Kim v Attorney-General of the Commonwealth [2013] FCA 902
Citation:
Kim v Attorney-General of the Commonwealth [2013] FCA 902
Parties:
YEON KIM v ATTORNEY-GENERAL OF THE COMMONWEALTH and ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
File number:
ACD 74 of 2012
Judge:
FOSTER J
Date of judgment:
6 September 2013
Catchwords:
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – whether certificates issued by or on behalf of the Attorney-General for the Commonwealth pursuant to s 39A(8) and s 39B(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) were invalid because the Attorney-General self-evidently failed to take into account a number of matters which the applicant contended were inevitably required to be taken into account when regard is had to the legislative framework of which s 39A and s 39 form part and to the subject matter, scope and purpose of that scheme in the circumstances of the present case
ATTORNEY-GENERAL OF THE COMMONWEALTH First Respondent
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL Second Respondent
JUDGE:
FOSTER J
DATE OF ORDER:
6 SEPTEMBER 2013
WHERE MADE:
CANBERRA
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.The application be dismissed.
2.The applicant pay the first respondent’s costs of and incidental to the application.
Note:Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
ACD 74 of 2012
BETWEEN:
YEON KIM Applicant
AND:
ATTORNEY-GENERAL OF THE COMMONWEALTH First Respondent
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL Second Respondent
JUDGE:
FOSTER J
DATE:
6 SEPTEMBER 2013
PLACE:
CANBERRA
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
The applicant, Dr Kim, is a senior public servant employed by the Australian Bureau of Agricultural Resource Economics and Sciences, a research organisation within the Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry. The first respondent is the Attorney-General of the Commonwealth (the Attorney-General). The second respondent, the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the AAT) filed a submitting appearance.
The…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Kim v Attorney-General of the Commonwealth and more:
The case of Kim v Attorney-General of the Commonwealth involves an applicant, Dr Kim, who sought a review of an adverse security assessment issued by the Director General of Security (DGS) of the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation (ASIO). The applicant's security clearance had been revoked, and he was barred from accessing classified information. Dr Kim applied to the Security Appeals Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) for a review of the adverse security assessment. During the AAT proceedings, the Director General of Security sought confidentiality orders and certificates to protect sensitive information. The applicant was represented by Mr Ronald, a solicitor from Colquhoun Murphy.
The primary legal issues in this case revolved around the application and interpretation of sections 39A and 39B of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (AAT Act), as well as the validity of the certificates issued by the Attorney-General. The applicant argued that the certificates issued by the Attorney-General were invalid because they were not supported by the necessary statutory basis. He also contended that the proceedings in the Security Appeals Division should not be entirely private, and that he should have been given access to the evidence and submissions made by the Director General of Security.
The Court considered the statutory provisions governing the proceedings in the Security Appeals Division and the issuance of certificates by the Attorney-General. The Court found that the certificates issued by the Attorney-General were indeed valid and properly issued under sections 36(1)(a), 39A(8), and 39B(2)(a) of the AAT Act. The Court held that the proceedings in the Security Appeals Division could be conducted in private as per section 39A(5) of the AAT Act, and that the applicant was not entitled to be present when the Director General of Security adduced evidence or made submissions that were subject to a certificate under section 39A(8). The Court further held that the applicant did not have a right to be present when such evidence was adduced or submissions were made, unless the responsible Minister consented.
In conclusion, the Court upheld the validity of the certificates issued by the Attorney-General and found that the proceedings in the Security Appeals Division could be conducted in private. The Court dismissed the applicant's claims and upheld the adverse security assessment issued by the DGS. The applicant's appeal to the Full Court is pending.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
These Reasons for Judgment determine the applicant’s claims for final relief in respect of the certificates. THE RELEVANT FACTS As mentioned at [1] to [4] above, the DGS issued an adverse security assessment of the applicant on 15 September 2011. In that assessment, it was alleged that the applicant had had unreported contact with officers of the NIS which included the provision of information to NIS officers in connection with the FTA. In section 4 of that assessment, which is headed Advice, the DGS said:The prescribed administrative action recommended by ASIO in this case is that [the Australian Government Security Vetting Agency]:•Revoke Dr Kim’s SECRET security clearance; and•Before issuing any further security clearance to Dr Kim, obtain a further security assessment from ASIO.Further, ASIO recommends that [the Department of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries] takes action to prevent Dr Kim from:•Accessing any classified, caveated or government information not available to the general public (whether national security classified or not); and•Accessing any areas within [the Department of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries] to which access is limited on security grounds. The grounds for the adverse security assessment issued in respect of the applicant were attached to the assessment. They were not tendered in evidence before me. I do not know whether they were furnished to the applicant. On 25 October 2011, the applicant applied to the Security Appeals Division of the AAT for merits review of the DGS’s adverse security assessment issued on 15 September 2011. The applicant’s application to the AAT listed Mr Ronald, a solicitor from Colquhoun Murphy, solicitors, as his representative. Mr Ronald acted as the applicant’s representative throughout the AAT proceedings. He continues to act for the applicant. In the interlocutory stages, the DGS made a number of applications to the AAT seeking confidentiality orders in respect of documents and information to be relied upon in due course at the AAT hearing. In particular, on 23 January 2012, the AAT made directions for the filing of evidence, including classified evidence, by the DGS and the applicant. On 24 January 2012, Jason Clare, who was then the Acting Attorney-General, issued a certificate pursuant to ss 36, 39A and 39B of the AAT Act. I set out below the entirety of that certificate. On 13 February 2012, a copy of the 24 January 2012 certificate was provided to Mr Ronald. As a result of orders made by the AAT, specific documents were made the subject of confidentiality orders but were not sought to be protected by any certificate from the Attorney-General. At par 16 of the affidavit of Ms Sekler affirmed on 31 January 2013, Ms Sekler, who is the solicitor employed by Australian Government Solicitor who has the carriage of this and other matters concerning the applicant, said:The unredacted parts of the three tranches of confidential documents referred to in paragraph 15 above were not the subject of requests for or grants of Attorney-General’s certificates. The unredacted parts of those documents contain information that I was instructed by ASIO would be prejudicial to security if it was to enter the public domain at that time but could, if subject to confidentiality orders, be provided to RJCG and his legal advisors without prejudicing security, largely because RJCG was likely to already be aware of such information. This is to be contrasted with the documents that were the subject of a certificate issued by the Attorney-General. I was instructed by ASIO that the information covered by the certificates could not be provided to RJCG or his legal advisors, even subject to confidentiality orders, without prejudicing security.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Section 39 of the AAT Act provides: 39 Opportunity to make submissions concerning evidence(1)Subject to sections 35, 36 and 36B, the Tribunal shall ensure that every party to a proceeding before the Tribunal is given a reasonable opportunity to present his or her case and, in particular, to inspect any documents to which the Tribunal proposes to have regard in reaching a decision in the proceeding and to make submissions in relation to those documents.(2)This section does not apply to a proceeding in the Security Appeals Division to which section 39A applies. Section 39A governs the way in which hearings in the Security Appeals Division are to be conducted. That section is in the following terms:39A Procedure at certain hearings in Security Appeals DivisionReview of security assessment(1)If an application for a review of a security assessment is made to the Tribunal, the Tribunal is to review the assessment in accordance with this section.Parties(2)The parties to the proceeding are the Director General of Security and the applicant, but the Commonwealth agency to which the assessment is given is entitled to adduce evidence and make submissions.Director General of Security must present all relevant information(3)It is the duty of the Director General of Security to present to the Tribunal all relevant information available to the Director General, whether favourable or unfavourable to the applicant.Member may require parties to attend etc.(4)The presidential member who is to preside, or is presiding, at the hearing may, at any time, require either or both of the parties to attend or be represented before the member for the purpose of conferring with the member concerning the conduct of the review with a view to identifying the matters in issue or otherwise facilitating the conduct of the proceedings.Proceedings to be in private(5)The proceedings are to be in private and, subject to this section, the Tribunal is to determine what people may be present at any time.Right of parties etc. to be present(6)Subject to subsection (9), the applicant and a person representing the applicant may be present when the Tribunal is hearing submissions made or evidence adduced by the Director General of Security or the Commonwealth agency to which the assessment was given.(7)The Director General of Security or a person representing the Director General, and a person representing the Commonwealth agency to which the assessment was given, may be present when the Tribunal is hearing submissions made or evidence adduced by the applicant.Security/defence certificate(8)The Minister administering the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation Act 1979 (the responsible Minister) may, by signed writing, certify that evidence proposed to be adduced or submissions proposed to be made by or on behalf of the Director General of Security or the Commonwealth agency to which the assessment was given are of such a nature that the disclosure of the evidence or submissions would be contrary to the public interest because it would prejudice security or the defence of Australia.(9)If such a certificate is given:(a)the applicant must not be present when the evidence is adduced or the submissions are made; and(b)a person representing the applicant must not be present when the evidence is adduced or the submissions are made unless the responsible Minister consents.(10)If a person representing the applicant is present when evidence to which a certificate given under subsection (8) relates is adduced or submissions to which such a certificate relates are made, the representative must not disclose any such evidence or submission to the applicant or to any other person.Penalty:Imprisonment for 2 years.Note:Subsection 4B(2) of the Crimes Act 1914 allows a court to impose an appropriate fine instead of, or in addition to, a term of imprisonment.Protection of identity of person giving evidence(11)If the Director General of Security so requests, the Tribunal must do all things necessary to ensure that the identity of a person giving evidence on behalf of the Director General of Security is not revealed.Evidence and submissions(12)The Tribunal must first hear evidence adduced, and submissions made, by or on behalf of the Director General of Security and any evidence or submissions that the Commonwealth agency to which the assessment was given may wish to adduce or make.(13)The Tribunal must next permit the applicant, if he or she so desires, to adduce evidence before, and make submissions to, the Tribunal.(14)The Tribunal may, on its own initiative and at any stage of the proceedings, invite a person to give evidence, or cause a person to be summoned to give evidence.(15)If a person invited or summoned to give evidence under subsection (14) is an officer or employee of the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation or of the Commonwealth agency to which the assessment was given, subsection (8) applies as if any evidence to be given by the person were evidence proposed to be adduced by or on behalf of the Director General of Security or that agency, as the case may be.(16)If:(a)a party presents his or her case to the Tribunal; and(b)after that case has been presented, the other party adduces evidence; and(c)the Tribunal thinks that, because of evidence adduced by the other party, the first mentioned party should be further heard;the Tribunal must give the first mentioned party an opportunity of adducing further evidence but must not give to the applicant any particulars of any evidence to which a certificate given under subsection (8) relates.(17)A member of the Tribunal may ask questions of a witness before the Tribunal and the presidential member presiding may require a witness to answer any such question.Dismissal of application(18)If the applicant fails within a reasonable time:(a)to proceed with the application; or(b)to comply with a direction by the Tribunal in relation to the application;a presidential member or senior member, on behalf of the Tribunal, may dismiss the application without proceeding to review the security assessment.
Decision
Reasons for decision
In a judgment originally delivered on 27 March 2013 which was subsequently redacted to some extent in order to prohibit the disclosure of certain matters (RJCG v Director-General of Security; RJCG v Attorney-General of the Commonwealth and Anor [2013] FCA 269 (the first judgment), I summarised the relevant background facts in this matter in the following way:1The applicant is a Commonwealth public servant employed in a senior capacity by a research organisation within a Commonwealth Department of State.2Between 2001 and 2011, the applicant held a security clearance for access to classified information up to and including “SECRET”. Without such a security clearance, the applicant’s career as a senior public servant in his specialist field will end.3On 15 September 2011, an adverse security assessment of the applicant was made by the Director-General of Security (DGS) of the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation (ASIO). The DGS has control of ASIO under the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation Act 1979 (Cth) (ASIO Act) (see s 7 and s 8 of the ASIO Act). 4The adverse security assessment of the applicant was based upon allegations that the applicant had unreported contact with officers of the intelligence service of a country which is generally friendly to Australia, which I shall, for the time being, call “country X”. It was alleged that the applicant had provided information to an intelligence officer working for the intelligence service of country X in connection with government to government negotiations between Australia and country X concerning an important bilateral trade agreement. It was said that this conduct on the part of the applicant constituted “… acts of foreign interference …” within the meaning of that expression as defined in s 4 of the ASIO Act. 5The applicant sought a review of the adverse security assessment in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) pursuant to s 54 of the ASIO Act. That review must be conducted in accordance with s 39A and s 39B of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (AAT Act). 6Section 39A(5) provides that the review proceedings are to be held in private in the Security Appeals Division of the AAT and, subject to s 39A, the AAT is to determine who may be present at the hearing at any time.7Subsections (6)–(11) of s 39A are in the following terms:Right of parties etc. to be present(6)Subject to subsection (9), the applicant and a person representing the applicant may be present when the Tribunal is hearing submissions made or evidence adduced by the Director General of Security or the Commonwealth agency to which the assessment was given.(7)The Director General of Security or a person representing the Director General, and a person representing the Commonwealth agency to which the assessment was given, may be present when the Tribunal is hearing submissions made or evidence adduced by the applicant.Security/defence certificate(8)The Minister administering the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation Act 1979 (the responsible Minister) may, by signed writing, certify that evidence proposed to be adduced or submissions proposed to be made by or on behalf of the Director General of Security or the Commonwealth agency to which the assessment was given are of such a nature that the disclosure of the evidence or submissions would be contrary to the public interest because it would prejudice security or the defence of Australia.(9)If such a certificate is given:(a)the applicant must not be present when the evidence is adduced or the submissions are made; and(b)a person representing the applicant must not be present when the evidence is adduced or the submissions are made unless the responsible Minister consents.(10)If a person representing the applicant is present when evidence to which a certificate given under subsection (8) relates is adduced or submissions to which such a certificate relates are made, the representative must not disclose any such evidence or submission to the applicant or to any other person.Penalty:Imprisonment for 2 years.Note:Subsection 4B(2) of the Crimes Act 1914 allows a court to impose an appropriate fine instead of, or in addition to, a term of imprisonment.Protection of identity of person giving evidence(11)If the Director General of Security so requests, the Tribunal must do all things necessary to ensure that the identity of a person giving evidence on behalf of the Director General of Security is not revealed.8Section 39B provides that the Attorney-General of the Commonwealth may issue a public interest certificate the effect of which is to deny access to information or material specified in the certificate which is adduced in proceedings to which s 39A applies. Such a denial of access would extend to the review applicant and to his or her legal representatives.9On 17 August 2012, the AAT, in its Security Appeals Division, published an open Decision and Reasons for Decision (the open decision) by which it affirmed the adverse security assessment made by the DGS in respect of the applicant. I understand that, on the same day, the AAT published a closed decision dealing with secret classified information (the closed decision). I have not looked at the closed decision. 10The applicant was dissatisfied with the open decision and, by a proceeding commenced in this Court on 14 September 2012 (No ACD 72 of 2012), appealed to this Court pursuant to s 44 of the AAT Act on five questions of law, from the open decision. In the event that the applicant presses that appeal, it will be heard by a Full Court. The applicant’s s 44 appeal has not yet been fixed for hearing. 11For the purposes of and in connection with the applicant’s review application in the AAT, two certificates were issued in the name of the Attorney-General. Those certificates were dated 24 January 2012 and 7 March 2012 respectively. Those certificates had the effect of denying access to the applicant and his legal representatives to certain material tendered before the Tribunal during the hearing of his review application. The Attorney-General and the acting Attorney-General relied upon ss 36(1)(a), 39A(8) and 39B(2)(a) of the AAT Act as the statutory foundation for the issue of these two certificates.