Kola v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs
Link copied
CaseCopied
45 min read
Full text
Kola v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [2002] FCAFC 59
Kola v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [2002] FCA 265
NOTE: CHANGES TO THE MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION (MNC)
The Federal Court adopted a new medium neutral citation (FCAFC) for Full Court judgments effective from 1 January 2002. Single Judge judgments will not be affected and will retain the FCA medium neutral citation.
The transitional arrangements are as follows:
All Full Court judgments delivered prior to 1 January 2002 will retain the FCA medium neutral citation.
All Full Court judgments delivered between 1 January 2002 to 30 April 2002 have been assigned parallel medium neutral citations in both the FCA and FCAFC series.
All Full Court judgments delivered from 1 May 2002 will contain the FCAFC medium neutral citation only.
FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Kola v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [2002] FCA 265
MIGRATION – ethnic Albanians from Serbia flee to Albania and thence to Australia – whether RRT extended an invitation to the appellants in compliance with s 425(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) – whether the primary Judge had erred in applying the “effective protection” test – whether the RRT had failed to undertake inquiries on the effective protection issue – whether evidence to support the RRT’s finding that the appellants could enjoy effective protection in Albania.
Constitution, s 75(v)
Convention relating to the Status of Refugees 1951, Arts 1A(2), 33
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Kola v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs and more:
The case of Kola v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs involved two appeals against the decisions of the Refugee Review Tribunal (RRT) to affirm the decisions of the delegate to refuse protection visas to the Kolas and the Bitanis, who are ethnic Albanians from Serbia. The applicants argued that they had a well-founded fear of persecution on return to Serbia due to their ethnicity, and that they could not reasonably relocate within Serbia. The primary judge dismissed the appeals, finding that the RRT had adequately considered the applicants’ claims and provided them with the opportunity to address relevant issues.
The key legal issues before the court were whether the RRT had failed to properly inform the applicants of the effective protection issue, and if so, whether this amounted to a ground of review. The applicants argued that the RRT had not adequately considered the possibility of persecution if they were returned to Albania, and that this constituted a failure to review their claims. The court found that the RRT had sufficiently informed the applicants of the need to address the effective protection issue, and that any confusion in the RRT’s reasoning did not amount to a failure to review the claims.
The court held that the RRT had asked the correct questions and made findings on those questions, and thus had properly reviewed the applicants’ claims. The court also found that the criticism of the RRT’s findings amounted to an attempt to review the merits of the decision, which is not permissible. The no evidence ground of review also failed as none of the findings identified by the applicants were matters that had to be established before the decision-maker could reach a decision.
In conclusion, the court found that the RRT had adequately considered the applicants’ claims and provided them with the opportunity to address relevant issues. The appeals were dismissed, and the applicants were ordered to pay the respondent’s costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The appeal be dismissed.
2. The appellants pay the respondent’s costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
The RRT held hearings in respect of each application on 28 June 2000. The hearings were held by videolink since, for reasons not explained on the appeal, the Kolas and Bitanis were in Queensland and the RRT member in Melbourne. The hearings were held successively, the Bitanis’ application being heard before that of the Kolas. None of the appellants was represented before the RRT.BACKGROUNDTHE KOLAS The RRT found that the Kolas are nationals of the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia (“FRY”). Each was born in or near Presheve, in an area of Serbia very close to the borders with Kosovo and Macedonia. The Kolas are ethnic Albanians who speak Albanian. They are Roman Catholics. Mr Kola was 27 years old at the time of the RRT decision. He was educated in Presheve and worked as a self-employed painter between 1991 and 1998. Mrs Kola described herself in her application for a protection visa as a “housewife”. The Kolas lived in a village near Presheve which, although in Serbia, had a mainly ethnic Albanian population. Mr Kola claimed that in early April 1999 he and his wife had been forced to flee their home by the Serbian Police and Army, after he had witnessed his brother being killed. They, along with other family members, were forced to walk to the Macedonian border from where they were transported to Tirana. They were issued with refugee cards and photographic identification at a refugee camp located near the city. The Kolas stayed in the refugee camp until December 1999. While in Albania, they obtained false documents in order to leave that country for Australia. In their application and in their oral evidence before the RRT, the Kolas claimed to fear persecution in Serbia by reason of their race in that, as ethnic Albanians, they were at risk of being killed or seriously harmed by Serbs. They further claimed that they could not reasonably locate to any other place in Serbia. They made no mention of any fear of persecution if they were returned to Albania.THE BITANIS Like the Kolas, the Bitanis are ethnic Albanian Roman Catholics, who lived near Presheve in Serbia. Mr Bitani, who was 25 at the date of the RRT hearing, was educated in Presheve and worked as a self-employed salesman. Mrs Bitani was also born in Presheve and until her departure for Albania, had lived in that area all her life. The Bitanis fled Presheve in March 1999 and made their way to Albania where they were registered as refugees by the International Red Cross. From there they made their way to Australia. The Bitanis claimed to fear persecution in Serbia for much the same reasons as the Kolas advanced.THE LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK Section 36 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (“Migration Act”) provides for protection visas. At the time both applications were filed in this Court, s 36 was in the following terms:“36 (1) There is a class of visas to be known as protection visas.(2) A criterion for a protection visa is that the applicant for the visa is a non-citizen in Australia to whom Australia has protection obligations under the Refugees Convention as amended by the Refugees Protocol. (3) Australia is taken not to have protection obligations to a non-citizen who has not taken all possible steps to avail himself or herself of a right to enter and reside in, whether temporarily or permanently and however that right arose or is expressed, any country apart from Australia, including countries of which the non-citizen is a national. (4) However, if the non-citizen has a well-founded fear of being persecuted in a country for reasons of race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or political opinion, subsection (3) does not apply in relation to that country. (5) Also, if the non-citizen has a well-founded fear that: (a) a country will return the non-citizen to another country; and (b) the non-citizen will be persecuted in that other country for reasons of race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or political opinion; subsection (3) does not apply in relation to the first-mentioned country.”
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
In our opinion, even assuming the RRT failed to give the Kolas fair notice of the effective protection issue, it cannot be said that it failed to “review” the delegate’s decision in the limited sense referred to in Minister v Anthonypillai. The RRT, as we explain later, asked the correct questions and made findings on those questions. It did not misconceive the nature of its statutory obligation.THE NO EVIDENCE GROUND Ms Layton identified seven findings that she submitted had been made without evidence, thereby enlivening the ground of review provided for in s 476(1)(g) of the Migration Act. As we have noted, Ms Layton, when pressed with the need for the Kolas to satisfy one or other of pars 476(4)(a) or (b), nominated (a) as applicable to the present case. Section 476(4)(a) of the Migration Act provides that the “no evidence” ground specified in s 476(1)(g) is not to be taken as having been made out unless the decision-maker was required by law to reach that decision only if “a particular matter was established” and there was no evidence from which the decision-maker could reasonably be satisfied that the matter was established. Ms Layton did not explain how any of the seven findings could come within s 476(4)(a) and it is difficult to see how any would: cf Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs v Applicant C [2001] FCA 1332, at [76]-[79]. For example, a finding that Mr Kola “agreed at the hearing that he and his spouse are permitted to return to Albania and live there” does not come within s 476(4)(a). Similarly, the finding that certain country reports made no mention of Kosovar Albanians being mistreated for Convention reasons can hardly be a “particular matter” that had to be established before the decision-maker could reach a decision to grant or not grant the Kolas protection visas. In any event, the criticism of the RRT for making the findings amounted to an attempt to review the merits of the decision. For example, it was said that the RRT’s finding that it was “satisfied that Kosovar Albanians are not identified and targeted for criminal acts” had no evidence to support it. In fact the RRT took into account country information that supported, if not compelled, that finding. It is true that the finding that Mr Kola “agreed that he was permitted to stay in Albania” was not precisely accurate, because a statement to that effect was made by Mrs Kola. But the statement was made in Mr Kola’s presence. Clearly enough, the RRT either mistakenly referred to Mr Kola instead of Mrs Kola or intended to refer to the fact that Mr Kola did not take issue with his wife’s evidence. In either case, the finding was not one that falls within s 476(4)(a) of the Migration Act. The no evidence ground fails.THE EFFECTIVE PROTECTION QUESTION Ms Maharaj fairly acknowledged that the RRT’s reasoning on the effective protection question reflected some confusion on its part. There are passages in the RRT’s reasons which appear to assume, incorrectly, that the test for determining whether an applicant for a protection visa has a “right to enter and reside in a [third country]” for the purposes of s 36(3) of the Migration Act is the same as the test for determining whether a third country can provide effective protection to the applicant such that Australia does not owe “protection obligations” to that applicant under s 36(2) of the Migration Act: see Minister v Applicant C, at [44]-[65], per Stone J (with whom Gray and Lee JJ agreed).
Decision
Reasons for decision
The RRT gave virtually identical reasons for affirming the delegate’s decision in relation to the Bitanis.THE JUDGMENTS OF THE PRIMARY JUDGETHE KOLAS The primary Judge first identified the large number of grounds of review relied on by the Kolas. His Honour then noted that the appellants sought to rely on affidavit evidence, primarily in order to establish that the Kolas had not been properly informed by the RRT that an important issue in determining their claim to a protection visa was whether they could be refouled to Albania without being at risk of persecution in that country for a Convention reason. His Honour rejected the affidavits on the ground, inter alia, that proof of the relevant facts “should be effected by reference to the primary material as to what transpired before the [RRT]”. The primary Judge considered that a number of grounds identified by the Kolas boiled down to contentions that the RRT had wrongly regarded Art 33 of the Convention and s 36 of the Migration Act as being satisfied if:“(a)the information before it indicated that [the Kolas] were legally permitted to enter and stay in a third or intermediate state without that state refouling them to their country of nationality where they were refugees; and(b)there was no information before it indicating that Kosovo refugees from the former Federal Republic of Yugoslavia in Albania were persecuted in Albania for a Convention reason.”The primary Judge observed that the Kolas’ submissions were in large measure premised on the proposition that s 420(2)(b) of the Migration Act, which requires the RRT to act according to substantial justice and the merits of the case, obliged the RRT to properly consider and investigate their claims. The Kolas submitted that the RRT had not done so. In his Honour’s view, however, this approach had been foreclosed by the decision of the High Court in Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Eshetu (1999) 197 CLR 611. His Honour next addressed the submission that the RRT had erred in law by failing to tell the Kolas of the potential relevance of Art 33 of the Convention and s 36(3) of the Migration Act and failing to give them an opportunity to give evidence bearing on those issues. He rejected the submission. His Honour pointed out (at [24]) that the RRT had told the Kolas at the commencement of the hearing“that one element of being a person to whom Australia owes protection obligations was that they not have effective protection in a third country, and it specified Albania as the only relevant third country because they had lived there. They were told that they would have to show that they do not have a right to enter and reside in Albania provided Albania would not send them back to the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia. They were also told that the Tribunal’s decision on such matters is reached on their oral evidence, their written statements and information from other sources. There was no specific questioning of Mr Kola at interview about any fears he had whilst living in Albania, but he said his parents were living there. Mrs Kola explained that the applicants were registered as refugees in a camp in Albania, and that they lived there for nine months. She said:‘We saw that in Albania, that people were corrupted and you couldn’t do everything, and we thought that maybe we could go from here somewhere else, and so that we did.'She said that legally the applicants might still live in Albania, but that it was criminal elements which they feared. She said they were targeted because they had money and as victims of violent crime. However, whilst they were in the refugee camp, they were free to come and go as they wished, including to Tirana. The Tribunal at the end of the hearing told the applicants of a provisional view that, on their own evidence, they could get effective protection in Albania. Mr Kola responded:‘It’s very hard to find protection in Albania because even their own people can’t be protected by the government.’”The primary Judge concluded that the transcript established that the Kolas had been informed of the need to address whether they could return and live safely and have effective protection in Albania. It was therefore not necessary to determine whether a complete failure to identify that issue could give rise to a ground of review.