McCarthy and Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

[2014] AATA 83 

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Numbers

2012/3125 and 2014/0584

Re

Andrew McCarthy

APPLICANT

And

Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President RP Handley

Date 21 February 2014
Place Sydney

The decisions under review are affirmed.

.........................[sgd]...............................................

Deputy President RP Handley

Catchwords

COMPENSATION – transitional provisions – Whether notice of injury given as soon as practicable according to Commonwealth Employees’ Compensation Act 1930 – injury reported to the Sick Bay – particulars of notice recorded on medical record

COMPENSATION – transitional provisions – whether failure to make a claim within six months the result of mistake or reasonable cause – ignorance of the right to make a claim not reasonable cause

COMPENSATION – claim for injury arising out of medical treatment – Commonwealth not liable for knee injury – not liable to pay compensation for osteoarthritis arising from an operation to treat that injury

Legislation

Commonwealth Employees’ Compensation Act 1930 (Cth) s 16
Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) ss 4(3), 124

Cases

Commonwealth of Australia v Connors (1989) 86 ALR 247
Hunt and Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission [2010] AATA 259
Long and Comcare [2003] AATA 116
Muras and Department of Defence (1998) 52 ALD 579
Siemsen and Comcare [1999] AATA 871
Telstra Corporation v Roycroft (1997) 77 FCR 358
Wallace and Comcare [2002] AATA 1131

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President RP Handley

  1. Mr McCarthy (the Applicant) has applied to the Tribunal for the review of decisions of delegates of the Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission (MRCC) (the Respondent):

    (1) a decision dated 21 March 2012 to affirm a decision to refuse Mr McCarthy’s claim for compensation in respect of an injury to his right knee; and

    (2) a decision dated 30 January 2014 to affirm a decision to refuse Mr McCarthy’s claim for compensation for osteoarthritis of his right knee.

    BACKGROUND

  2. Mr McCarthy was born in New South Wales in 1951. He left school in Year 9 and enlisted in the Royal Australian Navy (RAN) at the age of 15. In the Navy, he trained as an aircraft engineer. He served in the Navy, working mostly on helicopters, until 7 July 1976.

  3. During his period of service, Mr McCarthy claims to have suffered a number of incidents involving his right knee while stationed at HMAS Nirimba. On 18 December 1968, he was playing hockey during a compulsory sports afternoon and was struck on the right knee by a hockey stick. Several days after this incident Mr McCarthy went on recreational leave. During leave on 19 January 1969, he lost his balance when walking backwards and fell into the Hawkesbury River near Windsor, twisting his right knee, causing it to lock. Mr McCarthy returned to Nirimba later that day and sought medical attention for his knee on 20 January 1969. His knee was bandaged and treated with physiotherapy.

  4. Subsequently, on 11 February 1969, while running to his cabin in heavy rain, Mr McCarthy’s knee locked and he experienced significant pain. He consulted a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McCarthy and Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commis... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 83
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Applicant, Mr McCarthy, has sought a review of decisions made by the Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission (MRCC) regarding his claims for compensation for injuries to his right knee sustained during his service in the Royal Australian Navy. The claims in question pertain to a meniscal tear and subsequent osteoarthritis in his right knee. Mr McCarthy argued that these injuries occurred during his military service, specifically in incidents on 18 December 1968 and 11 February 1969. The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether Mr McCarthy's injuries arose out of, or in the course of, his military service, and if the Commonwealth was liable for compensation under the Commonwealth Employees’ Compensation Act 1930. Additionally, the Tribunal had to determine if Mr McCarthy's failure to claim compensation within the statutory six-month period was due to reasonable cause.

The Tribunal examined the evidence provided by Mr McCarthy, including his service medical records and his testimony, against the statutory requirements for compensation claims. It was established that Mr McCarthy had reported his knee injuries to the Sick Bay and received medical treatment, with the details of these injuries recorded in his medical records. However, the Tribunal found that the evidence did not conclusively link the meniscal tear to the incidents reported by Mr McCarthy. Furthermore, the Tribunal concluded that Mr McCarthy's failure to claim compensation within the statutory six-month period was not due to reasonable cause, as ignorance of the right to claim was not deemed reasonable. Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the MRCC's decisions to refuse Mr McCarthy's claims for compensation.

Given the findings, the Tribunal concluded that Mr McCarthy's claims for compensation could not succeed due to the legal requirements not being met. The decisions under review were affirmed, and Mr McCarthy's claims for compensation were dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr McCarthy (the Applicant) has applied to the Tribunal for the review of decisions of delegates of the Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission (MRCC) (the Respondent):(1) a decision dated 21 March 2012 to affirm a decision to refuse Mr McCarthy’s claim for compensation in respect of an injury to his right knee; and(2) a decision dated 30 January 2014 to affirm a decision to refuse Mr McCarthy’s claim for compensation for osteoarthritis of his right knee.BACKGROUND Mr McCarthy was born in New South Wales in 1951. He left school in Year 9 and enlisted in the Royal Australian Navy (RAN) at the age of 15. In the Navy, he trained as an aircraft engineer. He served in the Navy, working mostly on helicopters, until 7 July 1976. During his period of service, Mr McCarthy claims to have suffered a number of incidents involving his right knee while stationed at HMAS Nirimba. On 18 December 1968, he was playing hockey during a compulsory sports afternoon and was struck on the right knee by a hockey stick. Several days after this incident Mr McCarthy went on recreational leave. During leave on 19 January 1969, he lost his balance when walking backwards and fell into the Hawkesbury River near Windsor, twisting his right knee, causing it to lock. Mr McCarthy returned to Nirimba later that day and sought medical attention for his knee on 20 January 1969. His knee was bandaged and treated with physiotherapy. Subsequently, on 11 February 1969, while running to his cabin in heavy rain, Mr McCarthy’s knee locked and he experienced significant pain. He consulted a RAN Doctor about this incident that day and received treatment. He was later referred to an Orthopaedic Surgeon, Dr C Selby Brown who, on 26 February 1969, diagnosed a tear to Mr McCarthy’s right medial meniscus. On 21 March 1969, Dr Selby Brown performed a meniscectomy on Mr McCarthy’s right knee at the RAN Hospital at HMAS Penguin. This involved the removal of the meniscus. He received physiotherapy to assist his recovery from the operation. On his discharge from the Navy, on 7 July 1976, Mr McCarthy did not report any symptoms affecting his right knee. After leaving the Navy, Mr McCarthy worked for a number of aviation companies as an aircraft maintenance engineer. In 2002, Mr McCarthy consulted a General Practitioner (GP) about pain in his right knee which had been troubling him for approximately 2 years. He was referred to an Orthopaedic Surgeon, Dr W Kuo, and had a number of x-rays in the following 2 years as well as an arthroscopy on 28 July 2004. In 2008, Dr Kuo advised Mr McCarthy to reduce his working hours. On 6 February 2008, Mr McCarthy applied to his then employer, Jetstar to continue his employment on a casual basis, having previously been working full time. The request was granted on 1 March 2008, and Mr McCarthy worked casually, averaging about 20 hours a week, until he retired in October 2013. In July 2011, Mr McCarthy was advised by an RSL advocate that he could make a claim for compensation. On 5 August 2011, Mr McCarthy applied to the MRCC for compensation with respect to the meniscal tear in his right knee. His claim was refused by a delegate of the MRCC in a decision dated 5 January 2012, on the basis that the injury did not arise out of, or in the course of, military service. The delegate also stated that the extensive period of time between the alleged original injury and the claim prejudiced the MRCC in its ability to verify the claim. Mr McCarthy applied for a review of this decision. The decision was affirmed by another delegate of the MRCC on 21 March 2012 and, on 23 July 2012, Mr McCarthy applied to the Tribunal for a review of this decision.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Section 9 of the 1930 Act states that the Commonwealth is liable to compensate an individual for personal injury arising out of, or in the course of, his employment by the Commonwealth. Mr McCarthy claims to have experienced two incidents involving injuries to his right knee during service. The question for the Tribunal is whether the right meniscal tear was the result of either of these incidents, being the injury on 18 December 1968 when he was hit on the knee by a hockey stick and the injury sustained on 11 February 1969 when he was running to his cabin in the rain. If the Tribunal decides that Mr McCarthy should be compensated for the injury to his knee, the further question is whether he should also be compensated for osteoarthritis of his knee, the subject of his more recent claim.THE FACTUAL EVIDENCE Mr McCarthy provided statements dated 21 March 2013 and 25 March 2013 and gave oral evidence at the hearing. The Tribunal also had the benefit of Mr McCarthy’s Service Medical Records which were included in the Tribunal documents. Mr McCarthy said he enlisted in the Navy at the age of 15 years and 9 months on 8 July 1967. On 18 December 1968, he was hit on the right knee by a hockey stick while playing hockey during a compulsory sport afternoon on the Base at HMAS Nirimba. He thinks it was this incident which was the starting point of the problems with his knee. Four or five days later, he went on leave, during which he does not recall any problems with his knee until the last day, Sunday 19 January 1969, when at the Hawkesbury River near Windsor he walked backwards and fell into the River, twisting his knee which locked in the water. Mr McCarthy said Naval apprentices were told to get treatment at the time they had a medical problem and so his brother took him to Parramatta Hospital where he was treated as an outpatient and “given the all clear”. That evening, his brother drove him back to the Base and the next day he reported to the Sickness Quarters (the Sick Bay). He recalls having his knee bandaged and being given heat treatment. A Daily Medical Record dated 20 January 1969 completed by Lieutenant L Barnett, a Medical Officer at Nirimba, records a diagnosis of “Effusion R knee” and states that the injury happened when Mr McCarthy was:… walking backwards in water & R knee ‘came out’. Eventually went ‘back in’. No previous trouble. No previous damage. Mr McCarthy’s recollection of exactly what happened 45 years ago is understandably hazy. He said he was one of about 600 apprentices. Normally, he would have been required to attend ‘parade’ and then marched off to class. On 20 January 1969, his knee probably would have been swollen, so he would not have marched but would have attended class. Mr McCarthy thinks his knee “settled down” after the incident on 19 January 1969 although a Daily Medical Report dated 24 January 1969, completed by Lieutenant Barnett, refers to treatment continuing and to Mr McCarthy being excused from marching and doubling and sport. On 28 January 1969, Mr McCarthy was admitted to the Sickness Quarters at Nirimba for “Synovitis right knee” and discharged on 3 February 1969. Mr McCarthy could not recall whether he had further treatment after discharge but, on 7 February 1969, he was reviewed by Lieutenant Barnett who recorded the treatment as increased exercise and ‘IR heat’, noting that Mr McCarthy was excused sport and marching and doubling (Daily Record dated 7 February 1969).

Decision

Reasons for decision

Thus, I regret, as a result of the operation of the law, Mr McCarthy’s claims for compensation cannot succeed and the decisions under review must be affirmed.DECISION The decisions under review are affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established