
| Fractlse and Procedure: whether securlty | for | costs should be |
| avarded agalnst a trustee company. | ||
| Trade Practlces Act 1975 5 .52 |
| Federal Court Rules | o . 2 @ r.3 |
| LAUNDRY COIN-WASH NOMINEES | FTY. | LIMITED | V . DUNLOP | OLYMPIC |
| LIMITED, J. | C. | h HOWARD W I G H T FROFRIETARP | LIMITED and TREVOP |
| BALTrWk' | |||
| Srnlthers J. |
28 June 1985
Melbourne.
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA )
)
| VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY | 1 | VG | No. | 298 of 1984 |
| ) | ||||
| GENERAL DIVISION | ) |
| BETWEEN: | LAUNDRY | COIN-WASH |
LEASING NOMINEES
PTY. LIMITED
(Applicant)
| - | AND: DUNLOF OLYMPLIC |
LIMITED, J.C. &
HOWARD WRIGHT
FROFRIETARY LIMITED
AND TREV@R BALDOCK
(Respondents)
Judse Makinq Order: Smlthers J.
| Date of Order: | 28 June 1985 |
| Where Made: | Melbourne. |
O R D E R
| (a) Undertakings | havlnq | been | glven | to the | Court | by | the |
applicant and Its dlrectors that subject to further
| order the capital assets In the hands | of the applicant |
| wlll not be disposed of by it, there be | no order for the |
| provislon of security for costs which may | be payable to |
| the respondent. |
| (b) | The respondents' costs | of and incldental to this motion |
be pald by the applicant.
| IN THE FEDERAL COURT | OF AUSTRALIA ) |
)
| VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY | ) | VG No. 298 of 1984 |
| \ | ||
| GENERAL DIVISION | ) |
| BETWEEN: | LAUNDRY | COIN-WASH |
LEASING NOMINEES
PTY. LIMITED
(Applicant)
(Respondents)
Coram: Smithers J.
| D,te: | 28 June 1985 |
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
| This is a motion in which the respondents seek | an order |
against the applicant for securlty for costs.
According to the statement of claim, whlch was flled on
| 14 | November 1984, the applicant seeks relief | in | respect of |
conduct of the respondents alleged to have been mlsleadlng or
| deceptive in contravention | of the provlsions of s.52 of the | ||
| Trade Practices Act 1974 |
|
| consequence of that conduct the applicant agreed | to purchase |
| from the first and second named respondents a business | of a |
| manufacturer and wholesaler | of bedding furniture theretofor |
| carried on by the first and second named respondents or one | of |
c .
2 .
| them. The misleading | and | deceptive | conduct | was | said | to |
conslst of a representation to the appllcant that the turnover
| of the | business was approxlmately | $500.000 | per annum and |
| certain | other | representatlons | concernlng | sales, | turnover, |
| capacity and profit | of the business. | These representations |
| are | alleged | to | have | been | untrue. | The appllcant. It is |
| alleged, was | induced by | these representations to enter into |
the agreement and thereby suffered damage.
| By the defence whlch was flled on | 17 December 1984 the |
respondents admit that the thlrd named respondent as the
| servant or aqent | of the second named respondent represented to |
| the | appllcant | that | the | turnover | of | the | buslness | was |
| approxlmately $500,000 per | annum | hut | deny | that | that |
| representation was false. Otherwise they deny that any | of the |
| representatlons were made or | were false. They also deny that |
| the agreement to purchase the | busmess was made wlth the flrst |
respondent and that the business had been carried on by the
flrst…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Laundry Coin-Wash Nominees Pty Ltd v Dunlop Olympic Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1985] FCA 292
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered the relevant legal provisions and the nature of the applicant's business as a trustee for a unit trust. The court recognised that the applicant held assets in trust for the benefit of others, and any attempt to execute against those assets would be unproductive. The court also noted that the respondents were aware of the applicant's role as a trustee and had not raised the issue of the unavailability of assets earlier in the proceedings. The court acknowledged that ordering security for costs would not frustrate the litigation but highlighted the difficulties a successful respondent would face in executing against the applicant's assets.
The court concluded that the applicant, being a trustee company, should establish that recourse to its property would be available to the party against whom it brought its action and be adequate to meet the possible liability for costs. The court required the applicant and its directors to provide undertakings that the capital assets in the applicant's hands would not be disposed of pending further order, which ensured the applicant would have property and legal entitlements sufficient to provide for its liability. Consequently, the court did not order further security for costs and ordered that the respondents' costs of and incidental to the motion be paid by the applicant.
This case highlights the importance of considering the nature of the applicant's business and the availability of assets when deciding whether to order security for costs in proceedings involving a trustee company. The court balanced the need for protecting the respondents' interests with the inherent difficulties in executing against the applicant's assets due to its role as a trustee.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi