MYVC and and Minister for Foreign Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

[2014] AATA 511

Division

Security Appeals Division

File Number(s)

2014/0032

Re

MYVC

APPLICANT

And

Director-General of Security

RESPONDENT

File Number(s)

2014/0033

Re

MYVC

APPLICANT

And

Minister for Foreign Affairs

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President RP Handley
Senior Member G Ettinger
Senior Member JF Toohey

Date 28 July 2014
Place Sydney

1.The decisions under review are affirmed.

2.Pursuant to s 35AA of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 the Tribunal directs that these reasons are to be published in full only to the parties and otherwise be published only in redacted form after deleting all information which might serve to identify the applicant and that the publication of the name of the applicant be prohibited.

3.Pursuant to s 39B(11) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 the Tribunal directs that the evidence and all information given to the Tribunal in its closed hearing is not to be communicated to any person and, pursuant to s 43AAA(5) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, the Tribunal directs that its findings relating to any matters not disclosed in these reasons are not to be given to the applicant.

............[sgd]............................................................

Deputy President RP Handley

NOTE

·Pursuant to s 35AA of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, the Tribunal has directed that the publication of the name of the applicant be prohibited. Publication of matter identifying the applicant may be an offence.

·Section 63(5) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 provides the following:

Contempt of the Tribunal

A person is guilty of an offence if:

(a) the person engages in conduct; and

(b) the person’s conduct would, if the Tribunal were a court of record, constitute a contempt of that court.

Penalty: 30 penalty units or imprisonment for 6 months, or both.

  1. MYVC (the Applicant) has applied for the review of two decisions:

    (i)an adverse security assessment made by the Director-General of Security of the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation (ASIO) (the Respondent) who assessed that if MYVC holds an Australian passport, he would be likely to engage in conduct that might prejudice the security of Australia or another foreign country; and

    (ii)a decision made by the Minister for Foreign Affairs (the Minister) to cancel MYVC’s Australian passport and refuse to issue him with a new passport should he reapply.

    BACKGROUND

  2. MYVC, who [redacted] was born in [redacted]. He arrived in Australia in [redacted] 2002. He was granted permanent residency in [redacted] 2004 and became an Australian citizen in [redacted] 2006. MYVC is married to an Australian citizen and has [redacted] children [redacted] are also Australian citizens. Since being granted Australian citizenship, MYVC has spent a significant time outside Australia, mostly in [redacted], where he is residing currently.

  3. On [redacted] 2012, MYVC was interviewed by ASIO officers with regard to involvement in people smuggling. He provided information about his international travel history, family situation, business activities, personal relationships and financial status and denied having any personal involvement in people smuggling activities.

  4. On [redacted] 2013, the Director-General of ASIO made an adverse security assessment in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MYVC and and Minister for Foreign Affairs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 511
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter of MYVC and the Minister for Foreign Affairs was before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The Applicant, MYVC, sought review of two decisions made by the Director-General of Security of the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation (ASIO) and the Minister for Foreign Affairs. The first decision was an adverse security assessment that MYVC would likely engage in conduct prejudicial to the security of Australia or another foreign country. The second decision was the Minister's decision to cancel MYVC's Australian passport and refuse to issue him with a new one. The Applicant argued that the adverse security assessment was not justified and that the Minister's decision to cancel his passport was unreasonable. The court had to determine whether the adverse security assessment was correct, justified, and whether the evidence was sufficiently probative to justify the assessment. Additionally, the court had to decide whether the Minister's decision to cancel MYVC's passport was lawful and reasonable.

The court found that the adverse security assessment was correct and justified based on the evidence provided by ASIO. The evidence included MYVC's involvement in people smuggling activities while travelling on his Australian passport. The court also found that the Minister's decision to cancel MYVC's passport was lawful and reasonable. The court held that the Minister's power was discretionary and that there were strong grounds supporting the exercise of that power to prevent MYVC from engaging in conduct prejudicial to the security of Australia. The decisions under review were affirmed.

The court affirmed the decisions under review, upholding the adverse security assessment and the decision to cancel MYVC's passport. The court found that the evidence provided by ASIO was sufficient to justify the adverse security assessment and that the Minister's decision was lawful and reasonable. The Applicant's application for review was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

MYVC (the Applicant) has applied for the review of two decisions: (i)an adverse security assessment made by the Director-General of Security of the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation (ASIO) (the Respondent) who assessed that if MYVC holds an Australian passport, he would be likely to engage in conduct that might prejudice the security of Australia or another foreign country; and(ii)a decision made by the Minister for Foreign Affairs (the Minister) to cancel MYVC’s Australian passport and refuse to issue him with a new passport should he reapply.BACKGROUND MYVC, who [redacted] was born in [redacted]. He arrived in Australia in [redacted] 2002. He was granted permanent residency in [redacted] 2004 and became an Australian citizen in [redacted] 2006. MYVC is married to an Australian citizen and has [redacted] children [redacted] are also Australian citizens. Since being granted Australian citizenship, MYVC has spent a significant time outside Australia, mostly in [redacted], where he is residing currently. On [redacted] 2012, MYVC was interviewed by ASIO officers with regard to involvement in people smuggling. He provided information about his international travel history, family situation, business activities, personal relationships and financial status and denied having any personal involvement in people smuggling activities. On [redacted] 2013, the Director-General of ASIO made an adverse security assessment in respect of MYVC and, on [redacted] 2013, requested that the Minister cancel his passport and refuse to issue him with a new passport should he reapply. This request was made on the ground that if MYVC held an Australian passport, he would be likely to engage in conduct that might prejudice the security of Australia or a foreign country, and his passport should be cancelled or a renewal of his passport refused in order to prevent him from engaging in such conduct. On [redacted] 2013, the Minister made a decision to cancel MYVC’s passport. MYVC was advised of this by letter [redacted]. In this letter, the Minister’s delegate made a formal demand under s 24 of the Australian Passports Act 2005 (the Passports Act) that MYVC surrender his Australian passport on the ground that it had been cancelled. On [redacted] 2014, MYVC applied to the Tribunal for a review of the decisions. RELEVANT LAW AND ISSUES MYVC seeks the review of firstly, an adverse security assessment by ASIO, and secondly, the decision of the Minister to cancel his passport pursuant to that assessment. Pursuant to s 17(1) of the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation Act 1979 (the ASIO Act), the functions of ASIO include:(c)to advise Ministers and authorities of the Commonwealth in respect of matters relating to security, in so far as those matters are relevant to their functions and responsibilities. Section 37(1) states:The functions of the Organisation referred to in paragraph 17(1)(c) include the furnishing to Commonwealth agencies of security assessments relevant to their functions and responsibilities. Section 37(2) requires that an adverse or qualified security assessment be accompanied by a statement of grounds for the assessment.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The procedure governing the conduct of the Tribunal’s review is that stipulated in s 39A and s 39B of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (the AAT Act). (See, for example, Re BLBS and Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade (2012) 129 ALD 380, at [43ff].) Section 43AAA(2) provides that upon the conclusion of this review, the Tribunal must make and record its findings in relation to the security assessment, and those findings may state the Tribunal’s opinion as to the correctness of, or justification for, any opinion, advice or information contained in the assessment. However, s 43AAA(3) provides that the Tribunal must not make findings in relation to an assessment that would have the effect of superseding any information taken to be part of the assessment unless, in the Tribunal’s opinion, the information is incorrect, incorrectly represented or could not reasonably be relevant to the requirements of security. ASIO’S UNCLASSIFIED EVIDENCE The Respondents provided affidavits from a senior ASIO officer using the pseudonym ‘Alan Masling’: an open affidavit [redacted] and a closed affidavit [redacted]. Mr Masling also gave evidence at the hearing both in open and closed sessions. Mr Masling is [redacted] Mr Masling’s closed affidavit and much of the evidence relied upon by the Respondent is the subject of Ministerial certificates issued pursuant to s 39A(8) of the AAT Act and, therefore, was not disclosed to the Applicant and may not be disclosed in this Statement of Reasons. Non-disclosure to the Applicant made Mr Bodisco’s task of cross-examining Mr Masling and presenting a case for the Applicant a very difficult one. In relation to Mr Masling’s evidence, conscious of those difficulties, the Tribunal invited Mr Bodisco to identify any questions to which the Applicant sought an answer, but which would be subject to the Ministerial certificates. The Tribunal undertook to put any questions to Mr Masling in closed session. In his open affidavit, Mr Masling said the adverse security assessment for MYVC included advice that MYVC:15.1 has been involved in people smuggling; 15.2 has engaged in these activities overseas while travelling on his Australian passport; and15.3 would have restricted ability to engage in people smuggling activities if his Australian passport were cancelled. Mr Masling said that when MYVC was interviewed by ASIO officers on [redacted] 2012 he was given opportunities to admit involvement in people smuggling activities. Mr Masling noted that MYVC denied any involvement in people smuggling and claimed he was involved in legitimate business activities:23. During the interviews, the applicant provided information that he was involved in overseas business activities [redacted]24. ASIO assessed that the applicant was involved in people smuggling regardless of whether he was also involved in such legitimate activities overseas. In open evidence at the hearing, Mr Masling said the role of ASIO is to collect intelligence and provide advice to Government on issues relating to security. ASIO has been concerned with territorial integrity [redacted], with the definition of ‘security’ in s 4 of the ASIO Act being amended in 2010 to include serious threats to Australia’s territorial and border integrity. [redacted]

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Minister’s power is a discretionary one. In MYVC’s case, the Tribunal is comfortably satisfied, on the basis of the closed evidence, that there are strong grounds supporting exercise of the Minister’s power in order to prevent MYVC from engaging in conduct prejudicial to the security of Australia. The decision under review is therefore affirmed.DECISIONS The Tribunal affirms the decisions under review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.