Nottingham v Australian Financial Complaints Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Nottingham v Australian Financial Complaints Authority [2023] FCA 58  

Appeal from: Decision of the Australian Financial Complaints Authority dated 22 April 2022
File number(s): NSD 371 of 2022
Judgment of: BURLEY J
Date of judgment: 8 February 2023
Catchwords: ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – appeal from decision of the Australian Financial Complaints Authority – where superannuation member’s election to maintain insurance cover not received by trustee of superannuation fund – whether Authority erred in law in determining that the trustee had not received the election form – whether the Authority erred in law by failing to take into account a relevant consideration of whether the system adopted by the trustee to comply with Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993 (Cth) s 68AAA was adequate – appeal dismissed
Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 761A, 1053, 1055, 1055A, 1057, Pt 7.10A

Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993 (Cth) s 68AAA

Treasury Laws Amendment (Protecting Your Superannuation) Act 2019 (Cth) Sch 2 Pt 2 item 3

Australian Financial Complaints Authority – Complaint Resolution Scheme Rules

Cases cited:

BHL19 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2020] FCAFC 94; 277 FCR 420

Corporation of the City of Enfield v Development Assessment Commission [2000] HCA 5; 199 CLR 135

Haritos v Federal Commissioner of Taxation [2015] FCAFC 92; 233 FCR 315

QSuper Board v Australian Financial Complaints Authority Ltd [2020] FCAFC 55; 276 FCR 97

Reeves v Nulis Nominees (Australia) Limited (Trustee) [2022] FCA 627

Sharp Corporation of Australia Pty Ltd v Collector of Customs [1995] FCA 707; 59 FCR 6

Tarrant v Australian Securities and Investment Commission [2015] FCAFC 8; 317 ALR 328

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Number of paragraphs: 40
Date of hearing: 28 October 2022
Counsel for the Appellant: The Appellant appeared in person
Counsel for the First Respondent: Mr A R Di Stefano
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Becketts Lawyers
Counsel for the Second Respondent: Mr O K Wolahan
Solicitor for the Second Respondent: Kelly Hazel Quill Lawyers

ORDERS

NSD 371 of 2022
BETWEEN:

PHILLIP RAYMOND NOTTINGHAM (AS EXECUTOR OF THE ESTATE OF STEPHEN MATTHEW BEERE)

Appellant

AND:

AUSTRALIAN FINANCIAL COMPLAINTS AUTHORITY

First Respondent

AUSTRALIANSUPER PTY LTD

Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

BURLEY J

DATE OF ORDER:

8 FEBRUARY 2023

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal be dismissed.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

1       INTRODUCTION

[1]

2       BACKGROUND

[3]

3       RELEVANT LEGISLATION

[9]

4       THE DECISION OF THE AUTHORITY

[14]

5       THE APPEAL

[18]

6       CONSIDERATION

[23]

6.1      The appellant’s submissions

[23]

6.2      Analysis

[27]

7       DISPOSITION

[40]

BURLEY J:

1.                 INTRODUCTION

  1. The appellant is the executor of the estate of the late Stephen Matthew Beere (deceased). He brings an appeal under s 1057(1) of the CorporationsAct 2001 (Cth) against the decision of the second respondent (Authority) dated…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nottingham v Australian Financial Complaints Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 58
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Nottingham v Australian Financial Complaints Authority involved the deceased, who had been a member of the AustralianSuper superannuation fund, and the trustee of the fund. The deceased had elected to maintain his insurance cover, but the trustee had not received the election form, resulting in the cancellation of his insurance cover and the denial of the $80,000 death benefit. The appellant, representing the deceased, appealed the decision of the Australian Financial Complaints Authority, which affirmed the decision of the trustee.

The legal issues in this case were whether the Authority erred in law by determining that the trustee had not received the election form, and whether the Authority failed to consider the reliability of the system adopted by the trustee to comply with the Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993 (Cth) s 68AAA. The court considered whether the Authority had jurisdiction and powers concerning the fairness and reasonableness of a decision, not its lawfulness, and whether the Authority was prohibited from making a determination that was contrary to law.

The court dismissed the appeal, finding that the Authority had not erred in law in determining that the trustee had not received the election form. The court also found that the Authority did not fail to consider the reliability of the system adopted by the trustee, as the system was not inherently unreliable and the trustee had taken steps to ensure that it complied with the requirements of s 68AAA of the SIS Act. The court held that the Authority had jurisdiction and powers concerning the fairness and reasonableness of a decision, not its lawfulness, and that the Authority was not prohibited from making a determination that was contrary to law.

The appeal was dismissed, and no orders were made.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Section 1057 of the Corporations Act provides that a party to a superannuation complaint may appeal to this Court, on a question of law, from the Authority’s determination of the complaint. 2. BACKGROUND The deceased joined the AustralianSuper superannuation fund (Fund) on 31 October 2001 and received default insurance cover through the Fund, including death cover. He ceased to pay any amount in respect of his fund on 13 July 2012. On 12 March 2019, the Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993 (Cth) (SIS Act) was amended by the Treasury Laws Amendment (Protecting Your Superannuation) Act 2019 (Cth) (PYS Act) as part of a package of reforms which included, in s 68AAA(1), a provision which relevantly provided that the trustee of a regulated superannuation fund must ensure that it only provides insurance to a member with an “inactive” account where the member has elected to obtain or maintain the insurance cover. The trustee was required by s 68AAA(2) to ensure that each member was invited to elect in writing to take out or maintain insurance cover. Section 68AAA applied from 1 July 2019 and transitional provisions under Item 3 of Part 2 of Schedule 2 of the PYS Act required the trustee to notify members who might be affected by the new measures to provide them with an opportunity to elect for their insurance to continue. As he had not made a contribution since July 2012, the deceased’s account was deemed under s 68AAA to be inactive. He was given notice on 23 April 2019 that he needed to notify the trustee by 30 June 2019 if he wanted his insurance cover to continue. By 30 June 2019 the deceased’s account in the Fund remained inactive. The trustee formed the view that, having not received an election from the deceased, his insurance cover must be cancelled in accordance with the requirements of s 68AAA(1) of the SIS Act. The deceased died between 3 and 5 August 2019. The trustee declined to pay the $80,000 death benefit that would otherwise have been payable in respect of the deceased. The appellant complained to the Authority about the failure to pay. He contended that the deceased had signed and sent a form electing to maintain his insurance cover, a copy of which was found in his personal papers. The Authority affirmed the decision of the trustee not to compromise the appellant’s claim by paying him $80,000. In the present appeal, the appellant challenges the decision of the trustee. The appellant represented himself at the hearing. The trustee was represented by Mr Di Stefano of counsel. The Authority was represented by Mr Wolahan of counsel. The parties all filed written submissions in advance of the hearing. 3. RELEVANT LEGISLATION Section 68AAA of the SYS Act relevantly provides:Benefits provided by taking out insurance--inactive accounts(1)Each trustee of a regulated superannuation fund must ensure that a benefit is not provided by the fund to, or in respect of, a member of the fund under a choice product or MySuper product held by the member by taking out or maintaining insurance if:(a)the member’s account is inactive in relation to that product for a continuous period of 16 months; and(b)the member has not elected under subsection (2) that the benefit will be provided to, or in respect of, the member under the product by taking out or maintaining insurance, even if the member’s account is inactive in relation to that product for a continuous period of 16 months.Note: This section does not apply in relation to regulated superannuation funds with no more than 6 members (see section 68AAD).(2)Each trustee of the regulated superannuation fund must ensure that each member of the fund who holds a choice product or MySuper product offered by the fund may elect, in writing, that a benefit specified in the election is to be provided to, or in respect of, the member under the product by taking out or maintaining insurance, even if the member’s account is inactive in relation to that product for a continuous period of 16 months.(2A) A member's election:(a) that:(i)is given under subsection (2); or(ii)because of a previous application of this subsection, is taken to have been given under subsection (2);to the trustee of a regulated superannuation fund (the original fund ); and(b)that is in force immediately before the transfer of the benefits of the member from the original fund to another regulated superannuation fund (the successor fund );continues in force (and may be dealt with) as if it had been given under subsection (2) to the trustee of the successor fund, if:(c)the successor fund confers on the member equivalent rights to the rights the member had under the original fund in respect of the benefits; and(d)before the transfer, the trustee of the successor fund had agreed with the trustee of the original fund that the successor fund will confer such equivalent rights on the member.(3)For the purposes of this section, a member of a regulated superannuation fund has an account that is inactive in relation to a choice product or MySuper product for a period if the trustee, or trustees of the fund, have not received an amount in respect of the member that relates to that product during that period.(4)The prohibition in subsection (1) ceases to apply to benefits provided to, or in respect of, a member of the fund under a choice product or MySuper product held by the member if the trustee, or trustees of the fund, receive an amount in respect of the member that relates to that product after the account has been inactive in relation to the product for 16 months.(5)However, the prohibition in subsection (1) applies again if the member's account is again inactive in relation to the product for a period of 16 months.…

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Authority erred in law in determining that the trustee had not received the election form from the deceased.
2. Whether the Authority failed to have regard to a relevant consideration, specifically the reliability of the system used by the trustee to comply with the requirements of s 68AAA of the SIS Act.

Held
1. The court concluded that the Authority did not err in law in determining that the trustee had not received the election form from the deceased.
2. The court concluded that the Authority did not fail to have regard to a relevant consideration, specifically the reliability of the system used by the trustee to comply with the requirements of s 68AAA of the SIS Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The second is whether the Authority failed to have regard to a relevant consideration, being the reliability of the system used by the trustee to comply with the requirements of s 68AAA of the SIS Act in circumstances (a) where the trustee should have known that in adopting this system there was an unacceptable risk of insurance being cancelled for members who did not intend to do so, and (b) the trustee could have adopted a better system, that would not have resulted in the deceased’s insurance cover being cancelled, or to obtain insurance to cover the risk of member elections being lost in the mail. 6. CONSIDERATION6.1 The appellant’s submissions The first issue centres on the findings of the Authority that the trustee had not received the election form from the deceased. The appellant asks how, given that the insured complied with his obligation to send the election form, the trustee was able to benefit from the protection from the fault of others (here, the system of mail delivery) to enable it to decline cover. Put another way, he asks how the Authority could be correct to decide that the trustee did not receive the election form in the light of the evidence that it did receive. The appellant submits that the Authority erred because it had evidence under oath from a witness proving that the insured complied to the full extent with the option that was designated by the trustee by mailing the election form and inadequate, unsworn evidence as to the systems in place within the trustee’s offices as to receipt of the form. As the appellant put it in his submissions, “What is the proof of the obligation having been performed as requested and the subsequent loss of cover due to no fault of the insured but at the systems design of the [trustee]”. The appellant submits that there was no evidence before the Authority that enabled it to find that the trustee did not receive the document and thus could not process it, or that the mail system failed, or that a wrong address was placed on the envelope. The second issue posed by the appellant may be summarised as whether the Authority failed to have regard to a relevant consideration, being consideration of the reliability of the system adopted by the trustee to receive notices from an insured. The appellant submits that, prior to the introduction of s 68AAA, death cover continued unless formal notification of cancellation was received. The costs for the cover were deducted from an insured’s superannuation account automatically. With the change, the trustee, in having to receive confirmation from an insured to remain insured should have made sure that the process was “if not fail safe, as fail safe as possible”. He submits that equity requires a consideration as to whether the system designed by the trustee had an unacceptable risk to any insured of non-receipt of a notification. 6.2 Analysis The Authority’s jurisdiction and powers concern the fairness and reasonableness of a decision, not its lawfulness, although by s 1055(7) of the Corporations Act it is prohibited from making a determination that is contrary to law.