Da Staal Property Pty Ltd v Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

DA Staal Property Pty Ltd v Commonwealth of Australia [2021] QSC 216

PARTIES:

DA STAAL PROPERTY PTY LTD as trustee for the DA STAAL PROPERTY TRUST

(applicant)

v

COMMOMWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA

(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

BS 8032 of 2020

DIVISION:

Trial

PROCEEDING:

Originating Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court of Queensland at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

26 August 2021

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

29 July 2021

JUDGE:

Boddice J

ORDER:

1.     The valuer, in reaching the rent determination, undertook a task different to that contractually agreed between the parties.  The rent determination is invalid.

2.     I shall hear from the parties as to the form of orders and costs.

CATCHWORDS:

LANDLORD AND TENANT – LEASES AND TENANCY AGREEMENTS – CONSTRUCTION AND INTERPRETATION – OTHER MATTERS – where the applicant sought a declaration that a purported rental determination dated 29 May 2019 is invalid pursuant to the lease entered into between the applicant and the respondent – whether the rent determination was made in accordance with the process prescribed by that lease

Australian Vintage Ltd v Belvino Investments No 2 Pty Ltd (2015) 90 NSWLR 367

Mount Bruce Mining Pty Ltd v Wright Prospecting Pty Ltd (2015) 256 CLR

Strike Australia Pty Ltd v Database Corporate [2019] NSWCA 205

COUNSEL:

M May for the applicant

B O’Brien for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

Cooper Grace Ward Lawyers for the applicant

Minter Ellison Lawyers for the respondent

  1. By originating application, filed 24 July 2020, the applicant sought a declaration that a purported rental determination dated 29 May 2019 is invalid pursuant to the lease entered into between the applicant and the respondent.

  2. At issue is whether the rent determination was made in accordance with the process prescribed by that lease.

    Background

  3. The applicant is the owner of real property situated at 194 Musgrave Road, Berserker (“the property”).  That land is approximately 4,059 square metres in size.  Constructed upon it is a two-storey building, offering commercial tenancy space.

  4. By lease, executed on 13 November 2013, the respondent leased the property for use by Centrelink.  The lease had a commencement date of 29 May 2012, with an expiry date of 28 May 2019.

  5. By amendment dated 29 May 2018, the term of the lease was amended to 11 years, with the same commencement date.  There was to be a market review on 29 May 2019.  The amended lease also provided for two further terms of four years each, with specified market review dates for each term.

  6. On 27 March 2019, the respondent issued a market rent review notice to the applicant.  The parties were not able to reach agreement on the rental adjustment and, on 14 June 2019, the parties agreed to proceed by way of rental determination.

  7. On 25 October 2019, a valuer was nominated by the Australian Property Institute, in accordance with the terms of the lease.

  8. On 19 December 2019, the valuer issued a rent determination.  It concluded that the net rent for the property, from the date of review,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Da Staal Property Pty Ltd v Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QSC 216
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Da Staal Property Pty Ltd v Commonwealth of Australia involved a dispute over a purported rental determination made by a valuer in accordance with a lease agreement between the applicant, Da Staal Property, and the respondent, the Commonwealth of Australia. The lease, executed on 13 November 2013, specified a market review on 29 May 2019, and provided for a valuer to determine the open market rental value of the premises at the commencement of the rent period, taking into account various factors. On 19 December 2019, the valuer issued a rent determination, which the applicant disputed, contending it was not undertaken in accordance with the requirements of the lease. The central legal issue was whether the rent determination was made in accordance with the process prescribed by the lease.

The court found that the valuer did not consider comparable properties in the suburb or town in which the premises were located and instead considered premises that were not in a comparable suburb or town within the immediate vicinity. The court held that the valuer's determination was invalid as it did not comply with the contractual requirements of the lease. The court further held that the valuer's determination was not challengeable even if the valuer made errors or took into account irrelevant matters, as long as the valuer undertook the task required of him under the lease. The court concluded that the valuer had undertaken a task different to that contractually agreed between the parties, and therefore the rent determination was invalid.

The court ordered that the valuer's rent determination was invalid and invited the parties to provide input on the form of orders and costs. The court's decision highlights the importance of ensuring that rent determinations are made in accordance with the contractual requirements of the lease, and that the valuer undertakes the task required of him under the lease. The decision also emphasises that the valuer's determination is final and binding if it is made in accordance with the lease, and that the parties are contractually bound by that agreement.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The valuer, in reaching the rent determination, undertook a task different to that contractually agreed between the parties. The rent determination is invalid.

2. I shall hear from the parties as to the form of orders and costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

At issue is whether the rent determination was made in accordance with the process prescribed by that lease.Background The applicant is the owner of real property situated at 194 Musgrave Road, Berserker (“the property”). That land is approximately 4,059 square metres in size. Constructed upon it is a two-storey building, offering commercial tenancy space. By lease, executed on 13 November 2013, the respondent leased the property for use by Centrelink. The lease had a commencement date of 29 May 2012, with an expiry date of 28 May 2019. By amendment dated 29 May 2018, the term of the lease was amended to 11 years, with the same commencement date. There was to be a market review on 29 May 2019. The amended lease also provided for two further terms of four years each, with specified market review dates for each term. On 27 March 2019, the respondent issued a market rent review notice to the applicant. The parties were not able to reach agreement on the rental adjustment and, on 14 June 2019, the parties agreed to proceed by way of rental determination. On 25 October 2019, a valuer was nominated by the Australian Property Institute, in accordance with the terms of the lease. On 19 December 2019, the valuer issued a rent determination. It concluded that the net rent for the property, from the date of review, was $565,675 plus GST and outgoings per annum. The rent payable prior to that review was $806,213 plus GST and outgoings per annum. Although the lease provided that the valuer’s determination is final and binding, the applicant disputed it, contending it was not undertaken in accordance with the requirements of the lease. The respondent did not accept that contention.Lease Relevantly, the lease provided that the market review method was specified in Schedule 7 of the lease, with the rent to be determined in accordance with the market review method. The lease further provided:“5.1. Role of Valuer5.1.1.The Valuer musta.determine the open market rental value of the Premises at the commencement of the Rent Period (the Effective Date);b.act as an expert and not as an arbitrator;c.give a written determination with reasons within 28 days after the Valuer’s appointment; andd.in making its determination must consider the written and oral submissions of a Party received within 30 days after the Valuer’s appointment.5.2Fees5.2.1The fees and expenses of the Valuer must be paid by the Landlord and the Tenant equally.5.3Determination final5.3.1The Valuer’s determination is final and binding.5.3.2The Valuer must determine the open market rental value of the Premises at the Effective Date assuming that:a.the Landlord is a willing but not anxious landlord and the Tenant is a willing but not anxious tenant;b.the Premises are available with vacant possession;and taking into account:c.the open market rental value (other than rental values which have been escalated to a predetermined amount or in accordance with movements in the consumer price index or any other index) at the Effective Date expressed as a rental rate per square meter, of comparable premises in the suburb or town within which the Building is situated (and where there is insufficient evidence of comparable premises in the relevant suburb or town, then of comparable premises within a comparable suburb or town within the immediate vicinity of that in which the Building is situated) whether that value is determined in respect of new lettings with vacant possession or in respect of occupied premises;d.the Permitted Use of the Premises;e.the period which will elapse between the Effective Date and that Review Date immediately following the Effective Date, or if there is no Review Date, the end of the Term;f.the increased value of the Premises occasioned by the Landlord repainting or recarpeting the Premises pursuant to this Lease (provided that nothing in this clause will require the Tenant to reimburse the Landlord for the cost of that repainting or recarpeting);g.the restriction on user, assignment or sub-letting;h.the terms and conditions generally of the Lease;i.any rent-free period, financial contribution (including any contribution towards the cost of fitout) or other concession customarily or likely to be offered to new tenants of comparable vacant premises.but not taking into account:j.the adverse effect on the condition or rental value of the Premises of any breach of this Lease by the Tenant;k.any Fittings and other improvements or alterations installed in or made to the Premises by or for the Tenant, its sub-tenants or their respective predecessors in title during the Term, the Further Term or any period of prior occupation to the intent that the Premises for the purpose of determining the open market rental value will be regarded as cleared space but otherwise serviced and habitable;l.any increase in value in the Premises as a result of any structural alterations or other voluntary improvements made to the Premises or the Building (including installation of equipment) by the Landlord at its discretion for any reason at any time (except any carried out at the prior request of the Tenant to which the Tenant has not contributed either by way of service charge or otherwise);m.any special interest of the Tenant, its sub-tenants or their respective predecessors in title including the fact that the Tenant is a sitting tenant;n.goodwill occasioned by the Tenant, its sub-tenants or their respective predecessors in title;o.any right of the Tenant to use any part of the Building or the Land other than the net lettable area of the Premises and the Car Parking Bays;p.any naming rights the Tenant may have in respect of the Building;q.the rental value at the Effective Date of premises which have been leased on the basis that they have been purpose built or refurbished for the relevant tenant and for which a market review has not occurred under the relevant lease; orr.any area within the Building which is excluded from the Net Lettable Area of the Premises.”Rent determination

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The valuer determined an open market rental value for lease purposes of $565,675.Evidence Cliff Allard, a registered valuer in Queensland, opined the valuer did not consider a comparable property in the suburb/town in which the premises was located, namely, the property, and considered premises that were not in a comparable suburb or town within the immediate vicinity, being in Townsville, Hervey Bay and Maryborough. Further, the valuer failed to consider comparable premises in a comparable suburb or town in the immediate vicinity, being Gladstone and/or Yeppoon, and used rental evidence of premises that were not comparable premises. Mr Allard opined the valuer should have considered the property as leasing evidence for comparable premises in Rockhampton. Whilst the lease commenced in 2012, and was therefore not timely for comparison of open market rental value, all other aspects were comparable. The valuer should have considered the market rental agreed in 2012, with adjustments for general market rental movements in more typical commercial rentals in Rockhampton and the immediate vicinity and general movement of market rents for other Centrelink premises. Mr Allard further opined, whilst Centrelink offices in Townsville, Maryborough and Hervey Bay would typically constitute best evidence for comparison purposes, none of those locations met the comparable premises within a comparable suburb or town in the immediate vicinity requirement under the lease. Further, the Townsville property was not comparable, as it was far larger; Townsville had a far greater supply of alternate larger areas available to lease than compared to Rockhampton and the property was far smaller compared to Townsville Centrelink, was located within a locality where there were no comparable premises and the property suited every requirement of the tenant. Mr Allard opined that, if the valuer reasonably concluded there was no comparable evidence in Rockhampton, the valuer ought to have considered leasing evidence in Gladstone and Yeppoon. Had the valuer undertaken this task, he would have identified a Centrelink office potential lease renewal transaction in both Gladstone and Yeppoon, providing more relevant rental evidence in the immediate vicinity. Mr Allard further opined the premises located across the road from the property was not comparable, being a building of inferior design with inferior amenities, limited car parking and containing premises that would not meet the specific requirements of the limited use clause. The Centrelink premises at Townsville, Hervey Bay and Maryborough also contained lease terms and conditions which potentially impacted upon their market rent. Finally, Mr Allard opined that the valuer may not have had adequate regard to the parties’ submissions and the relevant terms of the lease. In cross examination, Mr Allard accepted that what are comparable premises in comparable suburbs or towns involves a subjective opinion about which valuers may come to different conclusions. Factors in assessing comparability include size, location, use and the age, condition, amenities and features of buildings located on the land. He also accepted it is preferable to look at leasing transactions at around the same time as the rent review date. There is a necessity to understand what the market is doing and one way to reach that understanding is to see what the market has done. Mr Allard accepted in undertaking that consideration of the marketplace he had referred to the Centrelink premises at Aitkenvale, Hervey Bay and Maryborough, as well as the premises across the road from the property, the same premises which he opined the valuer should not have considered in his determination.

Decision

Reasons for decision

These conclusions render it unnecessary to consider the applicant’s remaining contentions. Had it been necessary to do so, I would not have been satisfied that those considerations led to error on the part of the valuer that went to whether the valuer had undertaken the task required of him under the lease. Those considerations were errors falling within the exercise of discretionary judgments, which the parties contemplated and agreed to being undertaken by the valuer in reaching a final and binding rent determination.Conclusions The valuer, in reaching the rent determination, undertook a task different to that contractually agreed between the parties. The rent determination is invalid. I shall hear from the parties as to the form of orders and costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Finally, the valuer did not fail to act as an expert. The valuer undertook the task required of him, giving reasons for his rent determination. There was no requirement to detail an exact exposition of reasons for his conclusions.Consideration The parties, by clause 5.3.1 of the lease, contractually agreed that the valuer’s rent determination would be final and binding. They are contractually bound by that agreement if the rent determination is valid. The lease provides the contractual framework for deciding whether the rent determination was valid. Its validity depends upon whether the determination was made in accordance with the contract.[1] The rental determination is only open to review if the valuer has not carried out the task which he was contractually required to undertake.[2] If the valuer has undertaken that task, the rent determination is not challengeable even if the valuer made errors or took into account irrelevant matters.[1]Australian Vintage Ltd v Belvino Investments No 2 Pty Ltd (2015) 90 NSWLR 367 at [74].[2]Shoalhaven City Council v Firedam Civil Engineering Pty Ltd [2011] HCA 38; 244 CLR 305 at [26]-[27]. A consideration of the terms of the lease supports a conclusion that the task the valuer was contractually required to undertake was to determine the open market rental value of the premises at the commencement of the rent period, taking into account a variety of factors. Those factors included the open market rental value “of comparable premises in the suburb or town within which the building is situated (and where there is insufficient evidence of comparable premises in the relevant suburb or town, then of comparable premises within a comparable suburb or town within the immediate vicinity of that in which the building is situated)”. By its very terms, the parties contractually accepted that the task undertaken by the valuer required discretionary judgments, including what were comparable premises and what was “a comparable suburb and town”. However, whilst the parties contemplated and accepted a rental determination which involved discretionary decisions about comparable premises and a comparable suburb or town, the parties expressly agreed a limitation on a comparable suburb or town. That limitation was that it be a comparable suburb or town “within the immediate vicinity of that in which the building is situated”. A determination of what is the effect of that limitation requires a consideration of the proper construction of the lease. Such a construction requires this Court to objectively determine the rights and liabilities of the parties under the contract by reference to its context and purpose and asking what a reasonable businessperson would have understood those terms to mean.[3][3]Mount Bruce Mining Pty Ltd v Wright Prospecting Pty Ltd (2015) 256 CLR 104 at 46-51. A consideration of the terms of clause 5.3.2, by reference to the contract as a whole and the purpose of the contract, supports a conclusion that clause 5.3.2(c), properly construed, required that the valuer, when considering comparable premises within a comparable suburb or town, only to take into account a comparable suburb or town within the immediate vicinity of that in which the building is situated. The valuer was not to consider comparable premises in a comparable suburb or town outside that immediate vicinity.