TCXG and and Minister for Foreign Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

[2013] AATA 284

Division Security Appeals Division

File Number(s)

2012/3549

Re

TCXG

APPLICANT

And

Director General of Security

RESPONDENT

File Number(s)

2012/3550

Re

TCXG

APPLICANT

And

Minister for Foreign Affairs

RESPONDENT

NOTE

This decision has been published in accordance with the Tribunal’s decision in [2013] AATA 377. Pursuant to s 35AA of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, the Tribunal has directed that the publication of the name of the applicant and of the name of the applicant’s legal representative be prohibited. Publication of matter identifying the applicant may be an offence.

Section 63(5) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 provides the following:

Contempt of the Tribunal

A person is guilty of an offence if:

(a)    the person engages in conduct; and

(b)   the person’s conduct would, if the Tribunal were a court of record, constitute a contempt of that court.

Penalty: 30 penalty units or imprisonment for 6 months, or both.

DIRECTION

Pursuant to s 43AA of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, the Tribunal being satisfied that there is an obvious error in the written statement of reasons for the decision of 10 May 2013, directs the Registrar to alter the text by:

a.Deleting the second sentence of paragraph 29:

‘The certificated Statement of Grounds ASIO supplied to the Applicant contains the allegation that TCXG adheres to an extremist interpretation of Islam which condones the use of politically motivated violence (PMV) to defend the Islamic faith.’

and substituting therefor:

‘The un-certificated Statement of Grounds ASIO supplied to the Applicant contains the allegation that TCXG adheres to an extremist interpretation of Islam which condones the use of politically motivated violence (PMV) to defend the Islamic faith.’

b.Deleting the first sentence of paragraph 30:

‘However, the un-certificated version of ASIO’s Statement of Grounds contains additional specific allegations.’

and substituting therefor:

‘However, the certificated version of ASIO’s Statement of Grounds contains additional specific allegations.’

DECISION

Tribunal

Justice D Kerr, President
Mr RP Handley, Deputy President
Ms JF Toohey, Senior Member

Date 10 May 2013
Place Sydney

The Tribunal affirms the decisions under review.

..............[sgd]............................................

Justice D Kerr, President

CATCHWORDS

NATIONAL SECURITY – adverse security assessment – refusal of application for Australian passport – likely to engage in conduct which might prejudice security – correctness, justification for any opinion or information contained in assessment –whether evidence, information, material relied on sufficiently probative to justify assessment – decision affirmed.

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)

Australian Passports Act 2005 (Cth)
Australian Security Intelligence Organisation Act 1979 (Cth)
Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth)

CASES

Re BLBS and Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade (2012) 129 ALD 380

Edwards v The Queen (1993) 178 CLR 193

RJCG v Director-General of Security [2013] FCA 269

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Australian Passport Determination 2005

OPEN REASONS FOR DECISION

Justice D Kerr, President
Mr RP Handley, Deputy President
Ms JF Toohey, Senior Member

  1. TCXG (the Applicant) has applied for the review of two decisions:

    (i)an adverse security assessment made by the Director-General of Security of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read TCXG and and Minister for Foreign Affairs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] AATA 284
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, TCXG, sought a review of two decisions made by the Director-General of the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation (ASIO) and the Minister for Foreign Affairs. The first decision was an adverse security assessment, which concluded that TCXG, if granted an Australian passport, would likely engage in conduct that could prejudice the security of Australia or another foreign country. The second decision was a refusal by the Minister to grant TCXG an Australian passport. TCXG argued against the adverse security assessment and the refusal of the passport application, asserting that they do not hold extremist views and have no intention of engaging in politically or religiously motivated violence.

The legal issues before the court were whether the adverse security assessment was made lawfully and whether the Minister’s decision to refuse the passport application was justified. The court needed to determine if the evidence presented by ASIO sufficiently supported the adverse security assessment and if the Minister’s decision was reasonable, given the assessment. The court also had to consider whether TCXG’s arguments against the assessment and refusal were valid and whether the decisions were made in accordance with the applicable laws and principles of natural justice.

The court found that the adverse security assessment was well-supported by the evidence provided to ASIO, including TCXG’s own admissions and the broader context of their activities and affiliations. The assessment was detailed and based on a comprehensive review of TCXG's conduct and associations. The court further held that the Minister’s decision to refuse the passport application was reasonable, given the adverse security assessment. The court determined that the Minister had appropriately considered the security implications of granting TCXG a passport and had acted in accordance with the applicable statutory provisions. The court concluded that the decisions were lawful and justified, affirming both the adverse security assessment and the refusal of the passport application.

The court's decision was that the adverse security assessment and the Minister's refusal to grant a passport were upheld. The court found no grounds to overturn the decisions, thereby affirming both the Director-General's assessment and the Minister's decision. The court's reasoning was grounded in the evidence provided and the legal framework under which the decisions were made. The open reasons for the decision were published, in line with the Tribunal’s usual practice.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

TCXG (the Applicant) has applied for the review of two decisions: (i)an adverse security assessment made by the Director-General of Security of the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation (ASIO) (the Respondent) who assessed that if TCXG holds an Australian passport, [TCXG] would be likely to engage in conduct that might prejudice the security of Australia or another foreign country; and(ii)a decision made by the Minister for Foreign Affairs (the Minister) to refuse TCXG’s application for an Australian passport.BACKGROUND TCXG, [redacted] is an Australian citizen. [redacted] [redacted]. [redacted]. [redacted]. [redacted]. [redacted]. ASIO invited the applicant to participate in an interview prior to making its security assessment in respect of [TCXG’s] 2011 application for a new passport. ASIO INTERVIEW AND SECURITY ASSESSMENT On 21 December 2011, TCXG, accompanied by [TCXG’s lawyer], [redacted], voluntarily attended an interview with ASIO officers. The interviewers explained that they were providing TCXG with an opportunity to state [TCXG’s] views about politically motivated violence (PMV) and explain [TCXG’s] conduct in that regard. The interviewers asked TCXG to identify all of [TCXG’s] important relationships. TCXG was advised that the interview would not be recorded but that a detailed note of what [TCXG] was asked and [TCXG’s] answers would be taken. Notes of the interview prepared by ASIO were included in the documents provided to the Tribunal. [TCXG’s lawyer] told the Tribunal that his client did not dispute their content and accuracy. [redacted]. [redacted]. [redacted]. [redacted]. [redacted]. [redacted]. [redacted]. [redacted]. [redacted]. On 21 June 2012, the Director-General made a new adverse security assessment in respect of TCXG. On 12 July 2012, the Australian Passport Office contacted TCXG to inform [TCXG] that the Minister had decided to refuse [TCXG’s] application for an Australian passport. On 15 August 2012, TCXG applied to the Tribunal for a review of the Director-General’s and the Minister’s decisions.RELEVANT LAW AND ISSUES Pursuant to s 17(1) of the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation Act 1979 (the ASIO Act), the functions of ASIO include:(c)to advise Ministers and authorities of the Commonwealth in respect of matters relating to security, in so far as those matters are relevant to their functions and responsibilities. Section 37(1) states:The functions of the Organisation referred to in paragraph 17(1)(c) include the furnishing to Commonwealth agencies of security assessments relevant to their functions and responsibilities. Section 37(2) requires that an adverse or qualified security assessment be accompanied by a statement of grounds for the assessment. Section 4 defines ‘security’ as meaning:(a) the protection of, and of the people of, the Commonwealth and the several States and Territories from: (i) espionage; (ii) sabotage; (iii) politically motivated violence; (iv) promotion of communal violence; (v) attacks on Australia's defence system; or (vi) acts of foreign interference; whether directed from, or committed within, Australia or not; and (aa) the protection of Australia's territorial and border integrity from serious threats; and (b) the carrying out of Australia's responsibilities to any foreign country in relation to a matter mentioned in any of the subparagraphs of paragraph (a) or the matter mentioned in paragraph (aa).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

[redacted]. TCXG’S EVIDENCE TCXG provided an affidavit dated 31 January 2013 and gave oral evidence at the hearing, which, in accordance with s 39A(5) of the AAT Act, was held in private. In [TCXG’s] affidavit, [TCXG] said [TCXG] does not agree with ASIO’s assessment that [TCXG] holds extremist views. [TCXG] is simply a devout Muslim:5. I do not agree with engaging in violence such as suicide bombing, terrorist acts and thinks [sic] of that nature involving innocent people. That includes providing material support to those who may engage in such acts. 6. If my passport were reinstated I wish to travel overseas and possibly live overseas. I prefer to live in a country with an Islamic majority as then I blend in rather than stand out as I do in Australia. By standing out in Australia I am often the victim of unsolicited discriminatory comments which are at the least a nuisance.7. I have no intention of engaging in acts of politically and/or religiously motivated violence or supporting those who do. At the hearing, TCXG was asked about the security assessment interview with ASIO on 21 December 2011. [TCXG] said [TCXG] answered ASIO’s questions to the best of [TCXG’s] ability and does not think [TCXG] lied or twisted the truth. [TCXG] did avoid mentioning the names of friends because they might also be thought to be of bad character by association with [TCXG]. During the security assessment interview, [TCXG] acknowledged that [TCXG] practices a strict form of Islam. However, [TCXG] said that [TCXG] does not support war or wish harm on anyone whether Muslim or not. [TCXG] also does not believe in killing innocent people. [redacted]. [redacted]. [redacted].TCXG said [TCXG] has not engaged in any acts that would condone politically or religiously motivated violence and does not condone the killing of anybody. TCXG said (transcript 20 March 2013, p 14):I think that acts like terrorist acts and suicide bombing are not okay, but I think people’s rights to defend their homes and their wives and children is okay. I also think that if people could help people not to be oppressed by such governments like Syria, that it’s okay for them to help them, as long as they’re not crossing any moral grounds of killing and hurting innocent people. [redacted]. [redacted]. [redacted]. [redacted]. [redacted]. [redacted]. [redacted]. [redacted]. [redacted]. [redacted]. [redacted]. [redacted]. [redacted]. [redacted]. [redacted]. [redacted]. [redacted]. DISCUSSION As noted above, the Tribunal has been provided with both ‘open’ evidence and submissions and also with ‘closed’ evidence and submissions, the latter being the subject of a Ministerial certificate issued pursuant to s 39A(8) of the AAT Act and which may not, therefore, be disclosed in this Statement of Reasons. This makes the Tribunal’s task of explaining its decision to the Applicant a difficult one. The Tribunal will address the full Statement of Grounds and the certificated material in an additional closed Statement of Reasons provided to the Respondent.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal notes Justice Foster’s comment in RJCG v Director-General of Security [2013] FCA 269, at [58], that there is no foundation in the AAT Act for not publishing its Open Statement of Reasons. We have considered s 81(1) of the ASIO Act, to which Justice Foster referred at [59], and, in our view, this does not preclude us from publishing this Open Statement of Reasons. This Open Statement of Reasons will therefore be published as is the practice with other decisions of the Tribunal.DECISION The Tribunal affirms the decisions under review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.