DISTRICT COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Criminal)
R v SCOTT
Criminal Trial by Judge Alone
[2025] SADC 66
Judgment of his Honour Judge Soulio
6 May 2025
CRIMINAL LAW
Accused jointly charged with one Ms Temple on Information dated 27 May 2022 with two counts of trafficking in methylamphetamine.
Verdict: - As to both counts Not Guilty.
Controlled Substances Act 1984 (SA) ss 4, 32; Juries Act 1927 (SA) s 7, referred to.
R v Gardi [2015] SASC 186; Zenuni v The King [2022] SASC 106, considered.
R v SCOTT
[2025] SADC 66
Introduction
The accused, Paul John Scott, was jointly charged with one Susan Emily Temple on an Information dated 27 May 2022 with two counts of trafficking in a controlled drug, pursuant to s 32 of the Controlled Substances Act.
The particulars of the offence in each count are that the accused, on 3 April 2021 at Salisbury, trafficked in a controlled drug, namely methylamphetamine, knowing or being reckless as to the fact the substance was a controlled drug.
The reason that there are two counts is that there were two separate amounts of methylamphetamine found in a motor vehicle stopped by police on that date.
The Prosecution Case
The prosecution case, in broad overview, is that on 3 April 2021 police observed a motor vehicle bearing registration S494 BAN and determined that that vehicle had an active defect notice applicable to it. Police activated their lights, and the driver of the vehicle, Ms Temple, stopped the vehicle and alighted from the driver's side door. She approached police and identified herself. Police ascertained that Ms Temple was not authorised to drive due to previous drug driving convictions.
Police arranged for the vehicle to be impounded due to the status of Ms Temple's licence. The accused and Ms Temple were directed to remove personal items from the vehicle.
Police evidence from Police Officers Jackson and Cheney included that the accused collected a shopping bag from the front passenger side footwell. Ms Temple took possession of two backpacks which were also located in that footwell.
Police formed a suspicion regarding the circumstances in which the accused and Ms Temple were in the vehicle. I pause to observe that there was no challenge to the formation of that suspicion, nor to the lawfulness of the search that followed.
The search of the accused resulted in police finding a bundle of empty plastic resealable bags in the accused's right trouser pocket. The accused gave evidence during trial that those bags had been in the centre console of the vehicle and when police pulled the vehicle over he grabbed the plastic bags and put them in his pocket. He rather frankly said he did so out of “force of habit”.
Inside the vehicle police located a sunglasses case under the passenger side footwell. That case contained a number of small zip lock bags containing what, upon analysis, turned out to be methylamphetamine, with a mixed weight of 9.65 gm and a…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Scott and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2025] SADC 66
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The High Court found that the evidence presented was sufficient to establish the respondent's intent to kill. The court held that the respondent's actions, including the use of a lethal weapon and the circumstances surrounding the death, demonstrated a clear intention to cause fatal harm. The court further found that the trial judge had correctly directed the jury on the necessary mens rea for a murder conviction. The court emphasised that for a murder conviction, it must be proven that the accused had the intent to cause death or grievous bodily harm at the time of the offence. The High Court dismissed the appeal and upheld the conviction, finding that the evidence and legal directions were appropriate and aligned with the principles of criminal law.
The court's decision underscores the importance of clear and sufficient evidence in establishing the requisite intent for a murder conviction. The High Court's ruling provides clarity on the application of mens rea in murder cases and reinforces the necessity for a direct causal link between the accused's actions and the fatal outcome. The court's analysis ensures that the principles of criminal responsibility are applied consistently and fairly, protecting the integrity of the justice system.