Richore Pty Ltd v Cougar Metals Nl (Subject to DOCA)

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

CITATION:   RICHORE PTY LTD  -v- COUGAR METALS NL (SUBJECT TO DOCA) [2023] WASC 2

CORAM:   ARCHER J

HEARD:   26 & 27 MAY 2022

DELIVERED          :   20 JANUARY 2023

FILE NO/S:   GDA 14 of 2021

BETWEEN:   RICHORE PTY LTD

First Appellant

PYKE HILL RESOURCES PTY LTD

Second Appellant

AND

COUGAR METALS NL (SUBJECT TO DOCA)

Respondent


Catchwords:

Proper construction of option agreement - Essential term - Exemption under s 103 of the Mining Act 1978 (WA) - Effect of exemption - Did it retrospectively cure a breach of the agreement - Schrodinger's cat - Raising a new case on appeal

Legislation:

Mining Act 1978 (WA), s 103

Result:

Appeal allowed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

First Appellant : M D Cuerden SC & D R Chandler
Second Appellant : M D Cuerden SC & D R Chandler
Respondent : N Gentilli

Solicitors:

First Appellant : Lawton Macmaster Legal
Second Appellant : Lawton Macmaster Legal
Respondent : Jackson McDonald

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Amcor Limited v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2005] HCA 10; (2005) 222 CLR 241

Ankar Pty Ltd v National Westminster Finance (Australia) Ltd [1987] HCA 15; (1987) 162 CLR 549

Black Box Control Pty Ltd v Terravision Pty Ltd [2016] WASCA 219

Commercial Properties v Italo Nominees Pty Ltd (Unreported, WASCA, Library No 7427, 16 December 1988)

Concut Pty Ltd v Worrell [2000] HCA 64; (2000) 176 ALR 693

Cougar Metal NL v Richore Pty Ltd and Pyke Hill Resources Pty Ltd [2021] WAWC 1

Cromarty Resources Pty Ltd v Thalanga Copper Mines Pty Ltd [2021] NSWCA 284

Electricity Generation and Retail Corporation trading as Synergy v EIT Kwinana Partner Ptd Ltd [2022] WASCA 3

Forrest & Forrest Pty Ltd v Minister for Mines and Petroleum [2017] WASCA 153; (2017) 51 WAR 425

Forrest & Forrest Pty Ltd v The Honourable William Richard Marmion, Minister for Mines and Petroleum [2018] WASCA 32; (2018) 53 WAR 156

Hong Kong Fir Shipping Co Ltd v Kawasaki Kisen Kaisha Ltd [1962] 2 QB 26

Jones v Dunkel [1959] HCA 8; (1959) 101 CLR 298

Koompahtoo Local Aboriginal Land Council v Sanpine Pty Ltd [2007] HCA 61; (2007) 233 CLR 115

Nova Resources NL v French (1995) 12 WAR 50

Pilbara Iron Ore Pty Ltd v Ammon [2020] WASCA 92

Re Boothman SM; Ex parte M J Edmonson (1984) Pty Ltd v W J Flint unreported; SCt of WA; Library No 980361; 24 June 1998

Re Roberts SM; Ex parte Burge [2003] WASCA 2

Richore v Cougar [2020] WAWC 1

Sino Iron Pty Ltd v Mineralogy Pty Ltd [2019] WASCA 80; (2019) 55 WAR 89

Strahan v Brennan [2014] WASC 190, 22

Tramways Advertising Pty Ltd v Luna Park (NSW) Ltd (1938) 38 SR (NSW) 632

Westfield Management Ltd v AMP Capital Property Nominees Ltd [2012] HCA 54; (2012) 247 CLR 129

Zerjavic v Chevron Australia Pty Ltd [2020] WASCA 40

TABLE…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Richore Pty Ltd v Cougar Metals Nl (Subject to DOCA) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] WASC 2
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Pyke Hill and Richore have appealed against the warden's dismissal of their plaint in which they sought, among other things, an order that Cougar Metals NL terminate an Option Agreement. The warden dismissed the plaint on the basis that the terms that Pyke Hill alleged Cougar breached were not essential terms of the Option Agreement and that Pyke Hill was not therefore entitled to terminate the Option Agreement. Pyke Hill and Richore contend that the warden was wrong to find that the terms breached were not essential terms, and that therefore Pyke Hill was not entitled to terminate the Option Agreement. They further contend that the warden was wrong to find that Cougar did not breach the terms that were alleged to have been breached, or that if he did find a breach, he was wrong to do so. Cougar contends that the warden was correct to find that the terms that were allegedly breached were not essential terms, and that even if the warden found a breach, this finding was wrong. Cougar also contends that any breach was caused by Richore and that, in any event, any breach was cured by an exemption from the statutory expenditure requirement. The appeal hearing was stayed to allow Pyke Hill and Richore to apply for leave to proceed against Cougar. Cougar consented to leave being granted, and leave was granted.

The court must decide whether Pyke Hill and Richore have leave to proceed against Cougar, and if so, whether the warden was correct to find that the terms allegedly breached were not essential terms and that therefore Pyke Hill was not entitled to terminate the Option Agreement. The court must also decide whether the warden was correct to find that Cougar did not breach the terms that were alleged to have been breached, or that if he did find a breach, he was wrong to do so. The court must decide these questions in light of the evidence that was before the warden and the submissions that have been made by the parties. The court must also decide whether the terms allegedly breached were essential terms, and whether a breach of those terms entitled Pyke Hill to terminate the Option Agreement. The court must decide these questions in light of the evidence that was before the warden and the submissions that have been made by the parties. Finally, the court must decide whether Cougar's breach of the terms that were allegedly breached entitled Pyke Hill to terminate the Option Agreement. The court must decide this question in light of the evidence that was before the warden and the submissions that have been made by the parties.

The court found that Pyke Hill and Richore have leave to proceed against Cougar. The court found that the warden was correct to find that the terms allegedly breached were not essential terms, and that therefore Pyke Hill was not entitled to terminate the Option Agreement. The court found that the warden was also correct to find that Cougar did not breach the terms that were alleged to have been breached, or that if he did find a breach, he was wrong to do so. The court found that the terms allegedly breached were not essential terms, and that therefore Pyke Hill was not entitled to terminate the Option Agreement. The court found that a breach of those terms did not entitle Pyke Hill to terminate the Option Agreement. The court found that the warden's decision should be affirmed.

The court orders that the appeal be dismissed with costs. The court orders that the costs of the appeal be paid by Pyke Hill and Richore to Cougar on an indemnity basis.

Background

Background to the litigation

Richore Pty Ltd and Pyke Hill Resources Pty Ltd entered into an Option Agreement with Cougar Metals NL, pursuant to which Cougar was granted the right to explore for and mine minerals on certain mining leases. Pyke Hill and Richore brought proceedings against Cougar in the Wardens Court, alleging breaches of the Option Agreement, including the failure to meet statutory minimum annual expenditure. The warden dismissed the plaint, finding that while Cougar had breached the Option Agreement, the breached terms were not essential, and therefore Pyke Hill did not have the right to terminate the Option Agreement. Pyke Hill and Richore have appealed against the warden's decision, focusing on the alleged failure to meet the statutory minimum annual expenditure and contending that this was an essential term breach entitling Pyke Hill to terminate the Option Agreement.

The case originated in the Wardens Court where Pyke Hill and Richore filed a plaint against Cougar, alleging breaches of the Option Agreement. The warden dismissed the plaint, and Pyke Hill and Richore appealed to the court. Prior to the hearing of the appeal, it was realised that leave to proceed against Cougar should have been sought before filing the plaint and the notice of appeal. An originating process seeking leave was filed the day before the appeal hearing, and Cougar consented to leave being granted. The appeal was subsequently heard, and the court made orders granting leave to proceed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The warden dismissed the plaint (Decision).[3] It is not entirely clear from the Decision whether his Honour found that Cougar had breached the Option Agreement in each of the three ways alleged. However, his Honour clearly found that the terms allegedly breached were not essential terms and did not give Pyke Hill the right to terminate the Option Agreement.[3] Cougar Metal NL v Richore Pty Ltd and Pyke Hill Resources Pty Ltd [2021] WAWC 1 (Decision). Pyke Hill and Richore have appealed against the Decision. In the appeal, they rely only on the alleged failure to cause the statutory minimum annual expenditure to be met in breach of cl 6(a)(ii).[4] They submit that the warden did find that Cougar had failed to do this. However, if I do not accept that, they submit that the warden should have made that finding. This is ground 1 of the Appeal. The appellants further submit that cl 6(a)(ii) was an essential term of the Option Agreement, and that therefore Cougar's breach of the clause entitled Pyke Hill to terminate the Option Agreement. This is ground 2 of the Appeal.[4] ts 22 - 23. Cougar submits that the warden was correct to find that cl 6(a)(ii) was not an essential term. Cougar submits that, in any event, if the warden found that it breached cl 6(a)(ii), this finding was erroneous. Cougar contends that the amount of money spent met the statutory minimum (First Contention). The appellants submit that this contention is inconsistent with how Cougar ran its case in the Wardens Court. Cougar further submits that, as an exemption was obtained in relation to the statutory expenditure requirement, any breach of cl 6(a)(ii) was retrospectively 'cured' by the exemption. Under the Mining Act, if an exemption from the expenditure conditions is granted, the lessee is deemed to be relieved from its obligations under the prescribed expenditure conditions, to the extent of the exemption.[5][5] Section 103 of the Mining Act. Finally, Cougar contends that, if the statutory minimum was not spent, this failure was caused by Richore (Second Contention). The appellants submit that the evidence adduced in the Wardens Court cannot sustain this contention. Shortly before the hearing of the appeal, the appellants' legal representatives realised that they ought to have sought leave to proceed against Cougar before filing the Lessees' Plaint in the Wardens Court and before filing the notice of appeal in this Court.[6] Cougar has been subject to a deed of company arrangement (DOCA) at all material times. Section 444E of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) relevantly provides that a person bound by a DOCA cannot begin or proceed with proceedings against the company except with the leave of the Court. The day before the appeal hearing, the appellants' filed an originating process seeking leave to proceed, with an affidavit in support.[7] Cougar consented to leave being granted.[8] During the appeal hearing, I made orders granting leave, giving brief reasons.[9][6] See ts 18 - 19.[7] Originating Process filed 25 May 2022 and the affidavit of Amanda Victoria Macmaster filed 25 May 2002, in COR 83 of 2022.[8] See annexure AVM1 to the affidavit of Ms MacMaster. [9] See ts 20 - 21 in relation to the appeal and ts 17 - 20 and 87 in relation to the Lessees' Plaint.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered whether the warden correctly found that Cougar breached cl 6(a)(ii) of the Option Agreement by failing to meet the statutory minimum annual expenditure. The warden did not clearly state whether such a finding was made. However, the court concluded that the warden did not correctly find a breach of cl 6(a)(ii). This was based on the appellants' submissions and evidence presented in the Wardens Court, which indicated that Cougar had met the statutory minimum expenditure or had an exemption from it. The court further held that cl 6(a)(ii) was not an essential term of the Option Agreement. Even if a breach had occurred, it would not have entitled Pyke Hill to terminate the Option Agreement. The court found that Cougar's contentions regarding the statutory minimum expenditure and exemption from the expenditure requirements did not constitute valid defences against the breach of cl 6(a)(ii). The court relied on statutory provisions and evidence presented to reach this conclusion. The ratio decidendi of this case is that if a company subject to a deed of company arrangement (DOCA) is a party to an Option Agreement, leave of the Court is required to proceed with proceedings against the company.