State of South Australia v Goldstein

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA v GOLDSTEIN

[2016] SASC 202

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Blue

22 December 2016

CONTRACTS - BUILDING, ENGINEERING AND RELATED CONTRACTS - THE CONTRACT

CONTRACTS - BUILDING, ENGINEERING AND RELATED CONTRACTS - PERFORMANCE OF WORK - REMEDIES FOR BREACH OF CONTRACT

ARBITRATION

Action seeking declarations of invalidity of expert determinations and that they are not binding on the plaintiff. Third party action seeking parallel relief against the third parties in the alternative to the defence.

The plaintiff entered into a head contract with the second defendant for, inter alia, the design and construction of the new Royal Adelaide Hospital. The second defendant entered into a back to back construction contract with the third parties for the design and construction of the Hospital.

Clause 40.3(b) of the head contract, and clause 40(g) of the construction contract, provided that any dispute as to whether:

i.  something is a Defect or related to the rectification of a Defect; or

ii. damage to the Facility that has been caused by a Defect,

will be referred by either party for resolution by an Independent Expert in accordance with the Accelerated Dispute Resolution Procedures.

In February 2016, the plaintiff served amongst others defect notices alleging defects by undersized floor distribution rooms, an under-height loading dock, undersized ceiling exclusion zones and sewer pipes encroaching into the primary data room.

In July 2016, the third parties served on the second defendant and the second defendant served on the plaintiff dispute notices referring disputes to expert determination in respect of amongst others the alleged defects.

Disputes emerged concerning amongst other things:

1.  whether there had been informal agreement by State officers or employees to reduce the specified size of floor distribution rooms;

2.  whether defects involving the loading dock height, clinical areas ceiling exclusion zones and the primary data room pipes are reasonably capable of rectification;

3.  whether the State intends to rectify the defect involving the loading dock height;

4.  whether risk mitigation works carried out by the third parties are reasonable and sufficient to mitigate the defect involving the primary data room pipes.

In August 2016, the parties appointed the first defendant as independent expert to determine the disputes. It was agreed that the first defendant would determine whether the disputes fell within the scope of clause 40.3 and, if so, determine the substantive disputes (the expert agreement).

In September 2016, the first defendant issued expert determinations. He determined amongst other things that:

1.  State officers or employees had informally agreed to a reduction in the size of floor distribution rooms and the alleged defect in this respect was not a defect;

2.  the defects involving the loading dock height, clinical areas ceiling exclusion zones and the primary data room pipes are not reasonably capable of rectification;

3.  the State does not intend to rectify the defect involving the loading dock height;

4.  risk mitigation works carried out by the third parties are reasonable and sufficient to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read State of South Australia v Goldstein and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] SASC 202
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of State of South Australia v Goldstein revolves around disputes arising from a construction project involving the New Royal Adelaide Hospital. The State of South Australia, represented by the Minister for Health, entered into contracts with SAHP and HYLC for the design, construction, and maintenance of the hospital. The dispute primarily concerns the jurisdiction and determinations of Mr Goldstein, who was appointed as an independent expert under the contracts. The core legal issues the court had to address included whether Mr Goldstein had the authority to make certain determinations, whether the State was bound by his determinations, and the validity of the State's referral to arbitration concerning these determinations.

The court meticulously examined the contractual provisions, specifically clause 40.3(b) of the contracts, which outlined the procedures for dispute resolution and the scope of the independent expert's authority. The court found that Mr Goldstein's jurisdiction was limited to specific matters outlined in the contracts and did not extend to determining issues beyond the scope of the submitted disputes. The court also determined that the State's referral to arbitration was valid as the determinations in question were worth more than $1 million, and the conditional nature of the referral did not invalidate it.

In its reasoning, the court clarified that the State was entitled to refer certain disputes to arbitration under clause 71(o) of the contracts. The court rejected SAHP's argument that the notice of arbitration was invalid because it was conditional. The court further granted the State's request for declarations that certain proposed determinations by Mr Goldstein were beyond his jurisdiction, emphasizing that these determinations were either abandoned or hypothetical and thus not subject to declaration. This ruling helped clarify the boundaries of Mr Goldstein's authority and the process for resolving disputes under the contracts.

The final orders of the court affirmed the validity of the State's referral to arbitration and granted the declarations sought by the State, clarifying the scope of Mr Goldstein's jurisdiction and the nature of the disputes that could be referred to arbitration. This decision provided essential guidance on the interpretation of the contracts and the resolution of disputes in similar construction projects.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The following issues arise in the action:1.Did the parties agree, by their agreement appointing Mr Goldstein as the independent expert, that he was to determine conclusively his own jurisdiction to determine the substantive disputes?2.Did Mr Goldstein have jurisdiction under the contracts to determine whether there was a defect in respect of floor distribution room sizes by reference to matters other than the original contractual specification?3.Did Mr Goldstein have jurisdiction under the contracts to determine whether the rectification of defects involving the loading dock height, clinical areas ceiling exclusion zones and primary data room pipes is reasonable?4.Did Mr Goldstein have jurisdiction under the contracts to determine whether the State intends to rectify defects involving the loading dock height?5.Did Mr Goldstein have jurisdiction to determine whether risk mitigation works carried out by HYLC were reasonable and sufficient to mitigate the defect involving primary data room pipes?6.Is the State bound by Mr Goldstein’s determinations and if so to what extent and for what purposes?7.Was the State’s referral to arbitration of its disputes in respect of the expert’s substantive determinations ineffective because the value of the determination was not greater than $1 million or because the referral was expressed to be subject to the outcome of this action?8.Should declarations be granted at the instance of the State that Mr Goldstein did not have jurisdiction to make determinations that he did not make?Background On 20 May 2011, the Minister for Health on behalf of the State entered into the New Royal Adelaide Hospital Project Project Agreement (the head contract) with SAHP (designated “Project Co”) for the design, construction and financing of the Hospital to be completed by 4 April 2016 and the maintenance, licensed non-clinical operation and financing of the Hospital from the Date of Commercial Acceptance until 35 years after satisfaction of the conditions precedent (the Operating Term). SAHP’s remuneration was payable by quarterly service payments in arrears between the Date of Commercial Acceptance and the conclusion of the Operating Term (clauses 50.1, 1.1 and Schedule 3). On 20 May 2011, SAHP entered into the New Royal Adelaide Hospital Project Construction Agreement with HYLC (designated “the Builder”) for the design and construction of the Hospital for $1,849,834,546 exclusive of GST (the construction contract). For ease of reference, I refer to the head and construction contracts indiscriminately as the contracts. Clause 2.6(b) of the head contract summarises the principal responsibilities of SAHP in the following terms:Project Co must, in accordance with this Agreement:(i) finance or procure the financing of the Project;(ii)design the Works and in so doing manage the Design Development Process and procedure prepare the Design Documentation;(iii) construct the Facility;(iv) achieve Technical Completion and Commercial Acceptance;(v) provide the Services;(vi) deliver the Facility in accordance with the Handback Condition;(vii)perform all other obligations under this Agreement (except those obligations expressly required to be performed by the State under this Agreement); and(viii)pay the Licence Fee to the State under the Operating Term Licence to occupy and use the Site for the performance of the Services.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

I reject SAHP’s contention that the notice of arbitration is invalid because it was conditional.Conclusion The State was entitled pursuant to clause 71(o) to refer to arbitration the disputes the subject of the determination and it did so by its notice of arbitration dated 12 October 2016.Declarations concerning determinations sought but abandoned When the State instituted the action, HYLC and SAHP by the dispute notices were seeking determinations in respect of one or more of the four defects that ultimately became the subject of the trial including the following determinations:1.the defect complained of presents no loss of functionality or amenity and the nil sum modification change notice should be accepted by [Project Co/the State] as it will have no effect on the matters particularised in the change notice … and will not result in any Costs or Savings to be apportioned;2.alternatively, if the Independent Expert determines that there will be any savings associated with the modification, the modification change notice should be accepted for the reasons above subject to the payment to [Project Co/the State] of an amount determined by the Independent Expert as being [Project Co/the State]’s share of the net cost savings calculated in accordance with cl 52.13(c) and the change in compensation principles in schedule 4;3.further to 2 or in the alternative, if [the State/Project Co] contends and the Independent Expert agrees, that [the State/Project Co] has suffered loss as a consequence of the defect, the Independent Expert should approve the modification to remove the roadblock to technical completion and determine the fact and extent of any loss. Compensation for such loss should be agreed by the parties within seven days of the Independent Expert determination or, failing that, be determined by the Independent Expert in accordance with orthodox legal principle;4.If the Independent Expert finds that there is a defect, the defect complained of presents a minor loss of functionality or amenity and [HYLC/SAHP]’s rectification works, together with the modification change notice, providing a credit of [amount] should be accepted by [Project Co/the State]. HYLC and SAHP by the dispute notices were also seeking determinations in respect of one or more of the other eight defects the subject of the dispute notices that ultimately did not become the subject of the trial including the following determinations:1.if … the defect can be remedied, a determination … whether the defect could be treated as a technical completion outstanding item in order to mitigate any further loss or damage that would be suffered by [the State/Project Co] as a result of delays flowing from that rectification;2.If the … Defect cannot be rectified, the terms of a modification that would be required in order to remove the Defect …; The State seeks a declaration that these six proposed determinations were beyond the scope of the submission of a dispute for independent expert determination pursuant to clause 40.3(b) of the contract. SAHP and in turn HYLC resist the making of a declaration on the ground that they withdrew their requests for these six determinations at the end of August 2016 when they acknowledged that they were outside the expert’s jurisdiction, and a declaration should not be granted on matters not in dispute or matters that are hypothetical.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established