Niclin Constructions Pty Ltd v Robotic Steel Fab Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Niclin Constructions Pty Ltd v Robotic Steel Fab Pty Ltd & Anor [2023] QSC 218

PARTIES:

NICLIN CONSTRUCTIONS PTY LTD
ACN 614 074 065

(applicant)

v

ROBOTIC STEEL FAB PTY LTD
ACN 646 836 955

(first respondent)

AND
WILLIAM KOITKA (as Adjudicator No. 15023260)

(second respondent)

FILE NO:

BS11413 of 2023

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court of Queensland at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

29 September 2023

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

21 September 2023

JUDGE:

Applegarth J

ORDER:

1.  The application is dismissed.

2.  The applicant pay the first respondent’s costs of and incidental to the proceeding to be assessed, if not agreed.
  

CATCHWORDS:

CONTRACTS – BUILDING, ENGINEERING AND RELATED CONTRACTS – REMUNERATION – STATUTORY REGULATION OF ENTITLEMENT TO AND RECOVERY OF PROGRESS PAYMENTS – ADJUDICATION OF PAYMENT CLAIMS – where the applicant submitted a Payment Schedule in response to a Payment Claim made by the first respondent and the matter proceeded to an adjudication – where the Payment Schedule advanced an argument for the set-off of an amount for liquidated damages and referred to reasons contained in a Statement of Claim that was not attached to the Payment Schedule – where the adjudicator rejected the set-off claim because the Statement of Claim was not attached and therefore the alleged set-off was not substantiated - where the applicant contends that the adjudicator failed to consider the applicant’s submissions on the set-off claim or failed to give adequate reasons for rejecting its submissions – whether the adjudication decision is void for jurisdictional error because of a failure to consider the applicant’s submissions or a failure to provide adequate reasons for rejecting the applicant’s submissions

Building Industry Fairness (Security of Payment) Act 2017 (Qld), s 88(2), s 88(5)

Acciona Agua Australia Pty Ltd v Monadelphous Engineering Pty Ltd (2020) 4 Qd R 410, cited

Annie Street JV Pty Ltd v MCC Pty Ltd [2016] QSC 268, cited

Avopiling (NSW) Pty Ltd v Menard Bachy Pty Ltd [2012] NSWSC 1466, cited
Ceerose Pty Ltd v A-Civil Aust Pty Ltd [2023] NSWCA 215, cited

City of Ryde v AMFM Constructions Pty Ltd [2011] NSWSC 1469, cited

John Holland Pty Ltd v TAC Pacific Pty Ltd [2010] 1 Qd R 302, cited

R J Neller Building Pty Ltd v Ainsworth [2009] 1 Qd R 390, cited

COUNSEL:

J P Hastie for the applicant

T Ambrose for the first respondent

SOLICITORS:

Shand Taylor Lawyers for the applicant

Bell Legal Group for the first respondent

  1. The first respondent (Robotic) made a payment claim for $72,324.39 (excluding GST) for works carried out for the supply and installation of metal at a project at Stafford.  The applicant (Niclin) submitted a Payment Schedule and the matter proceeded to an adjudication.  The second respondent adjudicated the matter and provided 38 pages of reasons for deciding the adjudicated amount to be $70,148.17.

  2. The issue in the proceeding is whether the adjudication decision is void for jurisdictional error.  The point essentially…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Niclin Constructions Pty Ltd v Robotic Steel Fab Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QSC 218
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the court involved Niclin Constructions Pty Ltd, the applicant, and Robotic Steel Fab Pty Ltd, the first respondent. The dispute centred around an adjudication decision made in relation to a claim for progress payments under a construction contract. Specifically, the applicant sought to challenge the validity of the adjudicator's decision on the grounds that it was affected by jurisdictional error. The court was required to determine whether the adjudicator failed to consider the applicant's submissions regarding a set-off for liquidated damages or failed to provide adequate reasons for rejecting those submissions.

The court examined whether the adjudicator had properly exercised his jurisdiction by considering the applicant's submissions on the set-off issue and the consequences of not attaching the Statement of Claim to the Payment Schedule. The court noted that while the adjudicator did consider the set-off issue and the impact of the missing Statement of Claim, it was not necessary for the adjudicator to reach the objectively correct conclusion on the matter for the decision to be valid. The court concluded that the adjudicator had considered the relevant issue and provided reasons for his conclusion, thus the adjudication decision was not void for jurisdictional error.

The court dismissed the application and ordered the applicant to pay the first respondent's costs of and incidental to the proceeding to be assessed, if not agreed. This decision highlights the importance of attaching relevant documents to a Payment Schedule and the need for adjudicators to provide adequate reasons for their decisions, even if the outcome may not align with the applicant's submissions.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application is dismissed.

2. The applicant pay the first respondent’s costs of and incidental to the proceeding to be assessed, if not agreed.

Background

Background to the litigation

If the interlocutory application had proceeded, as the parties proposed, then I would not have granted an interlocutory injunction. Niclin’s claim of jurisdictional error did not appear to me to have sufficient prospects of success to deprive Robotic of the benefit of the adjudication decision, even for a relatively short time. However, during the hearing on 21 September 2023 it became apparent to me that the final hearing of the substantive application would reagitate, on the basis of the same evidence, the arguments before me about the validity of the adjudication decision. Therefore, I proposed, and the parties agreed, that I determine the point of substance.Essential facts Niclin’s Payment Schedule advanced an array of arguments. One was whether it could set off an amount (variously described as $405,000 and $476,000) for liquidated damages. In Annexure A to the Payment Schedule it stated:“For the reasons set out in the attached statement of claim, Niclin is entitled to set off the sum of $476,000.00 owing under the Stafford Subcontract as a debt against any amounts found to be payable under the Subcontract.”However, the Payment Schedule did not, in fact, attach the Statement of Claim. Robotic’s Adjudication Application raised that point. It submitted that: Niclin’s Adjudication Response submitted that its omission of the Statement of Claim did not matter because Robotic knew of the document, and that it was open to Niclin to substantiate the submissions it made in the Payment Schedule with information known to the parties, but which was not included in or attached to its Payment Schedule. That Robotic knew about the Statement of Claim was said to be apparent in the circumstances. The adjudication decision considered these and many other arguments that were agitated in connection with eight major issues in dispute. I should mention in that regard that the legal costs to the parties of preparing such voluminous and extensive submissions in the adjudication of a claim for less than $80,000 seems disproportionate. The costs of such an exercise, when the issues are already being litigated in the District Court, seem hard to justify on a cost-benefit analysis. The same applies to the volume of material and the costs of litigating a proceeding in the Supreme Court over a payment claim of less than $80,000. The adjudicator was able to deal briefly with Niclin’s assertion of a set-off of $476,000 for liquidated damages in relation to the Stafford project. He addressed the claim and Robotic’s submission that because the Statement of Claim formed an essential part of the reasons given in the Payment Schedule, its omission meant that “no reasons have actually been given in the payment schedule”, and that a deduction should not be allowed. The adjudicator previewed alternative arguments on the liquidated damages issue, but was not required to address them because of his decision on the submission I have summarised. The adjudicator agreed with Robotic. He concluded “that the statement of claim forms part of the reasons given in the payment schedule and as they were not provided with the payment schedule, I find that variation IV*71- Robofab - LD’s (Stafford) has not been substantiated”.Niclin’s case that the decision is void

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The adjudicator previewed alternative arguments on the liquidated damages issue, but was not required to address them because of his decision on the submission I have summarised. The adjudicator agreed with Robotic. He concluded “that the statement of claim forms part of the reasons given in the payment schedule and as they were not provided with the payment schedule, I find that variation IV*71- Robofab - LD’s (Stafford) has not been substantiated”.Niclin’s case that the decision is void Niclin submitted that the decision was affected by jurisdictional error and is thereby void because the adjudicator failed to take into account the argument that Niclin advanced before him about its entitlement to set off liquidated damages. The adjudicator’s alleged failure to consider Niclin’s submission was contended to be a failure “to consider” a matter that s 88(2)(d) of the Act required him to consider. Section 88(2)(d) requires an adjudicator to consider the Payment Schedule, together with “all submissions, including relevant documents, that have been properly made by the respondent in support of the schedule”. An associated argument by Niclin is that in failing to take its submission into account, there was a denial of procedural fairness. At the hearing on 21 September 2023 I suggested that Niclin’s complaint appeared to be about the adequacy of the adjudicator’s reasons. This is because the adjudicator did consider the liquidated damages set-off issue and the consequences of not attaching the Statement of Claim to the Payment Schedule. As a result, the parties provided supplementary written submissions on the adequacy of the reasons.Did the adjudicator consider Niclin’s submissions on the liquidated damages issue? Niclin submits that the adjudicator seems to have simply accepted Robotic’s submission that because the Statement of Claim was not attached, the set-off issue was not properly raised by the Payment Schedule and, having done so, proceeded to reject the set-off claim without further discussion or analysis. The valid exercise of an adjudicator’s jurisdiction is conditioned on the adjudicator having considered the matters set out in s 88(2) of the Act.[2] The valid exercise of an adjudicator’s decision is not conditioned on the adjudicator reaching what is objectively the correct conclusion on the questions of fact or law that are required by the consideration of the matters set out in s 88(2). Expressed differently, “there are many errors of fact and law which might be made by an adjudicator which would not be regarded as going to jurisdiction”.[3] [2]Acciona Agua Australia Pty Ltd v Monadelphous Engineering Pty Ltd (2020) 4 Qd R 410 (“Acciona”).[3]Ibid at [35]. In this matter, the adjudicator considered the issue of whether matters contained in the District Court Statement of Claim were raised by the Payment Schedule in circumstances in which the Statement of Claim was not attached to it. Having considered that issue, the adjudicator reached a conclusion.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.