Jarden v Earthquake Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV 2013-409-001332 [2014] NZHC 2406

BETWEEN

DAVID JOHN JARDEN and JOANNE

JARDEN Plaintiffs

AND

THE EARTHQUAKE COMMISSION First Defendant

LUMLEY GENERAL INSURANCE (NZ) LIMITED

Second Defendant

Hearing: (On Papers)

Judgment:

14 October 2014

JUDGMENT OF WHATA J

[1]      The plaintiffs make various claims against the defendants under a policy of insurance in respect of accidental loss to their house caused by the Christchurch earthquakes.   The second defendant, Lumley General Insurance (NZ) Limited (Lumley) seeks further and better particulars in relation to:

(a)       The  identification  of  the  sudden  and  accidental  loss  to  the  house caused by 4 September 2010, 22 February 2011 and 23 December

2011 earthquakes.

(b)      Particulars as to the repair cost. (c)      Particulars as to the rebuild cost.

JARDEN v THE EARTHQUAKE COMMISSION [2014] NZHC 2406 [14 October 2014]

Jurisdiction

[2]      An application for particulars is made under full r 5.21 of the High Court Rules.  This rule provides that a party may require another party to give “any further particular  that  may be  necessary to  give  fair  notice”  of  the  cause  of  action  or particulars required by the High Court Rules.   As essayed by Kos J in   Platt v Porirua City Council,1 the relevant principles are as follows:

[19]      It follows that the extent of particularisation of pleading has changed somewhat over the last 25 years.  But its fundamental function is unaltered. Particulars of pleading are important to:

(a)       inform defendants as to the case they have to meet;

(b)       limit the scope of matters the plaintiff may put in issue at trial (or in pre-trial settlement discussion);

(c)       enable the defendants to know what witnesses it will need to retain and enable them to start preparing evidence ahead of the formal exchange of evidence; and

(d)       provide   an   opportunity   for   a   defendant   to   seek   summary determination on the basis that the claim as pleaded is untenable.

Identification of sudden and accidental loss

[3]      The first amended statement of claim states at paragraph [8]:

8         By earthquakes on 4 September 2010, 22 February 2011 and 23

December 2011 the plaintiffs suffered sudden and accidental loss to the house including inter alia:

(1)      Cracking to concrete slab foundation;

(2)      Differential settlement with a floor level differential of

(a)       House – 26mm; (b)        Garage – 19mm;

(c)       Lounge only – 16mm;

(3)      17% of the house floor area sloping steeper than 1 in 200;

(4)      Noticeable areas of the garage floor are sloping steeper than

1 in 200;

(5)      Internal and external walls out of vertical;

1      Platt v Porirua City Council [2012] NZHC 2445.

(6)      Racking of house framing; (7)     Sagging of ceiling beam; (8) Leaking roof;

(9)      Doors and windows jamming and out of square; (10)        Brick cladding separated from wall studs;

(11)     Cracking to internal wall linings;

(12)     Detachment of wall linings from supporting studs.

[4]     The second defendant seeks the following particulars in relation to this paragraph:

In relation to paragraph 8 of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jarden v Earthquake Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 2406
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand heard a case brought by David John Jarden and Joanne Jarden against the Earthquake Commission and Lumley General Insurance (NZ) Limited. The plaintiffs sought compensation for damages to their house caused by the Christchurch earthquakes in 2010, 2011, and 2012. Lumley sought further particulars regarding the sudden and accidental loss to the house, the repair costs, and the rebuild costs. The court assessed the application for particulars under rule 5.21 of the High Court Rules, which allows a party to request further particulars to provide fair notice of the cause of action. The plaintiffs identified various damages caused by the earthquakes but did not differentiate between the earthquakes. The court found that further particularisation was unnecessary as the defendants could refute the claims based on the information provided. However, the court granted the application for a breakdown of the rebuild costs to provide clarity on the claim and the basis for it. The court convened a conference to discuss the breakdown without affecting the current timetable for a hearing. The costs of this application were reserved.

The primary legal issue in this case was whether the plaintiffs needed to provide further particulars regarding the sudden and accidental loss to their house caused by the earthquakes, the repair costs, and the rebuild costs. The court determined that while the plaintiffs had identified the damages caused by the earthquakes, they did not need to differentiate between the earthquakes as to the nature and type of loss caused by each of those earthquakes. However, the court found that further particularisation was necessary for the rebuild costs to provide clarity on the claim and the basis for it. The court's reasoning was based on the need for fair notice of the cause of action and the importance of particulars of pleading to inform defendants of the case they have to meet, limit the scope of matters the plaintiff may put in issue at trial, enable the defendants to know what witnesses they will need to retain, and provide an opportunity for a defendant to seek summary determination on the basis that the claim as pleaded is untenable.

The court declined the application for further particulars regarding the sudden and accidental loss to the house caused by the earthquakes but granted the application for a breakdown of the rebuild costs. The court found that the breakdown would provide clarity on the claim and the basis for it, which would assist the defendants in properly pleading, including acceptance of any matters alleged. The court convened a conference to discuss the breakdown without affecting the current timetable for a hearing. The costs of this application were reserved.

In summary, the court found that the plaintiffs did not need to provide further particulars regarding the sudden and accidental loss to their house caused by the earthquakes, but they did need to provide a breakdown of the rebuild costs. The court's decision was based on the need for fair notice of the cause of action and the importance of particulars of pleading to inform defendants of the case they have to meet, limit the scope of matters the plaintiff may put in issue at trial, enable the defendants to know what witnesses they will need to retain, and provide an opportunity for a defendant to seek summary determination on the basis that the claim as pleaded is untenable. The court's decision provides clarity on the claim and the basis for it, which will assist the defendants in properly pleading, including acceptance of any matters alleged.