1700919 (Refugee)

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

1700919 (Refugee) [2017] AATA 1617 (12 September 2017)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

CASE NUMBER:  1700919

COUNTRY OF REFERENCE:                  Afghanistan

MEMBER:Alison Murphy

DATE:12 September 2017

PLACE OF DECISION:  Melbourne

DECISION:The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and substitutes a decision not to cancel the applicant’s Subclass 866 (Protection) visa.

Statement made on 12 September 2017 at 5:10pm

CATCHWORDS
Refugee – Cancellation – Protection visa – Afghanistan – Conflicting information on identity documents – Family travel histories – Identity assessment – Afghan names – Nationality – Refugee documents

LEGISLATION
Migration Act 1958, ss 116, 352(4), 375A, 431, 440, 499
Migration Regulations 1994
Freedom of Information Act

CASES
Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1979) 24 ALR 577
Shi v Migration Agents Registration Authority [2008] HCA 31
Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1979) 2 ALD 634
Tarrant v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2013] AATA 926

Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been omitted from this decision pursuant to section 431 of the Migration Act 1958 and replaced with generic information which does not allow the identification of an applicant, or their relative or other dependant.

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration [in] January 2017 to cancel the applicant’s Subclass 866 Protection (Class XA) visa under s.116(1AA) of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act).

  2. The delegate cancelled the visa on the basis that she was not satisfied as to the applicant’s identity. The issue in the present case is whether that ground for cancellation is made out, and if so, whether the visa should be cancelled.

  3. For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that the decision to cancel the applicant’s visa should be set aside.

    BACKGROUND

  4. The applicant is [an age]-year-old male. He arrived in Australia by boat [in] May 2009 and lodged an application for a protection visa shortly afterwards. In that application he identified himself as a citizen of Afghanistan of Hazara ethnicity born in [year] [Village 1], Gharchbagh in Ghazni province in [year]. On the basis of information provided in his protection visa application, he was granted a class XA subclass 866 protection visa [in] September 2009. 

  5. The applicant is married with [children], all of whom live in Quetta, Pakistan.  In November 2009, the applicant applied for a split family offshore humanitarian visa in respect of his wife and their children and [in] May 2010, the applicant’s wife was interviewed by a departmental officer in Islamabad, Pakistan.  [In] January 2014 that visa application was refused.  The decision record notes that the delegate accepted the claimed relationship between the applicant and his family and that they were Afghan Hazaras by ethnicity who had moved from Afghanistan to Pakistan.  However the decision record noted the applicant’s family had not been assessed as refugees by the UNHCR and proposed for resettlement and the Australian community…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read 1700919 (Refugee) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 1617
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered a decision to cancel the protection visa of an applicant who arrived in Australia in 2009 and was granted a protection visa based on his claim of being an Afghan national of Hazara ethnicity. The applicant's visa was subsequently considered for cancellation under section 116(1AA) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) on the grounds that the Minister or delegate was not satisfied as to the applicant's identity. This dissatisfaction arose from inconsistencies in identity documents and information provided by the applicant and his wife during the processing of subsequent visa applications, including a partner visa for his family and an application for Australian citizenship.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether the ground for cancellation under section 116(1AA) of the Act was established. Specifically, the Tribunal had to assess whether the delegate was reasonably satisfied that the applicant's identity was not established, given the conflicting information and the identity assessment report which concluded that the applicant's claimed identity was not supported. The Tribunal also needed to consider the Department's Procedures Advice Manual, which outlines that delegates must have regard to individual circumstances and the potential for legitimate difficulties in obtaining identity evidence, particularly for those with refugee status.

In its reasoning, the Tribunal noted that the applicant's Hazara ethnicity and his residence in Afghanistan, Iran, and Pakistan were not in dispute. The core issue was the applicant's nationality. The Tribunal examined the conflicting information regarding the applicant's and his wife's birthplaces and travel histories, as well as the identity officer's findings that the provided documentation was fraudulent and that the applicant was not a witness of truth. However, the Tribunal also considered the context provided by DFAT reports regarding Hazara migration patterns and Afghan citizenship laws. The Tribunal ultimately concluded that the decision to cancel the applicant's visa should be set aside.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that the decision to cancel the applicant’s visa should be set aside.BACKGROUND The applicant is [an age]-year-old male. He arrived in Australia by boat [in] May 2009 and lodged an application for a protection visa shortly afterwards. In that application he identified himself as a citizen of Afghanistan of Hazara ethnicity born in [year] [Village 1], Gharchbagh in Ghazni province in [year]. On the basis of information provided in his protection visa application, he was granted a class XA subclass 866 protection visa [in] September 2009. The applicant is married with [children], all of whom live in Quetta, Pakistan. In November 2009, the applicant applied for a split family offshore humanitarian visa in respect of his wife and their children and [in] May 2010, the applicant’s wife was interviewed by a departmental officer in Islamabad, Pakistan. [In] January 2014 that visa application was refused. The decision record notes that the delegate accepted the claimed relationship between the applicant and his family and that they were Afghan Hazaras by ethnicity who had moved from Afghanistan to Pakistan. However the decision record noted the applicant’s family had not been assessed as refugees by the UNHCR and proposed for resettlement and the Australian community does not have the capacity to offer resettlement to all persons seeking it. While the delegate accepted there was no evidence of any other country being available to provide for their resettlement, she did not consider there to be compelling reasons to grant the applicant’s family an offshore humanitarian visa. The applicant travelled to Quetta to see his family for three months in each of 2010 and 2013. [In] April 2013 the applicant sponsored an application for a [partner] visa for his family. On 19 December 2013 the Minister introduced ‘Direction Number 62 – Order for Considering and Disposing Of Family Stream Visa Applications’. The effect of that direction is that family visa applications sponsored by any person who arrived in Australia by boat are to be given the lowest processing priority. The applicant’s [partner] visa has not yet been finalised. [In] April 2016 a delegate of the Minister sent the applicant a Notification of Intention to Consider Cancellation (NOICC), advising him that the Department of Immigration and Border Protection intended to cancel his visa on the ground that he was not satisfied as to his identity. The NOICC set out the protection claims made by the applicant in a protection visa application lodged [in] August 2009. It stated that [in] April 2013, the applicant and his wife [applied] for a [partner] visa. During the processing of the partner visa application, concerns were raised as to the genuineness of identity documents provided and that application has not been finally determined. The NOICC sets out that [in] February 2014 the applicant applied for Australian citizenship. His application was approved [in] November 2014 however due to the concerns raised during the processing of his partner visa application, his acquisition of citizenship was deferred and an identity assessment was requested. [In] September 2015 an identity officer from the Department of Immigration and Border Protection concluded that based on research and interview, the applicant’s identity was ‘not supported’. The particulars contained in the identity officer’s report were set out as follows:Having carefully considered all the available information provided by the client and his wife, my assessment is that there is no reliable information and documentary evidence in support of their claimed Afghan nationality. Their ability to speak to the Hazaragi language is not sufficient to conclude that they are Afghan Hazaras who resided unlawfully in Iran and Pakistan.Although he has not been completely consistent with their (sic) travel history, I find it likely that the client and his family did reside in Iran. It is also likely that they were issued with documents such as Amayesh cards (Refugee cards), and with birth certificates for his children who were born in an Iranian hospital.Although during his entry interview he inadvertently disclosed that he stayed in Iran lawfully (Question 24, Page 29), and that he has frequently travelled to Iran, there is no evidence in support of the possibility that they had obtained permanent residence in Iran. I am, however, yet to be convinced that, during the [number] years he had resided in Iran, he had only been issued with a “Mothajeer Card”, and that he was deported to Afghanistan without being issued with any documentation of his deportation. The inconsistent histories provided by the client and his wife support an assertion that they may have been deported from Iran to Pakistan, which in turn supports the possibility that they are Pakistani nationals.The likelihood of their being Pakistani nationals is also supported by the fact that the client’s and his family’s names follow a Pakistani naming pattern.I have found no credible and reliable evidence in support of the client’s identity. So far he has only been able to produce fraudulent documentation for his family; this leads me to find that the client is not a witness of truth. Accordingly, I am not satisfied that he is [applicant’s name], an Afghan national who has resided unlawfully in Pakistan. As he is not a witness of truth, I disbelieve his claims that he has no documentation in support of his true identity and nationality. The fraudulently issued taskeras, birth certificates and Afghan passports fail to support his claims.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Therefore I direct under s. 440 of the Act that the names of the witnesses who gave evidence at hearing must not be published or otherwise disclosed except as required by law.CONSIDERATION – DOES THE GROUND FOR CANCELLATION EXIST? The applicant’s visa was cancelled under s. 116(1AA) of the Act. A visa may be cancelled under s. 116(1AA) of the Act if the Minister or his delegate is not satisfied as to the visa holder’s identity. In this case the delegate considered the applicant has given two or more documents or pieces of information about his identity which are inconsistent with each other, as a result of which she was unable to form a conclusion regarding which document or piece of information is genuine. The Department’s Procedures Advice Manual (PAM3) sets out that when considering whether the ground set out in s.116(1AA) is established, delegates must have regard to the visa holders individual circumstances and take into account the fact that some visa applicants will have had legitimate difficulties in obtaining evidence of their identity, particularly those who have refugee status. The Policy states that s.116(1AA) will not apply if:·the visa holder has used a fraudulent identity to obtain a visa but their true identity is later confirmed; or·in response to a notice under s.119, the visa holder satisfies the delegate as to their true identity. The delegate’s record of decision dated [in] January 2017 indicates that in reaching this conclusion she gave weight to the identity assessment dated [in] September 2015 which concluded the applicant’s claimed identity was not supported. She also considered the applicant and his wife had otherwise given inconsistent and contrary information. I address each of the matters considered by the delegate and the identity officer to be adverse to the applicant’s claims to be an Afghan national below.The applicant’s Hazara ethnicity It is not in dispute that the applicant is of Hazara ethnicity or that he has spent time living in Afghanistan, Iran and Pakistan. Rather at issue in this case is whether the applicant and his family are nationals of Afghanistan or Pakistan. DFAT reports that ethnic Hazaras have lived in Afghanistan for centuries and Hazaras resident in Pakistan have migrated from Afghanistan over the last century, the majority arriving in two waves - the first during the Soviet occupation of Afghanistan from 1979 and the next in 1996 following the Taliban takeover in Afghanistan[4]. The applicant has consistently stated he was born in Afghanistan in [year] to Afghan national parents and left that country for Iran in 1970 following the death of his father. The applicant’s wife has consistently stated she was born in Afghanistan in [year] and lived in that country until she married the applicant and moved to Iran in [year]. [4] DFAT 2014 DFAT Thematic Report Hazaras in Afghanistan and Pakistan 26 March 26 March at 2.19 If the applicant and his wife were in fact born in Afghanistan to Afghan parents, the applicant and his wife are Afghan citizens pursuant to that country’s citizenship laws. Similarly their children will be deemed Afghan citizens, whether or not they were born in Afghanistan[5].[5] Article 9, 10 and 11 of the Law on Citizenship of the Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan (Law on Citizenship)