Platt v Porirua City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV 2012-485-597 [2012] NZHC 2445

BETWEEN  STEPHEN WILLIAM PLATT Plaintiff

ANDPORIRUA CITY COUNCIL First Defendant

ANDKEITH LATIMER Second Defendant

ANDKEITH LATIMER AND CHRISTINE ELIZABETH LATIMER

Third Defendants

ANDBERNARD VINES Fourth Defendant

Hearing:         5 September 2012

Counsel:         M C Josephson with S J Baldwin for Plaintiff

P A Robertson for First Defendant
A V Williamson for Second and Third Defendants
J C Corry for Fourth Defendant

Judgment:      20 September 2012

JUDGMENT OF THE HON JUSTICE KÓS

[1]      To what extent must a plaintiff in a leaky home case particularise his claim?

[2]      Because of the ten-year longstop limitation period,1a modest tsunami of leaky home or building claim filings has occurred recently in the High Court.   Many statements of claim are relatively rudimentary in detailing alleged building defects and the alleged responsibility therefor.  Oftentimes that is because the owners are not

really  sure.    They  know  the  house  leaks.    Some  of  the  manifest  causes  and

1 Building Act 2004, s 393.

PLATT v PORIRUA CITY COUNCIL HC WN CIV 2012-485-597 [20 September 2012]

consequences of the leaks may be visible.  Some others may come to light only after non-destructive testing.  A better picture may be obtained when the plaintiff’s expert has prepared a report.   In the very real tsunami of leaky building problems New Zealand has suffered since the late 1990s,2  the second wave consequent litigation, and  the  subsequent  channelling  of  that  litigation  by  limitation  considerations, building experts are not easy to obtain.  Some plaintiffs are waiting many months to

obtain expert reports.  Even then, without fully destructive testing (which occurs on demolition of defective work and its reconstruction), the exact causes, and their extent, may not be fully apparent.   All of this presents particular difficulties in particularising a claim.

Background

[3]      The plaintiff in this case pleads that he purchased a residential property in Paremata, a seaside suburb north of Wellington, from its original developers in 2003. The statement of claim then pleads:

The dwelling was built with building defects, including, but not limited to, those set out in schedule 1.

[4]      The schedule is a one and a half page document.   It identifies defects in relation to the roof, elevations, window and cladding junctions, ground clearances and ground slope.   It will suffice for present purposes to set out the three defects claimed in relation to the roof:

1.   Inadequate protection of timber framed parapets to roofs exacerbated by lack of adequate falls in places;

2.   Inadequate clearance of parapet cladding to roof membranes and roof flashings;

3.   Poor detailing of profiled metal roofs including but not limited to:

(a)     Lack of turn downs to roofs cladding on small lower roofs on northern and southern elevations;

2      See G McLay “Legal Doctrine, The Leaky Home Crisis, and the Limits of Judicial Lawmaking” in Alexander et al The Leaky Buildings Crisis (Thomson Reuters, Wellington, 2011) at  3–7. As Professor McLay notes, depressingly similar issues had arisen in British Columbia, Canada, earlier in the 1990s.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Platt v Porirua City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 2445
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand was asked to decide how much detail was required in the particulars of a leaky building claim against a council. The plaintiff in this case purchased a residential property in 2003 and alleged that the dwelling was built with defects. The plaintiff sued the council, alleging that it breached its duties in relation to the building consent and inspection regime. The council sought further and better particulars of the plaintiff's claim. The court found that the plaintiff's statement of claim needed to be more particularised in certain respects. Firstly, the statement of claim needed to particularise any objective standards that the plaintiff said formed part of the standards the builder and contractors were required to meet. Secondly, the statement of claim needed to explain adequately how the council was required to ensure compliance with those objective standards. Thirdly, the plaintiff must particularise how the council's non-compliance with the pleaded standards required of it resulted in loss. The court held that particulars relating to the scope of the remedial work and the timing of the construction of the house were not required. The court allowed the application to the extent set out above and directed that the plaintiff file an amended statement of claim by a certain date.