Annie Street JV Pty Ltd v MCC Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Annie Street JV Pty Ltd v MCC Pty Ltd & Ors [2016] QSC 268 

PARTIES:

ANNIE STREET JV PTY LTD
ACN 160 994 016

(applicant)

v
MCC PTY LTD
ACN 002 243 263

(first respondent)
MAX TONKIN (ADJUDICATOR J1066620)
(second respondent)
MICHAEL HOPE CHESTERMAN
(Adjudication Registrar)
(third respondent)

FILE NO/S:

SC No 9681 of 2016

DIVISION:

Trial

PROCEEDING:

Trial

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

21 November 2016

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

25 October 2016

JUDGE:

Flanagan J

ORDER:

1.  The applicant’s originating application filed 20 September 2016 is dismissed.

2.  I will hear the parties as to costs.

CATCHWORDS:

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – DECLARATIONS – EXCESS OR WANT OF JURISDICTION – PARTICULAR INSTANCES OF JURISDICTIONAL ERROR – where the applicant and the first respondent were parties to construction contract – where the first respondent served a payment claim under the Building and Construction Industry Payments Act 2004 (Qld) (the Act) – where the second respondent made an adjudication decision under the Act – where the second respondent determined, as part of the adjudication, that the applicant was not entitled to set-off an amount for liquidated damages – where the applicant alleges that this part of the second respondent’s decision is affected by jurisdictional error – whether the second respondent’s decision that the applicant was not entitled to set-off an amount for liquidated damages was without foundation and illogical, with a deficient reasoning process – whether the second respondent’s decision that the applicant was not entitled to set-off an amount for liquidated damages involved a failure to provide reasons or adequate reasons in accordance with s 26(3)(b) of the Act – whether the second respondent’s decision that the applicant was not entitled to set-off an amount for liquidated damages involved a denial, to the applicants, of natural justice

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – DECLARATIONS – EXCESS OR WANT OF JURISDICTION – PARTICULAR INSTANCES OF JURISDICTIONAL ERROR – where the applicant and the first respondent were parties to construction contract – where the first respondent served a payment claim under the Building and Construction Industry Payments Act 2004 (Qld) (the Act) – where the applicant served a payment schedule under the Act – where the payment schedule did not raise contractual time limitations as a basis for withholding payment – where the second respondent did not consider contractual time limitations in the adjudication – whether, in not considering contractual time limitations, the second respondent committed jurisdictional error

Building and Construction Industry Payments Act 2004 (Qld), s 17, s 18, s 24, s 26(2)

Judicial Review Act 1991 (Qld), s 18(2)(b), Schedule 1, Part 2

Bauen Constructions v Westwood Interiors [2010] NSWSC 1359, cited
Camden v McKenzie [2008] 1 Qd R 39; [2007] QCA 136, cited
Chase Oyster Bar Pty Ltd v Hamo Industries Pty Ltd (2010) 78 NSWLR 393; [2010] NSWCA 190, cited
City of Ryde v AMDM Constructions Pty Ltd & Anor [2011] NSWSC 1469, cited
Craig v South Australia

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Annie Street JV Pty Ltd v MCC Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] QSC 268
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Annie Street JV Pty Ltd v MCC Pty Ltd, the applicant sought declaratory and injunctive relief against the first respondent and the second respondent. The first respondent was a party to a construction contract with the applicant, and it served a payment claim under the Building and Construction Industry Payments Act 2004 (Qld). The applicant responded with a payment schedule in which it deducted an amount for liquidated damages. The second respondent adjudicated the dispute, determining that the applicant was not entitled to set-off the liquidated damages. The applicant alleged that the second respondent's decision was affected by jurisdictional error, including that it was without foundation, illogical, and denied natural justice.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the second respondent's decision that the applicant was not entitled to set-off an amount for liquidated damages was affected by jurisdictional error. The court had to determine if the second respondent's decision was without foundation and illogical, involved a failure to provide reasons or adequate reasons, and whether it denied natural justice. Additionally, the court had to consider whether the second respondent committed jurisdictional error by not considering contractual time limitations in the adjudication.

The court found that the second respondent's decision was not affected by jurisdictional error. It held that the decision was not without foundation or illogical, and that the second respondent provided adequate reasons for its decision in accordance with the statutory requirements. The court further found that the second respondent did not deny natural justice by failing to provide an opportunity for the applicant to respond to the first respondent's adjudication application. Regarding the consideration of contractual time limitations, the court concluded that the second respondent did not commit jurisdictional error by not considering these limitations, as the applicant did not raise them in its payment schedule.

The court dismissed the applicant's originating application for declaratory and injunctive relief, finding no jurisdictional error in the second respondent's decision. The court will hear the parties as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicant’s originating application filed 20 September 2016 is dismissed.

2. I will hear the parties as to costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons which follow the applicant’s originating application for declaratory and injunctive relief should be dismissed.Background On 19 July 2016 the first respondent served a payment claim for $808,843.44.[4] The claim was made under a contract for a building project involving the construction of 18 residential units in New Farm, Brisbane. [4] Exhibit “ETB-1” to the Bird affidavit. The payment claim was served pursuant to s 17 of the Act On 27 July 2016 the superintendent, Mr Dugan, on behalf of the applicant, served a payment schedule in which it scheduled $nil.[5][5] Exhibit “ETB-2” to the Bird affidavit. The payment schedule was served pursuant to s 18 of the Act. On 8 August 2016 the first respondent served an adjudication application.[6] The adjudication application comprised 11 lever-arch folders, including a statutory declaration of Mr Scroope, a director of the first respondent.[7][6] The adjudication application was served pursuant to s 21 of the Act.[7] The Bird affidavit, [4]; Exhibit “CS-1” to the affidavit of Christopher Scroope, filed 14 October 2016, CD8. On 23 August 2016 the applicant served an adjudication response.[8] The adjudication response comprised one lever-arch file[9] including a statutory declaration of Mr Dugan.[8] Pursuant to the regime set out in s 24 of the Act.[9] The Bird affidavit, [4]; Exhibit “ETB-5” to the Bird affidavit.The first alleged jurisdictional error An adjudication decision is not reviewable under the Judicial Review Act 1991 (Qld).[10] Both parties accept however that an adjudicator’s decision may be declared void if it is affected by jurisdictional error.[11][10] See s 18(2)(b) and Schedule 1, Part 2 of the Judicial Review Act 1991 (Qld).[11] Written Submissions for the Applicant, [11]. The proposition is implicitly accepted in the Outline of Submissions of the First Respondent; Northbuild Construction Pty Ltd v Central Interior Linings Pty Ltd [2012] 1 Qd R 525 at [6] per Margaret McMurdo P, at [33] per Chesterman JA and at [78] per White JA. The applicant, through Mr Dugan, deducted $164,160.00 for liquidated damages in the payment schedule. Such damages were able to be claimed pursuant to clause 34.7 of the contract if the first respondent did not reach practical completion by the date for practical completion. Item H of the Special Conditions provided, in effect, that the date for practical completion was “35 weeks after the completion of the Basement (Definition Basement Completion is the following:- Excavation, Retaining Walls and Basement Slab).” The claim for liquidated damages was based on the applicant’s contention that the superintendent, Mr Dugan, and Mr Scroope had made an agreement to amend or vary the contract with effect that the 35 week period identified in item H commenced on 19 March 2015 rather than commencing after the completion of the basement. The adjudicator’s decision in respect of this issue is said to reveal jurisdictional error. It is first necessary to consider the statutory framework in which the adjudicator was required to give reasons for the decision.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The relevant provision in respect of an adjudicator’s decision is s 26:“Adjudicator’s decision(1) An adjudicator is to decide—(a)the amount of the progress payment, if any, to be paid by the respondent to the claimant (the adjudicated amount); and(b)the date on which any amount became or becomes payable; and(c)the rate of interest payable on any amount.(2) In deciding an adjudication application, the adjudicator is to consider the following matters only—(a)the provisions of this Act and, to the extent they are relevant, the provisions of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991, part 4A;(b)the provisions of the construction contract from which the application arose;(c)the payment claim to which the application relates, together with all submissions, including relevant documentation, that have been properly made by the claimant in support of the claim;(d)the payment schedule, if any, to which the application relates, together with all submissions, including relevant documentation, that have been properly made by the respondent in support of the schedule;(e)the results of any inspection carried out by the adjudicator of any matter to which the claim relates.(3) The adjudicator’s decision must—(a)be in writing; and(b)include the reasons for the decision, unless the claimant and the respondent have both asked the adjudicator not to include the reasons in the decision.” A decision under s 26(1) has three subjects, namely the adjudicated amount, the date for payment and the rate of interest. The adjudicated amount is a single amount determined as the amount of the progress payment to be made.[12] An adjudication decision under the Act is, therefore, not a series of decisions as to amounts owing in respect of discrete claims.[13][12] Multiplex Constructions Pty Ltd v Luikens & Anor [2003] NSWSC 1140 at [92] per Palmer J; James Trowse Constructions Pty Ltd v ASAP Plasterers Pty Ltd [2011] QSC 145 at [57]-[59] per Atkinson J; BM Alliance Coal Operations Pty Ltd v BGC Contracting Pty Ltd [2012] QSC 346 at [48] per Applegarth J; Thiess Pty Ltd v Warren Brothers Earthmoving Pty Ltd [2012] QSC 373 at [61]-[62] per A Lyons J.[13] Outline of Submissions for the First Respondent, [16]. I consider s 26(2) in more detail below in dealing with the second alleged jurisdictional error. As to s 26(3)(b), the only requirement is that the adjudicator “include the reasons for the decision”. The relevant “decision” for which reasons must be included is the decision identified in s 26(1). The procedures outlined in Part 3 and in sections 17 to 26 of the Act in particular, are how the object of the Act stated in s 7 is to be achieved.[14] That object is to ensure that a person is entitled to receive, and is able to recover, progress payments if the person relevantly undertakes to carry out construction work under a construction contract. [14] Section 8 of the Act. In Craig v South Australia[15] the High Court stated:[16]“… jurisdictional error will occur where an inferior court disregards or takes account of some matter in circumstances where the statute or other instrument establishing it and conferring its jurisdiction requires that that particular matter be taken into account or ignored as a pre-condition of the existence of any authority to make an order or decision in the circumstances of the particular case.”[15] (1995) 184 CLR 163.[16] (1995) 184 CLR 163, 177.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.