ASY17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

ASY17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2019] FCA 1888

Appeal from: ASY17 v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2019] FCCA 1041
File number: SAD 81 of 2019
Judge: WHITE J
Date of judgment: 15 November 2019
Catchwords: MIGRATION – appeal from the Federal Circuit Court (the FCC) dismissing an application for judicial review of the decision of the Immigration Assessment Authority (IAA) refusing the Appellant’s application for a Safe Haven Enterprise Visa – whether the FCC erred in failing to find that the IAA failed to consider two items of evidence (Ground 1) - Appellant sought leave to file and argue new ground (Ground 2) - whether proposed new ground “irrationality in reasoning” has merit – irrationality or unreasonableness – appeal allowed on Ground 2.
Legislation:

Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth) s 25D

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 65, 473CB, 473CC, 473DC, 473EA

National Health Act 1953 (Cth)

Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) reg 1.12(1)(e)

Cases cited:

AAM15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] FCA 804; (2015) 231 FCR 452

Applicant WAEE v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCAFC 184; (2003) 236 FCR 593

AYJ15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCA 863

BYA17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2019] FCAFC 44; (2019) 163 ALD 483

BZD17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCAFC 94

Coulton v Holcombe [1986] HCA 33; (1986) 162 CLR 1

Dornan v Riordan (1990) 24 FCR 564

Han v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCA 331

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Eden [2016] FCAFC 28; (2016) 240 FCR 158

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Singh [2014] FCAFC 1; (2014) 231 FCR 437

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Stretton [2016] FCAFC 11; (2016) 237 FCR 1

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZSRS [2014] FCAFC 16; (2014) 309 ALR 67

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Li [2013] HCA 18; (2013) 249 CLR 332

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZMDS [2010] HCA 16; (2010) 240 CLR 611

Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Yusuf [2001] HCA 30; (2001) 206 CLR 323

Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs v SGLB [2004] HCA 32; (2004) 78 ALJR 992

Murad v Assistant Minister for Immigration & Border Protection [2017] FCAFC 73; (2017) 250 FCR 510

NBMB v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2008] FCA 149; (2008) 100 ALD 118

O’Brien v Komesaroff [1982] HCA 33; (1982) 150 CLR 310

Summers v Repatriation Commission [2015] FCAFC 36; (2015) 230 FCR 179

Sun v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCAFC 52; (2016) 243 FCR 220

University of Wollongong v Metwally (No 2) (1985) 59 ALJR 481

VUAX v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2004] FCAFC 158, (2004) 238 FCR 588

WAJR v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ASY17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCA 1888
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of ASY17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection involves an appeal against the Federal Circuit Court's (FCC) dismissal of an application for judicial review of the decision of the Immigration Assessment Authority (IAA) to refuse the Appellant's application for a Safe Haven Enterprise Visa. The Appellant contested the IAA's failure to consider two pieces of evidence, which were raised as grounds of appeal. Additionally, the Appellant sought leave to file and argue a new ground, namely the irrationality in the reasoning of the IAA's decision. The appeal was allowed on the second ground.

The legal issues before the court were whether the FCC erred in failing to find that the IAA had not considered the two items of evidence presented by the Appellant, and whether the proposed new ground of irrationality in reasoning had merit. The Appellant argued that the IAA had not considered the Leadership Certificate and the statement of the Appellant's brother, and that the proposed new ground of irrationality in reasoning should be accepted.

The court found that the Appellant had not shown any error by the FCC Judge in relation to the Leadership Certificate, as the IAA member had expressly stated that she had regard to the material referred to the IAA by the Departmental Secretary under s 473CB of the Act, and the Appellant's counsel accepted that both the Leadership Certificate and the brother's statement had been before the IAA member. The court also found that the IAA member had considered the brother's statement, and that it was not readily apparent that even if the IAA member had overlooked the Leadership Certificate, it could have deprived the Appellant of the possibility of obtaining a successful outcome.

Regarding the new ground of irrationality in reasoning, the court found that the proposed new ground had merit. The IAA had made inconsistent and irreconcilable findings of fact, which led to the conclusion that the IAA had acted irrationally and/or failed to conduct a review of the Minister's delegate's decision as required by s. 473CC of the Act. The Appellant was granted leave to amend further the Amended Notice of Appeal and to argue the new ground.

The appeal was allowed, the orders of the FCC were set aside, and a writ of certiorari was issued quashing the affirmation of the IAA's decision to refuse the Appellant's Safe Haven Enterprise Visa application. The case highlights the importance of considering all relevant evidence in decision-making and the consequences of making inconsistent and irreconcilable findings of fact.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Appellant has leave to amend further the Amended Notice of Appeal in the form of the document entitled “Proposed Second Amended Notice of Appeal” filed on 28 August 2019.

2. The Appellant have leave to argue Ground 2 in the Second Amended Notice of Appeal.

3. The appeal be allowed.

4. The orders of the Federal Circuit Court made on 22 March 2019 in ADG63/2017 be set aside.

5. A writ of certiorari be issued quashing the affirmation of the Immigration Assessment Authority made on 25 January 2017 of the decision of the Minister’s delegate to refuse the Appellant’s Safe Haven Enterprise Visa (Subclass 790) application.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In BYA17, it was held that the failure of the IAA to make any reference to news reports containing, potentially, independent and objective corroboration of important aspects of the appellant’s claims, coupled with the IAA’s detailed consideration of other new information on which the appellant’s had sought to rely, warranted an inference that it had not considered the news reports, at [55]. The Full Court referred in this respect to Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Yusuf [2001] HCA 30; (2001) 206 CLR 323 at [69].Did the IAA fail to consider the two items of evidence? The submissions of counsel for the appellant concerning the two items of evidence seemed to repeat the submissions made to the FCC Judge. They did not seek to identify error in the FCC Judge’s reasons: only that his Honour should have reached a different conclusion. In my opinion, the appellant has not shown any error by the FCC Judge in relation to the Leadership Certificate. First, the IAA member stated expressly, at [4], that she had regard to the material referred to the IAA by the Departmental Secretary under s 473CB of the Act, and the appellant’s counsel accepted that both the Leadership Certificate and the brother’s statement had been before the IAA member. Secondly, the IAA member’s reasons proceeded on the assumption that the appellant was a youth leader, and that he had engaged in leadership activities, at [42]. Having regard to those two considerations, it is not to be readily inferred that the IAA member overlooked the Leadership Certificate when assessing whether the appellant’s claim to have attended Con Cuong Church was credible. In any event, it is not readily apparent that, even if the IAA member had overlooked the Leadership Certificate, it could have deprived the appellant of the possibility of obtaining a successful outcome. That is especially so given that there is no logical connection between the appellant’s possession of the Leadership Certificate on the one hand, and his claimed attendance at the Con Cuong Church, on the other. When these matters were raised with the appellant’s counsel during the appeal hearing, he effectively abandoned this complaint, saying “without formally withdrawing that aspect of the appeal, I don’t intend to press the point”. The position with respect to the alleged failure of the IAA member to consider the possible corroborative significance of the statement of the appellant’s brother is a little more complex. The IAA member did refer twice to the claims of the appellant’s brother: at [3], when she said that she had considered the appellant’s brother and sister in law’s claims to the extent that they were relevant to the appellant’s own claims; and at [33], when she referred to the low level and brief nature of the involvement of the appellant’s brother. The member did not engage, at least expressly, in any evaluation of the potential corroborative effect of the brother’s statement for the appellant’s claims. In particular, the member did not consider the truthfulness of the brother’s statement and, if true, how it may bear on the assessment of the appellant’s claims.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The delegate then went on to assess the appellant’s protection claims separately from his brother and sister-in-law.The IAA’s decision The IAA member also concluded that the appellant was not a member of the same family unit in the defined sense. No complaint has been made in relation to that finding. As the delegate had assessed the appellant’s application separately, the IAA member treated the decisions made in relation to the appellant, his brother and his sister-in-law as separate matters. However, the member said that, in assessing the appellant’s application she had taken into account the brother and sister-in-law’s claims which were relevant to the appellant. The appellant claimed to fear persecution from the Vietnamese government because he is a devout Catholic, a youth group leader, an active member of his church community, and a pro-Catholic religious activist. The appellant also claims that, if he returns to Vietnam, he will be targeted as a failed asylum seeker and illegal departee. The appellant gave evidence of an incident in Vietnam said to have occurred on 9 August 2012 when he was asked by an elder at his church to take children to pray at Con Cuong Church, located approximately 100 km from his home. He claimed to be the only adult present on this excursion apart from the bus driver. When the appellant and children arrived at the church there were barriers and so they prayed in a nearby building which formed part of the Church property. They also held banners with statements reading “Justice and Peace for Vietnam” and denouncing the use of force against the Church. Whilst the appellant and children were there, a police officer asked the appellant for his details and told him that they could not pray at that place. The appellant claimed that, after returning home, the police twice requested (in writing) that he attend a police station for questioning. He did not comply with this request and shortly, after the second request, he fled Vietnam for fear that, if he remained, he may be arrested, detained or tortured. The IAA member noted that the appellant’s claims turned principally on his involvement with a Catholic youth group and his attendance at the prayer session at the Con Cuong Church on 9 August 2012. There is no suggestion in the materials that the appellant had gone to the Con Cuong Church on any other occasion. In relation to these claims, the IAA member accepted:·that the appellant is a devout Catholic; ·that he was an active member of his local church;·that the appellant has encouraged people to live and work in accordance with Catholic principles in the past; and ·that as the appellant gets older he may become more active in proselytising. However, the IAA member had a number of concerns about the appellant’s evidence concerning the events on 9 August 2012, finding:(a)there was an inconsistency between the appellant’s written statement that he had entered the Con Cuong Church and his claim in his interview with the delegate that, by reason of barriers, he and his group had not been able to enter the church but had prayed in a smaller building nearby. The IAA member considered that, if in fact the appellant and his group had been unable to enter the actual church by reason of barricades, this was a significant omission from his written statement; (b)there was an inconsistency between the appellant’s written statement that he had arrived at the Con Cuong Church as part of a group of 30 Catholic youths made up of one or two representatives from each local area, with the appellant being the only representative from his youth group, and his interview evidence that he had been the leader of a group of 30 children (it seems from his local area) with some as young as seven, who went to the Con Cuong Church to pray; (c)it was implausible that the appellant, aged only 15 years, had been given the responsibility of leading a group of about 30 children to Con Cuong Church, approximately 100 km away, especially given the volatile history of that Church, the recent violent and protracted protests there, and the myriad risks involved; and (d)the appellant’s explanation for being unable to produce the two letters he had received from the police requiring him to attend for questioning (he said that his father had destroyed them) gave rise to “some concerns”.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

However, the way in which the IAA member referred to the brother’s claim indicates that she had considered it. It seems implausible that the member could have done so without having regard to the brother’s statement. That being so, this Court should be slow to conclude that the FCC Judge had been in error in concluding that this material had been considered by the IAA member. In my opinion, this is an instance of the Tribunal not having to mention every single matter, or item of evidence to which it had regard.A new ground – irrationality in reasoning As a result of a matter raised by the Court, the appellant applied to amend further the Notice of Appeal so as to add a new Ground 2 as follows:2.The Federal Circuit Court should have found that the decision of the IAA was irrational and or amounted to a failure to conduct a review in that it contained findings of fact that were inconsistent and irreconcilable. Particulars2.1At paragraph [25] of the Decision, the Authority accepted the submission from the Appellant’s representative that the Appellant “could reasonably deduce that his involvement at Con Cuong may have been linked to the letters he claims he later received from the police”. 2.2The Authority’s acceptance of that submission was a finding of fact that the appellant had been at Con Cuong as claimed and had received letters from the police which were linked to his attendance at Con Cuong.2.3At paragraph [32] of the Decision, and contrary to the finding referred to in 2.2 above, the Authority made a finding of fact that it did not accept the Appellant had attended at the Con Cuong Church and further found “that the appellant has fabricated these matters to strengthen his protection claims to fear harm on the basis of his religion, and as a person who is politically and religiously active and opposed to the government”.2.4In arriving at inconsistent and irreconcilable findings of fact, the Authority acted irrationally and/or failed to conduct a review of the 1st Respondent’s decision as required by s. 473CC of the Act, and thereby erred. The appellant acknowledged that he had not advanced this ground in the FCC and that he would need leave to argue it. Subsequently, the parties filed submissions in relation to the appellant’s application for leave to amend further the Notice of Appeal and for leave to argue the new ground. The appellant also filed a supporting affidavit. The parties agreed that the Court should deal with the two aspects of the appellant’s application (leave to amend and leave to argue a new ground) at the one time and that it should do so on the papers. In his affidavit, the appellant deposed that he had relied on the advice of his solicitor in deciding the grounds to advance in the application for judicial review and that he had not previously been informed that the proposed new ground may be available. The Minister did not seek to cross examine the appellant on his affidavit and did not submit that his evidence should not accepted. That evidence is plausible and I do accept it. Relevant principles