Re BLBS and Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read


CATCHWORDS – SUMMONS –adverse security assessment and decision to refuse to issue or cancel a travel document - whether to agree to request to issue summonses - relevant principles in deciding to issue or refuse to issue a summons – regard had to issues to be considered and decided in reviewing decisions – outline of issues -  summonses issued.

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – SUMMONS -  whether inspection order required when documents voluntarily provided – documents provided under summons are provided under compulsion – inspection order required – acknowledges and emphasises that subject to implied undertaking limiting use of documents.

Acts Interpretation Act 1901 s 15AB(1)(b)
Administrative Appeals Tribunal 1975 ss 3(1), 21(2), 25, 28, 29, 29A, 33, 35, 35AA, 36, 36B, 38A, 39A(8), (10) (14), 39B(2)(a), (3), (4), (5), (7), (8) and (11), 40(1), (1B), (1C) and (1D), 43AAA, 66 and 68

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 ss 25, 33(1)(a), 33(1)(c), 35, 35(1), 35(2), 35(2)(a), 35(2)(aa), 35(2)(b), 35(2)(c), 35AA, 35AA(d), 36‑36D, 37, 37(1AAA), 39(1), 39(6), 39A, 39A(2), 39A(3), 39A(5), 39A(6), 39A(8)-39A(15), 39A(17), 39B, 39B(2), 39B(2)(a)-(b), 39B(3), 39B(4), 39B(5), 39B(7), 43, 43(1A), 43(2B), 43AAA, 43AAA(1)-43AAA(8) and 46
Australian Passports Act 2005 ss 14, 14(1), 14(1)(a)(i), 14(2), 14(3), 14(3)(a), 14(3)(a)(i), 14(3)(a)(ii), 14(3)(b), 14(3)(b)(iii), 15, 16, 18(1), 19 and 22(2)(d)
Australian Passports Bill 2004
Australian Passports Determination 2005 s 3.4

Australian Security Intelligence Organisation Act 1979 ss 4, 17(1)(c), 37(1), (2), (3) and (4), 35(1), 38(1), (1A) and (2)(b), 61 and 65(3)

Australian Security Intelligence Organisation Act 1979 ss 4, 8, 17, 17(1)(c), 35(1), 37(1), 37(2), 37(2)(a), 37(3), 37(4), 38(1), 38(1A), 38(2)-(5), 54(1)-(2), 61, 64, 65(3) and 81
Conveyancing Act 1919 s 66G
Evidence Act 1995 ss 7, 76 and 79
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) Part IVA
Income Tax Assessment Act 1936
Migration Act 1958 ss 36(2), 196(1) 429, 501, 501(2), 501(6), 501(6)(b) and 189(1)
Mines Act 1928 (Vic)
Motor Traffic Ordinance 1939 (ACT) s 139D(1)
Real Property Act 1900 s 86(1)
Stamp Duties Act 1920 (NSW) ss 65 and 66
Supreme Court Rules 1970 Part 55 Rule 10(b)
Tasmanian Criminal Code s 157(1)
Taxation Administration Act 1953 ss 14ZZE and 14ZZK(2D)
Telecommunications (Interception and Access) Act 1979
Telecommunications Act 1997 ss 58A and 581(3)
Trade Practices Act 1974 ss 45(4), 45A and 87(1A)

Associated Dominions Assurance Society Pty Ltd v John Fairfax & Sons Pty Ltd (1952) 72 WN(NSW) 250
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v CC (NSW) Pty Ltd (1999) 92 FCR 375
Australian Telecommunications Commission vKriegEnterprises Pty Ltd (1976) 14 SASR 303
Botany Bay Instrumentation & Control Pty Ltd v Stewart [1984] 3 NSWLR 98
Boughey v R (1986) 161 CLR 10; 65 ALR 609
Brown v Commissioner of Taxation [2001] FCA 276; (2001) 47 ATR 143
Brown v Federal Commissioner of Taxation [2001] FCA 276; (2001) 47 ATR 143
Chamberlain v The Queen (1984) 153 CLR 521
Chamberlain v The Queen (No. 2) (1990) 170 CLR 573
Chan Yee Kin v. The Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1989) 169 CLR 379

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re BLBS and Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] AATA 464
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involved a challenge by BLBS to a decision by the Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade to refuse to issue or cancel a travel document due to an adverse security assessment. The applicant sought to have the Minister's decision reviewed by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The central issue before the court was whether to grant the applicant's request to issue summonses to compel the production of documents that were voluntarily provided to the Tribunal. The court had to consider the principles that guide the issuance of summonses, particularly in light of the documents already being provided voluntarily. Furthermore, the court had to determine whether an inspection order was necessary when documents were provided under a summons, as these documents, though provided voluntarily, were produced under compulsion as per the summons.

The court examined the legal framework governing the issuance of summonses and the use of documents produced under such summonses. It noted that documents produced under a summons are not considered "evidence given before the Tribunal" or "documents lodged with the Tribunal" under the specified sections of the Act. The court highlighted that these documents are not evidence unless they are admitted in evidence, a step that occurs later in the proceedings. The court acknowledged that although documents provided under a summons are produced under compulsion, there is an implied undertaking limiting their use. This limitation was emphasised to ensure that the documents are not misused in the proceedings.

In issuing the summonses, the court considered the need for an inspection order to manage the use of the documents provided under the summons. The court determined that despite the voluntary nature of the provision, an inspection order was necessary to manage the documents' use effectively. This decision underscored the court's commitment to ensuring that the documents are used appropriately within the legal framework, maintaining the integrity of the review process. The court issued the summonses, thereby allowing the review process to proceed with the necessary documents under controlled conditions.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case concerns an application by BLBS to issue summonses to the Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade for the production of certain documents, following an adverse security assessment and the decision to refuse to issue or cancel a travel document. BLBS sought to challenge the decision to refuse to issue or cancel a travel document based on the adverse security assessment. The applicant argued that the Minister's decision was flawed and that certain documents, which were not provided voluntarily, were necessary for the proper review of the decision. The applicant believed these documents would substantiate their claim that the adverse security assessment was incorrect and the refusal to issue a travel document was unjust.

The Minister opposed the application for summonses, arguing that the documents were already available or could be obtained through other means. The Minister further contended that issuing summonses was not necessary and would not assist in resolving the issues at hand. The matter was brought before the court to determine whether the applicant's request for summonses should be granted, and if so, under what conditions.

The case originated from an application by BLBS to the court, requesting the issuance of summonses to the Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade for the production of certain documents. This application followed an adverse security assessment by the Minister and the subsequent decision to refuse to issue or cancel a travel document to BLBS. The Minister opposed the application, arguing that the documents were already available or could be obtained through other means and that issuing summonses was not necessary.

The court had to determine whether to agree to the request to issue summonses and, if so, under what conditions. The court considered the relevant principles in deciding to issue or refuse to issue a summons, including the issues to be considered and decided in reviewing the Minister's decisions. The court also considered whether an inspection order would be required when documents were voluntarily provided, and whether documents provided under a summons were subject to an implied undertaking limiting their use.

Ultimately, the court decided to issue the summonses, acknowledging and emphasising that the documents provided under the summons were subject to an implied undertaking limiting their use.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Documents produced under summons do not come within the description of “evidence given before the Tribunal” or of “documents lodged with the Tribunal or received in evidence by the Tribunal” as set out in ss 35(b) and (c) and in s 35(3) (emphasis added). They are not evidence unless admitted in evidence and that comes about at a later stage than this, if it comes about at all. Are they documents “lodged” with the Tribunal? This a question that I considered in Re Skase and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs[25]when I concluded that it does not extend to material that is produced to the Tribunal in accordance with a summons. I did so on the basis that books, documents or things are produced under a summons and not lodged. That is the language of ss 40, 61 and 62, all of which relate to the issue of a summons to “produce” them or failure to comply with it. It is also the language of s 39B in relation to documents “produced” in the Security Appeals Division of the Tribunal or in cases in which an Attorney-General’s public interest certificate has been issued.[26] [25] [2005] AATA 200[26] ss 36, 36B and 66 The word “lodge” is used in a variety of provisions; 52 in all. It is, for example, used in ss 35AA, 38A and 39B relating to the Security Appeals Division as well as in a number of sections of more general application: ss 21(2),[27] 28, 29(1)(d),[28] 29A(2),[29] 35,[30] 37(1),[31] 38[32] and 68.[33] Sections 36 and 36B include references to both words. Both relate to the protection of information from disclosure in Divisions other than the Security Appeals Division when the Commonwealth or a State Attorney-General certifies that disclosure of information concerning a specified matter or disclosure of matter in a document would be contrary to the public interest for a reason set out in ss 36(1) or 36B(1) as applying to the Attorney-General.[27] “Where, before the commencement of the hearing of a proceeding before the Tribunal, there is lodged with the Tribunal, as prescribed, a notice, signed by or on behalf of all the parties, stating that they have agreed that the proceeding should be dealt with by the Tribunal constituted by a presidential member alone, the Tribunal may, if the President directs under section 20B, be constituted for the purposes of that proceeding by a presidential member alone.”[28] “An application for review of a decision … if the terms of the decision were recorded in writing and set out in a document that was given to the applicant … shall be lodged with the Tribunal within prescribed time.”[29] “An application in respect of which a fee is waived under the regulations, whether at the time of lodgement or later, is taken to be made at the time it is lodged with the Tribunal.”[30] “Where it is satisfied that it is desirable to do so by reason of the confidential nature of any evidence or matter or for any other reason, the Tribunal may, by order: (a) …; and (aa) …; and (b) give directions prohibiting or restricting the publication of evidence given before the Tribunal, whether in public or in private, or of matters contained in documents lodged with the Tribunal or received in evidence by the Tribunal; and (c)….”[31] “… a person who has made a decision that is the subject of an application must … lodge with the Tribunal 2 copies of … (a) a statement …; and (b) every other document or part of a document that is in the person’s control …”[32] Section 38(1) gives the Tribunal power to order a person to lodge with the Tribunal a further statement when it is satisfied that a statement lodged under s 37(1)(a) is not adequate as provided in that provision.[33] Section 68(1) provides that a document that must be lodged under the Act must be lodged at a registry and s. 68(2) deals with documents lodged by facsimile.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether to agree to the request to issue summonses to the Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade for the production of certain documents.
2. What principles should be considered in deciding to issue or refuse to issue a summons in this context.
3. Whether an inspection order is required when documents are voluntarily provided and whether documents provided under a summons are subject to an implied undertaking limiting their use.

Held
1. The court agreed to the request to issue summonses to the Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade for the production of certain documents.
2. The principles considered in deciding to issue or refuse to issue a summons include the necessity for the documents to review adverse security assessments and decisions to refuse or cancel travel documents, the relevance of the documents to the issues being decided, and the availability of alternative means to obtain the documents.
3. An inspection order is required even when documents are voluntarily provided, and documents provided under a summons are subject to an implied undertaking limiting their use.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the request to issue summonses to the Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade for the production of certain documents. It was determined that the documents were necessary for the review of adverse security assessments and decisions to refuse or cancel travel documents. The court noted that the principles in deciding to issue or refuse to issue a summons must take into account the relevance of the documents to the issues being decided and the availability of alternative means to obtain the documents. The court concluded that an inspection order is required even when documents are voluntarily provided, as documents produced under a summons are provided under compulsion. Furthermore, the court acknowledged and emphasised that documents provided under a summons are subject to an implied undertaking limiting their use, which was consistent with the authorities cited and the statutory language regarding the production and lodging of documents with the Tribunal. This decision aligned with the previous case of Re Skase and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs, where it was concluded that documents produced under a summons do not fall under the definition of "documents lodged with the Tribunal." This decision established the binding legal principle that documents produced under a summons are subject to an implied undertaking limiting their use, even when voluntarily provided.