NOT €OR DISTRIBUTION lu ‘
4 ’ I : * - \ \
7t8 1 -
JUDGMENT No. ........ _. , - . S 1 1 4
| J | ~ | |
|
1 ,
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA ) . --- ’ 1 -.. - 4.
VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY 1 NO. VG 46 of 1984 1 GENERAL DIVISION ) BETWEEN:
ALEXANDRA PRIVATE GERIATRIC HOSPITAL PTY. LTD. (trading as “Alexandra Private Nursing Home?
Appllcant
- and -
NEAL BLEWETT (who is sued as the Commonwealth
Minister of State for Health)
and LAWRIE J. WILLETT (who is sued as the
Permanent Head of the Commonwealth Department
of Health)
Respondents
MINUTES OF ORDER
COURT: Woodward J
DATE : 15 March 1989 PLACE: Melbourne
Note: Settlement and entry of orders ace dealt with in
Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
The respondents pay to the applicant one third of its party-and-party costs in this matter, in
which judgment was given on 7 August 1984.
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA ) )
VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY 1 No. VG 46 of 1984 1 GENERAL DIVISION ) BETWEEN:
ALEXANDRA PRIVATE GERIATRIC HOSPITAL PTY. LTD.
(tradina as "Alexandra Private Nursina Home") - Applicant
- and -
NEAL BLEWETT (who is sued as the Commonwealth
Minister of State for Health)
and LAWRIE J. WILLETT (who is sued as the
Permanent Head of the Commonwealth Department
of Health)
Respondents
WOODWARD J REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
I heard this application for judicial review in
1984 and gave judgment on 7 August of that year; see 2 FCR
368. In doing so I said (at 3 8 7 ) .
"I shall not, however, attempt o deal separately with each way in which the
applicant's case is put. In their "Applicant's Statement of Issues", counsel have purported i entify to twenty-five separate (though overlapping) ways in which
the delegate fell into error, and an average
of four different ways in which each error can
be challenged under the ADJR Act, making a potential total of over 100 separate issues. I shall deal only with the alleged errors which in my view have some substance and, in
each of those cases, with the most obvious
ground or grounds of challenge under the Act." I then proceeded to deal with the one minor and two
major issues which called for declsion. I resolved all three of them against the applicant and dlsmrssed the applicatlon
wlth costs. On the principal and most time-consuming lssue -
the appropriate allowance for a profit element in fixlng nursing home fees - I expressed sympathy for the applicant
but found that its treatment by the respondents, although hard, was not unlawful.
In July 1985, a Full Court of this Court found that
the respondents' decision was unlawful and made appropriate
orders, see 7 FCR 341. There was no appeal from my flndings
on the other issues. The Full Court referred back to me for
further consideration the question of costs…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Alexandra Private Geriatric Hospital Pty Ltd v Blewett, N and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1989] FCA 78
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the court were whether the respondents' decisions in setting nursing home fees were lawful, particularly focusing on the allowance for a profit element. The applicant argued that the respondents had not properly considered the necessary profit margin for the operation of nursing homes, while the respondents maintained that the decisions were within their statutory authority and adhered to the correct procedures.
Woodward J initially dismissed the applicant's application, finding the respondents' treatment of the applicant, though difficult, not unlawful. However, a Full Court later found the respondents' decision unlawful and ordered a review of the costs. Upon reconsidering the matter, Woodward J concluded that while the applicant had succeeded on a significant issue, the other issues were also substantial. He determined that it was just for the respondents to pay one third of the applicant's total party-and-party costs to avoid further complications and expenses associated with detailed cost assessments.
The court ordered that the respondents pay one third of the applicant's party-and-party costs in the matter, reflecting a balanced approach to the resolution of the costs issue while considering the significance of the applicant's successful arguments and the complexity of the proceedings.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi