Sandercock and Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 59 min read

[2015] AATA 18

Division Veterans' Appeals Division

File Number

2014/0356

Re

Alan Sandercock

APPLICANT

And

Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President S D Hotop

Date 15 January 2015
Place Perth

The decision under review is affirmed.

.............................[sgd].........................................

S D Hotop

Deputy President

  1. Alan Sandercock (“the applicant”) has applied to the Tribunal for review of a “reviewable decision”, dated 9 December 2013, made by a delegate of the Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission (“the respondent”) under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (“SRC Act”), whereby it was determined that the respondent is not liable under the SRC Act to pay compensation to the applicant for hearing loss.

    The Evidence

  2. The evidence before the Tribunal comprised the “T Documents” (T1–T38, pp 1–142) lodged by the respondent in accordance with s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) and:

    ·Exhibits A1–A9 tendered by the applicant;

    ·Exhibits R1–R8 tendered by the respondent; and

    ·the oral evidence of the applicant, Dr Alastair Mackendrick and Professor Terence McManus.

    The Factual Background

  3. The following background facts are not in dispute and are found by the Tribunal on the basis of the T Documents.

  4. The applicant, who was born in August 1939, performed National Service training in the Australian Army in January/February 1958 and February/March 1959 (T8, pp 39–40).  He subsequently service in the Royal Australian Air Force (“RAAF”) Citizen Air Force from October 1962 to February 1965 and in the RAAF General Reserves from March 1965 to March 1970 (T14).  While in high school, the applicant had been a member of the army cadets in 1955 and 1956 (T3, p 19).

  5. On 8 July 2011 the applicant lodged with the Department of Veterans’ Affairs (“DVA”) a completed “Claim for Rehabilitation and Compensation” form, signed by him and dated 15 June 2011, whereby he claimed compensation under the SRC Act for “hearing loss” said to have been first sustained by him in 1955 when firing a “303 rifle” on a rifle range during a school cadet camp in Northam without the provision of protective ear muffs (T3, pp 7-13). In an accompanying statement, the applicant stated that he also fired a “303 rifle” and a “Bren, Owen and Vickers machine gun”, without ear protection, during his National Service training in 1958 and 1959, and a “.303rifle” at RAAF Pearce, without ear protection, in the period 1962–1965 (T3, p 19).

  6. On 31 January 2012 a delegate of the respondent made a determination under the SRC Act disallowing the applicant’s claim for compensation (T21).

  7. On 8 August 2012 a delegate of the respondent made a “reviewable decision” under the SRC Act affirming the abovementioned determination of 31 January 2012 (T25).

  8. On 22 July 2013 the Administrative Appeals Tribunal affirmed the abovementioned reviewable decision of 8 August 2012 (T28):  see Re Sandercock and Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission [2013] AATA 517.

  9. On 15 August 2013 the applicant lodged with the DVA a further completed “Claim for Rehabilitation and Compensation” form,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sandercock and Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Comm... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] AATA 18
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Alan Sandercock sought compensation from the Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission for hearing loss he claimed was sustained during his military service. The Commission denied his claim, and the Administrative Appeals Tribunal subsequently affirmed this decision. The key issues before the Tribunal were whether the applicant's hearing loss was causally related to his military service and whether his delay in reporting the condition and making a compensation claim was due to reasonable cause. The Tribunal found that while the applicant's hearing loss was indeed sustained during his service, there was insufficient medical evidence to establish a causal link between the loss and his military activities. Additionally, the Tribunal determined that the applicant's significant delay in reporting his condition and making a claim was not due to reasonable cause, as he had ample time to seek medical attention and file a claim. The Tribunal also found that the Commission was prejudiced by the applicant's failure to provide timely notice of his condition, as required by the relevant legislation. Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the Commission's decision to deny compensation.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The evidence before the Tribunal comprised the “T Documents” (T1–T38, pp 1–142) lodged by the respondent in accordance with s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) and:·Exhibits A1–A9 tendered by the applicant;·Exhibits R1–R8 tendered by the respondent; and·the oral evidence of the applicant, Dr Alastair Mackendrick and Professor Terence McManus.The Factual Background The following background facts are not in dispute and are found by the Tribunal on the basis of the T Documents. The applicant, who was born in August 1939, performed National Service training in the Australian Army in January/February 1958 and February/March 1959 (T8, pp 39–40). He subsequently service in the Royal Australian Air Force (“RAAF”) Citizen Air Force from October 1962 to February 1965 and in the RAAF General Reserves from March 1965 to March 1970 (T14). While in high school, the applicant had been a member of the army cadets in 1955 and 1956 (T3, p 19). On 8 July 2011 the applicant lodged with the Department of Veterans’ Affairs (“DVA”) a completed “Claim for Rehabilitation and Compensation” form, signed by him and dated 15 June 2011, whereby he claimed compensation under the SRC Act for “hearing loss” said to have been first sustained by him in 1955 when firing a “303 rifle” on a rifle range during a school cadet camp in Northam without the provision of protective ear muffs (T3, pp 7-13). In an accompanying statement, the applicant stated that he also fired a “303 rifle” and a “Bren, Owen and Vickers machine gun”, without ear protection, during his National Service training in 1958 and 1959, and a “.303rifle” at RAAF Pearce, without ear protection, in the period 1962–1965 (T3, p 19). On 31 January 2012 a delegate of the respondent made a determination under the SRC Act disallowing the applicant’s claim for compensation (T21). On 8 August 2012 a delegate of the respondent made a “reviewable decision” under the SRC Act affirming the abovementioned determination of 31 January 2012 (T25). On 22 July 2013 the Administrative Appeals Tribunal affirmed the abovementioned reviewable decision of 8 August 2012 (T28): see Re Sandercock and Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission [2013] AATA 517. On 15 August 2013 the applicant lodged with the DVA a further completed “Claim for Rehabilitation and Compensation” form, signed by him and dated 13 August 2013, whereby he claimed compensation under the SRC Act for “noise induced hearing loss” said to have been first sustained by him in May 1955, and further sustained by him in January/February 1958 and January/February 1959 when firing “303 rifle”, “Bren gun”, “Owen gun” and “Vickers machine gun”, without the provision of ear protection, at Army rifle ranges in Northam and Swanbourne (T29, pp 108–115). The applicant attached to that form “new evidence” in support of his claim and indicated in that form that he would provide further evidence in support of his claim (T29, pp 117, 114).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Alan Sandercock (“the applicant”) has applied to the Tribunal for review of a “reviewable decision”, dated 9 December 2013, made by a delegate of the Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission (“the respondent”) under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (“SRC Act”), whereby it was determined that the respondent is not liable under the SRC Act to pay compensation to the applicant for hearing loss.The Evidence The evidence before the Tribunal comprised the “T Documents” (T1–T38, pp 1–142) lodged by the respondent in accordance with s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) and:·Exhibits A1–A9 tendered by the applicant;·Exhibits R1–R8 tendered by the respondent; and·the oral evidence of the applicant, Dr Alastair Mackendrick and Professor Terence McManus.The Factual Background The following background facts are not in dispute and are found by the Tribunal on the basis of the T Documents. The applicant, who was born in August 1939, performed National Service training in the Australian Army in January/February 1958 and February/March 1959 (T8, pp 39–40). He subsequently service in the Royal Australian Air Force (“RAAF”) Citizen Air Force from October 1962 to February 1965 and in the RAAF General Reserves from March 1965 to March 1970 (T14). While in high school, the applicant had been a member of the army cadets in 1955 and 1956 (T3, p 19). On 8 July 2011 the applicant lodged with the Department of Veterans’ Affairs (“DVA”) a completed “Claim for Rehabilitation and Compensation” form, signed by him and dated 15 June 2011, whereby he claimed compensation under the SRC Act for “hearing loss” said to have been first sustained by him in 1955 when firing a “303 rifle” on a rifle range during a school cadet camp in Northam without the provision of protective ear muffs (T3, pp 7-13). In an accompanying statement, the applicant stated that he also fired a “303 rifle” and a “Bren, Owen and Vickers machine gun”, without ear protection, during his National Service training in 1958 and 1959, and a “.303rifle” at RAAF Pearce, without ear protection, in the period 1962–1965 (T3, p 19). On 31 January 2012 a delegate of the respondent made a determination under the SRC Act disallowing the applicant’s claim for compensation (T21). On 8 August 2012 a delegate of the respondent made a “reviewable decision” under the SRC Act affirming the abovementioned determination of 31 January 2012 (T25). On 22 July 2013 the Administrative Appeals Tribunal affirmed the abovementioned reviewable decision of 8 August 2012 (T28): see Re Sandercock and Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission [2013] AATA 517. On 15 August 2013 the applicant lodged with the DVA a further completed “Claim for Rehabilitation and Compensation” form, signed by him and dated 13 August 2013, whereby he claimed compensation under the SRC Act for “noise induced hearing loss” said to have been first sustained by him in May 1955, and further sustained by him in January/February 1958 and January/February 1959 when firing “303 rifle”, “Bren gun”, “Owen gun” and “Vickers machine gun”, without the provision of ear protection, at Army rifle ranges in Northam and Swanbourne (T29, pp 108–115). The applicant attached to that form “new evidence” in support of his claim and indicated in that form that he would provide further evidence in support of his claim (T29, pp 117, 114).

Decision

Reasons for decision

It follows, pursuant to s 124(2) of the SRC Act, that the applicant is not entitled to compensation under that Act in respect of the hearing loss condition, and the Tribunal so determines.Decision For the above reasons, the decision under review is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Section 10(1) of the 1930 Act applies where (relevantly) “an employee is suffering from a disease and is thereby incapacitated for work”. There being no medical evidence before the Tribunal that the applicant was, at any material time, incapacitated for work by reason of the hearing loss condition, the Tribunal is satisfied, and finds, that s 10(1) of the 1930 Act does not apply in relation to the applicant.Would s 16 of the 1930 Act have operated to prevent consideration of the applicant’s claim for compensation in respect of the hearing loss condition? Although, in the light of the foregoing analysis, it is unnecessary for the Tribunal to address this question, it will do so in deference to the parties’ submissions and for the sake of completeness. There can be no dispute that the applicant did not comply with the timeliness requirements prescribed by s 16(1) or s 16(4) of the 1930 Act. Specifically, the hearing loss condition was (as the Tribunal has found) sustained by the applicant at some time prior to 1965, and the applicant did not, at any time, serve notice thereof on the Commissioner for Employees’ Compensation (or any successor thereof), and did not make a claim for compensation in respect thereof until 8 July 2011 when he lodged a claim for compensation under the SRC Act for “hearing loss” with the DVA. In those circumstances the question arises as to whether the proviso in s 16(1) of the 1930 Act is satisfied such that consideration of the applicant’s claim for compensation in respect of the hearing loss condition is not prevented by the applicant’s failure to give such notice and by his failure to make a claim for compensation within the 6-month period prescribed by s 16(1) or s 16(4) of that Act. The Tribunal accepts the respondent’s submission that, given the very lengthy passage of time, it has been prejudiced by the applicant’s failure to give notice of the hearing loss condition before he “voluntarily left the employment of the Commonwealth” (within the meaning of s 16(1) of the 1930 Act), or indeed at any time before 8 July 2011. The applicant did not dispute that submission. The critical question which arises for the purposes of s 16(1) of the 1930 Act, therefore, is whether the applicant’s failure to give notice of his sustaining the hearing loss condition “as soon as practicable …” and before he “voluntarily left the employment of the Commonwealth”, and his failure to make a claim for compensation in respect of that condition within the prescribed 6-month period, were “occasioned by mistake, absence from Australia or other reasonable cause”, within the meaning of the proviso in s 16(1) of the 1930 Act. The applicant submitted that, in the period from 1962 to 2011, he had mistakenly believed that his hearing problems were due to the abscess (otitis media) which he had in his right ear in “1953/1954” and that, after becoming aware of the results of an audiogram in 2011 and consulting Dr Dyer on 6 April 2011 (see paragraph 22 above) and receiving a letter from Colonel Brennan, Director, Army Health, dated 27 April 2011 (see paragraph 23 above), he took reasonable action in promptly making a claim for compensation on 15 June 2011.