Westfield Management Ltd v AMP Capital Property Nominees Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FRENCH CJ,
HEYDON, CRENNAN, KIEFEL AND BELL JJ

WESTFIELD MANAGEMENT LIMITED AS
TRUSTEE FOR THE WESTART TRUST  APPELLANT

AND

AMP CAPITAL PROPERTY NOMINEES LIMITED
AS NOMINEE OF UNISUPER LIMITED IN ITS
CAPACITY AS TRUSTEE OF THE COMPLYING
SUPERANNUATION FUND KNOWN AS
UNISUPER & ANOR  RESPONDENTS

Westfield Management Limited v AMP Capital Property Nominees Limited

[2012] HCA 54

5 December 2012

S181/2012

ORDER

Appeal dismissed with costs.

On appeal from the Supreme Court of New South Wales

Representation

B W Walker SC with J Potts and J Hewitt for the appellant (instructed by Speed and Stracey Lawyers)

D F Jackson QC with M I Borsky and W A D Edwards for the respondents (instructed by Allens Lawyers)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

Westfield Management Limited v AMP Capital Property Nominees Limited

Contract law – Interpretation – Unitholders' agreement prohibited sale of trust property without unitholders' prior written consent – Whether prohibition on sale without consent fettered unitholder's right to vote for extraordinary resolution to wind up managed investment scheme under s 601NB of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).

Corporations law – Managed investment scheme – Trust registered as managed investment scheme under Ch 5C of the Corporations Act – Injunction obtained restraining majority unitholder from voting for extraordinary resolution to direct winding up of managed investment scheme under s 601NB of the Corporations Act without minority unitholder's consent – Minority unitholder alleged vote would contravene prohibition in unitholders' agreement – Whether unitholder's statutory right to vote under s 601NB can be fettered by contractual agreement.

Words and phrases – "extraordinary resolution directing the responsible entity to wind up the scheme", "managed investment scheme", "wind up".

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), Ch 5C, s 601NB.

  1. FRENCH CJ, CRENNAN, KIEFEL AND BELL JJ. The KSC Trust ("the Trust") is a managed investment scheme which is registered under Ch 5C of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). AMP Capital Investors Limited ("AMPCI") (formerly AMP Henderson Global Investors Limited) is the responsible entity of the scheme and the trustee of the Trust, which was constituted under a trust deed dated 23 March 1994 ("the Trust Deed"). The appellant, Westfield Management Limited ("Westfield") (in its capacity as trustee for the Westart Trust), and the first respondent, AMP Capital Property Nominees Limited ("AMPCN") (as nominee of the second respondent, UniSuper Limited), are unitholders of the Trust and members of the registered scheme[1].  Westfield holds one-third of the units and AMPCN the remaining two-thirds.

    [1]In these reasons the terms "unitholders" and "members" are used interchangeably.

  2. On 29 March 1994, the initial unitholders and the responsible entity entered into a Unitholders' and Joint Venture Agreement ("the Agreement"), which was varied on 30 October 2000[2].  The focus of this appeal is upon the terms of the Agreement.

    [2]In 1994 and 2000, the unitholders were entities other than Westfield and AMPCN.  When these companies later became unitholders, they both acceded to the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Westfield Management Ltd v AMP Capital Property Nominees Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] HCA 54
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia considered a dispute between Westfield Management Limited (appellant) and AMP Capital Property Nominees Ltd and UniSuper Limited (respondents) concerning the proposed winding up of a managed investment scheme. The Karrinyup Regional Shopping Centre was the primary asset of the KSC Trust, which was registered as a managed investment scheme under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The respondents, holding two-thirds of the units, wished to pass a resolution under s 601NB of the Act directing the responsible entity to wind up the scheme, which would involve selling the shopping centre and distributing the proceeds. The appellant, holding one-third of the units, opposed this and sought to prevent the respondents from voting for the resolution without its prior written consent, alleging a breach of a Unitholders' and Joint Venture Agreement.

The central legal issue before the High Court was whether a provision within the Unitholders' and Joint Venture Agreement, which prohibited the sale of the trust property without unitholders' written consent, operated to fetter a unitholder's statutory right to vote for an extraordinary resolution to wind up the managed investment scheme under s 601NB of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). Specifically, the court had to determine if the contractual prohibition on sale could override the statutory right to direct the winding up of the scheme.

The High Court reasoned that the statutory right conferred by s 601NB of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) to direct the winding up of a managed investment scheme could not be fettered by a contractual agreement. The court noted that while the Agreement contained provisions regarding the sale of the Karrinyup Regional Shopping Centre and the determination of the Trust, these provisions did not prevent a unitholder from exercising their statutory right to vote for a winding up. The court drew an analogy to English case law where provisions in a company's articles of association attempting to limit statutory rights were held invalid. The court concluded that the Agreement did not prevent AMP Capital Property Nominees Ltd from voting in favour of the winding up resolution.

Consequently, the High Court dismissed the appeal with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Karrinyup Regional Shopping Centre (KRS Centre) is the principal asset of the Karrinyup Shopping Centre Trust (KSC Trust). The KSC Trust is a unit trust and a managed investment scheme registered under Chapter 5C of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). AMP Capital Investors Ltd (AMPCI) is the trustee of the KSC Trust and the responsible entity of the scheme. Westfield Management Ltd (Westfield) holds one-third of the units in the KSC Trust, while AMP Capital Property Nominees Ltd (AMPCN), as nominee of UniSuper Limited (UniSuper), holds the remaining two-thirds. The dispute arises from AMPCN's intention to propose a resolution under section 601NB of the Corporations Act to wind up the KSC Trust, which would result in the sale of the KRS Centre and distribution of the proceeds among the unitholders. Westfield opposes this resolution and seeks to prevent AMPCN from voting in favour of it without Westfield's prior written consent.

The Unitholders' and Joint Venture Agreement (Agreement) governs the relationship between AMPCI, Westfield, and AMPCN. Clause 10.1 of the Agreement prohibits AMPCI, as the responsible entity, from selling the KRS Centre or any substantial part thereof without the written consent of all unitholders. It also mandates the termination of the Trust upon the sale of the entirety of the KRS Centre unless otherwise directed by the unitholders. Clause 10.2 similarly restricts AMPCI from acquiring any investments other than the KRS Centre or for the short-term investment of liquid funds without the written consent of the unitholders. Clause 16.2 of the Agreement further stipulates that all unitholders agree to exercise their voting rights to fully effect the provisions of the Agreement.

Westfield argues that the prohibition on selling the KRS Centre without unitholders' consent also restricts AMPCN's right to vote for a winding-up resolution under section 601NB of the Corporations Act. Westfield contends that such a vote would contravene the Agreement. Consequently, Westfield seeks an injunction to restrain AMPCN from voting for the winding-up resolution without its consent. The legal dispute centres on whether the contractual prohibition on selling the KRS Centre without consent can fettered the statutory right of unitholders to vote for a winding-up resolution under section 601NB of the Corporations Act.

The matter of Westfield Management Ltd v AMP Capital Property Nominees Ltd came before the court on appeal. The appellant, Westfield Management Ltd, sought to restrain the respondents from voting for a resolution to wind up the managed investment scheme without the prior written consent of the appellant. The respondents, AMP Capital Property Nominees Ltd and UniSuper Limited, sought to proceed with the resolution to wind up the scheme. The appeal arose from an interlocutory injunction obtained by the appellant restraining the respondents from voting for the resolution. The appeal was heard on the basis of written submissions and oral arguments, with the primary focus being on the interpretation of the Unitholders' and Joint Venture Agreement and the statutory provisions of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The court considered the precedent set in In re Peveril Gold Mines Ltd, where it was held that a company's articles of association could not limit members' statutory rights. This case similarly examines whether the contractual prohibition on the sale of trust property without unitholders' consent fetters the unitholder's right to vote for an extraordinary resolution to wind up the scheme. The appeal was dismissed with costs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH CJ, CRENNAN, KIEFEL AND BELL JJ HEYDON J
In re Peveril Gold Mines Ltd[41] may be considered pertinent to this case. There, the articles of association of a company purported to limit members' statutory rights. At that time, s 82 of the Companies Act 1862 (UK) gave members the right to present a petition for the winding up of the company. Byrne J, at first instance, observed that the articles could be regarded as a contract between the company and a prospective shareholder and that the company had no right to remove a safeguard provided by the Act as part of that contract[42]. In the Court of Appeal, Lindley MR said that registered limited companies are incorporated on certain conditions, including s 82[43]. Any article which, contrary to that section, limited the right of a contributory to petition for a winding up would be at variance with the statutory condition and invalid. Although the judgments do not refer, in terms, to the policy of the Act, it is evident that it was that to which the Court considered it was giving effect.[41][1898] 1 Ch 122.[42]In re Peveril Gold Mines Ltd [1898] 1 Ch 122 at 125-126.[43]In re Peveril Gold Mines Ltd [1898] 1 Ch 122 at 131.Conclusion and orders The Agreement does not operate so as to prevent AMPCN voting in favour of a winding up of the scheme constituted by the Trust at a meeting called to consider a resolution to that effect. The appeal should be dismissed with costs. The Karrinyup Regional Shopping Centre is the principal asset of the KSC Trust. The KSC Trust is a unit trust. It is a managed investment scheme registered under Ch 5C of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ("the Act"). AMP Capital Investors Ltd ("AMPCI") is the trustee of the KSC Trust, and the responsible entity of the scheme. One-third of the units in the KSC Trust are held by the appellant, Westfield Management Limited. Two‑thirds are held by the first respondent, AMP Capital Property Nominees Limited, in its capacity as nominee of the second respondent, UniSuper Limited. The first respondent wants the unitholders to pass a resolution under s 601NB of the Act directing AMPCI, as the responsible entity, to wind up the scheme[44]. If the scheme were wound up, the Karrinyup Regional Shopping Centre would be sold and the proceeds would be distributed among the unitholders. The appellant opposes the resolution, and seeks to restrain the respondents from voting for it without the prior written consent of the appellant. [44]For s 601NB, see above at [3]. The outcome of this appeal turns entirely on the terms of the Unitholders' and Joint Venture Agreement ("the Agreement"). AMPCI, the appellant and the respondents are bound by the Agreement. Clause 10.1 of the Agreement provides:"(a)[AMPCI], in its capacity as responsible entity of the KSC Trust, shall not sell the [Karrinyup Regional Shopping Centre] or any substantial part thereof, without the written consent of the Unitholders.(b)On completion of the sale of the [Karrinyup Regional Shopping Centre], or if part of the [Karrinyup Regional Shopping Centre] has already been sold, the completion of the sale of the remainder of the [Karrinyup Regional Shopping Centre], [AMPCI], in its capacity as responsible entity of the KSC Trust, shall thereupon determine the Trust unless otherwise directed by the Unitholders."Clause 10.2 of the Agreement provides: "[AMPCI], in its capacity as responsible entity of the KSC Trust, shall not without the written consent of the Unitholders acquire any investments other than the [Karrinyup Regional Shopping Centre] or for the short-term investment of liquid funds." Clause 16.2 of the Agreement provides: "Each and all of the Unitholders mutually agree that they will so exercise their respective voting rights as unitholders under the Trust Deed so as to most fully and completely give effect to the intent and effect of the provisions of this deed."

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH CJ, CRENNAN, KIEFEL AND BELL JJ, HEYDON J

The court in Westfield Management Ltd v AMP Capital Property Nominees Ltd examined the interplay between contractual restrictions and statutory rights in the context of managed investment schemes. The key issue was whether the prohibition on selling the Karrinyup Regional Shopping Centre without unitholders' written consent, as stipulated in the Unitholders' Agreement, could feasibly restrict unitholders' right to vote for an extraordinary resolution to wind up the scheme under section 601NB of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The court delved into the interpretation of the Unitholders' and Joint Venture Agreement, particularly Clause 10.1, which prohibited the sale of the shopping centre without written consent, and Clause 16.2, which required unitholders to exercise their voting rights in a manner that gave effect to the Agreement's provisions.

In addressing whether the prohibition on selling the property without consent could fetter the unitholders' right to vote, the court relied on the principle that statutory rights are often paramount to contractual restrictions that seek to diminish them. The court noted that the purpose of section 601NB was to provide unitholders with the right to direct the winding up of the scheme, a fundamental aspect of their investment rights under the Act. The court distinguished between the nature of the statutory right and the contractual restriction, concluding that the latter could not override the former. This interpretation was guided by the principle established in In re Peveril Gold Mines Ltd, where it was held that contractual agreements could not limit statutory rights provided by legislation, particularly when such statutory rights were integral to the legislative scheme.

Further, the court examined whether the statutory right to vote under section 601NB could be fettered by the contractual agreement in the Unitholders' and Joint Venture Agreement. The court held that contractual provisions could not abridge the statutory rights granted by the Corporations Act. The court emphasized that managed investment schemes are subject to specific statutory protections designed to safeguard unitholders' interests, and any attempt to limit these statutory rights through contractual means would be ineffective. This interpretation aligns with the broader policy of the Act to ensure that unitholders have significant control over the winding up of the scheme.

Moreover, the court addressed whether the Unitholders' Agreement could prevent AMP Capital Property Nominees Limited from voting in favour of a winding up of the scheme. The court determined that the Agreement did not operate to prevent AMP Capital from exercising its statutory right to vote. The court reasoned that the Agreement could not be used to circumvent the statutory right to direct the winding up of the scheme, as such a right was fundamental to the legislative framework governing managed investment schemes. The court's decision was grounded in the principle that statutory rights are sacrosanct and cannot be easily restricted by private agreements.

In conclusion, the court dismissed the appeal and held that the Unitholders' Agreement did not prevent AMP Capital from voting in favour of a winding up of the scheme. The court's reasoning was rooted in the principle that statutory rights under the Corporations Act cannot be fettered by contractual restrictions, particularly when such statutory rights are designed to protect unitholders' fundamental interests. This decision reinforces the paramountcy of statutory rights in managed investment schemes and ensures that unitholders retain the ability to direct the winding up of the scheme, as provided by the Act.