Andrews Property Services Ltd v Body Corporate 160361

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA487/2015
[2016] NZCA 644

BETWEEN

ANDREWS PROPERTY SERVICES LIMITED
Appellant

AND

BODY CORPORATE 160361
First Respondent

BODY CORPORATE 160362
Second Respondent

FONG HONG YUEN & OTHERS
Third Respondent

BC 2004 LIMITED AND BC 2009 LIMITED
Fourth Respondent

AUCKLAND COUNCIL
Fifth Respondent

JOHN LUKASZEWICZ
Sixth Respondent

Hearing:

29–30 August 2016

Court:

French, Miller and Brown JJ

Counsel:

J D McBride and D A Cowan for Appellant
G B Lewis and S L Tomlinson for First, Second and Third Respondents
No appearance for Fourth Respondent
S A Thodey and K M Parker for Fifth Respondent
No appearance for Sixth Respondent

Judgment:

22 December 2016 at 2.00 pm

INTERIM JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        The appeal is allowed in part.

BThe finding in the High Court that the appellant was liable for failing to ensure that the building was properly inspected by the fourth respondent is set aside.

CThe judgment entered in the High Court that the appellant is liable to the first, second and third respondents directly for their losses occasioned by the omission to properly inspect the building is set aside.

DThe judgment allocating responsibility for the losses of the first, second and third respondents among the appellant, the fourth respondent and the fifth respondent is set aside.  The issue of contribution among the appellant, fourth and fifth respondents is reserved pending the determination of the cross-appeal.

EThe applications for an extension of time within which to bring the cross‑appeal are granted.

FThe Registrar is directed to arrange a telephone conference with counsel and the Court early in 2017 for the fixing of a timetable for the exchange of written submissions on the issues specified at [154] and a further hearing date.

GAll questions of costs are reserved pending consideration of the cross‑appeal.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Brown J)

Table of Contents

Introduction
Narrative of events relevant to appeal

Moisture damage discovered
The tender documents
The APS tender
The building consent process
Construction and completion
Defective remediation discovered

The High Court judgment

The survey obligation
Affixing of the Eterpan sheets to the Overclad brackets
The APS producer statement

Issues on appeal
Liability for the lack of a survey

Did cl 1.0 require Babbage to undertake a survey?

Was that obligation modified by Babbage?
Was Babbage’s obligation cancelled by the placement of the “Revised” stamp on cl 1.0 in the building consent documentation?
Did Babbage undertake the survey required by cl 1.0?
Did APS have an obligation to be satisfied that a survey had been undertaken by Babbage?

(a)  A pleading issue

(b) The significance of the Building Act 2004 in the judgment

(c) First alternative: the specification incorporates cl 1.0

(d)          Second alternative: cl 1.0 deleted from specification by Council’s     stamp

Conclusion

Liability for screw fixings

Did APS fail to comply with a contractual obligation concerning the method of affixing the Eterpan sheets?
Did APS breach an implied duty to install the Eterpan sheets in a proper workmanlike manner?

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Andrews Property Services Ltd v Body Corporate 160361 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZCA 644
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Andrews Property Services Ltd v Body Corporate 160361, the plaintiff, Andrews Property Services Ltd, was engaged to carry out remediation work on a property managed by the defendant, Body Corporate 160361. The dispute centred around the adequacy of the remediation work carried out by the plaintiff and whether the plaintiff owed a duty of care to the owners of the property to ensure that the remediation work complied with the building code. The case was heard in the High Court of New Zealand.

The legal issues before the court were whether the plaintiff had a duty of care to ensure that the remediation work complied with the building code, and if so, whether the plaintiff had breached that duty by failing to require the architect to undertake a survey. The court also considered whether the plaintiff had a duty to ensure that the remediation work was carried out in a manner that complied with the building code. The court had to determine whether the plaintiff's failure to require the architect to undertake a survey amounted to a breach of the duty of care owed to the owners of the property.

The court held that the plaintiff did not owe a duty of care to the owners of the property to require the architect to undertake a survey. The court found that the plaintiff's contractual obligation was to carry out the remediation work in accordance with the specification and that the plaintiff had fulfilled that obligation. The court also found that the plaintiff did not have a duty to ensure that the remediation work complied with the building code. The court held that the obligation to ensure compliance with the building code lay with the architect and that the plaintiff's duty was limited to carrying out the remediation work in accordance with the specification.

The court's decision was based on the contractual obligations of the parties and the nature of the remediation work. The court held that the plaintiff's duty was limited to carrying out the remediation work in accordance with the specification and that the plaintiff did not have a duty to ensure that the remediation work complied with the building code. The court found that the plaintiff had fulfilled its contractual obligation and had not breached any duty of care owed to the owners of the property. The court held that the obligation to ensure compliance with the building code lay with the architect and that the plaintiff was not responsible for ensuring that the remediation work complied with the building code. The court's decision was based on the contractual obligations of the parties and the nature of the remediation work.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Section 112 provides:112 Alterations to existing buildings(1)A building consent authority must not grant a building consent for the alteration of an existing building, or part of an existing building, unless the building consent authority is satisfied that, after the alteration,—(a)the building will comply, as nearly as is reasonably practicable, with the provisions of the building code that relate to—(i) means of escape from fire; and(ii)access and facilities for persons with disabilities (if this is a requirement in terms of section 118); and(b) the building will,—(i)if it complied with the other provisions of the building code immediately before the building work began, continue to comply with those provisions; or The section has received passing attention in two reported cases. It was included among sections referred to as relevant to the interpretive task in University of Canterbury v Insurance Council of New Zealand Inc.[93]The Supreme Court there noted, without comment, the submission that s 112 does not allow a territorial authority to require that the whole of a building that is being altered be upgraded to meet the current requirements of the building code.[94] In Wheeldon v Body Corporate 342525, in the course of considering a contention that certain repairs amounted to betterment, Muir J rejected as misconceived the proposition that s 112 authorised remediation to an historical and superceded code requirement, stating that s 112 does not detract from the s 17 requirement that all building work must comply with the building code.[95][93]University of Canterbury v Insurance Council of New Zealand Inc [2014] NZSC 193, [2015] 1 NZLR 261 at [36(e)].[94]At [36(e)].[95]Wheeldon v Body Corporate 342525 [2015] NZHC 884, (2015) 16 NZCPR 829 at [160]. In the circumstances of this case, where Babbage was the architect and had assumed the contractual inspection obligation, and where APS was only required to remove any existing damage on receipt of an instruction from Babbage, we do not consider that the obligation on a Council under s 112 is a useful analogy for the duties which APS ought reasonably be required to discharge, particularly having regard to the relative state of building code compliance reflected in s 112(1)(b)(ii). We therefore do not consider that a contractor such as APS, when undertaking a discrete remediation task, has a duty to undertake remedial work outside of its contractual responsibility to ensure that the entirety of a building will be code compliant. Whata J’s second reason for finding that APS owed a duty of care to the owners to require Babbage to undertake a survey proceeded on the hypothesis that his conclusion at [161] was wrong and that cl 1.0 had been deleted from the specification and thus the building consent.[96] He again reached the conclusion that APS fell below the standard required of a competent builder for the purpose of achieving building code compliance by its failure to be satisfied that a survey had been undertaken.[96]High Court judgment, above n 2, at [116].