BLBS and Director-General of Security and Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read

[2013] AATA  820

Division SECURITY APPEALS DIVISION

File Number(s)

2011/1521

Re

BLBS

APPLICANT

And

Director-General of Security 

RESPONDENT

Division SECURITY APPEALS DIVISION

File Number(s)

2011/1519

Re

BLBS

APPLICANT

And

Minister for Foreign Affairs

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

President D Kerr
Deputy President J W Constance
Senior Member G D Friedman

Date 19 November 2013
Place Melbourne
  1. The decisions under review are affirmed.

  2. Pursuant to s 35AA of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 the Tribunal directs that these reasons are to be published in full only to the parties and otherwise be published only in redacted form after deleting all information which might serve to identify the applicant and that the publication of the name of the applicant be prohibited.

  3. Pursuant to s 39B(11) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 the Tribunal directs that the evidence and all information given to the Tribunal in its closed hearing is not to be communicated to any person and, pursuant to s 43AAA(5) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, the Tribunal directs that its findings relating to any matters not disclosed in these reasons are not to be given to the applicant.

    ........................................................................

    NOTE
    Pursuant to s 35AA of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, the Tribunal has directed that the publication of the name of the applicant be prohibited. Publication of matter identifying the applicant may be an offence.

    Section 63(5) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 provides the following:

    Contempt of the Tribunal

    A person is guilty of an offence if:

    (a)    the person engages in conduct; and

    (b)    the person’s conduct would, if the Tribunal were a court of record, constitute a contempt of that court.

    Penalty: 30 penalty units or imprisonment for 6 months, or both.

    Catchwords

    NATIONAL SECURITY—adverse security assessment—request for Minister to cancel passport and to order surrender of foreign travel documents—whether request must disclose relevant suspicion—whether Tribunal required to or should defer to the assessments and opinions of ASIO and its officers—history of independent review—standard of satisfaction required—ASIO Act—Director-General’s Security Assessment Determination No 2 as policy guidance—interpretation of Determination.

    NATIONAL SECURITY—cancellation of passport and surrender of foreign travel documents—standard of satisfaction required for lawful request—“suspects on reasonable grounds”—well‑settled technical legal meaning—“would be likely to engage in conduct”—language not ambiguous or obscure—“conduct that might prejudice the security of Australia or a foreign country” —no relevance to standard of satisfaction required—conduct must be of that nature.

    NATIONAL SECURITY—reviews of adverse security assessment and decisions to cancel passport and require surrender of foreign travel documents—point of time at which Tribunal is to review—when a cancellation request made by ASIO expires and is no longer valid.

    NATIONAL SECURITY—“speculation” not prohibited—role of ASIO as national security organisation—adverse assessment and decisions requiring cancellation of passport and surrender of foreign travel documents.

    PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE—lies—as relevant to proof of a denied contention—must relate to material issue and must be explicable only on the basis that the truth would implicate the person telling the lie.

    PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE—requirements for reasoning to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BLBS and Director-General of Security and Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] AATA 820
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants in this case, BLBS, sought judicial review of decisions by the Director-General of Security to cancel their passports and require them to surrender their foreign travel documents. The dispute centred on the legal basis for the Director-General's decisions, the adequacy of the evidence provided by the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation (ASIO), and the standard of proof required to justify such actions. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia, where the applicants challenged the validity of the decisions under the Security of Australia Act and the Director-General’s Security Assessment Determination.

The primary legal issues before the court were the criteria for a lawful request by the Director-General to cancel a passport and order the surrender of foreign travel documents, the standard of proof required for such a request, and the extent to which the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) should defer to the assessments and opinions of ASIO and its officers. Additionally, the court had to determine the appropriate point in time for the AAT to review the cancellation request and whether the AAT was required to consider classified materials.

The court held that the Director-General's request for passport cancellation must disclose the relevant suspicion to a standard that justifies an "actual apprehension" that the applicant might engage in conduct that might prejudice the security of Australia or a foreign country. The court clarified that the language used in the legislation was not ambiguous and that the standard of satisfaction required is well-established in legal terms. The court further found that the AAT is not required to defer to the assessments of ASIO and its officers but must review the evidence independently. The court also determined that the AAT should review the request at the time it is made and that a cancellation request expires and becomes invalid if not acted upon within a reasonable timeframe.

In this case, the court concluded that the unclassified evidence provided by ASIO did not meet the required standard of satisfaction for a lawful request. The court also found that the classified evidence, which was not disclosed due to national security concerns, was necessary for the AAT to fully review the Director-General’s decision. The court set aside the decisions of the Director-General and remitted the matter to the AAT for reconsideration in light of its findings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Between 2 October 2008 and 12 May 2010 inclusive, BLBS was interviewed by officers of ASIO on five separate occasions. There are no transcripts of these interviews as they were not recorded. He was also interviewed by the AFP. That interview was recorded. We have taken into account the reports ASIO made of the five interviews it conducted and the transcript of the interview the AFP undertook. Our reasons refer to their contents only to the extent directly material to our decision.The ASIO/AFP interviews and BLBS’s evidence to the TribunalThe second ASIO interview - 3 September 2009 During his second interview, conducted on 3 September 2009, BLBS was asked what he thought of people who wanted to conduct an act of terrorism in Australia. The report of the interview records the following: [BLBS] said the events in Afghanistan were not justification for this kind of behaviour in Australia … [BLBS] said that Australia was good to “us”, and provided a home and work, did not deserve to be attacked. [BLBS] said that if people were upset about troops in Afghanistan and they wanted to travel there and do something about it, then that would be their choice. [BLBS] … sought clarification on what the difference between Australia and Afghanistan was, and [BLBS] said that Afghanistan is a Muslim country and if people want to travel there to defend it, that is very different to doing something in Australia, which would not be ok, as Australia is not a Muslim country. There is no dispute that this is an accurate record of what BLBS said during that interview. One of the ASIO officers who conducted that interview, XXX, gave evidence. XXX agreed in cross-examination that the Applicant was “very clear and forthright” in his view that Australia did not deserve to be attacked and that he expressed “vehement disagreement with the proposition that violent jihad was religiously permissible in Australia.”[15]The Applicant’s travel in [redacted] 2009-2010[15] Transcript 23/07/13 p 91. From [redacted] 2009 until [redacted] 2010 BLBS travelled in [redacted], attending several schools and mosques. He attended some lectures at [redacted]. This experience increased his desire to continue to study his religion and the Arabic language.[16] [16] The Applicant told ASIO officers of his studies in [redacted] when he was interviewed on 7 January 2010.The fourth ASIO interview - 11 March 2010 The Applicant was interviewed for a fourth time on 11 March 2010. During that interview BLBS advised the ASIO officers that he intended to travel to [redacted] at the end of 2010 to undertake further Islamic studies. He said that he had no plans to travel overseas “in the near future”. The Applicant also stated that he believed “it is someone’s choice to travel overseas to defend Islam in any country where Islam was under attack.”When advised by the ASIO officers that it is an offence under Australian law to travel overseas and fight against a foreign government, BLBS said he was unaware of this.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In his written submissions, Mr Berger accepted that there “may be reasonable doubt about ASIO’s ultimate assessment” but submitted that the Tribunal would be justified in finding a lawful basis for the Director-General making the cancellation request if there “was some basis for an actual apprehension” that if BLBS’s passport was not cancelled there was “more than a [sic] insubstantial or negligible risk (in the order of 10% or less) that he might engage in politically motivated violence either in Australia or overseas”. The Tribunal’s conclusions We have explained why we do not accept that Mr Berger’s analysis accurately reflects the legal test for the threshold of satisfaction that the Tribunal should apply to such a request—but even assuming its validity we do not think what was put against BLBS in the unclassified materials meets even that low threshold. None of the individual factors relied upon by ASIO examined in context provide a basis for the Tribunal to form the least “actual apprehension” that BLBS would engage in such conduct. Nor, taken together, can they do so. A finding by the Tribunal, particularly in this Division, need not be based on direct evidence. There will many instances where various pieces of intelligence information assessed by a process of inductive reasoning, taken together can validly justify a conclusion despite no single element being compelling. However, valid reasoning to a circumstantial conclusion depends on confidence in the existence of the underlying bits of the puzzle, or parts of the mosaic or strands of rope from which connecting inferences can be drawn. In the present case, restricting its consideration to the open materials, the Tribunal has concluded (a) BLBS did not share common views with those with whom he was asserted to associate; (b) his failure to have comprehensive plans about who he would meet and at which institution he would study in Yemen was not inconsistent with his claimed intention of looking to go there to undertake intensive Islamic studies; (c) BLBS’s statements about his understanding of his religion in earlier interviews are not inconsistent with his positive assertion in the Tribunal that he would not choose to participate in militant jihad activities if he was permitted to travel overseas; and (d) that any inconsistencies in his accounts or reluctance to answer questions can be explained for other reasons. None of those findings, as individual bits of a puzzle or as parts of a mosaic or strands of a rope, can be added one to the other or woven together in a way to collectively justify the assessment ASIO made. Were that the end point we would set ASIO’s adverse assessment aside.THE CLASSIFIED EVIDENCE AND MATERIALS That conclusion does not, unfortunately for the applicant, discharge the Tribunal’s function. We also have to take into account the classified materials and evidence. Much is covered by certificates issued by the Attorney-General that prevent its disclosure to BLBS. They also prevent disclosure of that material in these reasons. Our Closed Reasons can be provided only to the Director-General of Security.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established