IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY
I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA ŌTAUTAHI ROHE
CIV-2023-409-42
[2024] NZHC 389
BETWEEN ROSS ARTHUR GRAINGER and VIRGINA KATE LANGMUIR
First Plaintiffs
SHANE CUNNINGHAM COAKLEY and JOANNE ELIZABETH BLAKE
Second Plaintiffs
CHRISTOPHER JOHN ROYDS, as trustee of the MP FAMILY TRUST
Third Plaintiff
IAN HARTLEY DUFF and GLENYS GRACE DUFF
Fourth Plaintiffs
EARLY VALLEY FARM LIMITED
Fifth Plaintiffcontinued….
Hearing: 19 February 2024 Appearances:
F W Rose for Plaintiffs
T C Weston KC and R J H Scott for First Defendant
Judgment:
29 February 2024
JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE LESTER
GRAINGER v ORION NEW ZEALAND LIMITED [2024] NZHC 389 [29 February 2024]
ANDANN LOUISE VAN ASCH, DANIEL GERRIT VAN ASCH and PAUL HENRY
DRURY VAN ASCH, as trustees of the ESTATE OF GD VAN ASCH
Sixth Plaintiffs
AND CORYSTON FARM LIMITED
Seventh Plaintiff
ANDPETER CHRISTOPHER EASTGATE and ROBYN MARGARET JAMIESON, as
trustees of the ESTATE OF HELEN MARY GRAHAM
Eighth Plaintiffs
AND IAN TERENCE FORRESTER
Ninth Plaintiff [Discontinued]
AND LANSDOWNE VALLEY LIMITED
Tenth Plaintiff
AND MCVICAR HOLDINGS LIMITED
Eleventh Plaintiff [Discontinued]
AND AF SCOTT FORESTRY LIMITED
Twelfth Plaintiff (struck out)
AND ORION NEW ZEALAND LIMITED
First Defendant
ANDLEISURE INVESTMENTS NZ LIMITED PARTNERSHIP
Second Defendant
[1] The first defendant applies for further particulars and to strike out part of the third amended statement of claim.1
[2] The plaintiffs allege that Orion New Zealand Limited (Orion) in February 2017 caused a fire on Early Valley Road in the Port Hills of Christchurch, that caused extensive damage. The plaintiffs allege the fire started near Pole reference number AX 728 in Early Valley Road on 13 February 2017. The plaintiffs claim two
1 At the time the application was filed, it concerned the second amended statement of claim. In response, plaintiffs prepared a proposed third amended statement of claim which while not yet filed, counsel agreed would be the subject of the present application. I refer to that draft pleading as the third amended statement of claim.
conductors, that is two power lines, came into contact (clashed) creating an overcurrent event. The fuse located at Pole AX 728 (an explosion drop out (EDO) fuse) operated as a result of the overcurrent event causing (the plaintiffs say) molten metal articles to be ejected. Orion disputes this occurred.
[3] An EDO fuse is designed to operate when there is an overcurrent event. Power lines coming into contact can cause an overcurrent event.
[4] That the fuse failed at Pole AX 728 does not necessarily mean the overcurrent event occurred at that Pole. The overcurrent event could have happened anywhere downstream of Pole AX 728 for a length of three kilometres which involves some 29 spans on the main line. Accordingly, the clash of power lines could have happened at any one of those 29 spans downstream of Pole AX 728.
[5] The plaintiffs position is that although they cannot say at which of those spans the power lines clashed, this does not need to be…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Grainger v Orion New Zealand Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] NZHC 389
- Decision Date