Body Corporate 160361 v BC 2004 Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2011-404-4890 [2015] NZHC 2979

BETWEEN

BODY CORPORATE 160361

First Plaintiff

BODY CORPORATE 160362
Second Plaintiff

FONG HONG YUEN & ORS Third Plaintiff

AND

BC 2004 LIMITED AND BC 2009
LIMITED
First Defendants

ANDREWS PROPERTY SERVICES LIMITED

Second Defendant

AUCKLAND COUNCIL Third Defendant

Continued…

Hearing:

8 October, 2 November 2015

Further submissions 4 November 2015

Counsel:

G B Lewis and M Greenhalgh for First, Second and Third
Plaintiffs
D A Cowan and J D McBride for Second Defendant (Andrews
Property Services Ltd)
S A Thodey and T C Wood for Third Defendants (Auckland
Council)

Judgment:

27 November 2015

JUDGMENT OF WHATA J [QUANTUM AND COSTS]

This judgment was delivered by Justice Whata on 27 November 2015 at 10.00 a.m., pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date:

BODY CORPORATE 160361 v BC 2004 LIMITED AND BC 2009 LIMITED [2015] NZHC 2979 [27

November 2015]

ANDPBS DISTRIBUTORS LIMITED First Third Party (In Liquidation)

FAÇADE DESIGN SERVICES LIMITED Second Third Party (Discontinued)

RONALD CHARLES HANLEY Third Third Party (Discontinued)

JOHN LUKASZEWICZ Fourth Third Party

Solicitors:

Grimshaw & Co., Auckland

Rainey Law, Auckland Heaney & Partners, Auckland Copy to:

J Lukaszewicz, Blockhouse Bay, Auckland

Introduction

[1]      In my judgment of 31 July 20151  I found that the first, second and third defendants were liable to the plaintiffs in varying respects relating to the negligent installation  of  the  Overclad  rain  shield  system  to  the  Fleetwood  Apartments. Quantum of liability and costs remained to be resolved if they could not be agreed. This judgement is in two parts dealing first with quantum of liability and then costs.

PART 1: QUANTUM Liability findings

[2]      The defendants were found liable in negligence for failing to ensure that the Overclad  was  installed  in  compliance  with  the  Building  Code.2  The liability in respect of each defendant comprises compensatory, consequential and general damages. As to compensatory damages the judgment observes:

[233]    Relevant to both types of measure, the APS tender approved by BC1 anticipated remediation of existing damage and a weather-tight building, but clearly states that the costs of the repair of the exiting damage will be additional  to  the  cost  of  installing  the  Overclad.  BC1  (and  the  existing owners as at 2005/2006) could not have reasonably expected to be put in a situation where the repairs were (or would be) undertaken without incurring the cost of those repairs. Therefore the prima facie measure of their loss is a wasted cost measure as framed by James White (an expert quantity surveyor called by the Council), namely:

(a) The wasted cost of the installation of the Overclad; (b) The cost of the removal of the Overclad;

(c) The increased cost of securing a safe weather-tight building in

2014.

[3]      And further:

[237]    Unfortunately only Mr White assessed the quantum of compensatory damages on the basis of a wasted costs analysis. Ms Thodey also sought leave to provide further submissions and evidence in the event that I get to this…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Body Corporate 160361 v BC 2004 Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 2979
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Body Corporate 160361 v BC 2004 Limited [2015] NZHC 2979 involves a dispute over the negligent installation of an Overclad rain shield system at the Fleetwood Apartments. The plaintiffs, Body Corporate 160361, 160362, and Fong Hong Yuen, sought compensation for the damage caused by the negligent installation. The defendants included BC 2004 Limited, BC 2009 Limited, Andrews Property Services Limited, and Auckland Council. The primary issues revolved around the quantum of liability and the method of calculating damages, particularly whether wasted costs were an appropriate measure. The court found that the defendants were liable for negligence and that the plaintiffs were entitled to wasted costs as damages, plus interest. The defendants contested the application of wasted costs and argued for alternative measures of damages. However, the court upheld the wasted costs methodology, rejecting the defendants' claims of issue estoppel and pleading deficiencies. The court also addressed the issue of increased costs and interest, concluding that the plaintiffs were entitled to interest on wasted costs at the prescribed rate. Finally, the court ruled on the plaintiffs' entitlement to consequential losses and general damages, which were to be calculated based on agreed schedules. In terms of costs, the court assessed the reasonableness of the plaintiffs' costs, determining that certain attendances were appropriately categorized under band C, while others were band B. The court also addressed the issue of increased costs for post-Calderbank offer attendances, awarding a 25% uplift. The plaintiffs were awarded their reasonable costs and disbursements, while Mr. Lukaszewicz, a self-represented plaintiff, was awarded a partial indemnity for professional legal services.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established