Patto v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Patto v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [2000] FCA 1554

IMMIGRATION – refugees – application for protection visa – applicant Iraqi national – applicant travelled to Greece - refused refugee status in Greece – applicant nevertheless resided in Greece for seven years – whether Greece third safe country offering effective protection against refoulement to Iraq – finding by Tribunal of legal right or practical protection – no evidence or other material to justify the making of the decision – decision based on existence of a non-existent fact – decision set aside and remitted to Tribunal.

Migration Act 1958 (Cth)

Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Thiyagarajah (1998) 80 FCR 543 followed
Rajendran v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1998) 166 ALR 619 cited
Al-Zafiry v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1999) 58 ALD 663 cited
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Al Sallal (1999) 94 FCR 549 cited
Jong Kin Koe v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1997) 74 FCR 508 cited
SZ v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (2000) 173 ALR 353 cited
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Gnanapiragasam (unrep, Fed Court, 25/9/98, Weinberg J) cited
Tour Gul v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] FCA 1537 cited
Nefiodova v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] FCA 179 cited
Pat Tai Choi v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1998) 55 ALD 140 cited
Yilan v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [1999] FCA 854 followed

Plender and Mole, Beyond the Geneva Convention: Constructing a De Facto Right of Asylum From International Human Rights Instruments, Nicholson and Twomey (eds), Refugee Rights and Realities Cambridge UP (1999) pp 81-105
Vedstet-Hansen, “Non-Admission Policies and the Right to Protection: Refugees’ Choice versus States’ Exclusion” in Nicholson and Twomey (eds) Refugee rights and Realities Cambridge UP (1999) p 271
Goodwin-Gill, The Refugee in International Law,  2nd Edition, Clarendon 1996) at p 137
K Hailbronner, The Concept of “Safe Country” and Expeditious Asylum Procedures: A Western European Perspective (1993) 5 IJRL 31
M Kjaerun, The Concept of Country of First Asylum (1992) 4 IJRL 514
Achermann and Gattiker, Safe Third Countries: European Developments (1995) 7 IJRL 19
Federal Ministry of the Interior, Recent Developments in German Law on Asylum and Aliens (1994) 6 IJRL 225

Marx and Lumpp, The German Constitutional Court’s Decision of 14 May 1196 on the Concept of “Safe Third  Countries” – A Basis for Burden Sharing in Europe (1996) IJRL 419
Noll, The Non-admission and Return of Protection Seekers in Germany (1997) 9 IJRL 415
Stephens, The Asylum and Immigration Act 1996: Erosion of the Right to Seek Asylum (1998) 61 MLR 207
Legomsky, The New Techniques for Managing High Volume Asylum Systems (1996) 81 Iowa Law Rev 671
Taylor, Australia’s “Safe Third Country”: Provisions Their Impact on Australia’s Fulfilment of its Non-Refoulement Obligations (1996) 15 U Tas Law Rev 196

PETROS ESHO PATTO v THE MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Patto v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] FCA 1554
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Patto v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs is a case concerning the eligibility of an Iraqi national, Petros Esho Patto, for a protection visa under Australia's Refugees Convention. Patto fled Iraq and lived illegally in Greece for seven years before coming to Australia using a forged Greek passport. His application for a protection visa was refused on the basis that effective protection was available to him in Greece. The primary issue before the court was whether the Refugee Review Tribunal had a proper basis to conclude that effective protection was available to Patto in Greece.

The court examined the evidence and submissions presented to the Tribunal, including an affidavit from an expert in Greek law who opined that Patto did not have a right to re-enter Greece and would be at risk of being returned to Iraq if returned there. The court also noted the country information report supplied to the Tribunal which suggested that Greece was tolerant of an illegal population and did not generally deport unless a person came to notice for criminal activities. However, the court found that the Tribunal did not adequately address the evidence and submissions concerning Patto's status as a refugee and the availability of effective protection in Greece.

The court held that the Tribunal had erred in its decision by not making an assessment of Patto's status as a refugee and by not adequately considering the evidence and submissions concerning the availability of effective protection in Greece. The court set aside the Tribunal's decision and remitted the matter to the Tribunal for reconsideration according to law. The court also ordered that the Respondent pay the Applicant's costs of the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Tribunal’s decision of 20 December 1999 affirming the decision not to grant the Applicant a protection visa is set aside.

2. The matter is remitted to the Tribunal for reconsideration according to law.

3. The Respondent is to pay the Applicant’s costs of the application.

Background

Background to the litigation

It is sometimes the case that an applicant for Australia’s protection under the Refugees Convention has come to this country from another where protection was available. In that event, it is open to Australia to return the person to that safe third country without breaching its obligations under the Convention. This case concerns an Iraqi national who says he fled from Iraq but lived as an illegal immigrant in Greece for seven years before coming to Australia on a forged Greek passport. His claim for a protection visa has been refused because it is said effective protection was available to him in Greece which, incidentally, refused his claim for asylum. In deciding that effective protection was available in Greece, the Refugee Review Tribunal has not made any assessment of the applicant’s status as a refugee. The question in this case is whether the Tribunal had any proper basis for the conclusion it reached.Factual Background Petros Esho Patto is an Iraqi national who was born on 1 July 1946 in Dohuk in Iraq. He was educated first at primary school in Dohuk and thereafter in Baghdad. He served for a few months in the Iraqi armed forces in 1970 and from October 1970 to June 1984 worked as a clerk with the Eastern Brewery in Baghdad. He served five years after that with the Iraqi armed forces and returned to employment in June 1989 with the Eastern Brewery. From 1989 to October 1991 he worked as a chef. He was married in July 1972. He has four children of the marriage, two of whom are in their twenties. The other two are 19 and 16 years of age respectively. Mr Patto is a Christian of Caldanian ethnicity. He has four brothers and sisters. According to Mr Patto the events which have led to his application for a protection visa began in May 1991 in Iraq when his wife was denied a ration book because she was a Christian. He went to the shopkeeper and argued with him. In the course of that argument he reflected upon the ruling Ba’ath regime. He was subsequently summoned to the Security Office of the Ba’ath Party. He was detained for ten days and assaulted. He claimed that in July 1991 he was warned by people in the Security Office that if he received any information from his brothers who were then living in the United States or if he communicated with them he would be executed because they had escaped from Iraq. He was required to sign a document to that effect. It was repeated to him several times that he was prohibited from contacting his brothers because they had left Iraq illegally. Mr Patto was afraid that they would call him and he would find himself in trouble. He feared his telephone was being tapped. He went to his sister’s house, rang his brothers in the United States and told them not to telephone him. About two months later he received a warning that his life was in danger and that he should leave Iraq as soon as possible. He and his family moved to his sister’s house in Baghdad overnight and the next morning hired a car and drove to Dohuk where they stayed for a month. There he met a Kurdish man who agreed to take the family to Turkey for $US5,000. On Mr Patto’s account he and his family left Iraq illegally on forged passports on 6 January 1992 travelling first to Turkey and then into Greece. They stayed only a short time in Turkey because he only had a ten day visa.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In summary the grounds of application are as follows:1.That the Tribunal erred in that there was no evidence or other material to justify its finding that Mr Patto had a right to return to Greece. 2.The Tribunal erred in that there was no evidence or other material to justify the finding, or alternatively that it was a wrong application of the law to the facts that Mr Patto would enjoy “effective protection” in Greece for the purposes of Article 33 of the Refugee Convention.3.The Tribunal contravened s 424 A of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) in failing to invite Mr Patto to comment upon the country information. (This ground was not pressed) Evidence on the Review In addition to the materials which were before the Tribunal and the Tribunal’s reasons for decision counsel for the applicant tendered an affidavit of Nicholas Venizelakos a person admitted as a barrister and solicitor of the Supreme Court of Victoria and also admitted to practice under the laws of Greece since 1981 and a current member of the Athens Bar Association. Mr Venizelakos has provided expert evidence in matters involving Greek law pending before various Australian courts including the Family Court of Australia and various State Supreme Courts. Mr Venizelakos referred to various Greek statutes on the assumption of the following facts:(a) Patto left Greece on a false Greek passport under a false name;(b) that Patto no longer holds a valid Greek passport; (c) that he has no visa to enter or re-enter Greece; and (d) that his application for refugee status was refused by Greece,Mr Venizelakos was of the opinion that Patto does not have a right to re-enter Greece. He does not satisfy the requirements of s 6(1) of Law No 1975 in respect of entry – departure, residence, work, deportation, procedure of recognition of foreign refugees and similar provisions. Even though he holds no valid passport or a valid travelling document and has no valid visa to enter Greece, authorities at the Athens airport would have the power to prohibit him from entering Greek territory on either a permanent or interim basis. He could however apply for a visa from the Greek Consulate in Perth or in Canberra. However he would not be able to stay in Greece on a temporary basis for more than three months. Absence a valid visa he could be refused entry. Mr Venizelakos was also of the opinion that if returned to Greece, Patto would be exposed to a real risk of being returned to Iraq. In regard to his departure from Greece under a false passport in violation of s 4(4) of the Act the consequence would be that appropriate Greek authorities would not only have the power to prosecute him but also to send him back to the country of his origin either Australia or to Iraq where he comes from. Moreover, Patto would not be entitled to apply again in Greece for refugee status. His previous application was rejected and a new application would be rejected under s 25(1)(b) of the Act as he would not be coming directly from a country where his life or freedom is at threat. In the circumstances he would not fulfil the requirements of the Convention. Statutory Framework

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH J
In a country information report dated 10 August 1999 supplied to the Tribunal and derived from the Department of Immigration and Multicultural Affairs in Athens the following observation appeared:“The Greek Government is extremely tolerant of an illegal population and generally do not deport unless a person comes to notice for criminal activities. There is a large illegal community of Iraqis in Greece (generally boat arrivals from Turkey) and it is possile (sic) to remain in Greece for long periods with no official status. The Greek Government has undertaken to regularise the status of illegals, offering the opportunity to register with the police and apply for either a work permit or asylum. (It should be noted that Greece has the lowest official acceptance rate of refugee claims in Europe).In real terms an illegal can register with the police, (in some cases obtain a work permit) and obtain an interview for either asylum or a work permit in approximately 2 years’ time. The registration process to date has been characterised by delays and extensions of expiry dates. In the short term it provides illegals with a number which registers an official (if illegal) presence in Greece and in some instances permission to work.”The Tribunal’s Decision The Tribunal referred to the factual background already outlined. In oral evidence before the Tribunal Mr Patto had been asked about his life in Greece. He told the Tribunal he had had continuous employment in the same factory until the time of his departure. His older son and daughter are employed and have been in their current jobs for several years. His youngest child is of school age and learns English a couple of days a week. All his children were entitled to attend Greek schools. Asked about access to health care he said that if he were to get sick he would get a letter from a charitable organisation such as Caritas. If he wanted private health care he would have to pay otherwise it was free. He had to spend money to get dental treatment. He did not pay tax. Whatever the employer paid him he accepted. He was employed under his own name. Asked why he did not continue to live in Greece Mr Patto said that he was an illegal citizen. He could not complain if he were robbed. He did not have the same rights as Greek citizens and in particular did not own a house or a car. He was working there illegally and had to hide from the Department of Employment. He used to avoid officials from the Department when they inspected the factory. Asked why he could not return to Greece he said he could not go back to Greece because he would not be able to live there as a free man. Asked why he had made different claims in his various applications for protection he responded that he had relied on the services of a translator who worked outside the Australian Embassy in Athens. The applicant could not read English and therefore could not be sure that statements prepared on his behalf were accurate. The Tribunal accepted Mr Patto’s account of his identity, that he had travelled from Iraq to Greece on an illegal Iraqi passport and to Australia on an illegal Greek passport. It then turned its attention to the question whether effective protection would be available for Mr Patto if he were returned to Greece. In the Tribunal’s view effective protection meant protection which would effectively ensure that there would be no breach of Article 33 of the Refugee Convention if he happened to be a refugee and cited Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Thiyagarajah (1998) 80 FCR 543. It also relied upon the observation of the Full Court in Karthigesu Rajendran v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1998) 166 ALR 619 where it was said:“In substance the Full Court decision [in Thiyagarajah] is to the effect that for the purposes of determining whether Australia has protection obligations under the Convention, it is necessary to look to the individual circumstances of a particular visa applicant to determine whether, if Australia were to return that person to the third or intermediate country, Australia might be in breach of one of the operative Articles of the Convention (relevantly Art. 33). If not, then whether or not the visa applicant is a “refugee” under Art. 1, Australia has no protection obligations in respect of that person …”.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH J

Full text does not contain this section.