Lendlease Building Pty Ltd v BCF Airport Systems Pty Ltd & Ors

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:  Lendlease Building Pty Ltd v BCS Airport Systems Pty Ltd &
Ors [2024] QSC 164
PARTIES:  LENDLEASE BUILDING PTY LTD
(plaintiff)
v
BCS AIRPORT SYSTEMS PTY LTD
(first defendant)
AND
JOHN TUHTAN
(second defendant)
AND
REGISTRAR APPOINTED UNDER S 150 OF THE
BUILDING INDUSTRY FAIRNESS (SECURITY OF
PAYMENT) ACT 2017 (QLD)
(third defendant)
FILE NO:  2108 of 2023
DIVISION:  Trial Division
PROCEEDING:  Trial
ORIGINATING  Supreme Court at Brisbane
COURT: 
DELIVERED ON:  30 July 2024
DELIVERED AT:  Brisbane
HEARING DATE:  12 and 13 June 2023
JUDGE:  Sullivan J
ORDER:  The application is dismissed.

CATCHWORDS: CONTRACTS – BUILDING, ENGINEERING AND

RELATED CONTRACTS – REMUNERATION –

STATUTORY REGULATION OF ENTITLEMENT TO

AND RECOVERY OF PROGRESS PAYMENTS – PAYMENT CLAIMS – where the plaintiff was the principal

contractor under a head contract for construction work to be

performed at the Gold Coast Airport – where the plaintiff entered into a sub-contract with the first defendant – where the

first defendant delivered a payment claim to the plaintiff in the

amount of $1,215,733.23 – where an adjudication decision was

made in respect of the sub-contract in the amount of

$995,081.18 – where the plaintiff seeks a declaration that the adjudication decision is void – whether such a declaration

ought to be made

ADMINISTATIVE LAW – JUDICIAL REVIEW –

GROUNDS OF REVIEW – JURISIDCITIONAL MATTERS

– where an adjudication decision in the amount of $995,081.18

was made under the Building Industry Fairness (Security of

Payment) Act 2017 (Qld) – where the border between

Queensland and New South Wales runs through the

construction work to be performed – where the plaintiff asserts

that s 61(4) excludes from the operation of the Act construction

work carried out outside of Queensland – whether the proper

construction of s 61(4) of the Act gives rise to a jurisdictional

fact – whether a payment claim in a cross-border project must

reasonably identify the location of the construction work

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – JUDICIAL REVIEW –

GROUNDS OF REVIEW – PROCEDURAL FAIRNESS –

where the plaintiff submits that a failure by the adjudicator to consider submissions was a breach of natural justice in the

decision-making process – whether the adjudicator failed to consider the submissions – whether any such failure was

material

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – JUDICIAL REVIEW –

REVIEWABLE DECISIONS AND

CONDUCT – DISTINCTION BETWEEN ADMINISTRATIVE AND JUDICIAL FUNCTIONS – where

the land upon which the Gold Coast Airport is sited is regulated under the Commonwealth Places (Application of Laws) Act 1970 (Cth) - whether the adjudicator was exercising judicial

power within the meaning of s 4 of that Act

Accident Compensation Act 1985 (Vic), s 85

Acts Interpretation Act 1954 (Qld), s 27(b)

Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act

1999 (NSW), s 7(3), s 13, s 32

Building Industry Fairness (Security of Payment) Act 2017

(Qld), s 3, s 61, s 64, s 65, s 66, s 68, s 70, s 75, s 91 ,s 92, s 4

s 93, s 98, s 99, s…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lendlease Building Pty Ltd v BCF Airport Systems Pty Ltd & O... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QSC 164
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Lendlease Building Pty Ltd sought a declaration that an adjudication decision in favour of BCF Airport Systems Pty Ltd, in the amount of $995,081.18, was void. The court was asked to consider whether the adjudication decision was made in accordance with the statutory provisions governing the security of payments in the construction industry. This case involved the construction of baggage handling systems at the Gold Coast Airport, where Lendlease was the principal contractor and BCF Airport Systems Pty Ltd was the sub-contractor. BCF Airport Systems Pty Ltd submitted a payment claim to Lendlease for $1,215,733.23, which was subsequently adjudicated in BCF's favour in the amount of $995,081.18. Lendlease challenged the validity of the adjudication decision, arguing that the adjudicator failed to consider submissions, misapplied the statutory provisions, and that the decision-making process breached natural justice.

The court considered whether the adjudicator's failure to consider certain submissions was material and whether it amounted to a breach of natural justice. The court also examined whether the adjudicator was exercising judicial power within the meaning of the Commonwealth Places (Application of Laws) Act 1970 (Cth). Additionally, the court assessed whether the proper construction of the Building Industry Fairness (Security of Payment) Act 2017 (Qld) gave rise to a jurisdictional fact, and whether a payment claim in a cross-border project must reasonably identify the location of the construction work. The court concluded that the adjudicator's failure to consider the submissions was not material, and that there was no breach of natural justice. The court also found that the adjudicator was not exercising judicial power within the meaning of the Commonwealth Places (Application of Laws) Act 1970 (Cth). Furthermore, the court determined that the proper construction of the Building Industry Fairness (Security of Payment) Act 2017 (Qld) did not give rise to a jurisdictional fact, and that a payment claim in a cross-border project did not necessarily need to reasonably identify the location of the construction work.

The court dismissed Lendlease's application to set aside the adjudication decision, finding that Lendlease was not entitled to the injunction it sought. The court found that the adjudication decision was valid and that Lendlease was not entitled to the declaration it sought. The court also ordered that the application be dismissed and that further submissions be heard on the issue of costs. The court further noted that there had been monies previously paid into Court and that it would hear the parties in relation to any consequential orders which flow from these reasons.

Orders

Orders of the court

The application is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Before turning to any of the issues, it is appropriate to set out the relevant background facts. Contract and background facts The contract between Lendlease and BCS is dated 3 July 2019. It was for the design and construction of certain baggage handling works at the Gold Coast Airport. As with most contracts involving significant construction tasks, the contract itself has a variety of constituent parts. In this case, there is a head page, a Formal Instrument of Agreement, a set of standard terms, an appendix, schedules and a series of annexures. In summarising the contract below, I will make reference to various of those constituent parts. The head page of the contract provided relevantly as follows: “MAJOR WORKS SUBCONTRACT PROJECT: Gold Coast Airport - Southern Terminal Expansion - Project Lift SITE ADDRESS: East Avenue, Bilinga … SUBCONTRACTOR: BCS Airport Systems Pty Ltd … WORKS: Baggage Handling Systems … ANNEXURES Annexure A: Subcontract Sum … Annexure D: Drawings Annexure E: Scope of Work … Annexure G: Special Conditions …” The site address given is one which is within Queensland, and the project is referred to as the Gold Coast Airport, but as stated above, it is uncontentious in this proceeding that part of the construction works which were to be performed were sited in New South Wales. The Formal Instrument of Agreement defined Lendlease by that descriptor, but described BCS as the “sub-contractor” for the purposes of the contract. The standard terms of the contract were, in part, amended by certain other special conditions contained in Annexure G. For the purposes of continuity, when I set out the standard terms below, I have simply incorporated those amendments contained in Annexure G and footnoted the special condition clause in which the amendment appears. With that qualification, the standard terms of the contract relevantly provided as follows: “SUBCONTRACT CONDITIONS … 1. DEFINITIONS AND INTERPRETATION 1.1 Definitions In the Subcontract, unless the context requires otherwise: … Drawings - the drawings and other documents identified in Annexure D: Drawings. … Subcontract Sum - the amount stated in the Appendix, as may be further described in Annexure A: Subcontract Sum, or such other sum or sums as may become payable under the Subcontract. … Works - the whole of the work to be executed in accordance with the Subcontract by the Subcontractor, including Variations provided for by the Subcontract, which is to be handed over to Lendlease. WUC (‘work under contract’) - the work which the Subcontractor is or may be required to carry out and complete under the Subcontract and includes Variations, remedial work, Plant and temporary works. … 15. MATERIAL AND WORKS 15.1 Quality of Materials, WUC and work … The contract then contained an appendix, which was to be read with the standard terms. That appendix relevantly provided as follows: “APPENDIX Subcontract Conditions The contract then included schedules. Schedule D set out the design requirements as follows: “SCHEDULE D: DESIGN REQUIREMENTS 1. Design by the Subcontractor

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

As a result of my answer to this issue, I have not had to deal with the detailed submissions which were made as to whether s 4(5) of the CPAL Act would have resulted in only certain sections being disapplied, or alternatively the whole of the BIF Act being disapplied. Conclusion In conclusion, as a result of the reasons set out above, Lendlease has not succeeded in its application to set aside the adjudication application. Lendlease is not entitled to the injunction which it seeks. There had been submissions made on the potential to sever parts of the adjudication decision pursuant to s 101(4) of the BIF Act. It has been unnecessary to consider such submissions in light of my conclusions to the various issues. Accordingly, the application ought to be dismissed. On the issue of costs, I will hear the parties further on what is the appropriate costs order. In addition, it is my understanding that there has been monies previously paid into Court. I will hear the parties in relation to any consequential orders which flow from these reasons.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established