Mizner v State of Queensland (Corrective Services)

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Mizner v State of Queensland (Corrective Services) [2025] QCA 169

PARTIES:

JASON MIZNER
(applicant/appellant)
v
STATE OF QUEENSLAND (CORRECTIVE SERVICES)
(first respondent)
JOEL SMITH
(second respondent)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 12149 of 2024
QCAT No 4 of 2022

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

Application for Leave Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act/Appeal Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act

ORIGINATING COURT:

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal – [2024] QCAT 468 (Judicial Member Forrest, Senior Member Traves)

DELIVERED ON:

12 September 2025

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

13 March 2025

JUDGES:

Bond JA and Gotterson AJA and Crowley J

ORDERS:

1.   Leave to appeal be granted in respect of Grounds 7, 9, 11, 13 and 15.

2.   The appeal is dismissed.

3.   Unless the respondents seek a contrary order, there be no order as to costs.

4.   In the event that the respondents do seek a contrary order on the question of costs:

a.   Within 7 days of delivery of judgment, the respondents are to file and serve written submissions as to the order sought with respect to costs.

b.   Within 7 days of receipt of the respondents’ submissions, the appellant is to file and serve written submissions as to the order sought with respect to costs.

c.   The Court will decide the appropriate order to be made on the papers.

5.   The Court makes non-publication orders in the terms of the draft proposed orders, which were marked for identification “A” at the hearing on 13 March 2025.

CATCHWORDS:

HUMAN RIGHTS – DISCRIMINATION LEGISLATION – INDIRECT DISCRIMINATION – where the appellant is a prisoner in a correctional centre – where the prisoners in that correctional centre may be required to share their cells unless placed on a “do not double up” list – where the appellant has been diagnosed with mental conditions of post-traumatic stress disorder and borderline personality disorder – where the appellant has physical impairments to his leg and foot – where the appellant claims that his mental and physical impairments cause him to suffer “appreciable or more than minimal disadvantage” when required to comply with the policy that does not allow him to be placed on the do not double up list – whether suffering “appreciable or more than minimal disadvantage” in complying with a requirement is sufficient to infringe s 11(1)(a) of the Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld)

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS – QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL – where the appellant relied on a psychiatrist report at first instance – where there were a number of psychological reports before the Tribunal – where the material evidence provided by the psychiatrist was that the appellant suffered from an impairment – where the respondent conceded and the Tribunal accepted that the appellant suffered from an impairment – where the Tribunal did not explicitly refer to the psychiatrist report relied on by the appellant or the evidence of the psychiatrist given at the hearing – where the Tribunal considered the source material which the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mizner v State of Queensland (Corrective Services) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] QCA 169
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellant, a prisoner at the Wolston Correctional Centre (WCC), appealed against a decision of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) that found the respondents had not discriminated against the appellant. The appellant claimed that he suffered indirect discrimination and that his human rights had been infringed under the Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld) and the Human Rights Act 2019 (Qld). The primary issues for determination were whether the Tribunal erred in its consideration of the evidence, in its interpretation of the statutory provisions, and in its determination of the appellant's claims of discrimination and human rights infringements.

The court examined the evidence and the reasoning process of the Tribunal. It noted that the Tribunal did not explicitly refer to the psychiatrist's report or evidence but considered the source material that the report reproduced. The court found that the Tribunal's omission did not constitute error as it had considered the material evidence. Regarding the appellant's claims of suffering "appreciable or more than minimal disadvantage," the court held that the Tribunal's finding that the appellant did not suffer "serious disadvantage" was open on the evidence. The court also determined that the appellant's claims of human rights infringements under the Human Rights Act 2019 (Qld) were not established as they were contingent on the finding of indirect discrimination under the Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld).

The court dismissed the appeal and made orders regarding leave to appeal, the dismissal of the appeal, and the non-publication of certain information. The court also provided directions for the parties to submit on the question of costs if the respondents sought a contrary order.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Leave to appeal be granted in respect of Grounds 7, 9, 11, 13 and 15.

2. The appeal is dismissed.

3. Unless the respondents seek a contrary order, there be no order as to costs.

4. In the event that the respondents do seek a contrary order on the question of costs:

a. Within 7 days of delivery of judgment, the respondents are to file and serve written submissions as to the order sought with respect to costs.

b. Within 7 days of receipt of the respondents’ submissions, the appellant is to file and serve written submissions as to the order sought with respect to costs.

c. The Court will decide the appropriate order to be made on the papers.

5. The Court makes non-publication orders in the terms of the draft proposed orders, which were marked for identification “A” at the hearing on 13 March 2025.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I will later return to the issue of leave to appeal when addressing the subject grounds of appeal.The respondents’ decisions and the appellant’s application to the Tribunal Evidence adduced at the hearing before the Tribunal established the following matters. The WCC is a high security prison for adult males. Accommodation at the WCC is divided between residential and secure accommodation. It accommodates protection prisoners. It is known as a “shared cell occupancy centre”, where single cells are the exception. The facility initially had 600 individual cells but over time as the number of inmates to be accommodated grew, bunk beds were placed in most of the cells to house more prisoners. As at 30 May 2022, there were 1049 beds across the 600 cells, however, there were also 871 complex protection prisoners that had to be appropriately and safely accommodated across those cells. As at 25 May 2022, there were 81 prisoners on the DNDU List at the WCC. Operations at the WCC are to be conducted in accordance with all applicable state laws, including in particular the CSA, together with supporting QCS policies and procedures, stipulated in Custodial Operations Practice Directives (COPDs). Of particular importance is s 18 of the CSA, which provides that “whenever practicable” each prisoner in a corrective services facility must be provided with a room that is not shared with any other prisoner. Due to the overcrowding at the WCC it is not practicable for every inmate to have their own cell. Indeed, doubling up has become the norm and prisoners are required to share a cell unless they are included on the DNDU List. Prisoners are only placed on the DNDU List in exceptional circumstances. Decisions concerning shared accommodation allocation and eligibility for inclusion the DNDU List are made in accordance with the “COPD – Prisoner Accommodation Management – Cell Allocation” (Cell Allocation COPD). Although the Cell Allocation COPD had undergone several revisions over time, insofar as the appellant’s case is concerned the shared cell accommodation placement considerations contained within it (COPD Criteria) remained largely unchanged at all material times. According to Version 6.0 of the Cell Allocation COPD, implemented 16 December 2021, considerations that may impact on whether prisoners are suitable to share a cell included but were not limited to:(a) if the prisoner has been previously victimised within a corrective services facility;(b) if the prisoner has previously perpetrated violence against other prisoners;(c) the prisoner’s history of self-harm and/or suicide attempts;(d) the prisoner’s offence and correctional history;(e) the prisoner’s relationships and known associations;(f) the prisoner’s religious and cultural background;(g) intelligence information;(h) the prisoner’s known physical and/or mental health, medical issues, disability and/or cognitive impairment (including liaison with PMHS and/or QHealth if the prisoner is a known open client of these services);(i) current warnings including escape risk, self-harm episode, enhanced security offender, identified risk, maximum security offender and sex offender flags;(j) individualised risk assessment for sexual offender placements;(k) if the prisoner is identified as a prisoner of concern;(l) if the prisoner is identified as Elevated Base Line Risk (EBLR);(m) if the prisoner is transgender or identifies as LGBTIQA+;(n) any other significant issues of concern; or(o) if the prisoner is on remand.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

According to evidence given by the second respondent, whilst each of the COPD Criteria were relevant to decisions made about cell placements, in his experience the most important factors were (the primary considerations):(a) [excluded from publication by order of the Court dated 12 September 2025 until further order];(b) [excluded from publication by order of the Court dated 12 September 2025 until further order]; and(c) [excluded from publication by order of the Court dated 12 September 2025 until further order]. In addition to the COPD Criteria that applied across all QCS facilities, due to issues of overcrowding and the scarcity of single cells, the WCC also employed a more limited set of local criteria to determine a prisoner’s eligibility to be placed on the DNDU List (Local Criteria). The Local Criteria included the primary considerations as well as the following matters:(a) whether the prisoner was on observations;(b) whether the prisoner was on an Intensive Management Plan (IMP) or Maximum-Security Unit (MSU) reintegration;(c) whether the prisoner had a psychotic disorder which had been confirmed by the PMHS;(d) whether the prisoner had an EBLR;(e) whether there were adverse intelligence holdings in respect of the prisoner;(f) whether Queensland Health had requested that the prisoner be accommodated in a single cell;(g) whether the prisoner was on a temporary placement;(h) whether the prisoner was on a guardianship order. A prisoner who satisfied any of these primary considerations would not be required to double-up and would be included on the DNDU List. A prisoner who did not might still be included on the DNDU List if they satisfied any one or more of the other factors listed in the COPD Criteria or the Local Criteria, subject to individual assessment. All assessments of requests for inclusion on the DNDU List at the WCC were carried out by a QCS prison psychologist. In carrying out the assessment, the psychologist would interview the prisoner, review relevant case file notes and other records and complete an assessment form. The assessment form included a top section, headed “Must be in a single cell”, under which the three primary considerations were listed, and a further section, headed “Assessment required”, under which the Local Criteria were listed. The assessment form also included a further section for a general formulation and assessment of the request. In each case, the psychologist would undertake an individualised and nuanced assessment of the particular prisoner and their circumstances to determine whether they were suitable for inclusion on the DNDU List. Despite the fact that the COPD Criteria purported to identify factors relevant to whether a prisoner might be suitable to be placed in shared cell accommodation, as the Tribunal noted in its reasons, at paragraph [11]:“…the process appears to have become one in which prisoners who did not immediately qualify for the DNDU list but who nevertheless did not wish to ‘double up’ made request or application, in various permissible ways, to be assessed and considered for inclusion on the DNDU list. Through this process, the overcrowded accommodation demands at the WCC seem to have caused the cell allocation decision making at that facility, in practice, to move from one of decisions being made about who might be allocated to a shared cell to one of decisions being made as to who should not be required to share a cell.”