RJCG v Director-General of Security

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

RJCG v Director-General of Security [2013] FCA 269

Citation: RJCG v Director-General of Security [2013] FCA 269
Appeal from: RJCG v Director-General of Security [2012] AATA 540
Parties:

RJCG v THE DIRECTOR-GENERAL OF SECURITY

RJCG v ATTORNEY-GENERAL OF THE COMMONWEALTH and ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

File numbers: ACD 72 of 2012
ACD 74 of 2012
Judge: FOSTER J
Date of judgment: 27 March 2013
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – whether certain material before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal and this Court should be the subject of non-publication orders – relevant principles discussed
Legislation: Access to Justice (Federal Jurisdiction) Amendment Act 2012 (Cth), Sch 2
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), ss 39A, 39B, 43AAA and 44
Australian Security Intelligence Organisation Act 1979 (Cth), ss 4, 7, 8 and 81
Crimes Act 1914 (Cth), s 85B
Criminal Code 1995 (Cth), s 93.2
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), former s 50 and Pt VAA
Cases cited: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Air New Zealand Limited (No 4) [2012] FCA 1439 followed
Hogan v Australian Crime Commission (2010) 240 CLR 651 applied
Lodhi v The Queen (2006) 199 FLR 288 cited
Date of hearing: 31 October 2012
Date of last submissions: 30 November 2012
Place: Canberra
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 72
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr LT Grey
Solicitor for the Applicant: Colquhoun Murphy
Counsel for the Director-General of Security and for the Attorney-General of the Commonwealth: Mr A Berger
Solicitor for the Director-General of Security and for the Attorney-General of the Commonwealth: Australian Government Solicitor
Counsel for the Administrative Appeals Tribunal: The Administrative Appeals Tribunal submitted save as to costs

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

ACD 72 of 2012

ON APPEAL FROM THE SECURITY APPEALS DIVISION OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
BETWEEN:

RJCG
Applicant

AND:

THE DIRECTOR-GENERAL OF SECURITY
Respondent

JUDGE:

FOSTER J

DATE OF ORDER:

27 MARCH 2013

WHERE MADE:

CANBERRA

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The use of the acronym “RJCG” to identify the applicant in this proceeding cease.

2.As and from 27 March 2013, the correct name of the applicant, Yeon Kim, be used in all documents filed herein.

3.Orders 3 and 4 made on 31 October 2012 be vacated. 

4.Up to and including 22 April 2013, the documents comprising the Administrative Appeals Tribunal’s open file not be published or disclosed to any person other than the parties to this proceeding, the legal representatives of the parties, the Court and its staff.

5.Up to and including 22 April 2013, information identifying the foreign country, the foreign intelligence service and the foreign intelligence officers referred to in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal’s open file not be published or disclosed to any person other than the parties to the proceedings, the legal representatives of the parties, the Court and its staff.

6.The Director-General of Security pay the applicant’s costs of and incidental to the Interlocutory Application filed by the Director-General of Security on 26 October 2012.  

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read RJCG v Director-General of Security and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCA 269
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In RJCG v Director-General of Security, the Federal Court of Australia was tasked with determining whether certain materials presented to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) and subsequently to the Court should remain subject to non-publication orders. The dispute involved a security assessment conducted by the Director-General of Security (DGS) against the applicant, RJCG, who contested the assessment's secrecy and its impact on his ability to defend himself adequately. The applicant sought to have the non-publication orders vacated and to compel the DGS to reveal the identity of the foreign country and intelligence service involved.

The legal issues before the Court included the interpretation and application of former s 50 of the Federal Court Act, which allowed the Court to restrict publication of evidence to prevent prejudice to the administration of justice or the security of the Commonwealth. The Court also needed to consider the principles governing the use of in camera hearings under s 93.2 of the Criminal Code and the implications of s 43AAA of the AAT Act regarding the disclosure of findings in security assessment proceedings.

The Court examined the necessity for the non-publication orders, emphasizing that such orders should only be made if strictly necessary to prevent prejudice to the administration of justice or the security of the Commonwealth. The Court noted that the standard required was one of 'necessity,' which is higher than mere convenience or reasonableness. In applying these principles, the Court found that certain material, including parts of the open decision and specific evidentiary documents, should remain protected to avoid potential prejudice. However, the Court decided to vacate orders that restricted the publication of the applicant's name and other details that were not deemed necessary to maintain secrecy.

Ultimately, the Court ruled that the acronym "RJCG" should no longer be used to identify the applicant, and his correct name, Yeon Kim, should be used instead. The Court also vacated certain non-publication orders but maintained others to protect sensitive information. Additionally, the Court ordered the DGS and the Attorney-General to pay the applicant's costs related to the interlocutory applications.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The use of the acronym “RJCG” to identify the applicant in this proceeding cease.

2. As and from 27 March 2013, the correct name of the applicant, Yeon Kim, be used in all documents filed herein.

3. Orders 3 and 4 made on 31 October 2012 be vacated.

4. Up to and including 22 April 2013, the documents comprising the Administrative Appeals Tribunal’s open file not be published or disclosed to any person other than the parties to this proceeding, the legal representatives of the parties, the Court and its staff.

5. Up to and including 22 April 2013, information identifying the foreign country, the foreign intelligence service and the foreign intelligence officers referred to in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal’s open file not be published or disclosed to any person other than the parties to the proceedings, the legal representatives of the parties, the Court and its staff.

6. The Director-General of Security pay the applicant’s costs of and incidental to the Interlocutory Application filed by the Director-General of Security on 26 October 2012.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

1. The use of the acronym “RJCG” to identify the applicant in this proceeding cease.

2. As and from 27 March 2013, the correct name of the applicant, Yeon Kim, be used in all documents filed herein.

3. Order 3 made on 31 October 2012 and Order 1 made on 8 February 2013 be vacated.

4. Up to and including 22 April 2013, the contents of Exhibit 1 and Exhibit JCMR-6 to the affidavit of James Charles McNair Ronald sworn on 26 September 2012; the contents of Exhibit IMS-18 and Exhibit IMS-19 to the affidavit of Irene Maria Sekler affirmed on 31 January 2013; and the contents of the applicant’s Outline of Submissions filed on 30 November 2012, not be published or disclosed to any person other than the parties to this proceeding, the legal representatives of the parties, the Court and its staff.

5. The Attorney-General of the Commonwealth pay the applicant’s costs of and incidental to the Interlocutory Application filed by the Attorney-General on 26 October 2012.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Immediately before its repeal on 12 December 2012, former s 50 of the Federal Court was in the following terms:50 Prohibition of publication of evidence etc.(1)The Court may, at any time during or after the hearing of a proceeding in the Court, make such order forbidding or restricting the publication of particular evidence, or the name of a party or witness, as appears to the Court to be necessary in order to prevent prejudice to the administration of justice or the security of the Commonwealth.(2)This section does not limit section 23HC. At [4] of Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Air New Zealand Limited (No 4), Perram J said:Former s 50 is concerned with evidence, not with the production of material at a stage anterior to its tender: cf. Cyclopet Pty Ltd v Australian Nuclear Science and Technology Organisation [2012] FCA 1326 at [25] per Jacobson J. The principles governing its exercise are clear and were comprehensively explained in Hogan v Australian Crime Commission (2010) 240 CLR 651 at 664 [30]-[33] per curiam. The provision is enlivened either because it is necessary to avoid prejudice to the security of the Commonwealth or to the administration of justice. ‘Necessary’ is a strong word and the reference in former s 50 to the security of the Commonwealth shows that the provision is not concerned with trivialities: Hogan at [30], citing Australian Broadcasting Commission v Parish (1980) 43 FLR 129; [1980] FCA 33 at 133 (FLR) per Bowen CJ. Once the necessity appears, there is no balancing exercise to be engaged in; the order is simply to be made. This is because the word ‘may’ in former s 50 does not disclose the presence of a discretion: Hogan at [31]-[32]. So too, the standard required by former s 50 before the power is enlivened is that of ‘necessity’ and this is to be contrasted with, and distinguished from, less demanding standards, such as whether the order sought would be ‘convenient, reasonable or sensible’: Hogan at [31]. With the exception perhaps of the proposition stated in the first sentence of the above extract, I agree with his Honour’s summary of the relevant principles. I intend to apply those principles in the present case. The material sought to be protected at the instigation of the DGS is material which is in evidence before me on the present Applications and for the purpose of determining the claims for relief made by the DGS. Section 93.2 of the Criminal Code provides:93.2Hearing in camera etc.(1)This section applies to a hearing of an application or other proceedings before a federal court, a court exercising federal jurisdiction or a court of a Territory, whether under this Act or otherwise.(2)At any time before or during the hearing, the judge or magistrate, or other person presiding or competent to preside over the proceedings, may, if satisfied that it is in the interest of the security or defence of the Commonwealth:(a)order that some or all of the members of the public be excluded during the whole or a part of the hearing; or(b)order that no report of the whole or a specified part of, or relating to, the application or proceedings be published; or(c)make such order and give such directions as he or she thinks necessary for ensuring that no person, without the approval of the court, has access (whether before, during or after the hearing) to any affidavit, exhibit, information or other document used in the application or the proceedings that is on the file in the court or in the records of the court.(3)A person commits an offence if the person contravenes an order made or direction given under this section.Penalty: Imprisonment for 5 years.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 17 August 2012, the AAT, in its Security Appeals Division, published an open Decision and Reasons for Decision (the open decision) by which it affirmed the adverse security assessment made by the DGS in respect of the applicant. I understand that, on the same day, the AAT published a closed decision dealing with secret classified information (the closed decision). I have not looked at the closed decision. The applicant was dissatisfied with the open decision and, by a proceeding commenced in this Court on 14 September 2012 (No ACD 72 of 2012), appealed to this Court pursuant to s 44 of the AAT Act on five questions of law, from the open decision. In the event that the applicant presses that appeal, it will be heard by a Full Court. The applicant’s s 44 appeal has not yet been fixed for hearing. For the purposes of and in connection with the applicant’s review application in the AAT, two certificates were issued in the name of the Attorney-General. Those certificates were dated 24 January 2012 and 7 March 2012 respectively. Those certificates had the effect of denying access to the applicant and his legal representatives to certain material tendered before the Tribunal during the hearing of his review application. The Attorney-General and the acting Attorney-General relied upon ss 36(1)(a), 39A(8) and 39B(2)(a) of the AAT Act as the statutory foundation for the issue of these two certificates. The hearing of proceeding No ACD 74 of 2012 is fixed to commence today (27 March 2013). I have made a number of orders in the period since the two sets of proceedings were first returned before the Court (ie since 12 October 2012), the effect of which was to prohibit the publication of certain material which was before the AAT for the purposes of the applicant’s review application in the AAT and also to prohibit the publication of other material subsequently created (including parts of the open decision and some evidentiary material filed in this Court). In particular, on 31 October 2012, I made the following orders on an interim basis:·In proceeding No ACD 72 of 2012: THE COURT ORDERS THAT:…2.Until further order, the contents of the Secret Confidential affidavit of David Taylor Irvine sworn on 26 October 2012 not be disclosed to any person and that the said affidavit be stored in a Class B safe. 3.Until further order, the documents comprising the AAT’s open file not be published or disclosed to any person other than the parties to these proceedings, the legal representatives of the parties, the Court and its staff. 4.Until further order, information identifying the foreign country, the foreign intelligence service and the foreign intelligence officers referred to in the AAT’s open file not be published or disclosed to any person other than the parties to these proceedings, the legal representatives of the parties, the Court and its staff. ·In proceeding No ACD 74 of 2012:THE COURT:…2.ORDERS that, until further order, the contents of the Secret Confidential affidavit of David Taylor Irvine sworn on 26 October 2012 not be disclosed to any person and that the said affidavit be stored in a Class B safe. 3.ORDERS that, until further order, the contents of Exhibits 1 and JCMR6 to the affidavit of James Charles McNair Ronald sworn on 26 September 2012 not be published or disclosed to any person other than the parties to these proceedings, the legal representatives of the parties, the Court and its staff.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

At [17]–[19] of his Written Submissions, the applicant submitted that:17. The Court will appreciate that it is inherent in the two proceedings commenced by the Applicant that he contends that there has been an excess of secrecy applied to his case which has resulted in his being unable to defend himself adequately in proceedings which will potentially lead to the destruction of his career, and resulted also in his being still in the dark about precisely what it is he is alleged to have done that amounts to an “act of foreign interference”. There is a serious issue in this application about whether another layer of unnecessary secrecy is to be added to the case. 18. If the motivation for the orders sought by the Respondents is in fact to avoid some kind of political or diplomatic embarrassment, then it is reasonable for the Court to consider carefully why and how the avoidance of such embarrassment is necessary for the “security” of the Commonwealth. A reasonable observer might well take the view that it is a matter of legitimate interest to citizens of Australia to know if agents of friendly nations have engaged in activities inconsistent with diplomatic cover involving an attempt to cultivate a senior public servant in Australia, and it is difficult to see why publication of the information would result in Australia’s “security” being adversely affected.19. Finally, it is relevant for the Court to know that the Applicant does not propose to pursue an application for an order under s.50 seeking that his real name be suppressed. The publication of his real name would, of course, leave very little doubt about which foreign country was involved. CONSIDERATION Section 43AAA of the AAT Act deals with the way in which the findings of the AAT in proceedings in its Security Appeals Division are to be handled. That section provides:43AAA Findings of Tribunal in certain proceedings before Security Appeals DivisionScope(1)This section applies to a review conducted by the Security Appeals Division.Findings(2)Upon the conclusion of a review, the Tribunal must make and record its findings in relation to the security assessment, and those findings may state the opinion of the Tribunal as to the correctness of, or justification for, any opinion, advice or information contained in the assessment.(3)The Tribunal must not make findings in relation to an assessment that would, under section 61 of the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation Act 1979, have the effect of superseding any information that is, under subsection 37(2) of that Act, taken to be part of the assessment unless those findings state that, in the Tribunal’s opinion, the information is incorrect, is incorrectly represented or could not reasonably be relevant to the requirements of security.Copies of findings to be given to parties etc.(4)Subject to subsection (5), the Tribunal must cause copies of its findings to be given to the applicant, the Director General of Security, the Commonwealth agency to which the assessment was given and the Attorney General.(5)The Tribunal may direct that the whole or a particular part of its findings, so far as they relate to a matter that has not already been disclosed to the applicant, is not to be given to the applicant or is not to be given to the Commonwealth agency to which the assessment was given.Applicant may publish findings(6)Subject to any direction by the Tribunal, the applicant is entitled to publish, in any manner that he or she thinks fit, the findings of the Tribunal so far as they have been given to him or her.Tribunal may attach comments to findings(7)The Tribunal may attach to a copy of findings to be given to the Director General under this section, any comments the Tribunal wishes to make on matters relating to procedures or practices of the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation that have come to the Tribunal’s attention as a result of a review.(8)The Tribunal must give the Minister a copy of any comments attached as mentioned in subsection (7).