Liaoning Zhongwang Group Co Ltd v Alfield Group Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 60 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Liaoning Zhongwang Group Co Ltd v Alfield Group Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 1223

File number: NSD 13 of 2017
Judge: GLEESON J
Date of judgment: 19 October 2017
Catchwords: ARBITRATION – application for summary judgment under s 31A of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) in respect of an application for enforcement of a foreign arbitral award under s 8(3) of the International Arbitration Act 1974 (Cth) – summary judgment and enforcement application resisted on the grounds that arbitration agreement not valid under the law of the country where the award was made, that the respondent was unable to present its case at the arbitration and that enforcement would be contrary to public policy – where law of foreign country not proved – where argued that arbitration agreement was a sham and that threats were made against the person of a director of the respondent preventing it from participating in the arbitration – application for summary judgment granted
Legislation:

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 31A

International Arbitration Act 1974 (Cth) ss 2D, 3, 8, 9, 39

Federal Court Rules 2011 , rr 26.01, 28.44

Cases cited:

Air Great Lakes Pty Ltd v K S Easter (Holdings) Pty Ltd (1985) 2 NSWLR 309

AJU v AJT [2011] SGCA 41; [2011] 4 SLR 739

Amasya Enterprises Pty Ltd v Asta Developments (Aust) Pty Ltd [2016] VSC 326

Application of ARD and RGD; re FGG and Family Law (Hague Convention on Intercountry Adoption) Regulations 1998 (Cth) [2014] NSWSC 1963

Australian Broadcasting Corporation v XIVth Commonwealth Games Ltd (1988) 18 NSWLR 540

Australian Maritime Systems Ltd v McConnell Dowell Constructors (Aust) Pty Ltd [2016] WASC 52

Bakri Navigation Co Ltd v Owners of the Ship ‘Golden Glory’ Glorious Shipping SA [1991] FCA 306; (1991) 217 ALR 152

BP Exploration Co (Libya) Ltd v Hunt [1980] 1 NSWLR 496; (1980) 47 FLR 317

Comandate Marine Corp v Pan Australia Shipping Pty Ltd [2006] FCAFC 192; (2006) 157 FCR 45

Commercial Union Assurance Company of Australia Ltd v Ferrcom Pty Ltd (1991) 22 NSWLR 389

Dallah Real Estate & Tourism Holding Co v Ministry of Religious Affairs of the Government of Pakistan [2010] UKSC 46; [2011] 1 AC 763

Damberg v Damberg [2001] NSWCA 87; (2001) 52 NSWLR 492

Danthanarayana v Commonwealth of Australia [2016] FCAFC 114

Deutsche Schachtbau-und Tiefbohrgesellschaft mbH v R’As al-Khaimah National Oil Co [1987] 2 Lloyd’s Rep 246; [1990] 1 AC 295

Dongwoo Mann+Hummel Co Ltd v Mann+Hummel GmbH [2008] 3 SLR 871; [2008] SGHC 67

Dynamit Actien-Gesellschaft v Rio Tinto Co Ltd [1918] AC 260

Equuscorp Pty Ltd v Glengallan Investments Pty Ltd [2004] HCA 55; (2004) 218 CLR 471

Florance v Hutchinson (1891) 17 VLR 471

Gujarat NRE Coke Limited v Coeclerici Asia (Pte) Ltd [2013] FCAFC 109; (2013) 304 ALR 468

Hebei Import & Export Corporation v Polytek Engineering Co Ltd [1999] HKC 205

Honeywell International Middle East Ltd v Meydan Group LLC…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Liaoning Zhongwang Group Co Ltd v Alfield Group Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] FCA 1223
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Liaoning Zhongwang Group Co Ltd sought summary judgment in the Federal Court for enforcement of an arbitral award made by the China International Economic and Trade Arbitration Commission (CIETAC) against Alfield Group Pty Ltd. The primary dispute was over the validity of the arbitration agreement and the process leading up to the arbitral award. Zhongwang argued that the arbitral award should be enforced under the International Arbitration Act 1974 (Cth), while Alfield contested the validity of the arbitration agreement and claimed that enforcement would be contrary to public policy.

The court needed to determine whether the arbitration agreement was valid and if there were any grounds to resist enforcement of the arbitral award. Specifically, Alfield argued that the arbitration agreement was not valid under Chinese law, that it had been coerced into participating in the arbitration, and that enforcement would contravene Australian public policy. Zhongwang contended that the arbitration agreement was valid and enforceable, and that Alfield had no reasonable prospect of successfully resisting enforcement.

The court found that there was no evidence to support Alfield’s claims that the arbitration agreement was invalid under Chinese law or that it had been coerced into the arbitration process. The court also rejected the argument that enforcement would be against public policy, as there was no evidence to suggest that the arbitration process was fundamentally unfair or that the award was obtained through fraud or misconduct. The court held that the arbitral award should be enforced as it was receivable as prima facie evidence under section 9 of the International Arbitration Act 1974 (Cth). Consequently, the court granted summary judgment in favour of Zhongwang and ordered enforcement of the arbitral award, along with payment of costs.

The final orders included enforcement of the CIETAC arbitral award, payment of specified sums in various currencies, and payment of the costs of the proceeding by Alfield.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The China International Economic and Trade Arbitration Commission Arbitral Award dated 11 August 2011 be enforced pursuant to s 8(3) of the International Arbitration Act 1974 (Cth).

2. The respondent pay the applicant the sum of AUD 2,256,533.84.

3. The respondent pay the applicant the sum of USD 463,653.60.

4. The respondent pay the applicant the sum of RMB 278,033.

5. The respondent pay the applicants costs of the proceeding.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

See, also, the observations of Hansen JA and Kyrou AJA at [141].BACKGROUND Zhongwang is a Chinese foreign corporation with its principal place of business in China. Alfield is an Australian registered company. Mr Wu is Alfield’s director and sole shareholder. The claims submitted to arbitration were based on a document expressed to be between the parties and titled “Mercantile Agreement” (“mercantile agreement” or “distribution agreement”). The document “accredits” Alfield to sell “AL extrusions” produced by Zhongwang in Australia and set out terms in relation to the sale of those products by Alfield and the payments due to Zhongwang. The document is expressed to apply from 1 January 2008 to 31 December 2008. Clause 12 of the mercantile agreement contains an arbitration clause which states:All disputes in connection with this contract or the execution there of shall be settled through friendly negotiations between two parties. If no settlement can be reached, The case in dispute shall then be submitted for arbitration to china international economic and trade arbitration commission, Beijing in accordance with it’s [sic] rules of procedure and the decision made by the arbitration organization shall be taken as final and binding upon both parties. The arbitration expenses shall be borne by the losing party unless otherwise awarded by the arbitration organization. Arbitration proceeding Zhongwang commenced the arbitration against Alfield on 25 October 2010. Steps taken between the initiation of proceedings and the hearing on 20 June 2011 are set out in the Arbitral Award. Alfield disputed that Zhongwang was entitled to rely on the Arbitral Award’s recitation of facts concerning those steps. Section 9(1) of the Act states that:(1)In any proceedings in which a person seeks the enforcement of a foreign award by virtue of this Part, he or she shall produce to the court:(a) the duly authenticated original award or a duly certified copy; and(b)the original arbitration agreement under which the award purports to have been made or a duly certified copy. Sections 9(2) and 9(3) set out requirements for the production of an authenticated original, certified copy, or certified translation of an “award” to the Court. There was no dispute that the Arbitral Award was produced in accordance with s 9(2) and s 9(3). Section 9(5) of the Act states that a document produced to the Court in accordance with s 9 is receivable as prima facie evidence of the matters to which it relates. Mr Scott QC, counsel for Alfield, submitted that s 9(5) of the Act should be read in the context of s 8(1) of the Act, which has the purpose and function of enforcing an arbitration award. It follows, he submitted, that the reference to “award” in s 9 of the Act does not include the recitations and findings of fact in the Arbitral Award – it refers only to that part of the Arbitral Award that is proposed to be enforced as a judgment of the Court, being the final dispositive portion of the document, which is analogous to orders of a Court. Mr Scott QC submitted that s 9(5) of the Act only allows that part of the document to be received as prima facie evidence.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Based on the Arbitral Award, and in the absence of any relevant evidence from Mr Wu, I do not accept that there is a real issue of fact as to whether Alfield objected to the jurisdiction of the tribunal at any stage during the arbitration proceeding. Alfield participated in the arbitration proceeding in the ways described in the Arbitral Award. Alfield did not make a challenge to the arbitration agreement in the arbitration proceeding: to the contrary, it invoked the arbitration agreement by its counterclaim. I also find that Alfield ceased to participate in the arbitration proceeding around the time that its agents lodged the “Explanation on Dissolution of the Agency Relationship” with the tribunal.Alfield’s evidence on summary judgment application Alfield’s evidence comprised two affidavits sworn by Mr Wu on 22 February 2017 and 30 March 2017, an affidavit of Irving Reichenberg sworn 31 March 2016 and expert translation of Chinese language documents by Lushan Qin.Sham Alfield contended, and I accept that, Mr Wu’s evidence is to the following effect:(1)on or around 2 October 2006 Zhongwang and Mr Wu entered into an agreement entitled “Contract for the Establishment of a Branch Company in Australia” pursuant to which Mr Wu was to set up a branch company of Zhongwang in Australia and be the branch manager of that company with profits shared;(2)between around October 2006 and July 2009 Alfield operated as Zhongwang’s Australian branch;(3)in June 2008 a representative from Zhongwang’s International Department requested that Alfield sign documents to assist with a listing in Hong Kong and stated that the documents “will only be used for external purposes and internally we run in the same fashion”;(4)this statement is corroborated by an email from another representative of Zhongwang dated 14 June 2008 which attached the mercantile agreement for Alfield’s signature and stated: “The Attached is an Merchantile Agreement between ZW and Alfield, which will support ZW’s stock to put on the market only”;(5)from the June 2008 conversation and the 14 June 2008 email, Mr Wu understood he was only signing the mercantile agreement on behalf of Alfield to help Zhongwang put its stock on the market, and that it was not meant to affect his relationship with Zhongwang or how Alfield operated; and(6)after Alfield signed the mercantile agreement, there was no change in the way Zhongwang and Alfield dealt with each other. However, as to (6), Mr Scott QC acknowledged that the execution of the mercantile agreement was followed, fairly shortly afterwards, by the execution of several versions of a document described as a “repayment plan” including versions dated 27 October 2008, 28 October 2008, 5 February 2009 and 19 March 2009. Mr Scott QC submitted that Mr Wu’s execution of these documents was consistent with the relationship of head company-branch office. By way of example, the document dated 28 October 2008, is headed “Australian Company ALFIELD’s repayment plan” and item 4 is headed “ALFIELD Company Undertaking”. However, the undertaking includes the words “I willingly accept legal responsibility for a failure to implement the above stipulations, and whatever penalty may be applied by the legal authority with jurisdiction where Zhongwang Group is located”.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Alfield contended that it is asking the Court to engage in a permissible review of the purported arbitration agreement and the arbitral process preceding the making of the Arbitral Award, and it does not seek impermissibly to “re-open” the arbitration.SUMMARY JUDGMENT: RELEVANT PRINCIPLESGeneral Pursuant to s 31A(l) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) and r 26.01(1) of the Federal Court Rules (“Rules”), in order to succeed on summary judgment Zhongwang must establish that Alfield has no reasonable prospect of resisting its application for enforcement of the award. In determining whether there is a reasonable prospect of success, the Court must make “a practical judgment ... as to whether [Alfield] has more than a ‘fanciful’ prospect of success”: cf. Polar Aviation Pty Ltd v Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2012] FCAFC 97; (2012) 203 FCR 325 at [47]; Spencer v Commonwealth [2010] HCA 28; (2010) 241 CLR 118 at [25]. Further, as the Full Court observed in Danthanarayana v Commonwealth [2016] FCAFC 114 at [4] (in the context of summary dismissal):[T]o summarily dismiss a proceeding, and thereby preclude a person from having their case determined on its merits at a final hearing, is a serious step taken only with great care and if it is possible to conclude with confidence that there is no reasonable prospect of success; this is so despite the fact that under s 31A(2) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ... the power to summarily dismiss a proceeding is not dependent on the case being “hopeless” or “bound to fail” for it to have no reasonable prospect of success. In particular, the existence of a real issue of law does not preclude summary judgment where a disputed point of law can be decided without the need for a trial or evidentiary hearing: cf. Jefferson Ford Pty Ltd v Ford Motor Company of Australia Ltd [2008] FCAFC 60; (2008) 167 FCR 372 at [74] per Rares J and [131] per Gordon J; Nichol v Discovery Africa Ltd [2016] FCAFC 182; (2016) 118 ACSR 554 at [137].Enforcement of arbitral awards In IMC Aviation Solutions Pty Ltd v Altain Khuder LLC [2011] VSCA 248; (2011) 38 VR 303 (“Altain Khuder”) at [3], Warren CJ emphasised that “in all but the most unusual cases, applications to enforce foreign arbitral awards should involve only a summary procedure”. At [53], her Honour said, concerning s 8(5) (on which Alfield sought to rely):Section 8(5)(a)–(e) require the enforcing court to be satisfied that a foreign award is tainted by either fraud or vitiating error on the part of the arbitral tribunal. Given that the Act declares arbitration to be ‘an efficient, impartial, enforceable and timely method by which to resolve commercial disputes’, the enforcing court should start with a strong presumption of regularity in respect of the tribunal’s decision and the means by which it was arrived at. The enforcing court should treat allegations of vitiating irregularity as serious. A correspondingly heavy onus falls upon the award debtor if it wishes to establish such an allegation on the balance of probabilities. Furthermore, the conduct of the parties to the agreement at each of the various stages prior to an enforcement order being sought in these courts, and its consistency with the defence subsequently asserted, will be a relevant fact to consider when deciding whether that burden has been discharged to the necessary standard.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Clause 12 of the mercantile agreement contains an arbitration clause which states:All disputes in connection with this contract or the execution there of shall be settled through friendly negotiations between two parties. If no settlement can be reached, The case in dispute shall then be submitted for arbitration to china international economic and trade arbitration commission, Beijing in accordance with it’s [sic] rules of procedure and the decision made by the arbitration organization shall be taken as final and binding upon both parties. The arbitration expenses shall be borne by the losing party unless otherwise awarded by the arbitration organization. Arbitration proceeding Zhongwang commenced the arbitration against Alfield on 25 October 2010. Steps taken between the initiation of proceedings and the hearing on 20 June 2011 are set out in the Arbitral Award. Alfield disputed that Zhongwang was entitled to rely on the Arbitral Award’s recitation of facts concerning those steps. Section 9(1) of the Act states that:(1)In any proceedings in which a person seeks the enforcement of a foreign award by virtue of this Part, he or she shall produce to the court:(a) the duly authenticated original award or a duly certified copy; and(b)the original arbitration agreement under which the award purports to have been made or a duly certified copy. Sections 9(2) and 9(3) set out requirements for the production of an authenticated original, certified copy, or certified translation of an “award” to the Court. There was no dispute that the Arbitral Award was produced in accordance with s 9(2) and s 9(3). Section 9(5) of the Act states that a document produced to the Court in accordance with s 9 is receivable as prima facie evidence of the matters to which it relates. Mr Scott QC, counsel for Alfield, submitted that s 9(5) of the Act should be read in the context of s 8(1) of the Act, which has the purpose and function of enforcing an arbitration award. It follows, he submitted, that the reference to “award” in s 9 of the Act does not include the recitations and findings of fact in the Arbitral Award – it refers only to that part of the Arbitral Award that is proposed to be enforced as a judgment of the Court, being the final dispositive portion of the document, which is analogous to orders of a Court. Mr Scott QC submitted that s 9(5) of the Act only allows that part of the document to be received as prima facie evidence. Dr Bell SC, counsel for Zhongwang, submitted that the entirety of the Arbitral Award was the “award” for the purpose of s 9, and accordingly the whole document, including the recitations and findings of fact, was receivable as prima facie evidence. He submitted that the entire document was styled “award” and noted that it was admitted into evidence without objection or limitation. CIETAC arbitrations are conducted pursuant to the CIETAC Arbitration Rules. The rules applicable to the arbitration were the CIETAC Arbitration Rules effective as from 1 May 2005. Article 43(2) of the CIETAC Arbitration Rules supports Mr Bell SC’s submission. That article states:The arbitral tribunal shall state in the award the claims, the facts of the dispute, the reasons on which the award is based, the result of the award, the allocation of the arbitration costs and the date on which and the place at which the award is made. The facts of the dispute and the reasons on which the award is based may not be stated in the award if the parties have agreed so, or if the award is made in accordance with the terms of a settlement agreement between the parties. The arbitral tribunal has the power to determine in the arbitral award the specific time period for the parties to execute the award and the liabilities to be borne by a party failing to execute the award within the specified time.