FLSZ and Director-General of Security

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read

FLSZ and Director-General of Security [2018] AATA 5900 (4 May 2018)

Division:Security Division

File Number:           2017/1386

Re:FLSZ

APPLICANT

AndDirector-General of Security

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President S A Forgie
Senior Member Egon Fice
Senior Member A Nikolic AM CSC

Date:4 May 2018

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal affirms the decision of the Director-General of Security dated 9 February 2017 to issue an adverse assessment against the applicant under s 37 of the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation Act 1979.

...........[sgd]............................................................

Deputy President S A Forgie

Catchwords

NATIONAL SECURITY – adverse security assessment – cancellation of visa – relevance of particular prescribed administrative action - decision affirmed.

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 ss 25(1)(a), 33(1)(a), 33(1)(c), 35, 35(1AA), 35AA, 37, 37(2), 39A, 39A(2), 39A(3), 39A(5), 39A(6), 39A(7), 39A(8), 39A(12) to 39A(17), 39B, 39B(2), 39A, 43, 43(1), 43(1A), 43AAA, 43AAA(2), 43AAA(3), 43AAA(4), 43AAA(5) and 43AAA(6)

Australian Passports Act 2005 ss 14(1) and 22(2)(d)

Australian Security Intelligence Organisation Act 1979 ss 4, 17(1)(c), 35, 35(1), 35(1)(b), 37, 37(1), 37(2), 37(2)(a), 37(2)(b), 37(3), 37(4), 38(1), 38(1A), 38(2), 38A, 39A(11), 39B(11), 54, 54(1), 61, 64 and 65(3)

Crimes Act 1914 Part 1AC

Criminal Code Act 1995 ss 3, 4, 15.4, 100.1, 100.1(1), 100.1(2), 100.1(3), 102.1, 102.1(2), 102.1(3), 102.1(4), 102.3, 102.4, 102.5, 102.6, 102.7, 102.8, 102.9, 103.1 and 103.2

Foreign Passports (Law Enforcement and Security) Act 2005

Immigration Act R.S.C. 1985 s 53(1)(b)

Migration Act 1958 ss 36(2)(aa), 36(2C), 36(2C)(a), 36(2C)(b), 36(2C)(b)(i), 116, 116(g), 116(1), 116(1)(g), 116(2) and 116(3)

Telecommunications Act 1997

United Nations Act 1945 s 5

Criminal Code (Terrorist Organisation—Islamic State) Regulation 2017 regs 5(1) and 5(1)(x)

Migration Regulations 1994 regs 2.43(1)(b), 2.43(2), 2.43(2)(a), 2.43(2)(a)(iii) and 2.43(3); Schedule 2 cl 866.225(a)

Security Assessment Determination No. 2 cl 6.2.1, 6.2.2, 6.3, 7, 7.1, and 7.2

Cases

George v Rockett [1990] HCA 26, (1990) 170 CLR 104; 93 ALR 483

Haritos v Commissioner of Taxation [2015] FCAFC 92; (2015) 233 FCR 315; 322 ALR 254; 66 AAR 403; 147 ALD 265; 99 ATR 588 at [62(8)]; 342; 275; 432; 286; 617

Hussain and Minister for Foreign Affairs and Anor [2008] FCAFC 128; (2008) 169 FCR 241; 248 ALR 456; 48 AAR 304; 103 ALD 66

Jaffarie v Director-General of Security [2014] FCAFC 102; (2014) 226 FCR 505; 313 ALR 593; 143 ALD 596;

MYVC v Director-General of Security [2014] FCA 1447; (2014) 234 FCR 134; 323 ALR 400; 65 AAR 369; 148 ALD 489

Plaintiff M47/2012 v Director-General of Security [2012] HCA 46; (2012) 251 CLR 1; 292 ALR 245;

Queensland Bacon Pty Ltd v Rees (1966) 115 CLR 266

Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634

Re CMHV and Director-General of Security and Minister for Foreign Affairs [2017] AATA 1547

RJCG v Director-General of Security [2013] FCA 269

Suresh v Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration) [2002] 1 SCR 3

Secondary Materials

1951 Convention Relating to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read FLSZ and Director-General of Security and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 5900
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by FLSZ against a decision by the Director-General of Security to affirm an adverse security assessment. The dispute arose from the Director-General's assessment that FLSZ posed a risk to security, which had consequences for FLSZ's visa status. The appeal was heard by Deputy S A Forgie P.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether FLSZ posed a risk to security within the meaning of section 4 of the ASIO Act. This involved determining the significance of certain Facebook posts made by FLSZ and assessing whether FLSZ's explanations for these posts were credible, particularly in light of expert evidence regarding extremist groups and foreign fighter travel. The court also considered the application of relevant regulations concerning visa cancellations based on security assessments.

The court reasoned that FLSZ's Facebook posts, particularly one dated 13 December 2016, conveyed a clear and extreme message advocating for the unification of Muslims and victory in various regions. Despite FLSZ's acknowledgment that the post was a mistake and appeared extreme, the court found that FLSZ's explanations did not adequately account for the content of the posts. The court concluded that the views expressed in the posts were consistent with FLSZ's actual views, leading to the finding that FLSZ was, directly or indirectly, a risk to security. This conclusion was informed by evidence detailing the activities of groups like ISIL and the calls for attacks against Western countries.

The court affirmed the Director-General's decision, finding that FLSZ posed a risk to security within the meaning of section 4 of the ASIO Act, specifically in relation to the likelihood of engaging in politically motivated violence, including acts that constitute terrorism offences.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The term “relevant visa” is defined in r 2.43(3) to mean a visa of any of the subclasses it lists. A visa of the sort held by FLSZ is not among them. Therefore, only r 2.43(2)(a) applied and, of the three scenarios, only that in r 2.43(2)(a)(iii) applied once ASIO had made an ASA that assessed FLSZ to be directly or indirectly a risk to security within the meaning of s 4 of the ASIO Act. BACKGROUND FLSZ gave both written and oral evidence. The findings we have made in this section of our reasons are based on that evidence. FLSZ was born overseas and was a child in 2002. That was the year in which FLSZ’s mother, FLSZ and FLSZ’s sibling moved to a second country where they were permitted to live as a family. In the early days after their arrival, the family rented a bedroom from another family and later moved with that family to another house where they rented a bedroom as before. That arrangement continued for a year or so before the family rented a house of their own. The children attended school in the second country - first one and then another – as well as attending the mosque each day to memorise the Quran and to develop their knowledge of the Arabic language. FLSZ’s mother met an Egyptian woman who became very close to her and a great supporter of the family. She was a Quran Teacher at a local mosque and enrolled the children at that mosque in order to develop their knowledge of the Arabic language and to memorise the Koran. FLSZ’s grandmother was granted a visa so that she could join the family. FLSZ’s mother was particularly pleased to see her mother as she had felt lonely and very much in need of her mother to assist her in caring for the children. By this time, the family had moved to an area where a greater number of Muslim families lived. FLSZ’s mother then began to meet other Muslim women, who helped her and her family and, as a consequence, she began to feel happier and less isolated in the community. She regarded education as paramount for her children and she ensured that they attended school as well as, until they were in the later years of their secondary education, remaining connected with their Arabic heritage through language and religious education. She arranged for them to have additional tutorials to assist them with their schoolwork. At the same time, the female members of the family attended Islamic Studies classes each Saturday evening. In November 2006, the family visited FLSZ’s uncle and cousins in Melbourne for the first time. In the following year, FLSZ’s aunt and her three children travelled from overseas to visit the family for a month and then returned home. Despite their contact with family, FLSZ’s mother and grandmother were again feeling increasingly isolated as the family had, by this time, moved to an area where fewer Muslim families lived. They missed their family overseas. In June 2009, the family travelled overseas for a holiday and remained there for six weeks. On their return, the family again travelled to Melbourne to visit family and FLSZ’s mother and grandmother found comfort in reuniting with their family. The decision was made to move the family to Melbourne but the family faced difficulties. Outside the family, they had no connections with Muslim communities in Melbourne and no entitlement to social security benefits at the time. The educational system was different and the children had to repeat a year of their schooling. FLSZ worked part time after school in order to bolster the family’s income. This meant that, initially at least, FLSZ did not achieve the same level of academic excellence as had been the case before the family’s move to Melbourne. A change in schools and assistance given to the family by a woman the family met greatly improved the family’s circumstances. That woman had first approached FLSZ’s mother and grandmother at the mosque when she had seen them crying.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

There is always someone who needs help, FLSZ said, and this work was undertaken on a voluntary basis from the heart. Even though not a member of NZF and just a volunteer, a message would be passed on to FLSZ if anyone needed help. FLSZ would provide assistance with paper work and in providing emotional support.Open evidence on behalf of ASIO Mr John Ward[85] gave evidence regarding the risks posed by those who are based in Australia and who travel to Syria and Iraq and the region. Until the end of 2012, many foreigners travelled to Syria to fight with one of the many Syrian opposition groups. Small numbers of Australians have been doing so since the late 1990s. Since 2013, the majority have travelled to Syria as well as to Iraq and the region more broadly in order to support extremist causes and extremist groups. [85] The name of “John Ward” is an assumed identity given by the Director-General under Part 1AC of the Crimes Act 1914 to a person who was employed by ASIO since the late 1970s. He held senior positions across ASIO’s counter-terrorism functions and was a member of its Senior Executive Service for the last 17 years of his service. He rose to become a First Assistant Secretary of the Division in ASIO responsible for counter-terrorism investigations, analysis, priority setting and intelligence requirements. He is now engaged as an employee performing a number of functions including appearing as a witness. A. Islamic State of Iraq and Levant Mr Ward said that, predominant among these groups is ISIL. It has attracted the majority of Australians. It is a group founded by Abu Bakar al-Baghdadi in 2013 and has become one of the most active of the terrorist organisations. It conducts daily attacks on security forces and civilians across Iraq and Syria. It does so in various ways including bombing public gatherings during holidays and religious festivals, conducting public executions and violent punishments in areas in which it operates, compelling people to live according to its interpretation of Sunni Islam and Sharia, or Islamic law and ethnically cleansing minority groups in Syria. In September 2014, ISIL called for attacks against a wide range of countries but focused particularly on those countries, including Australia, which had been involved against it in military action. It also called on action to be taken against disbelievers whether they be civilians or military personnel. A year later, the leader of Al-Qa’ida, Aymanai-Zawahiri, called on his supporters to work with ISIL. The two groups had previously had fundamental differences but they united to confront their common enemies and to carry out martyrdom operations in the West. Aymanai-Zawahiri also called on Muslims living in the West to carry out attacks in their own countries. In his oral evidence, Mr Ward refuted a suggestion that ISIL’s loss of ground in recent times in Iraq meant that it was of less significance than in the past. ISIL has become much more than a military force in countries such as Iraq and Syria. It has extended its reach beyond those lands by means of attacks, successful and otherwise, in Australia and elsewhere and by remaining a source of inspiration for those who would carry out those attacks in its name.B.Australians’ involvement with ISIL and similar organisations

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Acting under Chapter VII of the Charter of the United Nations, the Security Council went on to urge Member States to take various action. For example, it:“8. Calls upon all Member States to take national measures to suppress the flow of foreign terrorist fighters to, and bring to justice, in accordance with applicable international law, foreign terrorist fighters of, ISIL, ANF and all other individuals, groups, in accordance with applicable international law, by, inter alia, effective border controls, and, in this context, to exchange information expeditiously, improve cooperation among competent authorities to prevent the movement of terrorists and terrorist groups to and from their territories, the supply of weapons for terrorists and financing that would support terrorists;9.Encourages all Member States to engage with those within their territories at risk of recruitment and violent radicalisation to discourage travel to Syria and Iraq for the purposes of supporting or fighting for ISIL, ANF and all other individuals, groups, undertakings and entities associated with Al-Qaida.”[89] [89] Australia is a Member State as one of original Members of the states having participated in the United Nations Conference on International Organization at San Francisco, signed the Charter and ratified it: Charter of the United Nations; Chapter II, Article 3. Australia ratified the Charter in the Charter of the United Nations Act 1945; s 5.CONSIDERATION Having regard to the evidentiary material in this matter, we are of the opinion that FLSZ is, directly or indirectly, a risk to security within the meaning of s 4 of the ASIO Act in so far as the likelihood of engaging politically motivated violence is concerned. That expression draws in a wide range of behaviour but we have in mind that behaviour that is described as “acts that are terrorism offences”. What amount to “terrorism offences” is an expression whose net is also cast very widely. At [27] above, we have set out the offences which fall within Subdivision A of Division 72 of the Criminal Code and those which fall under Part 5.3 of that Code. FLSZ has given explanations for the Facebook posts but, having regard to the evidence of Mr Ward and to the text of the posts, we are of the opinion that FLSZ’s explanations do not make sense. In saying that, we have particular regard to the post dated 13 December 2016. It is a post rebuking Muslims who enjoy their lives with the “Mushrikīn” rather than uniting with fellow Muslims claiming to be Muwahhidīn and calling upon Allah to grant the Muwahhidīn victory in Irāq. Shām, Yemen, Khurasān, Shīshān, Masr, Al-Maghrib, al‑Sōmāl, CAR, all of Africa, the Balkans, Philippines, Burmā, return al-Andalus and to return all the lands of Islām back to them. FLSZ acknowledges having read the first paragraph when posting the material even if not acknowledging having read the rest of it carefully. The meaning of that first paragraph is clear and its message is such that it is unlikely that FLSZ would have posted the rest of the material without paying attention to what it said. FLSZ acknowledged at the hearing that the post was a big mistake and came across as very extreme. We agree but we do not agree that the material was posted without thought. For reasons we give in our closed reasons, we are of the opinion that the views that are presented in that post are, we find, consistent with views held by FLSZ.