Mizner v State of Queensland (Corrective Services) & anors

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

CITATION:

Mizner v State of Queensland (Corrective Services) & anors [2024] QCAT 468

PARTIES:

JASON MIZNER

(applicant)

v

STATE OF QUEENSLAND (CORRECTIVE SERVICES)

(respondent)

JOEL SMITH

(second respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

ADL004-22

MATTER TYPE:

Anti-discrimination matters

DELIVERED ON:

13 August 2024

HEARING DATES:

11, 12, 13, 14 April 2023 & 22 June 2023

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Judicial Member Colin Forrest
Senior Member Traves

ORDERS:

1.     The complaint made by the applicant and referred to the Tribunal on 24 December 2021 is dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

HUMAN RIGHTS – DISCRIMINATION LEGISLATION – INDIRECT DISCRIMINATION – where applicant a prisoner at The Wolston Correctional Centre – where applicant has an ‘impairment’ due to mental health conditions including post-traumatic stress disorder - where applicant wants to be located in a single cell – where certain prisoners placed on a “Do not Double Up’ List – where applicant did not satisfy the relevant criteria – where applicant not placed on the ‘Do not Double Up’ List - whether in formulating and applying that criteria the first respondent and second respondent, the then Chief Superintendent and General Manager of the WCC, indirectly discriminated against the applicant on the grounds of impairment in the administration of State laws and programs – whether there has been a breach of the Human Rights Act 2019 (Qld).

Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld), s 7, s 8, s 11, s 101
Corrective Services Act 2006 (Qld), s 5A, s 18, s 150, s 319A, s 319B, s 319H
Human Rights Act 2019 (Qld), s 8, s 13, s 15, s 16, s 17, s 25, s 29, s 30, s 58, s 59

Attorney-General for the State of Queensland v Grant (No 2) [2022] QSC 252
Attorney-General v Taunoa [2006] 2 NZLR 457
Bell v iiNet Ltd [2017] QCAT 114
Castles v Secretary of the Department of Justice (2010) 28 VR 141
Certain Children v Minister for Families and Children (No 2) (2017) 52 VR 441
D v Persons Unknown; F v Persons Unknown [2021] EWHC 157
Innes v Electoral Commission of Queensland (No 2) [2020] QSC 293
Johnston v Carroll (Commissioner of the Queensland Police Service [2024] QSC 2
JM v QFG [2000] 1 Qd R 373
Owen-D’Arcy v Chief Executive, Queensland Corrective Services [2021] QSC 273
SQH v Scott [2022] QSC 16
Thompson v Minogue [2021] VSCA 358

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

Ms E. Lewsey, counsel instructed by B. Smeed, Legal Aid Queensland

Respondent:

Mr C. Murdoch KC and Mr A.B. Fraser, counsel instructed by Crown Law

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. The Applicant is a 49 year old man currently serving a very lengthy sentence of imprisonment in a Queensland prison. He has been in prison in Queensland since January 2017 when he was returned to Australia from Thailand. In that country, he had spent almost eleven years in prison for similar offences to those for which he was imprisoned here, though the crimes for which he was imprisoned here were actually committed before he went…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mizner v State of Queensland (Corrective Services) & anors and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QCAT 468
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Mizner v State of Queensland (Corrective Services) & anors involved a prisoner at The Wolston Correctional Centre (WCC) who alleged that he was indirectly discriminated against due to his mental health conditions, which included post-traumatic stress disorder. The applicant sought to be placed in a single cell but was not included on the “Do not Double Up” List, which permitted certain prisoners to be housed in single cells. The applicant argued that the criteria used to determine eligibility for the List indirectly discriminated against him on the grounds of his impairment, in violation of the Human Rights Act 2019 (Qld).

The central legal issue was whether the decisions made by the first and second respondents, the then Chief Superintendent and General Manager of the WCC, to not place the applicant on the “Do not Double Up” List constituted indirect discrimination under the Human Rights Act. The court had to determine if the decisions limited the applicant’s human rights in a manner that was not reasonable or demonstrably justifiable, specifically whether the decisions breached the applicant’s rights to recognition and equality before the law, the right to life, protection from torture and cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment, the right to privacy and reputation, the right to liberty and security of person, and the right to humane treatment when deprived of liberty.

The court examined the compatibility of the decisions with human rights, focusing on whether the decisions placed limitations on the applicant’s human rights and if those limitations were reasonable and justified. The court found that the decisions did not limit the applicant’s human rights to an extent that was not reasonable or demonstrably justifiable. The court concluded that the applicant had not established that the decisions imposed a limit on his human rights that breached the Human Rights Act. Therefore, the complaint was dismissed.

ORDERS:
1. The complaint made by the applicant and referred to the Tribunal on 24 December 2021 is dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The complaint made by the applicant and referred to the Tribunal on 24 December 2021 is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The lawfulness of the decisions under the HRA is considered at the time when those decisions were made.[35][35]Johnston & ors v Carroll (Commissioner of the Queensland Police Service & anor [2024] QSC 2 at [20].Were the decisions compatible with human rights within the meaning of s 58(1)(a) of the HRA? Section 8 provides that an act, decision or statutory provision is ‘compatible with human rights’ if the act, decision or provision:(a)does not limit a human right; or(b)limits a human right only to the extent that is reasonable and demonstrably justifiable in accordance with s 13. A decision will limit a human right if it “places limitations or restrictions on, or interferes with, the human rights of a person”.[36] That necessarily involves considering whether the impact comes within the scope of the right. The scope is broadly construed by reference to the right’s purposes and underlying values.[37][36]Innes v Electoral Commission of Queensland (No 2) [2020] QSC 293 at [291]; Owen-D’Arcy v Chief Executive, Queensland Corrective Services [2021] QSC 273 at [130].[37] Austin BMI Pty Ltd v Deputy Premier [2023] QSC 95 at [306]; SCH v Scott (2022) 10 QdR 215. The factors to be considered in determining whether a limit on human rights is reasonable and justified are set out in s 13 which has been held to embody a ‘proportionality test’.[38][38]Owen-D’Arcy at [104] referring to Momcilovic v R (2011) 245 CLR 1 at [22], [34] per French CJ, [432] per Heydon J, [555]-[557] per Crennan and Kiefel JJ. Addressing whether a decision is compatible with human rights involves: (a)identifying the human rights relevant to the facts;(b)stating how the decision will limit the human rights; and(c)deciding whether the limits are reasonable and justified by reference to the matters in s 13(2).[39][39]This was the approach adopted in Owen-D’Arcy v Chief Executive, Queensland Corrective Services [2021] QSC 273. The Applicant bears the onus of establishing that the decision imposes a limit on human rights. If established, the Respondents bear the onus of justifying the limit.[40][40] Johnston at [70]-[71]; Owen-D’Arcy at [128] – [129]. The Applicant submitted that the following acts and/or decisions of the Respondents had limited his human rights to an incompatible extent and the limitations were not reasonable or demonstrably justifiable:(a)the assessment of the Applicant as being suitable for shared cell accommodation and deciding to place him in a shared cell from about 12 July 2020 until 28 September 2021 (the placement decision); and(b)the assessment of the Applicant as being ineligible for inclusion on the DNDU list on various dates from 1 January 2020 to the present (the assessments).(together, referred to as ‘the decisions’) The Applicant submits the decisions breached the following six human rights:(a)Section 15: the right to recognition and equality before the law;(b)Section 16: the right to life;(c)Section 17: protection from torture and cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment; (d)Section 25: right to privacy and reputation; (e)Section 29: right to liberty and security of person:(f)Section 30: humane treatment when deprived of liberty.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established