Re: CARMEL ELIZABETH McDONALD
And: DIRECTOR-GENERAL OF SOCIAL SECURITY
No. VG 196 of 1982
(1984) ADMN para 96-005 / (1984) ASSC para 92-000 / 1 FCR 354
Social Security - Crown
COURT
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
Woodward(1), Northrop(2) and Woodward(3) JJ.
CATCHWORDS
Social Security - invalid pension - meaning of "permanently incapacitated for work" - likelihood of persistence in the foreseeable future - whether any onus of proof.
Administrative Law - whether principles concerning onus of proof apply to hearings by administrative tribunals - importance of relevant legislation.
Social Security Act 1947 ss.14, 23, 24, 46(1) and 108.
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act ss.33(1)(c), 43 and 44.
Social Security - Invalid pension - Permanent incapacity for work - Meaning of "permanent" - Likelihood of persisting in the foreseeable future - Whether any onus of proof - Social Security Act 1947 (Cth), s. 24.
Social Security - Invalid pension - Onus of proof - Whether principles concerning onus of proof apply to grant, cancellation or refusal of pension - Appeal from decision confirming cancellation - Whether either party bears onus of proof - Social Security Act 1947 (Cth), ss 24, 14, 46(1) - Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), ss 33(1)(c), 43, 44.
Crown - Administrative Appeals Legislation (Cth) - Review of decision affirming cancellation of invalid pension - Whether principles concerning onus of proof apply - Social Security Act 1947 (Cth), ss 14, 46(1) - Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), ss 33(1)(c), 43, 44.
Words and phrases - "permanent incapacity" - Social Security Act 1947 (Cth), s. 23.
HEADNOTE
The Social Security Act 1947 (Cth), s. 24 provides:
"a person above the age of sixteen years who . . . is permanently incapacitated for work . . . shall be qualified to receive an invalid pension."
Held (per totam curiam), that for the purposes of the Social Security Act 1947 (Cth), s. 24, the true test of a permanent, as distinct from temporary, incapacity is whether in the light of the available evidence, it is more likely than not that the incapacity will persist in the foreseeable future.
Wicks v. Union Steamship Company of New Zealand Ltd (1933) 50 C.L.R. 328; Calico Printers' Association, Ltd v. Higham (1912) 1 K.B. 93, distinguished.
Per Jenkinson J. The Tribunal considered that the applicant's pension should be cancelled unless she were found to be permanently incapacitated for work, whereas the requirement of the Act was that the pension should be cancelled if she were found not to be permanently incapacitated for work.
Observations concerning the inapplicability of adversary proceeding concepts such as the onus of proof in administrative proceedings.
Dickinson v. Minister of Pensions (1953) 1 Q.B. 228 at 232, distinguished.
HEARING
Melbourne, 1983, December 12; 1984, March 27. #DATE 27:3:1984
APPEAL
Appeal from a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal which affirmed a decision to cancel an invalid pension granted under the Social Secutiry Act 1947 (Cth), s. 24.
P. N. Rose, for the applicant.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read McDonald v Director-General of Social Security and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1984] FCA 59
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues before the court were the interpretation of the phrase "permanently incapacitated for work" and the associated onus of proof required for McDonald to establish her eligibility for an invalid pension. The court needed to determine whether the onus of proof lay with McDonald to demonstrate the permanence and future persistence of her incapacity, or whether the Director-General bore this burden. Additionally, the court had to interpret the phrase "permanently incapacitated for work" and assess the evidence provided by McDonald concerning her health and capacity to work.
The court found that the onus of proof regarding the permanence and future persistence of incapacity for work did not solely rest on McDonald but was shared between both parties. The phrase "permanently incapacitated for work" was interpreted to mean that the incapacity must be both permanent and likely to continue into the foreseeable future. Given the evidence presented, the court concluded that the Administrative Appeals Tribunal had not adequately considered the requirements of the Act, particularly in relation to the shared onus of proof and the interpretation of "permanently incapacitated for work". Consequently, the court set aside the decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal and remitted the matter back for reconsideration, directing that the matter be reheard with or without further evidence, in light of the court's findings. The appeal was allowed, and the Director-General was ordered to pay McDonald's costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
(a) the appeal be allowed;
(b) the decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal be set aside;
(c) the matter be remitted to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal to be reheard, with or without further evidence, and decided in the light of this Court's reasons for judgment, and
(d) the Respondent pay the Applicant's costs. Appeal allowed with respondent to pay costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi