TSJY and Director-General of Security

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

[2015] AATA 243  

Division Security Appeals Division

File Number(s)

2013/3022

Re

TSJY

APPLICANT

And

Director-General of Security

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President J W Constance
Deputy President S E Frost
Senior Member N Isenberg

Date 23 April 2015  
Place Sydney

The adverse security assessment in respect of the Applicant, issued by the Director-General of Security on 22 May 2013, is affirmed.

....................[sgd]....................................................

Deputy President J W Constance

Catchwords

NATIONAL SECURITY – adverse security assessment – whether assessment should be affirmed as correct – assessed as involved in people smuggling – serious threat to territorial and border integrity – assessment affirmed

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) s 43AAA(3)

Australian Security Intelligence Organisation Act 1979 (Cth) ss 4, 17(1), 35(1), 37(2), 37(4), 54, 61

Cases

BLBS and Director-General of Security [2013] AATA 820
Sayed Akbar Jaffarie v Director-General of Security and Migration Review Tribunal [2014] FCAFC 102

Secondary Materials

Security Assessment Determination No.2, issued 28 July 2010.

UNCLASSIFIED REASONS FOR DECISION

INTRODUCTION

  1. The Applicant arrived in Australia by boat and without the necessary travel documents in 1999.  He was granted a visa shortly after his arrival. This visa entitled him to reside in Australia, but did not permit him to leave the country.

  2. In June 2007, the Applicant was granted a permanent visa. He travelled overseas on a number of occasions between 2007 and 2012. In early 2013 the Applicant was granted a Return (resident) visa. A short time later he left Australia.

  3. On 22 May 2013, whilst the Applicant was still overseas, the Director-General of Security issued an adverse security assessment in relation to the Applicant under the provisions of the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation Act 1979 (Cth). The relevant part of the assessment read:

    … it would not be consistent with the requirements of security (within the meaning of section 4 of the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation Act 1979) for [the Applicant] to continue to hold a permanent visa to reside in Australia and that he is directly or indirectly a risk to security, and recommend that his permanent visa be cancelled.

  4. On 24 May 2013, the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship cancelled the Applicant's Return (Residence) visa.  As a result of the cancellation, the Applicant was no longer entitled to travel to Australia.  He was advised that if he did so, he would be refused immigration clearance and removed from the country. The Applicant has not returned to Australia since.

  5. The Applicant has applied to the Tribunal to review the adverse security assessment issued on 22 May 2013.

  6. For the reasons which follow, and for those set out in the Classified Reasons for Decision, the adverse security assessment will be affirmed.

    THE ISSUE

  7. The issue for the Tribunal is whether to affirm as correct, to vary, or to set aside, the Respondent’s assessment that it is not consistent with the requirements of security for the Applicant to hold a Return (resident) visa to reside in Australia.

  8. The subsequent decision of the Minister to cancel the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read TSJY and Director-General of Security and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] AATA 243
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of TSJY and the Director-General of Security, the Applicant, a citizen of Afghanistan, faced a legal challenge regarding an adverse security assessment conducted by the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation (ASIO). The assessment was predicated on the belief that the Applicant was involved in people smuggling into Australia, which posed a serious threat to Australia’s territorial and border integrity. This assessment led to the cancellation of the Applicant's return visa and the refusal of his citizenship application. The primary legal issue before the court was whether the adverse security assessment issued by the Director-General of Security should be affirmed as correct.

The court had to determine if the assessment was justified based on the evidence presented, particularly considering the statutory definition of "security" under the Australian Security Intelligence Act 1979, which includes the protection of Australia’s territorial and border integrity from serious threats. The court considered the extensive evidence, including classified information, which was not disclosed in open court due to its confidential nature. The Applicant consistently denied any involvement in people smuggling during his interview with ASIO and his subsequent testimony. However, the court found the Applicant was not a truthful witness based on the classified evidence, concluding that he was involved in people smuggling and that his activities represented a serious threat to Australia’s border integrity. The court ultimately affirmed the adverse security assessment, upholding the Director-General’s recommendation to cancel the Applicant's visa and refuse his citizenship application.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The subsequent decision of the Minister to cancel the Applicant's visa is not the subject of this review. BACKGROUND The Applicant is 42 years old. He was born in Afghanistan and is a citizen of that country. In 1999, the Applicant arrived in Australia on a “Suspected Irregular Entry Vessel”. Early the following year, he was granted a 785 temporary protection visa by the Department of Immigration and Citizenship. The Applicant applied for a permanent protection visa in 2007. Upon receipt of the application, the Department requested the Australian Intelligence Security Organisation undertake a security assessment of the Applicant. ASIO issued a non-prejudicial security advice in relation to the Applicant and in June 2007 the Department issued the Applicant with a permanent protection visa. It should be noted that the definition of “security’ in the ASIO Act was amended in 2010 to include the provision relating to the protection of Australia’s territorial and border integrity. In June 2012, the Applicant applied for Australian citizenship. Again the Department requested a security assessment. As part of this assessment ASIO officers interviewed the Applicant in October 2012. He was advised at the interview that ASIO would rely on what he said to provide advice to the Department as to whether he posed a risk to national security. The Applicant was also warned that an adverse assessment may affect his residency entitlement and/or his citizenship application. The Department granted the Applicant a Return (resident) visa in February 2013 which enabled him to travel overseas. He departed Australia shortly after the visa was granted. The Director-General of ASIO issued an adverse security assessment in May 2013 and recommended to the Minister that the Applicant's citizenship application be refused and that his return visa be cancelled. In broad terms, the adverse assessment was based on the assessment that the Applicant was involved in smuggling people into Australia. The Minister implemented both recommendations in May 2013.THE LAW TO BE APPLIEDThe functions of ASIO The functions of the Organisation are set out in subsection 17(1) of the Australian Security Intelligence Act 1979 (Cth) and include the following:(a) to obtain, correlate and evaluate intelligence relevant to security;…(c) to advise Ministers and authorities of the Commonwealth in respect of matters relating to security, in so far as those matters are relevant to their functions and responsibilities.The meaning of “security” In section 4 of the Australian Security Intelligence Act 1979, “security” is defined to include:(aa) the protection of Australia’s territorial and border integrity from serious threats … In Sayed Akbar Jaffarie v Director-General of Security and Migration Review Tribunal[1] the Full Court of the Federal Court rejected an argument that the definition should be interpreted in a confined manner based on the breadth of the heads of power contained in the Australian Constitution. The Court said:The term ‘security’ and the phrase ‘the protection of Australia’s territorial and border integrity’ are thus not to be read in the confined manner advanced on behalf of Mr Jaffarie. Nothing in paragraph (aa) suggests that the phrase should be given anything other than the natural and ordinary meaning of the words employed. Indeed, if anything, the statutory context in which the phrase is employed strongly suggests that no pedantic or unnecessary construction should be placed upon the phrase.[2][1] [2014] FCAFC 102.[2] [2014] FCAFC 102,.at para 64.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The unclassified Statement of Grounds[9] states, in part:People smuggling poses a serious threat to Australia’s territorial and border integrity by providing an avenue for a large number of undocumented individuals to gain entry to Australia, potentially including individuals of security concern.……ASIO assesses [the Applicant ] is a prominent member of the Sayed Abbas maritime people smuggling syndicate in Australia […..] co-ordinating [....] involved in people smuggling. Specifically, ASIO assesses [the Applicant] has assisted in organising people smuggling ventures to Australia, sourced PIIs through the Afghan Azara community in Sydney [....] facilitating irregular maritime ventures targeting Australia.[…..] given his established people smuggling contacts, […..] provider of people smuggling services in the Sydney Afghan Azara community, and the profitable nature of people smuggling, ASIO assesses [the Applicant] will continue to engage in people smuggling activities targeting Australia and, as an Australia-based organiser for the Sayed Abbas network, represents a serious threat to Australia’s border integrity.EVIDENCE [9] Exhibit R2.The evidence of Mr Masling Mr Masling is a Senior Advisor to the Director-General of Security. Prior to his appointment to that position in December 2013, he was an officer of ASIO for approximately 27 years and gained significant experience in the analytical and operational areas of the Organisation. Mr Masling provided an affidavit sworn 3 October 2014 and gave evidence in both the open and closed hearings. Mr Masling acknowledged that not every activity involved with people smuggling constitutes a serious threat to Australia’s territorial and border integrity. He stated further:……ASIO is primarily concerned with investigating people smuggling facilitators and organisers. Such persons are of security interest as they have the capacity to illegally bring dozens or even hundreds of people to Australia, circumventing normal border controls. Additionally, there is a risk one or more of those people will prove to be of security concern themselves.[10][10] Exhibit R1, para.22. The adverse security assessment was made on the basis of confidential information which could not be disclosed at the open hearing as it is protected by public interest certificates. The Applicant was informed of the existence of this information at the interview conducted by ASIO officers on 11 October 2012. At this interview the Applicant denied any involvement in people smuggling. ASIO assesses that a Mr Sayed Abbas is a prominent Indonesia-based Afghan people smuggler who has organised irregular maritime ventures targeting Australia. Mr Abbas was arrested and detained in Indonesia in 2011 for alleged immigration offences. He remains in custody in Indonesia and may face extradition to Australia. It is the assessment of ASIO that a Mr Akbar Jaffarie is “a key Australia-based member of the Sayed Abbas maritime people smuggling syndicate which operates from Pakistan and Indonesia. He associates with individuals, including the applicant, involved in people smuggling ventures targeting Australia.”[11][11] Exhibit R1, para.35.

Decision

Reasons for decision

We have not made any findings that have the effect of superseding any information that is taken to be part of the assessment. The provisions of subsection 43AAA(3) are not enlivened.CONCLUSION The adverse security assessment in respect of the Applicant, issued by the Director-General of Security on 22 May 2013, will be affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The son strongly believed that rumours against the Applicant were circulated by his enemies within the Afghan community. When pressed for names, he said that he had suspicions but could not name any individual.CONSIDERATION Counsel for the Director-General conceded that, based on the unclassified material alone, the assessment should not be upheld. We agree. The Applicant has consistently denied any participation in the smuggling of people into Australia. He did so in the interview conducted on 11 October 2012 and in his evidence before this Tribunal. The interview conducted by two ASIO officers was extensive. It involved 1020 questions and was conducted over a period of more than two hours. The interviewing officers directly questioned the Applicant as to his involvement in people smuggling and his association with Mr Abbas. He denied any involvement in people smuggling and denied any knowledge of the involvement of any family member, friend or associate. He denied knowing or dealing with Mr Abbas. In the open hearing, Counsel advised that part of the assessment was based on the Applicant's relationship with Mr Jaffarie. The unclassified evidence in this regard does not justify a finding adverse to the Applicant. In both the open and the closed sessions, Mr Masling gave his evidence clearly and concisely, referring us to the various documents which supported the assessment. We are satisfied that he was an honest witness who gave his evidence carefully. He was fair to the Applicant and referred us to those aspects of the evidence which may be favourable to the Applicant. Although all of the details of the allegations against him could not be put to the Applicant, the thrust of the allegations were put directly to him in the interview and in cross-examination. Despite the alleged lack of understanding of the questions at the interview, by the time of the hearing before the Tribunal, there was no risk of misunderstanding by the Applicant as to the nature of the matters which gave rise to the assessment, notwithstanding that the sources of information were not disclosed. At all times the Applicant categorically denied any association with people smuggling and any association with Mr Abbas. Based on the classified evidence before us, we are satisfied that the Applicant was not a truthful witness. We are satisfied that he was involved in people smuggling while in Australia and that if he returned to Australia it is likely that he would continue to be involved in that activity. We are satisfied also that the Applicant knows Mr Abbas and has been associated with him in regard to people smuggling. Whilst we accept that not all activity involved in people smuggling necessarily involves a serious threat to Australia’s territorial and border integrity, we are satisfied that the Applicant was involved in activities which could have brought a significant number of people to Australia by circumventing normal border controls, as described by Mr Masling. We are satisfied that the conduct of the Applicant, if resumed, would likely be inconsistent with security in that it would likely be a serious threat to Australia’s territorial and border integrity.