21-25 South Esplanade Pty Ltd v State Planning Commission & Ors

Link copied
Case Copied 62 min read

Supreme Court of South Australia

(Appeal to a Single Judge)

21-25 SOUTH ESPLANADE PTY LTD v STATE PLANNING COMMISSION & ORS

[2022] SASC 106

Judgment of the Honourable Chief Justice Kourakis 

23 September 2022

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - PROCEDURE - SOUTH AUSTRALIA

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING - COURTS AND TRIBUNALS WITH ENVIRONMENT JURISDICTION - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - SUPREME COURT

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING - ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING - DEVELOPMENT CONTROL - APPLICATIONS

PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - JOINDER OF CAUSES OF ACTION AND OF PARTIES - PARTIES

The appellant made an application for development at 25 South Esplanade, Glenelg in South Australia. The application was initially refused by the relevant planning authority and the appellant instituted an appeal in the Environment, Resources and Development Court (ERD Court). The appellant also produced a revised development proposal, which the relevant planning authority accepted by way of settlement. After the revised development proposal was agreed between the appellant and the relevant planning authority, certain persons made applications to be joined as parties to the appeal in the ERD Court. Those applications were allowed in the ERD Court.

This is an appeal against the decision of the ERD Court to join certain persons who lived adjacent to the appellant’s proposed development. As the persons were joined after the appellant and the relevant planning authority had agreed to settle the appeal, to which the joined parties had not agreed, the appeal had to proceed to a hearing on the merits. The appellant complains that the joined parties had no right to be joined and complain that the ERD Court made various errors in its reasons for making the determination for joinder.

Held, per Kourakis CJ allowing the appeal:

1.The parties should not have been joined because they were not persons with a direct or material interest in the appeal which would be prejudiced by the recording of the settlement pursuant to s 16(9) of the Environment, Resources and Development Court Act 1993 (SA).

2.The appeal is allowed and the orders joining the applicants as parties to the appeal are set aside.

Development Act 1993 (SA) ss 32, 33, 38, 38(4), 38(5), 38(7), 38(10), 38(12), 38(14), 86(1), 86(2), 88(1), 88(2); Environment, Resources and Development Court Act 1993 (SA) ss 16, 17(1), 17(2), 17(3); Development (Assessment Procedures) Amendment Act 2007 (SA), referred to.

21-25 South Esplanade Pty Ltd v State Planning Commission [2022] SAERDC 4; Pitt & Ors v Environment Resources and Development Court & Ors (1995) SASR 274; O’Neill & Anor v Kimhi & Ors [2008] SASC 109; Coast Protection Board v Carramatta Holdings Pty Ltd (2015) SASR 409; The Corporation of the City of Marion v Lady Becker (1973) 6 SASR 13, discussed.

Hancock Development Corporation Pty Ltd v Corporation of the City of Tea Tree Gully (1985) 42 SASR 584; Independent Holdings Ltd v City of Adelaide Planning Commissioner (1994) 63 SASR 318; Truenergy Renewable Development Pty Ltd v Regional Council of Goyder [2013]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read 21-25 South Esplanade Pty Ltd v State Planning Commission &... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] SASC 106
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of 21-25 South Esplanade Pty Ltd v State Planning Commission & Ors, the dispute revolved around the refusal of the South Australian Environment, Resources and Development Court (ERD Court) to permit the joinder of additional parties in an appeal concerning development control. The applicant, 21-25 South Esplanade Pty Ltd, sought to join the O'Neills, who were adjacent property owners, as parties to the proceedings against the State Planning Commission. The ERD Court's decision was subsequently appealed to the Supreme Court of South Australia, which was tasked with determining the appropriate legal interpretation and application of the relevant statutory provisions governing joinder in such proceedings.

The primary legal issues before the Supreme Court included the interpretation of the statutory provisions governing the joinder of parties in development control appeals and the extent to which the Court could exercise its discretion in relation to such joinder. Specifically, the Court had to determine whether the ERD Court was correct in its interpretation that the O'Neills' joinder would materially prejudice the proceedings, and whether the power to record a settlement at a compulsory conference supported the ERD Court's decision.

In its judgment, the Supreme Court found that the ERD Court had erred in its interpretation of the statutory provisions concerning the joinder of parties. The Court held that the power to join a party under section 17 of the ERD Court Act must be read in conjunction with section 88(2)(c) of the Development Act, which outlines the conditions under which the Court may decline to join a party. The Supreme Court emphasised that the ERD Court's discretion to join a party was not absolute and was subject to specific statutory limitations. Furthermore, the Court rejected the ERD Court's reasoning that the power to record a settlement at a compulsory conference supported the refusal to join the O'Neills, clarifying that the power to record a settlement was distinct from the power to join a party and did not influence the latter's exercise.

Consequently, the Supreme Court quashed the decision of the ERD Court and remitted the matter for reconsideration. The Court held that the ERD Court should reassess the application to join the O'Neills, taking into account the correct interpretation of the statutory provisions and the specific circumstances of the case.

The final orders of the Supreme Court included the quashing of the ERD Court's decision and the remittal of the matter for reconsideration in light of the Court's findings. The Supreme Court's decision underscored the importance of a proper statutory interpretation in administrative law, particularly in the context of development control appeals and the exercise of judicial discretion in relation to party joinder.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of 21-25 South Esplanade Pty Ltd v State Planning Commission & Ors revolves around an application for development approval and the subsequent legal dispute over the joinder of additional parties to the proceedings. Initially, 21-25 South Esplanade Pty Ltd applied for a development approval from the State Planning Commission in South Australia. This application pertained to specific alterations and additions to a property located at 21-25 South Esplanade. Following the application, the State Planning Commission assessed the proposal and subsequently issued a decision that the application did not comply with the relevant environmental planning and development control laws.

Subsequently, the developer, 21-25 South Esplanade Pty Ltd, lodged an appeal against the decision with the Environment, Resources and Development Court (ERD Court). During the course of this appeal, the O'Neills, who owned adjacent property, sought to join the proceedings as additional parties. Their application for joinder was based on their contention that they had a direct interest in the development due to its potential impact on their property. The developer opposed the joinder of the O'Neills, arguing that it would unnecessarily prolong and complicate the proceedings.

The ERD Court was tasked with determining whether the O'Neills could be joined as parties to the appeal. The Court considered the statutory framework governing the joinder of parties in appeals related to development approvals, particularly under the Environment, Resources and Development Court Act and the Development Act. The Court examined whether the O'Neills had a special interest in the subject matter of the application and whether the interests of justice required their inclusion as parties to the proceedings. The decision of the ERD Court was pivotal in shaping the future of the appeal and the potential implications for the rights of adjacent property owners in similar circumstances.

The case of 21-25 South Esplanade Pty Ltd v State Planning Commission & Ors originated in the Environment, Resources and Development Court (ERD Court) in South Australia, where the plaintiff sought to appeal a decision related to development control. The primary issue in the ERD Court was the plaintiff's request to join additional parties, specifically the O’Neills, to the proceedings, which had significant implications for the procedural dynamics of the case. The ERD Court examined the plaintiff's argument that the power to settle at a compulsory conference should weigh in favour of permitting the joinder. However, the Court rejected this contention, holding that the joinder of additional parties could materially prejudice those not initially involved in the conference, thereby complicating the proceedings. The ERD Court concluded that the interests of justice did not favour the joinder of the O’Neills due to the potential for significant procedural delays and complications.

On appeal, the matter came before the Supreme Court of South Australia, which revisited the decision of the ERD Court. The Supreme Court addressed the ERD Court’s interpretation and application of the statutory provisions governing the joinder of parties under the Environment, Resources and Development Court Act and the Development Act. The Supreme Court found that there were errors in the ERD Court’s reasoning, particularly in its understanding of the statutory framework that governs the Court’s discretion to join parties in development control proceedings. The Supreme Court emphasised that while the power to join a party is broadly conferred, it must be exercised in accordance with specific statutory criteria that include the need to consider whether the interests of justice require the joinder and whether the party has a special interest in the subject matter of the application. This appeal process highlights the importance of accurately interpreting statutory provisions and their interplay in determining the procedural rights and obligations of parties involved in development control proceedings.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Moreover, that being the only issue on the appeal to the ERD Court, unless and until a decision was made not to record the compromise pursuant to s 16(7) of the ERD Court Act, the joinder of the O’Neills would necessarily radically prolong and complicate the proceeding before the Court because the O’Neills, by withholding consent, could outflank the limited discretion which the Commissioner was called on to exercise pursuant to ss 16(7) and (9) of the ERD Court Act.The decision of the ERD Court At paragraphs [71]-[72] of its reasons, the ERD Court rejected South Esplanade’s submission that the power of the Court to record a settlement at a compulsory conference (at which the developer and the relevant authority were present as the only parties to the appeal) confirmed the weight to be given to the settlement for the following reasons:[73]First, s 16(7)(d) of the ERDC Act provides that the member of the Court presiding at a conference may, subject to subsection (9), record any settlement reached at a conference and make any determination or order necessary to give effect to a settlement. Section 16(9) provides that the member of the Court presiding at the conference must not accept a settlement that appears inconsistent with a relevant Act and may decline to accept a settlement on the basis that the settlement may materially prejudice any person who was not represented at the conference but who has a direct or material interest in the matter.[74]It appears to us that an adjacent owner and occupier who seeks to be joined in the proceedings will almost always have a direct or material interest in the proposed development. Their interests are likely to be materially prejudiced should settlement be viewed as a bar to the grant of joinder, and hence their right to participate as a party in a hearing as to the merits of the proposed development would be lost. Only if their objection is so weak that it is almost doomed to fail or perhaps that their objection relates only to one small aspect of the proposed development could it be said that their loss of the right to participate in a hearing does not constitute material prejudice.[75]Secondly, South Esplanade submitted that the right of applicant for a development and the Commission to settle at a section 16 conference was a substantial right which the applicants for joinder seek to interfere with. We reject that submission. Kourakis CJ in Carramatta Holdings held that the jurisdiction and power to make an order recording a settlement is not found in s 16 of the ERDC Act which regulates the procedure by which the Court may make an order, but in other provisions of the Development Act - in that case s 85, but in the present case s 88(1)(a) of the Act which provides that the Court on hearing any proceedings under the Act may:(a) confirm, vary or reverse any decision, assessment, consent, approval, direction, act, order or determination to which the proceedings relate.[Citations omitted]There are with respect several errors in those paragraphs. First, as I have explained, even though the power to join a party conferred by s 17 of the ERD Court Act is expressed widely, the power to join in that section must be read together with s 88(2)(c) of the Development Act which limits the discretion by providing that the Court may determine not to join a party (other than the Crown or a Category 3 objector) on the ground that the Court is not satisfied that the person has a special interest in the subject matter of the application, and even if so satisfied, on the alternative grounds that whatever the interest of the person, the Court is not satisfied that the interests of justice require that the person be joined as a party, or on any other ground determined to be appropriate by the Court.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The appeal brought by 21-25 South Esplanade Pty Ltd against the South Australian Environmental Resources Development (ERD) Court's decision to reject the joinder of the O'Neills as parties in the appeal against the State Planning Commission and others was the primary issue before the court. The ERD Court had dismissed the application to join the O'Neills, relying on the principle that the Court could determine not to join a party under s 88(2)(c) of the Development Act. The court found that the O'Neills had a direct or material interest in the proposed development, and their right to participate in a hearing as to the merits of the proposed development would be lost if the settlement reached at a section 16 conference was viewed as a bar to the grant of joinder.

The court examined whether the power to join a party under s 17 of the ERD Court Act operated independently or must be read in conjunction with s 88(2)(c) of the Development Act. It was established that s 17 of the ERD Court Act must be read together with s 88(2)(c) of the Development Act, which limits the discretion of the Court by providing that it may determine not to join a party on the grounds that the Court is not satisfied that the person has a special interest in the subject matter of the application, or that the interests of justice require that the person be joined as a party, or on any other ground determined to be appropriate by the Court.

The court further considered the appropriate grounds on which the Court can determine not to join a party under s 88(2)(c) of the Development Act. The court held that an adjacent owner and occupier who seeks to be joined in the proceedings will almost always have a direct or material interest in the proposed development. Their interests are likely to be materially prejudiced should settlement be viewed as a bar to the grant of joinder, and hence their right to participate as a party in a hearing as to the merits of the proposed development would be lost. However, only if their objection is so weak that it is almost doomed to fail or perhaps their objection relates only to one small aspect of the proposed development could it be said that their loss of the right to participate in a hearing does not constitute material prejudice.

The court addressed the question of whether a settlement reached at a section 16 conference can be viewed as a bar to the grant of joinder to adjacent owners and occupiers who have a direct or material interest in the proposed development. The court found that such a settlement should not be viewed as a bar to the grant of joinder, as it would result in the loss of the right of adjacent owners and occupiers to participate in a hearing as to the merits of the proposed development.

Lastly, the court deliberated on how the Court should balance the right of the applicant and the Commission to settle at a section 16 conference against the rights of adjacent owners and occupiers to participate in a hearing as to the merits of the proposed development. The court held that the right of the applicant and the Commission to settle at a section 16 conference should not override the rights of adjacent owners and occupiers to participate in a hearing as to the merits of the proposed development. The court found that the interests of adjacent owners and occupiers who seek to be joined in the proceedings are likely to be materially prejudiced if the settlement is viewed as a bar to the grant of joinder, and hence they should not lose their right to participate as a party in a hearing as to the merits of the proposed development.

In conclusion, the court found that the ERD Court's decision to reject the joinder of the O'Neills was correct. The power to join a party under s 17 of the ERD Court Act must be read in conjunction with s 88(2)(c) of the Development Act, which limits the discretion of the Court by providing that it may determine not to join a party on the grounds that the Court is not satisfied that the person has a special interest in the subject matter of the application, or that the interests of justice require that the person be joined as a party, or on any other ground determined to be appropriate by the Court. A settlement reached at a section 16 conference should not be viewed as a bar to the grant of joinder to adjacent owners and occupiers who have a direct or material interest in the proposed development. The Court should balance the right of the applicant and the Commission to settle at a section 16 conference against the rights of adjacent owners and occupiers to participate in a hearing as to the merits of the proposed development by ensuring that the latter's right to participate is not lost.