Nefiodova v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs
Link copied
CaseCopied
31 min read
Full text
FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Nefiodova v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [2000] FCA 179
MIGRATION – refugees - appeal from the RRT decision to refuse to grant protection visa – credibility – distinction between a particular fact, an ultimate fact in issue and a conclusion – finding that evidence is fabricated is not a particular fact – whether decision based upon existence of particular facts which did not exist – whether RRT failed to make a finding on a material question of fact – where matter first raised at hearing, which should ordinarily have been raised on an earlier occasion, it may legitimately be relevant to credibility – whether applicant had a well-founded fear of persecution for reason of political opinion – imputed political belief is only relevant where actual belief is absent
YHELENA NEFIODOVA v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
N 1055 OF 1999
HELY J 28 FEBRUARY 2000 SYDNEY
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY
N 1055 OF 1999
BETWEEN:
YHELENA NEFIODOVA APPLICANT
AND:
MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS RESPONDENT
JUDGE:
HELY J
DATE OF ORDER:
28 FEBRUARY 2000
WHERE MADE:
SYDNEY
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1. The application is dismissed with costs.
Note: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY
N 1055 OF 1999
BETWEEN:
YHELENA NEFIODOVA APPLICANT
AND:
MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS RESPONDENT
JUDGE:
HELY J
DATE:
28 FEBRUARY 2000
PLACE:
SYDNEY
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
The applicant is a citizen of Russia who last arrived in Australia in July 1998, travelling on a passport other than her own. On 28 April 1999 the applicant…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Nefiodova v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affai... and more:
The case of Nefiodova v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs involved the applicant, Nefiodova, who sought refugee status in Australia. She alleged persecution in her home country, Russia, due to her refusal to act as a sexual lure for individuals being spied upon by the Federal Security Service (FSB). The matter was heard by the Refugee Review Tribunal (RRT), which rejected her claims. The Federal Court of Australia was called upon to review the RRT's decision. The central legal issue was whether the RRT's decision was based on non-existent facts that the applicant did not provide. The court examined whether any wrongly attributed evidence was critical to the RRT's decision and concluded that the RRT's findings were based on other credible evidence and reasons.
The court found that the RRT had indeed attributed some evidence to the applicant that she did not provide, but this did not undermine the RRT's overall decision. The court emphasised that a decision is based on a particular fact only if that fact is critical to the decision-making process. The wrongly attributed evidence did not form a critical link in the RRT's reasoning. Instead, the RRT's decision stemmed from its disbelief in the applicant's account, which it found to be full of inconsistencies and outlandish elements. These inconsistencies included the location of an assignation and the role of a person named Marina in the events described by the applicant. The RRT also noted other factors, such as the delay in seeking a protection visa, which contributed to its conclusion. The court concluded that the RRT's decision was not based on the wrongly attributed evidence but on other credible material and reasoning.
The court upheld the RRT's decision and dismissed the applicant's appeal. It ordered that the application be dismissed with costs, meaning the applicant would be responsible for the legal expenses incurred by the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs in defending the appeal. This outcome reinforced the importance of the RRT's role in assessing refugee claims and the court's function in reviewing those assessments for procedural fairness and correctness.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The application is dismissed with costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
In the result, I find that RRT attributed to the applicant evidence which she did not give in the respects alleged in Grounds 1(a), 1(b), 1(c), 1(h) and 1(j).Was the decision based on non-existent facts?60A decision is based on a particular fact if the fact is critical to the making of the decision: CurraghMining Ltd v Daniel (1992) 34 FCR 212 at pp 220-221. None of the evidence wrongly attributed to the applicant by RRT formed a link in a chain of reasoning such that the failure of a link brings down the decision which is dependent upon it. The more appropriate metaphor is the strand in a net adopted by Heerey J in Fernando (and see Vichlenkova v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs (1999) FCA 1338). The net does not necessarily fail because one or more of its constituent strands fails. RRT did not believe the applicant’s claims in relation to the FSB assignment. It did not accept that she left Russia, or remained away from Russia, for reasons associated with any assignment by FSB, as there was no such assignment. An assessment of the credibility of an applicant is largely a matter of impression. It is not always easy to detail the factors which produce that impression. The particular reasons which RRT gave for its conclusion that the applicant’s claims are a far-fetched concoction and utterly unreliable are to be found in the passages extracted at par 10 above. In RRT’s view the applicant’s account was full of outlandish elements, particularly the claim that she identified “И” and successfully accomplished her mission at their first meeting on the very first night after her briefing. That finding is not dependant upon the evidence wrongly attributed to the applicant by RRT, and stands independently of it. The inconsistencies which are specifically referred to in the extracted passage at par 10 above are:-whether the assignation took place at the applicant’s place, or at “И’s” place;-the clashing claims as to Marina’s significance in these events (see pars 7 and 8 above).The first of those matters is the subject of ground 1(b); the second is not the subject of any ground. RRT does refer in the “findings and reasons” section of its decision to another “fact” which is shown not to exist, namely that the applicant claimed that she decided to return to work because her boss had two nights off. But this does not seem to lead anywhere, and RRT’s conclusion, for whatever reason, is that the applicant did not intend to resume her career at the casino, but returned to work in October 1995 with the intention of staying for two nights only. Whilst RRT no doubt had in mind in reaching its conclusion all of the matters referred to in its decision, and not only those the subject of specific mention in the “findings and reasons” section of its report, the applicant has not established that RRT’s decision was based upon the evidence wrongly attributed to the applicant by RRT. There was other material, including the delay in seeking a protection visa which could lead, and which did lead, to a lack of satisfaction on the part of RRT that the applicant was a person to whom Australia owed protection obligations.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
A more accurate statement of what the applicant said (see RD 44, 226-227) was that it was against her political beliefs to be involved with the KGB or FSB. My attention was not directed to any statement on the part of the applicant to the effect of that attributed to her by RRT.Evidence statements attributed to the applicant which she did not make In the result, I find that RRT attributed to the applicant evidence which she did not give in the respects alleged in Grounds 1(a), 1(b), 1(c), 1(h) and 1(j).Was the decision based on non-existent facts?60A decision is based on a particular fact if the fact is critical to the making of the decision: CurraghMining Ltd v Daniel (1992) 34 FCR 212 at pp 220-221. None of the evidence wrongly attributed to the applicant by RRT formed a link in a chain of reasoning such that the failure of a link brings down the decision which is dependent upon it. The more appropriate metaphor is the strand in a net adopted by Heerey J in Fernando (and see Vichlenkova v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs (1999) FCA 1338). The net does not necessarily fail because one or more of its constituent strands fails. RRT did not believe the applicant’s claims in relation to the FSB assignment. It did not accept that she left Russia, or remained away from Russia, for reasons associated with any assignment by FSB, as there was no such assignment. An assessment of the credibility of an applicant is largely a matter of impression. It is not always easy to detail the factors which produce that impression. The particular reasons which RRT gave for its conclusion that the applicant’s claims are a far-fetched concoction and utterly unreliable are to be found in the passages extracted at par 10 above. In RRT’s view the applicant’s account was full of outlandish elements, particularly the claim that she identified “И” and successfully accomplished her mission at their first meeting on the very first night after her briefing. That finding is not dependant upon the evidence wrongly attributed to the applicant by RRT, and stands independently of it. The inconsistencies which are specifically referred to in the extracted passage at par 10 above are:-whether the assignation took place at the applicant’s place, or at “И’s” place;-the clashing claims as to Marina’s significance in these events (see pars 7 and 8 above).The first of those matters is the subject of ground 1(b); the second is not the subject of any ground. RRT does refer in the “findings and reasons” section of its decision to another “fact” which is shown not to exist, namely that the applicant claimed that she decided to return to work because her boss had two nights off. But this does not seem to lead anywhere, and RRT’s conclusion, for whatever reason, is that the applicant did not intend to resume her career at the casino, but returned to work in October 1995 with the intention of staying for two nights only. Whilst RRT no doubt had in mind in reaching its conclusion all of the matters referred to in its decision, and not only those the subject of specific mention in the “findings and reasons” section of its report, the applicant has not established that RRT’s decision was based upon the evidence wrongly attributed to the applicant by RRT. There was other material, including the delay in seeking a protection visa which could lead, and which did lead, to a lack of satisfaction on the part of RRT that the applicant was a person to whom Australia owed protection obligations.
Decision
Reasons for decision
HELY J
Soon after returning to work, the applicant was again sexually assaulted by the same bodyguards. This time she reported the matter to the police. The police sexually assaulted her, and warned her not to slander good people such as the casino manager’s bodyguards.RRT’s decision The applicant’s claims, as I have so far recounted them, were accepted by the Refugee Review Tribunal (“RRT”), but those claims would not of themselves found a fear of persecution for a Convention reason. The applicant did not suggest otherwise. Her claim to refugee status was based on later events to which I now turn. The applicant claimed that on her return to work in mid to late October 1995, she was approached by two unknown men who produced FSB identification, and who pressed her to act as a sexual lure for persons on whom they were spying. The applicant said that she could not establish for certain that these men were FSB officers, as it was dark when they showed her their identification. The applicant claims that although it was against her political principles to co-operate with FSB because of its lawless methods, she agreed to the request put to her by the two agents, because she feared that harm would befall her if she were to refuse. Thereafter the applicant engaged in the seduction of a man identified by the FSB agents, but after one evening she could not stand to continue with the arrangement that she had made with the FSB officers. She fled to Moscow. Whilst there she received a telephone call from the casino manager instructing her to return to Vladivostok under threat that her parents would be killed if she disobeyed. The applicant stayed in Moscow at the home of a woman called Marina, whose passport she used to get out of Russia. At another point in her evidence the applicant introduced a new claim that she moved out of Marina’s place to stay with one of Marina’s girlfriends. In December 1995 the applicant left Russia for Thailand. In 1995-1997 she lived in Thailand and Singapore. Between July 1997 and April 1998 she lived in Australia. Between April 1998 and July 1998 she lived in Thailand, and as earlier noted, came to Australia for the second time in July 1998. The applicant claims to have learnt in early 1998 that Marina had been stabbed to death. At one point in her evidence the applicant said that Marina was reported to have been killed in Moscow; at another point she was reported to have been killed during a visit to Vladivostok. The applicant believed that the FSB, or cronies of the two agents had killed Marina because Marina had helped the applicant to evade them. RRT was not persuaded that there was any substance in this speculation, particularly having regard to the lapse of time between the two events. Although RRT accepted the applicant’s evidence as to the sexual assaults that she suffered at the hands of the casino manager’s bodyguards, and at the hands of the police from whom she sought assistance, RRT did not accept the applicant’s evidence in relation to the undertaking of an assignment at the request of agents of FSB. RRT concluded that the applicant’s claimed reasons for leaving Russia, and for staying away, are “a far fetched concoction, and utterly unreliable”. RRT said that it reached this conclusion with confidence.