Tarrant v Australian Securities and Investments Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

[2013] AATA  926

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2011/5133

Re

Mervyn Ross Tarrant

APPLICANT

And

Australian Securities and Investments Commission

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

President D Kerr
Ms J L Redfern, Senior Member

Date 20 December 2013
Place Sydney

Decision Summary

The decision under review is affirmed.

The Tribunal’s order of 7 December 2011 staying ASIC from making any entry in the ASIC Gazette or issuing any media release notifying that orders have been made against the Applicant pursuant to sections 920A and 920B of the Corporations Act 2001 is revoked.

........................................................................

President D Kerr and Ms J L Redfern, Senior Member

Catchwords

Corporations Law – banning order – failure to comply with a financial services law – failure to have reasonable basis for financial advice – failure to disclose information about remuneration – false or misleading statements in respect of financial products – misleading or deceptive conduct in respect of a financial product or service

Corporations Law – banning order – length of banning order – no findings of fraud or dishonesty – contraventions serious and caused loss – applicant’s lack of insight into gravity of breaches – seven year banning order affirmed

Practice and Procedure – government policy – ASIC Regulatory Guide – whether Tribunal must apply policy unless policy unlawful or there are cogent reasons to the contrary – Tribunal not precluded from giving no weight to policy in a particular case – policy found to be sensible and calibrated – policy applied by Tribunal

Practice and Procedure – power of Tribunal to limit scope of review – limits of Tribunal’s power to confine the reception of evidence – relevance the criterion for admissibility of material in Tribunal – rules of evidence not applicable

Practice and Procedure – adjournments – failure by applicant to appear – history of non-compliance with directions – no evidence to suggest applicant’s circumstances likely to change if adjournment granted – adjournment refused

Practice and Procedure – applicant and witnesses absent from hearing – written statements – probative weight to be given to statements where not cross-examined

Practice and Procedure – application for dismissal of proceeding – failure by applicant to comply with directions of the Tribunal – circumstances in which Tribunal may dismiss application without proceeding to review the decision

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 ss 2A, 25(4A), 33(1), 42A(5)
Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 ss 1(2), 19
Corporations Act 2001 ss 50AAA, 761A, 766A(1)(a), 910A, 911A(1), 911A(2), 913B, 914A, 915A to 915J, 920(1)(f), 920A, 941A, 941B, 942C, 944A, 945A(1), 946A, 947B(2)(d), 947B(2)(e), 947C(1), 947C(2)(e), 947C(2)(f), 947D, 1012A, 1013C, 1013D, 1013E, 1013F, 1041E(1), 1041H(1)

Corporations Amendment (Future of Financial Advice) Act 2012

Cases

Re AK and Commissioner for Superannuation (1986) 11 ALN N106

Australian Postal Commission v Hayes (1989) 23 FCR 320

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Adler and ors (2002) 42 ACSR 80; [2002] NSWSC 483

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Fortescue Metals Group Ltd (2011) 190 FCR 364; [2011] FCAFC 19

Australian Securities…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tarrant v Australian Securities and Investments Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] AATA 926
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter of Tarrant v Australian Securities and Investments Commission involved a dispute regarding a banning order issued against Mr Tarrant for multiple breaches of financial services laws. The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) had alleged that Mr Tarrant, a financial adviser, engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct, failed to have a reasonable basis for financial advice, and did not disclose information about remuneration. The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether Mr Tarrant's actions constituted serious breaches of financial services laws, and if so, the appropriate length of a banning order. Additionally, the Tribunal had to consider the admissibility of certain evidence, the application of government policy, and the procedural aspects of the case, including the granting of adjournments and the absence of the applicant and witnesses.

The Tribunal found that Mr Tarrant had indeed breached various sections of the Corporations Act, including sections 947C, 1041E(1), 1041H(1), and 945A, and that these breaches were significant and serious. The breaches affected unsophisticated retail investors and occurred over an extended period, involving substantial sums of money and multiple instances of non-compliance. The Tribunal concluded that the consequences of these breaches were devastating for both investors and Tarrant Financial Concepts (TFC), the financial advisory firm operated by Mr Tarrant. Despite Mr Tarrant's lack of prior breaches and his assertion that he had acted prudently and professionally, the Tribunal was concerned about his lack of insight into the gravity of his breaches and his failure to accept responsibility for his actions.

The Tribunal affirmed a seven-year banning order for Mr Tarrant, noting that while there were no findings of fraud or dishonesty, the seriousness of the breaches and the resultant loss warranted a substantial penalty. The Tribunal also considered relevant government policy and found it to be sensible and appropriately calibrated, applying it in this case. The procedural aspects of the case, including the admissibility of evidence and the granting of adjournments, were also addressed by the Tribunal, which ruled that the applicant's history of non-compliance justified the refusal of further adjournments. The Tribunal gave appropriate weight to the written statements submitted by Mr Tarrant and his witnesses, despite their absence from the hearing and the inability to cross-examine them.

The Tribunal ultimately upheld the banning order, reflecting the seriousness of Mr Tarrant's breaches and the need to protect the public from further misconduct by him in the financial services sector. The Tribunal's decision was grounded in the evidence presented and the legal standards applicable to financial services law breaches, ensuring that the penalties imposed were commensurate with the gravity of the breaches.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

As the Tribunal noted previously in respect of Ex AV it remained open to ASIC to make submissions to such weight as Mr Wood’s statements were entitled to given their inherent credibility or lack thereof and in light of the fact that Mr Wood could not be cross-examined. Further as the Tribunal noted cross-examination per se is often less valuable in discrediting a witness than forensic examination in submissions by reference to objective materials and other credible evidence. It remained open to ASIC to mount both such attacks. BACKGROUND FACTS ASIC commenced investigations in relation to ASF in late 2009. As part of this process, ASIC issued notices to TFC and Mr Tarrant and conducted private examinations of Mr Tarrant and TFC staff under s 19 of the ASIC Act. ASIC also obtained documents and statements from investors, Mr Shawn Richard and TFC staff. Most of the key facts on which the banning was based are not in issue. They are evidenced by documents and have been accepted by Mr Tarrant and ASIC in their respective statements of facts issues and contentions. There is no dispute about the recommendations given to TFC clients by Mr Tarrant, nor is there dispute that monies were paid to Tarrants Finance by AAM from November 2008 to September 2009. Central to the question of whether Mr Tarrant has contravened numerous financial services laws is the dispute about whether Mr Tarrant agreed to recommend ASF in exchange for a so called marketing allowance from April 2008 and whether he had a reasonable basis for the advice he gave to eight clients of TFC to invest in ASF using, inter alia, self-managed super funds and gearing strategies. Mr Tarrant has worked as an accountant in the Wollongong area from about 1988. From 1992, he traded under the name “Tarrant Accountants & Business Advisers” (TABA). TABA provided a range of services, comprising tax, accounting and business advisory services. In 1999 Mr Tarrant expanded his advisory services to include financial advice. This advice was provided through TFC. TFC was incorporated on 12 March 1999 and was granted an AFSL on 2 October 2003. Prior to this, TFC was a licenced securities dealer. TFC provided financial planning and investment based services for a wide range of clients from 1999 until being placed in liquidation in 2010. Mr Tarrant is a certified practicing accountant, a registered tax agent and has a diploma in financial planning. In the relevant period, namely from March 2008 to December 2009, Mr Tarrant operated a group of companies and businesses which he referred to as the “Tarrant Corporate Group”. The group comprised TABA, TFC, Tarrant Enterprises Pty Ltd (Tarrant Enterprises), Tarrants Finance and Tarrants Legal Services Pty Ltd, which traded as Tarrants Law. He was the sole director of TFC, Tarrant Enterprises and Tarrants Finance and a non-legal director of Tarrants Legal Services Pty Ltd. Tarrants Finance was the corporate trustee for the Tarrants Finance Unit Trust which was owned by TFC (82%) and Tarrant Enterprises (18%). Tarrant Enterprises was the corporate trustee for the MRT Family Trust. The shareholders of Tarrant Enterprises were Mr Tarrant‘s sister and ex-wife. The beneficiaries of the MRT Family trust were Mr Tarrant and his son and daughter.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Tarrant submitted that the eight clients would have been better off but for the fraud by purporting to reconstruct each of their portfolios, excluding the loss. ASIC objected to this submission because the reconstruction is unsupported by evidence and is irrelevant to the question before the Tribunal. The Tribunal rejects the submission of Mr Tarrant. The methodology for the analysis adopted by Mr Tarrant in his reconstruction is not transparent and appears to rely on information that is not before the Tribunal. The Tribunal also agrees that this submission has little relevance given one of the key issues in the proceeding is whether ASF was a suitable investment for these clients. To exclude its failure is to not only reconstruct the result but the advice. Conclusions The Tribunal is satisfied that Mr Tarrant has breached:(a)s 947C in respect of 20 statements of advice;(b)s 1041E(1) in respect of statements made in 15 statements of advice;(c)s 1041H(1) in respect of representations made to TFC staff and thereby clients of TFC from early October 2008 to May 2009; and(d)s 945A in respect of advices given to eight TFC clients. These breaches were all significant and serious because they affected unsophisticated retail investors and were over an extended period. They involved large amounts of money and there were multiple breaches. The consequences of the breaches have been devastating for both investors and TFC. The Tribunal accepts the consequences have been detrimental for Mr Tarrant because he has built a business over many years that is now in liquidation. He states his reputation has been severely damaged. The Tribunal accepts the collapse of ASF and Trio Capital and resulting publicity, investigations and court actions are likely to have a significant effect on Mr Tarrant. Mr Tarrant was not responsible for the collapse of ASF and Trio but he was responsible for the advice he gave, the disclosure he failed to make and the representations made to investors and TFC staff. While the Tribunal accepts there is no evidence of prior breaches by Mr Tarrant it must also have regard to the fact Mr Tarrant does not accept responsibility for the breaches the Tribunal has found. Mr Tarrant lacks insight into the gravity of the breaches and this leads the Tribunal to have concerns about whether Mr Tarrant fully appreciates the obligations of an authorised representative. This was illustrated in his submissions. For example, when commenting on Mr Alafaci’s criticism of the advice he provided to DS and CS, Mr Tarrant made the following submission:The ASIC expert, Alafaci is out of line expecting an adviser to tell a 47-year-old and 42-year-old when they should retire or what is too much money to expect in retirement. It is not unusual for people in their 40s to think they can retire in their 50s but reality soon sets in and people reassess their expectations as they get older. This is not a situation to address with a 47-year-old and a 42-year-old client. This was a situation to help clients take advantage of the market crisis and that is what I did in a prudent and professional manner and then for the fraud at fund manager level.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established