Pure Elite Holdings Limited v Bodco Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND HAMILTON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA KIRIKIRIROA ROHE

CIV-2016-419-261

[2018] NZHC 844

BETWEEN

PURE ELITE HOLDINGS LIMITED

First Plaintiff

AND

PEH NEW ZEALAND LIMITED

Second Plaintiff

AND

EVER HEALTH NEW ZEALAND LIMITED

Third Plaintiff

AND

BODCO LIMITED

First Defendant and First Counterclaim Plaintiff

AND

BRIAN NOEL WAGSTAFF

Second Defendant and Second Counterclaim Plaintiff

AND

RICHARD CHEW YOUNG

Third Defendant and Second Counterclaim Plaintiff

AND

RANDOLPH EDWARD CASIMIR VAN DER BURGH

Fourth Counterclaim Defendant

AND

GEOFFREY IAN POLLARD

Fifth Counterclaim Defendant

Hearing: 19 April 2018

Appearances:

A S Ross QC and C Jiang for the Plaintiffs and the Counterclaim Defendants

S W Hood and E R Anderson for the First Defendant S M Jass for the Second and Third Defendants

Judgment:

30 April 2018

PURE ELITE HOLDINGS LIMITED v PEH NEW ZEALAND LIMITED [2018] NZHC 844 [30 April 2018]

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE SMITH


[1]                  On 19 April 2018, I heard argument on two applications. The first was an application by the first defendant (BODCO) for further particulars of the plaintiffs’ second amended statement of claim dated 12 May 2017 (the Claim). The second was an application by the plaintiffs for particular discovery.

[2]                  The plaintiffs filed an amended discovery application on 17 April 2018, and Mr Hood was not in a position to argue the amended application on 19 April. With the consent of counsel, I heard argument from Mr Ross on the discovery application, and then adjourned the application to allow Mr Hood to make written submissions on it and Mr Ross to make written submissions in reply.

[3]                  I now give judgment on the application by BODCO for further particulars of the Claim.

Background

[4]                  The plaintiffs say that the first plaintiff (Pure Elite) was established in 2012 to pursue opportunities for the sale of New Zealand dairy products to China, including infant milk formula.

[5]                  Pure Elite was interested in acquiring production assets in New Zealand to support what would be a vertically integrated chain, from farm gate through processing, canning and blending plants, to the Chinese market. The products would be distributed through the third plaintiff (Ever Health), with joint venture partners in Hong Kong and China to market and distribute the products.

[6]                  The plaintiffs say that the second defendant, Mr Wagstaff, who was a director of BODCO, approached them in about May 2014 to discuss the creation of an independent supply chain of milk powder products from New Zealand to China. Mr Wagstaff was also a director of Danpac (NZ) Ltd (Danpac), and Danpac owned the

business and assets of a powdered milk canning and blending plant that was then under construction at Te Rapa, Hamilton.

[7]                  Discussions ensued. A central component of the discussions was the capitalization of Danpac, to allow the construction of the plant to be completed and the business to be developed. The Danpac business would provide a necessary component of the vertical integration plan. There were also discussions over raising…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pure Elite Holdings Limited v Bodco Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NZHC 844
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Pure Elite Holdings Limited, PEH New Zealand Limited, and Ever Health New Zealand Limited (collectively referred to as "the plaintiffs") filed a lawsuit against BODCO Limited, Brian Noel Wagstaff, Richard Chew Young, Randolph Edward Casimir Van der Burgh, and Geoffrey Ian Pollard (collectively referred to as "the defendants") in the High Court of New Zealand. The plaintiffs sought damages for alleged breaches of contract, fiduciary obligations, and statutory provisions. The primary dispute centered on a Heads of Agreement (HOA) signed on 24 September 2014, which outlined a business plan for the acquisition and development of a powdered milk canning and blending plant in New Zealand. The plaintiffs claimed that the defendants wrongfully repudiated the HOA and committed breaches that resulted in significant financial losses.

The defendants, through their legal representatives, filed an application for further particulars regarding specific aspects of the plaintiffs' claim. They sought detailed information on the causes of action, the nature of the damages claimed, and the basis for certain valuation figures. The plaintiffs responded to these requests, providing general explanations and offering to supply additional details if necessary.

In considering the application for further particulars, Associate Judge Smith examined the legal principles governing the adequacy of pleadings and the need for particularisation. The judge noted that while pleadings must provide sufficient detail to inform the parties of the claims and defences, they do not require a full disclosure of all evidence. The primary focus was on whether the pleadings adequately outlined the plaintiffs' case and whether the defendants needed more specific information to understand and respond to the claims.

Regarding the plaintiffs' allegation that delays in raising capital due to internal issues at Enertech LLC Limited (a funding party) justified their failure to meet their obligations under the HOA, the judge found that the exact reasons for the delay were not critical to the plaintiffs' case. The plaintiffs did not assert that they had the funds available at any relevant time, and they did not claim that the HOA was frustrated or cancelled due to their inability to raise capital.

As for the plaintiffs' efforts to secure funding from a new cornerstone partner, the judge concluded that the specific details of these efforts were not necessary for the defendants to understand the plaintiffs' case. The plaintiffs' claim was that neither party fulfilled their capital commitments by March 2015, but the HOA remained in effect until May 2017.

Finally, concerning the plaintiffs' valuation of Danpac and the basis for their damages claim, the judge held that while the plaintiffs must provide an estimate and the basis for their valuation, they are not required to disclose the specific methodologies or comparative transactions used by their experts. This information is more appropriately addressed during the evidence stage of the trial.

Based on these considerations, the court dismissed the application for further particulars, finding that the plaintiffs' pleadings, supplemented by their responses, provided sufficient detail for the defendants to understand and respond to the claims. The plaintiffs were awarded costs on a 2B basis, with disbursements to be fixed by the registrar.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established