Shoalhaven City Council v Firedam Civil Engineering Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FRENCH CJ,
GUMMOW, HEYDON, CRENNAN, KIEFEL AND BELL JJ

SHOALHAVEN CITY COUNCIL   APPELLANT

AND

FIREDAM CIVIL ENGINEERING PTY LIMITED  RESPONDENT

Shoalhaven City Council v Firedam Civil Engineering Pty Limited
[2011] HCA 38
5 October 2011
S216/2010

ORDER

1.        Appeal allowed.

2.Set aside the order of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales made on 19 April 2010 and, in place thereof, order that the appeal to that Court be dismissed with costs.

3.The respondent pay the appellant's costs of the appeal to this Court.

On appeal from the Supreme Court of New South Wales

Representation

D F Jackson QC with J A Steele for the appellant (instructed by TressCox Lawyers)

Submitting appearance for the respondent

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. A person ("the Expert"), appointed under the provisions of a construction contract ("the Contract") to provide an expert determination of issues in dispute between the principal and the contractor, made a determination which the contractor contended was not binding on it.  The contractor sought a declaration to that effect in the Supreme Court of New South Wales.  The contractor's complaint related to the Expert's refusal to allow certain extensions of time which it claimed as of right arising out of variations to the works.  That refusal was said to be inconsistent with the Expert's use of a contractual discretion, conferred on the principal, to extend the time for completion of the works.  The discretionary extension was used by the Expert, in assessing the principal's claim for compensation for the contractor's delays, to allocate responsibility for delays between the principal and the contractor.  The contractor contended that the Expert's reasons for his determination, burdened with an unexplained inconsistency, meant that the determination did not accord with the requirements of the Contract and was therefore not binding on the contractor.

  2. The contractor's summons for a declaration was dismissed by Tamberlin AJ[1].  However, an appeal against that decision was allowed by the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales (Beazley, Campbell and Macfarlan JJA)[2].  The orders made by Tamberlin AJ were set aside and a declaration made that the Expert's determination was not binding on the parties.  Special leave to appeal to this Court against the judgment and orders of the Court of Appeal was granted on 3 September 2010 by Gummow, Heydon and Kiefel JJ.  The contractor was wound up by resolution of its creditors on 26 November 2010.  The appeal is continued pursuant to leave granted by McDougall J in the Supreme Court of New South Wales on 10 December 2010.  The contractor was not represented at the hearing of the appeal.

  3. The Expert's use of the principal's discretion to extend time as…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Shoalhaven City Council v Firedam Civil Engineering Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] HCA 38
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a dispute between Shoalhaven City Council (appellant) and Firedam Civil Engineering Pty Ltd (respondent) regarding a construction contract. The core of the dispute revolved around an expert determination made pursuant to a dispute resolution clause in the contract, which required the expert to provide reasons for their decision. Firedam contended that the expert's reasons were inconsistent, thereby invalidating the determination. The case reached the High Court of Australia following decisions by the primary judge and the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

The High Court was required to determine whether the expert's determination contained inconsistencies in its reasons, and if so, whether the court possessed the power to review and set aside such a determination made under the contract. Specifically, the court had to consider whether the expert's findings regarding Firedam's claims for extensions of time and the assessment of damages were logically coherent and adequately explained.

The High Court allowed the appeal, setting aside the order of the Court of Appeal and dismissing Firedam's appeal to that court with costs. The High Court found that the expert had not acted inconsistently in their reasons. The expert had considered different claims based on distinct criteria and had used the power to extend time under clause 54.6 as a mechanism to establish a benchmark for assessing general damages, rather than as a direct award of delay costs under clause 55.1. The court concluded that the expert's reasons, when read as a whole, provided a valid and sufficient explanation for the determination, and that the Court of Appeal had erred in finding inconsistencies that would warrant judicial intervention.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed.

2. Set aside the order of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales made on 19 April 2010 and, in place thereof, order that the appeal to that Court be dismissed with costs.

3. The respondent pay the appellant's costs of the appeal to this Court.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH CJ, CRENNAN AND KIEFEL JJ GUMMOW AND BELL JJ HEYDON J (dissent)
It was accepted before the primary judge that his Honour's decision in relation to variation 10(a) would determine, by parity of reasoning, the outcome in relation to variation 62. In the event that Firedam was unsuccessful in those matters, its challenge in respect of variation 12 would not be pressed. His Honour held:.There was no inconsistency between the reasons of the Expert for rejecting Firedam's claim for an extension of time pursuant to variation 10(a) and his reasons for allowing an extension of time of nine days in the exercise of the discretion conferred on Shoalhaven by cl 54.6. The Expert was dealing with different claims, based on different criteria and calling for different findings[20]..The Expert had used Shoalhaven's power to extend time under cl 54.6 in order to arrive at a reasonable and fair means by which general damages, the subject of Shoalhaven's cross-claim, could be calculated[21]..The Expert determined the nine day extension so that there would be a benchmark against which Shoalhaven's claim could be assessed[22]. .By parity of reasoning Firedam's submissions in relation to variation 62 were rejected. In light of the rejection of its claims in relation to variations 10(a) and 62, it did not press its claims in relation to variation 12[23]. [20][2009] NSWSC 802 at [34].[21][2009] NSWSC 802 at [34].[22][2009] NSWSC 802 at [35].[23][2009] NSWSC 802 at [38].The decision of the Court of Appeal The principal reasons for judgment in the Court of Appeal were delivered by Macfarlan JA. Beazley JA concurred, as did Campbell JA subject to qualifications and additional matters expressed in his Honour's separate reasons for judgment. Macfarlan JA's reasons involved the following steps: .The Expert Determination in relation to variation 10(a), that a delay of nine days should be attributed to Shoalhaven, was inconsistent with his finding, in relation to that variation, that Firedam had not discharged its onus of showing that delay for a defined period had occurred and that the additional work required caused delay in reaching completion[24]. .The Expert Determination in relation to variation 62, granting an extension of 89 days pursuant to cl 54.6, reflected a finding of fact inconsistent with the Expert's conclusion in dealing with Firedam's claims[25]. .It could be assumed, without deciding, that the Expert had the power to grant an extension of time under cl 54.6 – that proposition was not in issue[26]..The Expert's extension of time under cl 54.6 was granted because of a variation or breach of contract by Shoalhaven, which would have attracted the application of cl 55.1. Yet he awarded no delay costs under cl 55.1 to Firedam[27]..The Expert did not tell Firedam why it was not entitled to delay costs and thus "failed to give proper reasons for his decision"[28]. The Determination did not answer the contractual description[29].[24][2010] NSWCA 59 at [41].[25][2010] NSWCA 59 at [44].[26][2010] NSWCA 59 at [54].[27][2010] NSWCA 59 at [57].[28][2010] NSWCA 59 at [60].[29][2010] NSWCA 59 at [60], [63].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH CJ, CRENNAN AND KIEFEL JJ, GUMMOW AND BELL JJ,