Moloney v 21-25 South Esplanade Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Court of Appeal: Civil)

MOLONEY v 21-25 SOUTH ESPLANADE PTY LTD & ORS

[2024] SASCA 58

Judgment of the Court of Appeal  

(The Honourable President Livesey, the Honourable Justice Bleby and the Honourable Justice David)

10 May 2024

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING - COURTS AND TRIBUNALS WITH ENVIRONMENT JURISDICTION - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - ENVIRONMENT, RESOURCES AND DEVELOPMENT COURT AND ITS PREDECESSORS - POWERS ON APPEAL

The appellant owns property adjoining a proposed development in Glenelg.  The developer,
21-25 South Esplanade Pty Ltd (the respondent), sought planning consent from the second respondent, the State Planning Commission.  The Commission’s delegate, the State Commission Assessment Panel (SCAP), treated the development as a Category 2 development.


The appellant and others were notified and contended that the development should be refused planning consent.  Initially, the development comprised three underground levels, which included car parking space, and was proposed to rise more than 45 metres and 13 storeys.  The revised development is proposed to rise more than 40 metres and at least 10 storeys.  The development requires the demolition of two heritage listed dwelling houses.

The relevant portions of the Development Plan provide for a maximum of five storeys in the area of the development and protect heritage places from demolition.

SCAP refused planning consent and the respondent appealed to the Environment, Resources and Development Court (the ERD Court). The appellant and others sought to be joined to the planning appeal. Before the application for joinder was heard, SCAP and the respondent resolved the appeal on the basis of the revised development proposal. This occurred before a conference was conducted pursuant to s 16 of the Environment, Resources and Development Court Act 1993 (SA) (the ERD Court Act). 

An order for joinder was made by the ERD Court which permitted the appellant to contest the merits of the respondent’s revised development in the planning appeal.

The respondent appealed to a single judge of the Supreme Court, who allowed the appeal and set aside the order for joinder, finding that the joinder powers contained in s 17 of the ERD Court Act and s 88(2)(c) of the Development Act 1993 (SA) (now repealed) (the Development Act) were constrained by the respondent’s right to have the compromise reflected in orders of the ERD Court under s 16 of the ERD Court Act. 

The appeal judge distinguished the decision of the Full Court in Pitt v Environment Resources and Development Court (1995) 66 SASR 274 (Pitt) and declined to follow O’Neill v Kimhi [2008] SASC 109 (O’Neill) because those cases did not concern joinder where the planning appeal had been compromised.

HELD (the Court), allowing the appeal, and dismissing the notice of contention, setting aside the orders made by the appeal judge and restoring the orders made by the ERD Court:

1.The appeal judge erroneously constrained the operation of s 88(2)(c) of the Development Act by reference to the terms of s 16…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Moloney v 21-25 South Esplanade Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] SASCA 58
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned an appeal to the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia regarding a development application. The appellant, Mr Moloney, an adjoining landowner, sought to oppose a large apartment building proposed by the respondent, 21-25 South Esplanade Pty Ltd. The development, which involved demolishing heritage-listed dwellings, was significantly taller and more voluminous than permitted by the relevant Development Plan. The State Commission Assessment Panel (SCAP) initially refused planning consent due to substantial departures from the Development Plan's objectives regarding scale, massing, and heritage protection.

The legal issues before the Full Court included whether the Environment, Resources and Development (ERD) Court had erred in its approach to joinder applications under section 88(2)(c) of the Development Act, and the proper application of section 16 of the ERD Court Act. Specifically, the court considered the extent to which an applicant for joinder, such as Mr Moloney, should be permitted to contest the merits of a development application, and the ERD Court's powers and obligations when considering such applications, particularly in light of potential compromises and consequential orders.

The Full Court reasoned that once an order for joinder is made, the ERD Court is empowered to consider the merits of the development, potentially with the assistance of a contradictor. The court found that there were arguable issues regarding whether the revised development proposal was seriously at variance with the Development Plan and whether it constituted a "substantially different" development from the original, thereby potentially breaching the principles established in cases like *City of Marion v Lady Becker*. The court determined that applicants for joinder are likely to be in a position to assist the ERD Court with these matters, whether at a section 16 conference or in a hearing de novo.

The appeal was allowed, the notice of contention was dismissed, and the orders made by the appeal judge were set aside and replaced with those made by the ERD Court. The Full Court indicated that it would hear from the parties regarding costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

These reasons are structured as follows:Overview of the disposition of the appealFactual backgroundThe reasons of the ERD CourtThe reasons of the appeal judgeThe ERD Court and the relevant legislationThe ERD CourtSections 16 and 17 of the ERD Court ActThe Development Act (now repealed)Relevant authorities preceding this appealThe approach of the parties to this appealFirst question: joinder under s 88(2)(c) of the Development ActSub-section 88(2)(a)Distinguishing Pitt and not following O’NeillOther mattersSecond question: s 16 of the ERD Court ActDisposition of the appealConclusionFactual background A Category 2 representor and adjoining landowner in Glenelg, Mr Moloney (the appellant), contended that the development proposed by the developer, 21‑25 South Esplanade Pty Ltd (the respondent), should be refused planning consent. The order for joinder made by the ERD Court permitted the appellant to contest the merits of the respondent’s development in a planning appeal. The respondent proposes to construct a large apartment building which will wrap around the appellant’s residence on two sides. Initially, the development comprised three underground levels, which included car parking space, and was proposed to rise more than 45 metres and 13 storeys. The revised development is proposed to rise more than 40 metres and at least 10 storeys. The development requires the demolition of two heritage listed dwelling houses. The relevant portions of the Development Plan provide for a maximum of five storeys in the area of the development and protect heritage places from demolition. The respondent sought planning consent[8] from the second respondent, the State Planning Commission. The Commission’s delegate, the State Commission Assessment Panel (SCAP), treated the development as a Category 2 development. SCAP gave notice of the development application to the appellant and others in the immediate vicinity. The appellant and at least 23 others made representations opposing the development. The appellant relied on an expert planning report and the opinion of counsel that the development was seriously at variance with the Development Plan. In addition, SCAP permitted the appellant by counsel to make an oral address to it. [8] This was described as “development plan consent” under s 33(1)(a) of the Development Act, but it is now referred to as “planning consent” under s 102(1)(a) of the Planning, Development and Infrastructure Act 2016 (SA). Planning consent was sought under ss 32, 33(1)(a) and 44(1) of the Development Act, now replaced by ss 101, 102(1)(a) and 215(1) of the Planning, Development and Infrastructure Act 2016 (SA). On 30 June 2021, SCAP refused planning consent and gave reasons. They were:a)The proposal significantly departs from the intent of the Desired Character Statements within Urban Glenelg Policy Area 15 and Precinct 4 Five Storey, Precinct; Precinct PDC 20(b) and (c), and General Section Design and Appearance PDC 1 for the following reasons:i.The proposal does not achieve a sufficient transition in scale; andii.The proposal presents excessive massing, is insufficiently modulated and does not adequately acknowledge and respect the existing context.b)It has not been adequately demonstrated that the Local Heritage Place cannot be conserved in accordance with General Section Heritage Places Objective 1 and Objective 2.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Once an order for joinder is made, the ERD Court will consider the compromise and the consequential orders sought with the assistance of a contradictor. On the face of it there may, at the least, be real issues about whether the revised proposal is seriously at variance as well as whether it was “substantially different” from the original plan and, thereby, in breach of the Lady Becker principle.[136] The applicants for joinder are likely to be in a position to assist the ERD Court with these matters, whether at a s 16 conference or in a hearing de novo on the merits, or both. [136] City of Marion v Lady Becker (1973) 6 SASR 13, 28, 24 and 26 (Wells J). See also 44 (Bray CJ), 58 (Hogarth J) and 62, 67 (Zelling J). In Independent Holdings Ltd v City of Adelaide Planning Commissioner (1994) 63 SASR 318, 327, Millhouse J considered whether the revision altered “the essential character of the proposed development”. The ERD Court has since generally posed the question as whether the revision is “fundamentally different in character”, Citify Pty Ltd v Corporation of the City of Marion [2021] SAERDC 30, [32]; Clarke v District Council of Grant [2016] SAERDC 36, [51].Conclusion The appeal should be allowed. The notice of contention should be dismissed. The orders made by the appeal judge should be set aside and those made by the ERD Court should be restored. It will be necessary to hear from the parties as to costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.