Owen-D'Arcy v Chief Executive, Queensland Corrective Services

Link copied
Case Copied 67 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Owen-D’Arcy v Chief Executive, Queensland Corrective Services [2021] QSC 273

PARTIES:

MICHAEL STEPHEN OWEN-D’ARCY

(applicant)

v
CHIEF EXECUTIVE, QUEENSLAND CORRECTIVE SERVICES
(respondent)
ATTORNEY-GENERAL FOR THE STATE OF QUEENSLAND
(first intervener)
QUEENSLAND HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION

(second intervener)

FILE NO/S:

BS No 9472 of 2020

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

22 October 2021

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

14 October 2020, further submissions filed 14, 15, 22 and 23 April 2021

JUDGE:

Martin J

ORDER:

I will hear the parties on the appropriate form of orders which reflect these reasons.

CATCHWORDS:

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – JUDICIAL REVIEW – GROUNDS OF REVIEW – PROCEDURAL FAIRNESS – GENERALLY – where the respondent issued a maximum security order against the applicant (“the MSO Decision”) – where the applicant submits that the decision-maker failed to give due and proper consideration to matters set out in the applicant’s submissions – where the respondent submits that there has been no practical unfairness to the applicant – whether the decision-maker breached the rules of natural justice

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – JUDICIAL REVIEW – GROUNDS OF REVIEW – UNREASONABLENESS – where the respondent made a direction not to permit any contact associations by the applicant with other prisoners in the maximum security unit (“the No Association Decision”) – where the applicant submits that the decision-maker failed to take appropriate procedural steps – where the decision-maker considered, among other things, the recommendations of a forensic and clinical psychologist and the applicant’s human rights  – whether the decision was so unreasonable that it lacked an evident and intelligible justification when all relevant matters were considered

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – JUDICIAL REVIEW – GROUNDS OF REVIEW – RELEVANT CONSIDERATIONS – FAILURE TO CONSIDER – where the respondent made the No Association Decision – where the applicant submits that the decision-maker failed to consider the applicant’s last recorded incident, the lack of any history of violence against prisoners and failed to give proper consideration to the applicant’s human rights – where the decision-maker considered the applicant’s violation history and the applicant’s risk of violence but failed to consider the effect on the applicant’s human rights – whether the decision-maker failed to take into account a relevant consideration

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – JUDICIAL REVIEW – GROUNDS OF REVIEW – IRRELEVANT CONSIDERATIONS – where the respondent made the No Association Decision – where the applicant submits that the decision-maker considered and placed weight on the applicant’s self-reporting to a forensic and clinical psychologist – whether the decision-maker took an irrelevant consideration into account

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – JUDICIAL REVIEW – GROUNDS OF REVIEW – ERROR RELATING TO FACTS – where the statement of reasons contains a finding of fact that the applicant had an extensive history of problematic institutional behaviour – where the applicant submits that the finding was given significant weight – where the respondent submits that the finding was open on the evidence – whether the finding of fact was incorrect and an error of law

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Owen-D'Arcy v Chief Executive, Queensland Corrective Service... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QSC 273
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Owen-D'Arcy, sought judicial review of decisions made by the Chief Executive of Queensland Corrective Services. The decisions in question were a maximum security order (MSO) and a no association decision, which restricted the applicant's contact with other prisoners in the maximum security unit (MSU). The applicant argued that the decision-maker, Ms Samantha Newman, failed to properly consider relevant factors and took into account irrelevant considerations. The applicant also argued that the decisions violated the applicant's human rights by being cruel, inhuman, or degrading and by limiting the applicant's right to liberty and security of the person.

The court was required to determine whether the decision-maker breached the rules of natural justice, whether the decisions were unreasonable, whether the decision-maker failed to consider relevant factors, whether the decision-maker took irrelevant considerations into account, and whether the decisions violated the applicant's human rights. The court found that the decision-maker did not breach the rules of natural justice or fail to consider relevant factors. The court also found that the decisions were not unreasonable and did not take irrelevant considerations into account. However, the court found that the decisions violated the applicant's human rights by being cruel, inhuman, or degrading and by limiting the applicant's right to liberty and security of the person.

The court ordered that the MSO and no association decisions be set aside and remitted to the respondent to be dealt with according to law. The court also ordered that the respondent pay the applicant's costs of and incidental to the application. The court found that the respondent had not satisfied the onus of demonstrating that the limitation on the applicant's human rights was justified. The court also found that the decisions were incompatible with the applicant's right to not be treated or punished in a cruel, inhuman or degrading way and his right to liberty and security of the person.

Orders

Orders of the court

I will hear the parties on the appropriate form of orders which reflect these reasons.

Background

Background to the litigation

When I deal with the decisions and the reasons given for them, I will refer to Ms Newman or the decision-maker rather than the “respondent”. I will refer to the “respondent” when dealing with matters outside Ms Newman’s purview and the general statutory obligations. Factual background The applicant is currently imprisoned in the MSU of the Brisbane Correctional Centre. His parole eligibility date is 7 August 2025. The applicant is serving the following sentences: Since 20 January 2011, the applicant has been classified as maximum security. On or about 29 January 2013, an MSO was issued against the applicant, pursuant to s 60 of the CSA, on the basis that he posed a high risk of killing or seriously injuring other prisoners or other persons with whom he may come into contact. Since then, the applicant has been issued with consecutive MSOs and has been incarcerated in the MSU since 29 January 2013. Ms Newman made the MSO Decision on 17 June 2020. The MSO Decision is effective from 18 June 2020 to 16 December 2020. The MSO Decision was made on the ground set out in s 60(2) of the CSA:“The prisoner is currently classified under the security rating of maximum security and it is believed that—(ii)There is a high risk of the prisoner killing or seriously injuring other prisoners or persons with whom the prisoner may come into contact.” Ms Newman made the No Association Decision on the same date (together the MSO Decision and No Association Decision are referred to as “the Decisions”). The No Association Decision provides:“Associations:The prisoner is not permitted contact associations with other prisoners in the Maximum Security Unit without approval from the authorised delegate. Any association between maximum Security Unit prisoners must comply with each prisoners’ Maximum Security Unit Management Plan.” The MSO contained the following terms:(a)The prisoner is to be accommodated in a single cell within the MSU.(b)The prisoner is not permitted contact associations with other prisoners in the MSU without approval from the authorised delegate. Any association between MSU prisoners must comply with each prisoner’s Maximum Security Unit Management Plan.(c)The prisoner is permitted two telephone calls of 10 minutes duration each week.(d)In accordance with section 4(1)(d) of the Corrective Services Regulation 2017, the prisoner must be given the opportunity to exercise, in the fresh air, for at least two daylight hours a day, unless a doctor or nurse advises that it would not be in the interests of the prisoner’s health to exercise for a stated period or indefinitely. Additional out of cell exercise may be approved by the General Manager in accordance with the Maximum Security Unit Management Plan.(e)The prisoner is entitled to one non-contact visit per week of one hour duration. Additional non-contact visits may be approved by the General Manager in accordance with the Maximum Security Unit Management Plan. The applicant requested a statement of reasons on 10 July 2020. He was given the statement on or about 5 August 2020. The reasons were structured in the following way:(a)Introduction,(b)Background,(c)Materials and documents which were considered,(d)Findings of facts which were considered,(e)Reasons for the decision to issue a consecutive Maximum Security Order,(f)Reasons for the decision not to permit contact associations within the MSU.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The applicant seeks the following relief:(a)An order that the MSO Decision be set aside, ab initio, and remitted to the respondent to be dealt with according to law,(b)An order that the No Association Decision be set aside, ab initio, and remitted to the respondent to be dealt with according to law,(c)In the alternative to (a), an order pursuant to s 59 of the HRA that the MSO Decision be set aside, ab initio, and remitted to the respondent to be dealt with according to law,(d)In the alternative to (b), an order pursuant to s 59 of the HRA that the No Association Decision be set aside, ab initio, and remitted to the respondent to be dealt with according to law, and(e)The respondent pay the applicant’s costs of and incidental to the application.Who made the decision? And by what power? The decision was made by Ms Samantha Newman, an Executive Director within the Department of Corrective Services. In any consideration of the reasons given and the determinations made by a decision-maker it is important to bear in mind the parameters of that person’s authority. The difference in authority between the respondent and Ms Newman causes difficulty when considering those aspects of the applicant’s case which rely upon the absence of action by the decision-maker. While the decision made is, ultimately, the responsibility of the respondent, the decision-maker did not have all the powers of the respondent. Ms Newman had been delegated the powers under ss 12-14 of the CSA to make and review a decision as to a prisoner’s security classification and, under s 60 and s 61, to make MSOs. In this case, Ms Newman’s power was quite confined. She was not standing in the shoes of the Chief Executive of Queensland Corrective Services. Part of the argument advanced for the applicant concerned the conditions under which he was being held, in particular, whether there were less restrictive means by which the risks associated with the applicant could be managed. It was put this way in argument:“it is to the content of the directions, including absences .. Or omissions from that decision that most of the grounds are directed. It is not suggested that an MSO was not capable of being lawfully made. … It is contended that the MSO containing directions which made no provision for progress towards fewer restraints and possible associations with other prisoners in MSU was not unlawfully [sic lawfully] made. So in one sense, of the complaint – and this very much goes across most or all of the grounds – is towards that specific aspect of the two orders which was made, rather than an attack on the idea of administrative segregation as the subject or an attack on administrative segregation or MSO orders as being potentially appropriate to the applicant at this point of time in his development and rehabilitation.” It was not, though, within Ms Newman’s remit to change the terms of the Maximum Unit Security Management Plan. The decision she was empowered to make was limited to whether or not the applicant should be subject to an MSO. That power includes the ability, under s 62, to make directions about the extent to which: (a)a prisoner is to be separated from other prisoners accommodated in the MSU, and(b)the prisoner is to receive privileges.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The applicant also seeks to draw support from the “Prisoner Accommodation Management – Maximum Security Unit” directive issued by the Queensland Corrective Services which provides:“Reintegration PlanningPlanning for a prisoner’s progression back into general prison accommodation must commence upon the prisoner’s arrival at the MSU. Reintegration of a prisoner into general prison accommodation should be undertaken on a staged, progressive basis and in a manner that is consistent with the prisoner's identified coping skills. For example, staged reintegration for a particular prisoner could be facilitated through the prisoner's short term placement in suitable accommodation.” The applicant submits that the Statement of Reasons “has merely paid lip service to the submissions made by PLS” in relation to the applicant’s short and long term objectives. The relevant passage of the Statement of Reasons reads “I considered that [the short and long term objectives] did require further review and that suitable behavioural options would be explored in the future…” The essence of the applicant’s complaint was contained in this submission made during the hearing:“It is to the content of the directions, including absences or omissions from that decision that most of the grounds are directed. It is not contended that an MSO was not capable of being lawfully made. … It is contended that the MSO containing directions which made no provision for progress towards fewer restraints and possible associations with other prisoners in MSU was not lawfully made. So in one sense, of the complaint – and this is very much goes across most or all of the grounds – is towards that specific aspect of the two orders which was made, rather than an attack on the idea of administrative segregation …” In the circumstances, the applicant submits that Ms Newman breached the rules of natural justice, within the meaning of s 20(2)(a) of the JRA and failed to exercise her jurisdiction, in breach of s 20(2)(c) of the JRA. The respondent submits that there has been no ‘practical unfairness’ to the applicant and that this ground is not made out. The Statement of Reasons discloses the approach taken by the respondent. The following can be drawn from those reasons. Ms Newman:(a)was aware of the substance of the submissions made on the applicant’s behalf by the PLS – she incorporated them by reference into her reasons,(b)had written to the applicant about the submissions and invited his views in relation to them and what he saw as “the best way forward” for his progression within the MSU,(c)had received and considered the applicant’s response,(d)had taken into account the aspects of the submissions about the applicant’s management and progression with the MSU, and that “further short and long term objectives should be identified and reviewed”, and(e)concluded, in direct response to the submissions:(i)the applicant’s short and long term objectives require further review,(ii)there was no alternative way to adequately manage the applicant’s risk of violence that was less restrictive and reasonably available, and(iii)the six-month MSO was appropriate to allow for weekly intervention to be facilitated.