MZYOI v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship

Link copied
Case Copied 64 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

MZYOI v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2012] FCA 868

Citation: MZYOI v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2012] FCA 868
Appeal from: MZYOI v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2012] FMCA 203
Parties: MZYOI v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP  and KERRY ANNE HARTMAN IN HER CAPACITY AS INDEPENDENT MERITS REVIEWER
File number: VID 290 of 2012
Judge: DODDS-STREETON J
Date of judgment: 16 August 2012
Catchwords: MIGRATION – Appeal from decision of Federal Magistrate, dismissing an application for review of decision of the Independent Merits Reviewer (“IMR”) – whether IMR’s failure to notify appellant her decision would be based on a different factual finding to the delegate’s was a denial of procedural fairness – whether IMR’s alleged failure to put or put accurately, certain country information was a denial of procedural fairness – whether Federal Magistrate misconstrued IMR’s finding as conclusion that the appellant faced no real risk of serious harm in his travel – whether IMR failed to take into account relevant considerations or deal with an essential integer of the appellant’s claim – whether IMR made an illogical finding – grounds of appeal do not identify any jurisdictional error – appeal dismissed
Legislation: Migration Act 1958 (Cth), s 36(2)
Cases cited: Appellant S395/2002 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs; Appellant S396/2002 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (2003) 216 CLR 473 explained
Chan Yee Kin v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1989) 169 CLR 379 considered
Commissioner for Australian Capital Territory Revenue v Alphaone Pty Ltd (1994) 49 FCR 576 considered
Htun v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (2001) 194 ALR 244 considered
Kioa v West (1985) 159 CLR 550 applied
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Ibrahim (2010) 204 CLR 1 cited
Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs v NAMW (2004) 140 FCR 572 cited
Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZONJ (2011) 278 ALR 608 considered
Muin v Refugee Review Tribunal (2002) 76 ALJR 966 cited
MZYLR v Minister for Immigration [2011] FMCA 633 distinguished
MZYOI v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2012] FMCA 203 affirming
MZYPA v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2012] FCA 581 considered
NABE v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (No 2) (2005) 144 FCR 1 considered
Plaintiff M61/2010E v The Commonwealth (2010) 243 CLR 319 applied
Razai v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2012] FCA 394 considered
Re Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs; Ex parte Miah (2001) 206 CLR 57 cited
SZBEL v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2006) 228 CLR 152 distinguished
SZOOR v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2012] FCAFC 58 considered
VEAL v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2005) 225 CLR 88 considered
Date of hearing: 25 May 2012
Date of last submissions: 25 May 2012
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 168
Counsel for the Appellant: Mr M Stanton
Solicitor for the Appellant: Victorian Legal Aid
Counsel for the First…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MZYOI v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] FCA 868
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of MZYOI v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship involved an Afghan national, MZYOI, who sought refugee status in Australia after arriving in the country without a visa. He claimed to be a Hazara of Shia faith, and alleged persecution by the Taliban due to his association with a deceased relative, Ismael Danish. MZYOI claimed he was kidnapped, assaulted, and threatened by members of the Taliban, leading him to flee Afghanistan. The Federal Magistrates Court reviewed the case and dismissed MZYOI's application for judicial review. The court had to determine whether MZYOI was credible and whether he faced persecution in Afghanistan if returned.

The court examined MZYOI's claims and the evidence provided, including the country information and the delegate's and IMR's findings. The IMR did not find MZYOI to be a credible witness and concluded that he did not face persecution in Afghanistan. The IMR noted that there were differing views on the treatment of Hazaras in Afghanistan and that while some Hazaras might face persecution, it was not necessarily the case for MZYOI. The court had to weigh the evidence and determine whether MZYOI's claims were credible and whether he would face persecution if returned to Afghanistan.

The court found that MZYOI's claims were not credible, as he had provided inconsistent and vague evidence. The court also found that the IMR's conclusions were reasonable and based on the evidence. The court held that MZYOI did not face persecution in Afghanistan and dismissed his application for judicial review. The court found that the delegate's and IMR's decisions were lawful and reasonable.

The Federal Magistrates Court dismissed the appellant's application for judicial review and affirmed the decision of the delegate and IMR. The court held that the appellant was not a credible witness and that he did not face persecution in Afghanistan. The court found that the delegate's and IMR's decisions were lawful and reasonable, and that the appellant's claims were not supported by the evidence. The court dismissed the appeal and the appellant's application for judicial review.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

In my opinion, for the reasons that follow, the grounds are not established and the appeal should be dismissed.BACKGROUND The appellant is a male citizen of Afghanistan of Hazara ethnicity and the Shia faith, who was born in 1966. He arrived on Christmas Island by boat without a visa on 23 February 2010. On 23 April 2010, he requested a refugee status assessment (“RSA”) by the Department of Immigration and Citizenship. The appellant was interviewed by a delegate of the first respondent (“the Minister”) on 26 April 2010 and, on 16 June 2010, was notified of the Minister’s negative RSA. The appellant sought a review by the IMR, who interviewed him on 10 October 2010 and, on 24 January 2011, recommended that he not be recognised as a refugee. The appellant was notified of the recommendation on 5 April 2011. On 28 July 2011, he applied to the Federal Magistrates Court for judicial review, and in November 2011, filed an amended application which was dismissed on 19 March 2012. Before the delegate, the appellant claimed he was of Hazara ethnicity and was a Shia Muslim who had lived for 44 years in Jaghori where the Mayor, Mullah Irfani, who was formerly a Mujahadeen, was now a member of the Taliban. The appellant conducted a cloth shop in the bazaar established by his father until he left Afghanistan in January 2010. He claimed that in late 2009, about a week before his departure for Australia, three members of the Taliban, one of whom was Irfani’s nephew, came to his house. When his wife claimed he was not at home, the men broke in. The appellant claimed that after assaulting the family, the men kidnapped him, and took him to a former Mujahadeen base where they hit him, demanded money and threatened to kill him. The appellant claimed that he managed to escape. He returned to Jaghori, sold his stock and travelled to Christmas Island. Before the delegate, the appellant stated that the kidnapping was due to his association with his deceased distant relation, Ismael Danish, who had been a popular commander of a group in the Jaghori government. The appellant asserted that Danish was killed by Irfani in 2000, with the Taliban’s assistance, at which time the appellant was imprisoned, beaten and tortured for 24 hours. He was released at the behest of village elders. The appellant claimed that Danish regularly visited his shop prior to his death, after which the kidnappers visited his shop each week and demanded money, which he paid. The appellant claimed that during the kidnapping, the kidnappers asked him to explain why Danish had visited. He explained that Danish was his distant uncle and the kidnappers demanded that he pay $27,000 which Danish had owed. They also threatened the appellant’s family with death. When the appellant indicated that he could pay $7,500, the men took a note from the appellant to his wife instructing her to get the money. The appellant stated that after the kidnapping, he decided that it was no longer safe and made plans to leave. The Delegate’s reasons

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The DFAT information also set out the statement extracted at paragraph 26 above.The IMR’s conclusions The IMR noted that, as set out in the country information, there were different views as to the way Hazaras were currently treated and what might happen to them if they returned to Afghanistan. The IMR noted reports which concluded that the majority of Hazaras were currently not being persecuted on any consistent basis, although that situation might not last indefinitely. The IMR accepted that the appellant was a Hazara of the Shia Faith. She stated at [61] that:The claimant is from Haydar Jaghori Ghazni. I have considered a number of different reports about Jaghori. I accept that it is a district entirely populated by Hazaras. I accept that the district is currently safe and relatively stable compared to Pashtun districts in Ghazni. I accept the people in Jaghori district, enjoy better educational and health facilities than neighbouring provinces due to their better security environment. I accept that the Taliban remain at the outskirts of Jaghori. I accept that Jaghori remains out of reach of Taliban control due to the military and political power of Hizb-I Wahdat Kalili/Nasr faction. I do not accept that the claimant faces a real chance of serious harm amounting to persecution by the Taliban because he is a Hazara from Jaghori. The IMR did not consider the appellant to be a truthful or credible witness. She noted that he appeared unfamiliar with the life, political activities and views of Danish, had avoided answering questions and changed his evidence about Danish’s alleged visits to his shop. The IMR observed that the appellant did not appear to know when Danish was killed, but accepted that there was not a great emphasis on dates in the appellant’s culture. She stated that she therefore placed no weight on his vague evidence about when Danish was killed. Nevertheless, the IMR did take into account the appellant’s lack of knowledge about the circumstances of Danish’s death. The IMR did not accept that the appellant was targeted by Irfani’s men from 1997 to 2009 because he was a relative, friend or supporter of Danish. The IMR observed that the appellant appeared to fabricate his responses and significantly changed his story by the late introduction of a claim that a donation to a boys’ school caused his problems. Further, while country information indicated that associates or former supporters of Danish were at risk of harm only if actively involved in re‑forming similar factions, the appellant had not been involved in Danish’s political activities and acknowledged that he did not know what those political activities were. The IMR did not accept that Irfani’s men had the appellant imprisoned, came to his shop, continually threatened him and demanded money, or that his photograph was provided to Taliban. The IMR stated at [60]:I do not accept that in 2009 a week before the claimant left for Australia Irfani’s men came to his house kidnapped him demanded money from him and threatened to kill him. I am of the view that the claimant has fabricated these claims in order to strengthen his claim to refugee status.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established