Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: TX Australia Pty Limited v Broadcast Australia Pty Limited [2012] NSWSC 4 Hearing dates: 23, 24 November 2011 Decision date: 16 January 2012 Jurisdiction: Equity Division - Commercial List Before: Brereton J Decision: Summons dismissed with costs
Catchwords: CONTRACTS - Broadcasting and related industry contracts - plaintiff owner and operator of broadcast infrastructure - defendant has access to and use of plaintiff's infrastructure pursuant to contract - defendant exercises option to renew contract - contract provides for expert determination of licence fee if parties fail to reach agreement - expert charged with determining a reasonable fee having regard to rates charged to third parties at facility in question - term sheet determines that expert determination final and binding except if attended by manifest error or error of law - terms of contract direct task to be performed by expert and whether determination binding.
CONTRACTS - Plaintiff alleges error of law on basis expert misconceived function by adopting objective "market value" assessment to ascertain fee as opposed to a subjective "fair value" approach - function of expert determined by contractual provisions - contract provides for hybrid process requiring consideration of subjective and objective factors, with rates charged to third parties a mandatory consideration - contract requires appraisal akin to 'fair market value' - expert does not have regard to exclusively objective considerations and considers position of particular parties - expert did not misconceive function.
CONTRACTS - Plaintiff alleges error of law on basis expert failed to consider relevant factor - relevant consideration said to be 'special value' of contract to defendant - requirement for ascertainment of 'reasonable fee' refers to defendant as a willing but not anxious and involuntary purchaser - requirement for 'reasonable fee' antithetical to valuation proceeding on basis plaintiff a monopolist - expert did consider special value of contract to defendant.
CONTRACTS - Plaintiff alleges error of law on basis expert failed to give weight to current fees under original contract - expert had regard to such fees but concluded of limited relevance - not an error of law to weigh relevant factors in a particular way as opposed to not consider them - circumstances prevailing ten years previously when agreement first made materially different to present - fees agreed ten years previously not useful guide to what constitutes a 'reasonable fee'.
CONTRACTS - Plaintiff alleges error of law and manifest error on basis expert used incorrect comparator in assessing 'reasonable fee' - expert said to have incorrectly compared digital audio broadcasting with digital television broadcasting - audio broadcasting said to be inapposite comparator due to fact radio different medium to television with different cost factors - digital audio broadcasting fees considered by expert pertain to agreement between same parties and are relatively recent - errors in methodology employed by expert valuer not errors of law - matter of professional judgment as to weight to accord cost recovery and profit margin - expert evidence adduced in attempt to illustrate manifest…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read TX Australia Pty Ltd v Broadcast Australia Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
Details
- Case
- [2012] NSWSC 4
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
TX Australia Pty Ltd (TX) brought an action against Broadcast Australia Pty Ltd (Broadcast), seeking a declaration that an expert's determination of a licence fee was made in error of law, manifestly unreasonable, or otherwise not binding. The dispute arose from a contract between the parties, whereby Broadcast had access to and use of TX's broadcast infrastructure. Upon exercising an option to renew the contract, the parties were unable to agree on a licence fee, triggering the contract's expert determination clause. The Federal Court was tasked with determining the validity of the expert's determination.
The court examined whether the expert misconceived their function by adopting an objective "market value" assessment instead of a subjective "fair value" approach, as TX contended. The court found that the contract required a hybrid process considering both subjective and objective factors, and the expert's appraisal aligned with this requirement. TX further alleged the expert failed to consider the "special value" of the contract to Broadcast and the current fees under the original contract. The court held that the expert did not misconceive their function or make an error of law by considering these factors, as they had regard to the current fees and the special value of the contract to Broadcast. TX also argued that the expert used an incorrect comparator and failed to provide detailed reasons. The court found that the expert's methodology was a matter of professional judgment and that the reasons provided were sufficiently detailed.
Finally, TX claimed that the determination was manifestly unreasonable due to the magnitude of the reduction in the licence fee. The court found that the determination was not so unreasonably low as to be manifestly unreasonable, as it rewarded TX above its avoidable cost and was not unreasonable in the Wednesbury sense.
The court held that the expert's determination was valid and binding, dismissing TX's claims. The Federal Court found no error of law or manifest error in the expert's determination, and the reasons provided were sufficient under the contract. The court also held that the determination was not manifestly unreasonable, as it was based on market and cost considerations.
The court examined whether the expert misconceived their function by adopting an objective "market value" assessment instead of a subjective "fair value" approach, as TX contended. The court found that the contract required a hybrid process considering both subjective and objective factors, and the expert's appraisal aligned with this requirement. TX further alleged the expert failed to consider the "special value" of the contract to Broadcast and the current fees under the original contract. The court held that the expert did not misconceive their function or make an error of law by considering these factors, as they had regard to the current fees and the special value of the contract to Broadcast. TX also argued that the expert used an incorrect comparator and failed to provide detailed reasons. The court found that the expert's methodology was a matter of professional judgment and that the reasons provided were sufficiently detailed.
Finally, TX claimed that the determination was manifestly unreasonable due to the magnitude of the reduction in the licence fee. The court found that the determination was not so unreasonably low as to be manifestly unreasonable, as it rewarded TX above its avoidable cost and was not unreasonable in the Wednesbury sense.
The court held that the expert's determination was valid and binding, dismissing TX's claims. The Federal Court found no error of law or manifest error in the expert's determination, and the reasons provided were sufficient under the contract. The court also held that the determination was not manifestly unreasonable, as it was based on market and cost considerations.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.