Background
Background to the litigation
The Delegate stated (T2 5-11, R1):3. APPLICANT’S BACKGROUNDYou first arrived in Australia on [date omitted] February 2007 as an Illegal Maritime Arrival (IMA) and were subsequently transferred to Nauru on [date omitted] March 2007. On 14 December 2007, you applied for a Refugee (subclass 200) visa and provided your Sri Lankan birth certificate, National Identity card and copies of your parents’ Sri Lankan birth certificates. Your visa was granted on [date omitted] January 2008 and you arrived in Australia on [date omitted] January 2008.On [date omitted] January 2013, you were convicted of the offence ‘Failure to comply with a requirement to provide a breath analysis’ and were disqualified from driving for 10 months and fined $900.On [date omitted] December 2013, you lodged an application for conferral of Australian citizenship and provided your Sri Lankan National Identity card and birth certificate, a Western Australia driver’s licence, a copy of your Document for Travel to Australia (DfTtA) and copies of your parents’ Sri Lankan birth certificates. On [date omitted] December 2013, the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation (ASIO) requested that your application be referred for assessment. On [date omitted] February 2014, you were interviewed by ASIO officers in respect of your application for Australian citizenship and you were subsequently interviewed by ASIO again on 24 March 2014.On [date omitted] May 2017, you applied for a Resident Return (subclass 155) visa. This visa was granted on [date omitted] February 2018 and remains in effect at the time of this decision.On [date omitted] August 2017, ASIO issued a Qualified Security Assessment (QSA) in respect of your application for Australian citizenship. The QSA advised the Department that you had been involved in the facilitation of potential illegal immigrants (Plls) to Australia. ASIO further advised in the QSA that you were not a direct or indirect risk to security as at the date of the assessment.You have only travelled overseas once since the grant of your first visa, on [date omitted] June 2018. You returned on [date omitted] July 2018.…Qualified Security AssessmentI have considered the QSA issued by ASIO on [date omitted] August 2017, in which they assessed you as being involved in the facilitation of Plls to Australia. This QSA was based on two Security Assessment Interviews (SAls) conducted by ASIO with you, on [date omitted] February 2014 and [date omitted] March 2014. Subsequent to these interviews, ASIO assessed you as having been dishonest during the SAls regarding your knowledge of, and involvement in, people-smuggling activities and in relation to your peoplesmuggling associations. Specifically, ASIO assessed that you were involved in facilitating the passage of your father and another person on Search and Rescue (SAR) [detail omitted], which departed [location omitted] on [date omitted] July 2013 and capsized, resulting in the deaths of at least [number of deaths omitted] people.According to the Citizenship Policy, a person of good character would not be involved in the illegal movement of people or be associated with others who are involved in anti-social or criminal behaviour, or others who do not uphold and obey the laws of Australia. ASIO have assessed that you were involved in both of these activities, and that you were also dishonest with the Australian Government (ASIO) in relation to this involvement.Furthermore, in the QSA, ASIO stated that “border integrity policies have diminished the ability of people smugglers to undertake successful people-smuggling operations to Australia”. I have interpreted this to mean that you ceased in your facilitation of people smuggling ventures due to the success of the Australian Government’s approach to stopping people-smuggling, rather than as a result of a change in your character or a desire to stop. I place significant weight on these factors in my assessment of whether you are of good character.I have considered ASIO’s comment in the QSA that, should people-smuggling networks re-establish, you no longer have the intent or capability to undertake people-smuggling activities and, therefore, is not directly or indirectly a risk to security. However, while I have placed weight on this statement I have placed greater weight on ASIO’s assessment that it was a strengthening of government policies that led to you ceasing your association with people smuggling activities. I have also placed significant weight on the risk to Australian borders that may arise should you re-establish your previous networks and capabilities in relation to people smuggling and believe that there is not enough information before me to satisfy me of a change in character in relation to this behaviour. That is, the information before me indicates that your change in behaviour was circumstantial and related to Government policy, rather than having occurred due to a change in your personal moral qualities.I have considered the following statements regarding the QSA, made by your representative:·That you requested the second SAI and voluntarily divulged the knowledge of your father’s presence on SAR [detail omitted];·That ASIO's Qualified Security Assessment would amount essentially to an “opinion or advice”... such an opinion or advice could not be equated to a criminal charge or conviction;·Since you have not been convicted of people smuggling, your testimony during the SAls cannot be considered dishonest.In considering the representative’s claim that you “voluntarily divulged” the knowledge of your father’s presence on the boat, I am of the opinion that this alone does not demonstrate that you are of good character. Conversely, if you did voluntarily divulge this information at the second interview, I would consider this information to support ASIO’s assessment that you were dishonest during the first interview.For the purposes of Australian citizenship, assessing whether a person is of good character does not solely take into account a person’s criminal convictions, but considers the enduring moral qualities of the person. The fact that you have not been charged or convicted of people smuggling activities does not mean that you have not been involved in the activities to some extent, and does not mean that you can automatically be considered of good character. Furthermore, SAls conducted by ASIO are not conducted at the request of a citizenship applicant, rather, they are conducted by ASIO as the need arises, in order to ensure the integrity of Australian borders and the security of the Australian people. As such, while I have considered the statements provided by your representative, I have placed greater weight on the advice provided by ASIO, as this agency could reasonably be viewed as experts in the assessment of issues relating to Australia’s security, inclusive of matters relating to people smuggling.In conducting a security assessment on behalf of the Department of Home Affairs, ASIO draws on their global network of intelligence partners as well as their own unique collection and assessment capabilities. While their QSA may amount to an opinion or advice, it is made from a well-informed position, as they are Australia’s experts in National Security matters. As such, I have placed no weight on your representative’s assertion that an opinion or advice cannot be equated to a criminal charge or conviction, and significant weight on the information contained within the QSA.OffenceI am satisfied that you have a criminal record in Australia. Information held by the department regarding your criminal record in Australia indicates the following:·On [date omitted] January 2013 you were convicted of the offence ‘Failure to comply with a requirement to provide a breath analysis’. As a result, you were disqualified from driving for 10 months and fined $900.Under citizenship policy, I must consider whether the offence is serious or minor. Serious offences include, but are not limited to: crimes of violence (such as murder, manslaughter, assault, sexual assault, domestic violence, armed robbery, negligent or reckless driving occasioning injury or death), crimes against children and other vulnerable people, drug trafficking, people smuggling, fraud (including identity fraud), harassment or stalking, illegal pornography (including child pornography), breaches of immigration law, war crimes, crimes against humanity, genocide and terrorism. In addition, any other offences incurring prison sentences of 12 months or more.I am satisfied that you have not been convicted of an offence that would ordinarily be considered serious. Having regard to the sentence imposed, I am satisfied that your only offence is at the lower range of seriousness and that adds some weight to your good character.Attitude towards law enforcement/government officialsA person of good character would interact with Australian Government, or other, officials in a manner that is honest, respectful and cooperative. I have considered your dealings with the Western Australia Police and with ASIO officers during his two SAls. While the failure to comply with a requirement to provide a breath analysis conviction is on the lower end of the scale, and you have acknowledged that you should have provided the sample, I consider that you have shown a disregard for law enforcement. I consider you to have also displayed dishonesty in your dealings with ASIO, which continued even after you were provided with an opportunity to correct the misinformation provided, I have placed significant weight on these interactions as both demonstrate a willingness to lie or mislead Australian Government officials in order to achieve a favourable outcome for yourself.Character referencesCitizenship policy states that the onus is on the applicant to demonstrate that there has been a change in their character since last offending. You have provided information about volunteer and community work through your referee reports.Policy states referee reports can shed light upon an applicant’s character and should acknowledge, where applicable, any offence or other incident and explain why the applicant is nonetheless considered to be of “good character”. However, decision makers should note the inherent bias in any reference which is submitted by an applicant in support of their citizenship application.More weight should be given to references made as statutory declarations then [sic] those which are not. References should come from members of the community who have observed the applicant at work or in other contexts, and who are willing to provide contact details. Referees should also explain how long they have known the applicant for, and the context of their relationship.It is preferable that references are not submitted from family members. However, if they are, less weight should be given to them because of the societal expectation that family members would tend to support one another and play down unacceptable conduct. Decision makers should take particular care with references from victims of domestic violence.….Generally, the character references state that you are hardworking, honest and trustworthy and comment on your volunteer work at your temple and for members of the Tamil community in Western Australia. The character referees indicate that they support your application for Australian citizenship. Some of the character referees acknowledge your criminal offence and comment on your remorse and how you have accepted responsibility for this matter. I give the contents of the referee reports some weight in my assessment of whether you are of good character, however, note that none of the references provided by you refer to people smuggling, or your involvement with ASIO.SummaryWhile you have been convicted of one minor offence in Australia, you have also been assessed by an Australian government agency as a person who has been involved in people smuggling activities. I acknowledge that your character references state that you are an honest, hard-working member of the Tamil community, that you have not been charged or convicted with people smuggling offences, and that, if people smuggling activities were to recommence, you would no longer have the capability to participate. However, people smuggling is a very serious issue that poses a significant threat to the integrity of Australia's border, and places human lives at risk, as evidenced by the venture you were involved in where the boat capsized and at least [number of deaths omitted] people lost their lives. I have placed significant weight on your involvement in these activities as demonstrating that you are not of good character. I feel that not enough time has passed since your involvement in people smuggling, to demonstrate that you can be considered a person of good character for the purposes of the Act.(Original emphasis.)
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
The issue for determination by this Tribunal is whether the Applicant was, as at 18 October 2018, a person of good character for the purpose of satisfying s 21(2)(h) of the Citizenship Act.EVIDENCE The application for review was heard on 9 May 2019. The Applicant appeared in person, assisted by an interpreter, and was represented by Ms Graziotti of Estrin Saul. The Respondent was represented by Ms Ladhams of the Australian Government Solicitor. The Tribunal received the following evidence:·Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions (SoFIC) dated 7 March 2019 (Exhibit A1);·Statement by [name omitted] dated 7 March 2019 (Exhibit A2);·Statutory Declaration of [name omitted] dated 5 February 2019 (Exhibit A3);·Statutory Declaration of [name omitted] dated 5 February 2019 (Exhibit A4);·Statutory Declaration of [name omitted] dated 9 February 2019 (Exhibit A5);·Statutory Declaration of [name omitted] dated 9 February 2019 (Exhibit A6);·Statutory Declaration of [name omitted] dated 5 February 2019 (Exhibit A7);·Statutory Declaration of [name omitted] dated 8 February 2019 (Exhibit A7);·Letter from [name omitted] dated 7 February 2019 (Exhibit A9);·Statutory Declaration of [name omitted] dated 12 February 2019 (Exhibit A10);·Notices of tax assessment – 2010-2018 (Exhibit A11);·Letter from the Department of Immigration and Border Protection dated 14 March 2014 (Exhibit A12);·Hearing certificate (Exhibit A13);·T documents (T1-T23 pp1-200) (Exhibit R1);·The Respondent’s SoFIC dated 8 April 2019 (Exhibit R2); and·Hearing certificate (Exhibit R3). The Tribunal has reviewed all of the material before it. The Tribunal is satisfied that all relevant evidence was before it and that both parties were provided an opportunity to address the evidence, either orally or in writing. Relevant aspects of the evidence and material before the Tribunal will be analysed and referred to below. The Applicant makes the following contentions (A1):26.The Applicant contends that he meets the requirements for approval of Australian citizenship by conferral, including subsection 21(2)(h)) [sic] of the Act, and there are no legislative prohibitions to him becoming an Australian citizen under this subsection.27.The Applicant contends that the evidence before the Tribunal, namely his non-disclosure of the knowledge that his father was onboard SAR [detail omitted] (a fact he discovered after the vessel capsized) and his subsequent voluntary disclosure of this information to ASIO during the Second interview, does not demonstrate that he regularly practices deceptive and fraudulent conduct which is not in line with community standards.28.A further contention is whether the QSA’s finding that the Applicant facilitating the passage of two people to Australia (with no further evidence to support this having been provided to the Tribunal) is sufficient to consider he has been involved in the illegal movement of people so as to prevent him from being able to satisfy the good character requirement set out in s 21(2)(h) of the Act.29.The Tribunal equally has to determine whether there are any mitigating circumstances, or explanation provided by the Applicant which might address those concerns.…55.The Applicant has one minor conviction in Australia and no convictions in any other country.56.The delegate’s finding in the Decision that he was not of good character was made on the basis of his conduct during the First interview.Dishonesty during the First interview57.The Applicant was dishonest in the First interview as he denied knowing anyone onboard the people-smuggling venture known as SAR [detail omitted] (SAR [detail omitted]). The Applicant states the following about the First interview:I was also asked if there was anyone related to me or who had a connection to me on the boat that sank. I said no, because I meant that I was not involved with anyone getting on the boat. I did not organise the boat to come to Australia and I was not involved in anything to do with the boat. I also felt like I had been asked these questions out of the blue and I panicked. I knew my father had been on that boat but I did not tell the interviewers that at the time.58.On 1 March 2014 the Applicant contacted the Department via email and requested a second meeting. A copy of that email has been provided with this submission. Between the First interview and 1 March 2014 the Applicant did not receive any correspondence from ASIO or the Department.59.At the Second interview the Applicant disclosed that he knew his father was onboard SAR [detail omitted] and that he discovered this after the boat had capsized, emphasising that he did not assist his father to get onto SAR [detail omitted] nor was he involved whatsoever with the venture. He advised that he was aware that his father had been on SAR [detail omitted] during the First interview. He states:My father never informed me he would come on the boat or that he would try to come to Australia. I had no information about how my father got on the boat or who helped him. The only thing I knew was that my father was on the boat that sank. I found this out maybe the day after the boat sank. My mother called me and told me that my father went to Australia by boat and the boat had an accident. She didn’t know anything else, like whether my father was alive or how the boat sank. My mother updated me after he was picked up by another boat and taken to hospital. I don’t remember the date but this was before the ASIO interview.60. Between the First interview and Second interview the Applicant questioned his parents further and discovered that the smuggler who had organised SAR [detail omitted] was named “[name omitted]”. He was unaware of this at the time of the First interview but disclosed it during the Second interview.61.The Decision notes:A person of good character would interact with Australian Government, or other, officials in a manner that is honest, respectful and cooperative.62.There is no indication that the Applicant was not respectful or cooperative during the Second interview. His dishonesty in the First interview was limited to his non-disclosure of the knowledge that his father was on SAR [detail omitted], which he discovered after the vessel had capsized.63.Though the decision-maker was dismissive of the Applicant’s evidence that he requested the Second interview and voluntarily divulged his dishonesty, evidence of that request and acknowledgement of it by the Department have been provided with these submissions, and the Tribunal should consider these actions as a demonstration of the Applicant’s enduring moral qualities.64.The decision-maker’s finding that the Applicant displayed dishonesty in dealings with ASIO “which continued even after [he] was provided with an opportunity to correct the misinformation provided” ignores the fact that the Applicant sought that opportunity out by requesting the Second interview and used it to correct the misinformation provided in the First interview. It is unclear what further (uncorrected) dishonesty the delegate is referring to in this statement.65. Additionally, divulging his dishonesty during the Second interview has not led to a favourable outcome for the Applicant – to the contrary, he has gained no benefit whatsoever from this action, despite a clear effort to “right his wrongs” by contacting ASIO and requesting a second meeting.66.The recent case of Nguyen v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] AATA 1082 states:82 Citizenship of Australia is regarded as a special privilege when extended to those not automatically qualified. Earning it requires adherence not only to statutory requirements but also to the set of moral values and qualities related to honesty in dealings with the Government. These values and qualities are themselves a hallmark of good citizenship.83 Citizenship cannot be awarded on the basis of false statements. There are no excuses for making false statements in this regard.84 Equally, it is a hallmark of citizenship to take personal responsibility for one’s own actions and not cast them off onto the shoulders of others…67.The Applicant accepted responsibility for his dishonesty during the First interview at the next available opportunity (the Second interview). His application for Australian citizenship was made over five years ago and his first visa application was made over 11 years ago. Apart from this one lapse and one minor conviction, there is no evidence before the Tribunal to indicate that the Applicant has a pattern of behaviour of using deception or fraud.68.The Applicant’s voluntary disclosure of his dishonesty demonstrates he has an ability to distinguish right from wrong and an ability to behave in an ethical manner, conforming to the rules and values of Australian society. Attempting to rectify his mistake should be considered behaviour in accordance with community standards.“Facilitation” of people-smuggling69.The QSA noted that the Applicant was dishonest regarding “his knowledge of, and involvement in, people-smuggling activities and in relation to his people-smuggling associations”. The evidence on which this finding is seemingly based appears to be limited to the Applicant’s dishonesty regarding his “people-smuggling associations”, which in turn appears to be based on his non-disclosure of the knowledge that his father was on SAR [detail omitted] (discovered after the vessel capsized) and his later discovery of another name of a person on that vessel.70.The QSA report does not provide ASIO’s evidential basis for its finding that the Applicant was “involved in facilitating the passage of his father and another individual to Australia” or that he was “involved” in people-smuggling activities at all.71.The Macquarie Dictionary (Sixth Ed.) defines “facilitate” as “1. to make easier or less difficult; help forward (an action, a process, etc). 2. to assist the progress of (a person): to facilitate the customer to find the right product”.72.Pure knowledge of a fact or circumstance (in this matter, the name of a person on SAR [detail omitted] after it had already departed and capsized) cannot form a basis for a finding that another person “facilitated” the passage of that person when the ordinary dictionary meaning of “facilitate” is applied. Discovering a person is onboard a vessel once the vessel has already capsized cannot constitute behaviour that has made that person’s journey onto the vessel “easier or less difficult”, or be considered “help” at all.73.Section 233A of the Migration Act 1958 (Migration Act) contains the following offence:(1) A person (the first person) commits an offence if:(a)the first person organises or facilitates the bringing or coming to Australia, or the entry or proposed entry into Australia, of another person (the second person); and(b) the second person is a non-citizen; and(c)the second person had, or has, no lawful right to come to Australia.Penalty: Imprisonment for 10 years or 1,000 penalty units, or both.74.No prosecution has ever been commenced against the Applicant under this section (or any others in the Migration Act) at any time.75.This offence was inserted into the Migration Act by the Anti People Smuggling and Other Measures Act 2010, for which the explanatory memorandum states:The use of the term organise and facilitates is used to cover all conduct associated with people smuggling and is consistent with term used in the current section 232A of the Migration Act. The fault element of intention will attach to the physical element of conduct of organising or facilitating, by operation of the default elements in section 5.6 of the Criminal Code.76.This suggests an element of intention is required to find that a person has been involved in “facilitating” people smuggling. Nothing in the Applicant’s documents or the QSA suggests that he had (at any stage) an intention to organise or facilitate (or be involved in whatsoever) the illegal passage of people to Australia.77.On the contrary, the QSA states:ASIO assesses [the Applicant] does not currently hold the intent or capability to undertake people-smuggling activities…78.While the finding that the “success of the Australian Government’s approach to stopping people-smuggling” may be interpreted as a reason why the Applicant does not currently hold the capability to undertake people-smuggling activities, there is no indication that this is the basis for the Applicant not having an intention to undertake people-smuggling activities. Rather, that should be drawn from his consistent and repeated statements indicating that he does not have, and has never had, an intention to facilitate people smuggling, as well as the lack of evidence that he has been in any way involved in such activities apart from being related to a person onboard SAR [detail omitted].79.The finding in the Decision that the Applicant’s lack of capability or intention to undertake people-smuggling activities is due to stronger border protection policies is not stated in the QSA.80.The Decision also erroneously stated that ASIO assessed the Applicant to have been “associated with others who are involved in anti-social or criminal behaviour” and refers to him having “previous networks”. The QSA contains no findings whatsoever in relation to the Applicant’s associations or networks.81.The QSA’s lack of details regarding the evidentiary basis for its findings mean it is insufficient to be used as a sole basis for finding that the Applicant is not of good character.82.Policy notes that if an applicant has committed a “very significant offence” (with examples including taking the life of another person, sexual assault, crimes against children, war crimes, genocide) the period of “enduring moral quality” that would need to be demonstrated in order for a decision-maker to contemplate a finding that that person is of good character could be potentially “a period of many years” or effectively that they may never satisfy the good character requirement.83.Aside from the fact that the Applicant has never been charged with or convicted of a people- smuggling offence, his dishonesty during the First interview cannot be considered to be in the same realm as convictions for genocide, war crimes or crimes against children.84.Whatever contribution he had to people-smuggling (as his exact degree of “facilitation” appears to be limited to knowledge of two names of persons on SAR [detail omitted]) this contribution is clearly very small. There is no indication, suggestion or finding that the Applicant has ever profited (financially or otherwise) from involvement in people-smuggling or has been an organiser of people-smuggling activities.Are there any mitigating factors?85.Should the Tribunal find that the dishonesty displayed by the Applicant during the First interview, as well as the QSA’s findings in relation to his involvement in people-smuggling activities are sufficient for him to not meet the good character requirement, it should also consider whether there are any factors that mitigate the Applicant’s behaviour.86.Mitigating factors that are relevant to the Applicant’s conduct include:a.there is no evidence that the Applicant has been dishonest with the Department or ASIO at any other time. His first visa application was made in 2007 and he has lived in Australia for 11 years. He has consistently declared the Conviction and previous charges in his visa and citizenship applications and there is no evidence that he has provided false or misleading information to the Department or other government officials at any time other than during the First interview;b.he has been assessed by ASIO as not presenting a direct or indirect risk to national security and ASIO has not recommended against the Applicant becoming an Australian citizen;c.six years has passed since the First interview. During that time the Applicant has responded to numerous requests for further documents and information from the Department and has attended its office for an interview;d.there is no evidence he has ever endangered Australian society or members of the Australian community in any way;e.he has accepted responsibility and shown remorse for his conduct. This has been demonstrated through his behaviour (requesting a Second interview and voluntarily divulging his dishonesty) and statements made both to friends and to the Tribunal;f.he has made an otherwise conscious effort to obey and uphold Australian laws (having only been convicted of one minor offence six years ago during his 11-year residence in Australia);g.the Applicant was dishonest during an interview that he had no preparation or warning for (the invitation did not state that he would be interviewed by ASIO or what would be discussed during the interview). He was extremely surprised at the questions being asked of him and states that he “panicked” when asked whether he knew anyone onboard SAR [detail omitted] and answered incorrectly out of fear and panic about being sent back to Sri Lanka;h.he has a long and consistent history of full-time employment since arriving in Australia;i.he has been heavily involved in the Tamil community in Australia for the last 11 years and has undertaken many hours of voluntary work;j.he is well-respected within his community and employment circle; andk.he shares Australia’s democratic beliefs and respects its rights and liberties.87.In regard to responsibility and remorse, the Applicant states:I still feel bad about making that mistake in the first interview. Because of that one mistake, when I was younger, this has given me a bad character and reputation with the Department and my character has been tarnished.Apart from this, I have never given any untrue information about anything to the government. I have never given any false information to the government and I would never make this kind of mistake again in my life…I came to Australia by boat and am fully aware of the dangerous journey by the terrible sea. I never ever encourage my father or any other person to do this suicide journey. I never ever had greed in making money on some one death and pursuing this dangerous journey. I always work hard and honestly do my activities and earned my income.88.The evidence before the Tribunal demonstrates that the Applicant has, notwithstanding one lapse six years ago (which he attempted to rectify within weeks of it occurring), respected and abided by the law in Australia and other countries; been honest and financially responsible; been otherwise truthful in his dealings with the Australian government; and has behaved in accordance with Australia’s community standards.Character statements89.The Applicant provided a number of character references with his original application and has now obtained further updated statements for the Tribunal. The references have been provided by a range of community members, friends and colleagues.90.The Decision noted that:Generally, the character references state that you are hardworking, honest and trustworthy and comment on your volunteer work at your temple and for members of the Tamil community in Western Australia. Some of the character referees acknowledge your criminal offence and comment on your remorse and how you have accepted responsibility for this matter. [emphasis added]91.The references also confirm that the Applicant is a committed and trusted community member who takes his duties and responsibilities as a tax payer, worker, resident and community member very seriously.92.They also speak to a growth in the Applicant’s maturity over the last five years (since the First interview was conducted) and the fact that he has built a life in Australia and considers it to be his home (including having purchased two properties).93.The various character references lodged with the Department and the Tribunal show that the Applicant is respected and liked in his community and workplace, and is trustworthy, generous with his time, diligent and hard-working – factors which demonstrate enduring moral qualities.(Original emphasis, footnotes omitted.)
Decision
Reasons for decision
In determining whether the Applicant was of good character at the time that the Delegate made his decision, the Tribunal must take into account a number of considerations. These are outlined below. Was the Applicant of good character at the time the Delegate made the decision? The Tribunal accepts the Applicant is the subject of an alcohol related driving offence. For the purpose of this application it is considered to be minor. The Tribunal accepts the Applicant has submitted a number of statutory declarations attesting to his character (A2-A10). In the majority these statutory declarations acknowledge his alcohol driving offence and the allegation concerning his role in the facilitation of people smuggling. In summary the statutory declarations state:·He is an active member of the Tamil community.·He has a strong work ethic, is hard working and pays his taxes.·He is committed and acts as a volunteer in many roles in the Tamil community.·He is loyal, trustworthy and honest. The primary contention for the Tribunal relates to the very serious allegation that the Applicant was involved in the facilitation of people smuggling. The Tribunal notes the Applicant’s statutory declaration (A2). He states:ASIO interviews9. I can't exactly remember whether I was invited to the ASIO interview by phone or by email, but I was told it was a citizenship interview. I was questioned as to whether I was aware of anyone in Perth doing people smuggling, who was responsible for the boat that sank, if I was aware of anyone who was involved with the boat that sank.10.I was also asked if there was anyone related to me or who had a connection to me on the boat that sank. I said no, because I meant that I was not involved with anyone getting on the boat. I did not organise the boat to come to Australia and I was not involved in anything to do with the boat. I also felt like I had been asked these questions out of the blue and I panicked. I knew my father had been on that boat but I did not tell the interviewers that at the time.11.I did not have a lawyer or a representative at that time. I did not have any advice about what the interview was and what it meant. I didn't know they would be asking all these questions, I thought the questions would be about the court case I had at the time (I was acquitted).12.There were two people interviewing me and I had an interpreter. The interpreter was Indian and not very clear but I was able to understand them. At that stage my English was very bad.13.My father never informed [sic] me he would come on the boat or that he would try to come to Australia. I had no information about how my father got on the boat or who helped him. The only thing I knew was that my father was on the boat that sank. I found this out maybe the day after the boat sank. My mother called me and told me that my father went to Australia by boat and the boat had an accident. She didn't know anything else, like whether my father was alive or how the boat sank. My mother updated me after he was picked up by another boat and taken to hospital. I don't remember the date but this was before the ASIO interview.14.At the same time my mother called me I told some of my friends in my house that that had happened (there were 8 or 9 people living in my house at that time, also from Sri Lanka).15.After the ASIO interview (first one) I asked my mother how my father got on the boat. She told me the smuggler's name was [name omitted] but she did not know the last name. I did not know this name when I went to the first ASIO interview.16.My father has not tried to come to Australia again. I didn't know he was going to try to get on the boat. I have not helped anyone come to Australia by boat.17.My friend helped me with the citizenship application, I did not have a lawyer or agent helping me with it. After the interview, I went home and was thinking about the interview for a few days. I was feeling bad and uncomfortable because I did not declare that I had found out my father was on that boat.18.I emailed ASIO and told them I wanted to meet them again. I think I had the contact details from the interview. I am trying to log back into that email address as I have not used it for a long time and do not know what the password is.19.I also spoke to some friends about who ASIO was so I understood more why they were asking those questions.20.After that, ASIO replied to me and organised another interview. In that interview I admitted that I knew my father was on the boat that sank but because of fear and panic I said I did not know anyone on the boat. I also told them the smuggler's name that I had discovered. Then they asked all the same questions that they had asked in the first interview. All my other answers were the same.21.I still feel bad about making that mistake in the first interview. Because of that one mistake, when I was younger, this has given me a bad character and reputation with the Department and my character has been tarnished.22.Apart from this, I have never given any untrue information about anything to the government. I have never given any false information to the government and I would never make this kind of mistake again in my life.23.It took almost two years for the Department to give me the ASIO report. I got it after I made an online complaint and complained to the Ombudsman. The Department then called me around 4:30pm and told me to come to the Department office. Someone in the building handed me a normal white envelope which had the ASIO report inside. There was no letter or email from the Department and no one explained to me what this report was.24.My English was not good and I was very busy at work so by the time I realised what the report was and that I had only 28 days to appeal it, the 28 days was over. So I tried to call about it to say the clearance is wrong but they told me the time had passed for appealing it.