Bright Days Herston Pty Ltd v ATG Project & Property Solutions Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Bright Days Herston Pty Ltd v ATG Project & Property Solutions Pty Ltd [2025] QSC 147

PARTIES:

BRIGHT DAYS HERSTON PTY LTD

(ACN 601 164 309)
(applicant)

v
ATG PROJECT & PROPERTY SOLUTIONS PTY LTD

(ACN 160 517 493)
(first respondent)
CHRISTOPHER MORROW
(second respondent)
ADJUDICATION REGISTRAR APPOINTED UNDER SECTION 150 OF THE BUILDING INDUSTRY FAIRNESS (SECURITY OF PAYMENT) ACT 2017 (QLD)
(third respondent)

FILE NO/S:

BS 4991/24

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court of Queensland at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

25 June 2025

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

19 March 2025

JUDGE:

Treston J

ORDER:

Application is dismissed, with costs.

CATCHWORDS:

CONTRACTS – BUILDING, ENGINEERING AND RELATED CONTRACTS – REMUNERATION – STATUTORY REGULATION OF ENTITLEMENT TO AND RECOVERY OF PROGRESS PAYMENTS – ADJUDICATION OF PAYMENT CLAIMS – where the applicant and the first respondent entered into a construction contract and the first respondent made an adjudication application under the Building Industry Fairness (Security of Payment) Act 2017 (Qld) after a dispute arose in relation to a payment claim – where the applicant objected to the first adjudicator determining the application due to a reasonable apprehension of bias – where by an email in response to the applicant’s objection, the first adjudicator advised that he did not intend to issue a decision – where the first respondent then requested the Registrar refer the adjudication application to a subsequent adjudicator (the second respondent) – where the applicant advances two grounds by which the decision of the second respondent was affected by jurisdictional error – where the applicant contends the second respondent did not have jurisdiction to determine the adjudication application because the first adjudicator’s decision not to issue a decision, was in fact, a decision made under the Act – where the applicant contends the second respondent failed to take into account mandatory considerations being, the applicant’s submissions regarding the second respondent’s jurisdiction to determine the application and the applicant’s submissions to the first respondent regarding a subsequent payment – whether the second respondent had jurisdiction to determine the application – whether the second respondent failed to consider mandatory considerations thereby constituting a jurisdictional error

Building Industry Fairness (Security of Payment) Act 2017 (Qld), ss 80, 81, 84, 85, 88, 90, 94, 95
Building Industry Fairness (Security of Payment) Regulation 2018 (Qld), s 13

Acciona Agua Australia Pty Ltd v Monadelphous Engineering Pty Ltd (2020) 4 QR 410
Ceerose Pty Ltd v A-Civil Aust Pty Ltd (2023) 112 NSWLR 225
Chevron Park Pty Ltd v Groupline Constructions Pty Ltd & Ors [2024] QSC 202
Duro Felguera Australia Pty Ltd v Samsung C&T Corporation (2018) 52 WAR 323
S.H.A. Premier Constructions Pty Ltd v Niclin Constructions Pty Ltd [2020] QSC 307
Lendlease Building Pty Ltd v BCF Airport Systems Pty Ltd & Ors [2024] QSC 164
Martinus Rail Pty Ltd v Qube RE: Services (No 2) Pty Ltd (No 2) [2024] NSWSC 1223
Probuild Constructions (Aust) Pty Ltd v Shade Systems Pty Ltd (2018) 264…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bright Days Herston Pty Ltd v ATG Project & Property Solutio... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] QSC 147
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Bright Days Herston Pty Ltd and ATG Project & Property Solutions Pty Ltd were involved in a dispute regarding a construction contract. The dispute centred on an adjudication application made by ATG under the Building Industry Fairness (Security of Payment) Act 2017 (Qld) after a payment claim was made. Bright Days objected to the adjudicator's determination of the application due to concerns about bias. The adjudicator responded by stating he would not issue a decision, leading ATG to request the Registrar refer the adjudication application to another adjudicator. Bright Days then challenged the second adjudicator's decision, arguing it was affected by jurisdictional error on two grounds. The first was that the second adjudicator did not have jurisdiction to determine the adjudication application because the initial adjudicator's decision not to issue a decision was a decision under the Act. The second was that the second adjudicator failed to consider mandatory considerations, including Bright Days' submissions regarding the second adjudicator's jurisdiction and a subsequent payment made by Bright Days.

The court found that the second adjudicator did have jurisdiction to determine the adjudication application because the initial adjudicator's decision not to issue a decision was not a decision under the Act. The court also found that the second adjudicator did not fail to consider mandatory considerations. The court held that the second adjudicator adequately addressed the jurisdictional issues and considered all relevant submissions made by Bright Days. The court concluded that the second adjudicator's decision was not affected by jurisdictional error.

The application was dismissed with costs. The court found that Bright Days' arguments regarding jurisdictional error were not substantiated and that the second adjudicator's decision was valid. The court ordered that the application be dismissed and that Bright Days pay the costs of the proceeding.

Orders

Orders of the court

Application is dismissed, with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons which follow, Bright Days’ application is dismissed.Background On 25 September 2023, ATG served Payment Claim 22 on Bright Days for the sum of $1,323,003.95 (including GST). On 10 October 2023, the Superintendent issued the Progress Payment Certificate 22 certifying the amount of $782,738.00 (including GST) in response to the Payment Claim. The GST component was $711,580.00. On 17 October 2023, Bright Days served Payment Schedule 11 on ATG in response, scheduling an amount of $71,158.00. Some of the detail in the Payment Schedule is set out below at [61(b)]. On 19 October 2023, ATG made an Adjudication Application under the Building Industry Fairness (Security of Payment) Act 2017 (Qld) (the Act). On 26 October 2023, the adjudicator, Mr Trattler, in accordance with s 81 of the Act, confirmed acceptance of the 19 October adjudication application No. QBCC 2381736. On 27 October 2023, solicitors on behalf of Bright Days wrote to Mr Trattler, noting his appointment in respect of the 19 October Adjudication Application (and another application irrelevant for the purposes of this proceeding) and observed:“We invite you to consider:(a) Section 80 of the Building Industry Fairness (Security of Payment) Act 2017 (Qld);(b) Section 13(1) of the Building Industry Fairness (Security of Payment) Regulation 2018 (Qld); and(c) The Code of Conduct for Adjudicators (Version 1.0, November 2018) issued by the Queensland Building Construction Commission.” Although the letter did not expressly say it, the reference to s 80, s 13 and the Code of Conduct, went to issues related to the adjudicator’s eligibility or otherwise, to adjudicate. Section 80 of the Act provides: Given that no party contended Mr Trattler was a party to the construction contract, the letter of 27 October could only be construed as a reference to a potential conflict of interest under subsection (b). On 30 October 2023, Mr Trattler replied with correspondence to the parties as follows:“The Respondent has requested that I consider whether I have a conflict of interest under section 80 of the Act, with reference to the regulation and code of practice.The Regulation relevantly provides:13 Conflicts of interest─Act, s 80(1)For section 80(b) of the Act, an adjudicator has a conflict of interest if─(a)the adjudicator or a family member of the adjudicator─(i)is, or is contracted to be, employed or otherwise engaged by the claimant or respondent for the adjudication application; or (ii)is an owner of a building, structure or land in relation to which construction work or the supply of related goods and services to which the adjudication application relates is being carried out; or(iii)is carrying out construction work or the supply of related goods and services in relation to a building, structure or land to which the adjudication application relates; or(iv)has a direct or indirect pecuniary or other interest in a matter to be considered during the adjudication that could conflict with the proper performance of the adjudicator in adjudicating the adjudication application; or (b)the claimant or respondent for the adjudication application is a family member of the adjudicator.I confirm that none of those subsections apply. Neither I nor any family member has an interest in the parties or the work. I am not aware of any conflict involving the Claimant or the Respondent or any matter which would prevent me from deciding the adjudication fairly between the parties. If there is something in particular, the Respondent will need to be express in the communication regarding the issue.By way of disclosure, my employer engages the same solicitors as the Respondent on an unrelated matter. I am providing instructions to a different partner of that firm and will be communicating with her about that unrelated matter during the time that these adjudications are occurring. While not a conflict of interest under the legislation, there is a possibility of a perceived conflict of interest.I ask that both parties confirm in writing that they agree to me acting in those circumstances. Please respond by 5pm on 31 October 2023.”(underlining added)

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 2 November 2023, Mr Trattler wrote to the parties as follows:“Thank you for the response to my email, which I have considered.I understand the comments from the Claimant regarding the process and there not being any ability for a Respondent to ‘not agree’ to an adjudicator.Having considered the matter in detail, please be advised that I do not intend to issue a decision, as given the Respondent’s stated objections, I am concerned that an independent observer may consider that there is an appearance of bias given the need to communicate with the Respondent’s solicitors outside of the adjudication process.The Claimant’s attention is drawn to section 94 of the Act.” (my underlining) Section 94 of the Act provides:“94 Claimant may make new application in certain circumstances(1)Subsection (2) applies if an adjudicator, who accepts a referral to decide an adjudication application (the original application), does not decide the application within the period required under section 85.(2)The claimant may do either of the following within 5 business days after the period mentioned in subsection (1)─(a)request the registrar refer the original application to another adjudicator; or (b)make a new adjudication application (the new application) under section 79 …” Section 94 therefore provides that in certain, limited, circumstances a claimant may make a new application for an adjudication, or ask the Registrar to refer it to another adjudicator. Those certain, limited, circumstances occur if an adjudicator has, firstly, accepted a referral to decide an adjudication application and, secondly, does not decide the application within the period required under s 85. Before making a new adjudication application, ATG wrote to Mr Trattler on 6 December 2023, observing that the 19 October 2023 Adjudication Application was due to be decided on 4 December 2023, and made reference to the notice of 2 November 2023, referring the claimant’s attention to s 94 of the Act and asked:“So that the Claimant can take the appropriate steps pursuant to that section, we would be grateful if the Adjudicator would confirm the following matters:1. The Adjudicator has not made a decision on either Adjudication Applications 2381736 or 2381846 within the time required by section 85 of the Act.2. The Adjudicator has not received from the Respondent an Adjudication Response in either of adjudication applications 2381736 or 2381846.” The adjudicator responded the same day as follows:“I confirm that an adjudication decision was not made in either application within the time required by the Act and did not receive an adjudication response in either matter.” On 7 December 2023, ATG requested the Registrar refer the adjudication application to another adjudicator, and on 13 December the second respondent confirmed acceptance of that adjudication application. On 19 December 2023, ATG served the adjudication application on the adjudicator. On 20 December 2023 Bright Days served its adjudication response.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the circumstances, Ground 1 of the application fails. Bright Days’ submission that Mr Trattler’s decision was not one which enlivens s 94 cannot be sustained. Accordingly, the subsequent adjudicator did have jurisdiction to determine the application and his decision cannot be impugned on the basis that he lacked jurisdiction.Ground 2 – failure to take account of mandatory considerations There appeared to be three sub-grounds to the second ground advanced by Bright Days, being:(a)the adjudicator failed to consider submissions made by Bright Days about the first ground (jurisdiction), and thereby failed to comply with s 88(2)(d) of the Act;(b)the adjudicator failed to consider submissions made by Bright Days about a payment which Bright Days had made to ATG after its Payment Schedule had been served, but before the adjudicator issued the adjudication decision, and thereby failed to comply with s 88(2)(d) of the Act; and(c)in failing to consider Bright Days’ submissions about that subsequent payment, the adjudicator failed to determine the “amounts of the progress payment … to be paid” as required by s 88(1)(a) of the Act. In these ways, Bright Days submits that the adjudicator has fallen into jurisdictional error. As to the first sub-ground, Bright Days made the same submission to the adjudicator which it made in this court, being that the effect of Mr Trattler’s email of 2 November was a “decision” under s 84(2)(a)(i) that he did not have jurisdiction to adjudicate the application, that there was no power to refer the matter for a second adjudication under s 94, meaning the adjudicator did not have jurisdiction to determine the application. It is true that the adjudicator did not expressly refer to the matter having been previously allocated to Mr Trattler, who then by his email of 2 November declined to decide it. However, it cannot be said that the adjudicator did not turn his mind to the question of jurisdiction. The adjudicator set out at paragraphs [13] to [33] of the decision, that before he decided the adjudication application, he had to decide whether he had jurisdiction to so adjudicate it. He addressed the matters necessary to reach that conclusion including that there was a construction contract to which the Act applied, a payment claim had been served on a person who is or may be liable to make a payment, an adjudication application had been made and the application had been “referred to and accepted by an eligible adjudicator”. The adjudicator then turned to consider each of those matters, and concluded at paragraph 30, that he was satisfied that he had jurisdiction to adjudicate the application. It was common ground between the parties that for this argument to succeed, Bright Days must demonstrate:(a)first, that the adjudicator failed to comply with s 88(2)(d) by failing to consider Bright Days’ submission; and(b)second, that the adjudicator’s failure to comply with s 88(2)(d) was material in the sense that there was a realistic possibility that a different decision could have been made had there been compliance with that condition.