O'Neil v Beattie

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA ŌTAUTAHI ROHE

CIV-2019-409-339

[2022] NZHC 3504

BETWEEN

ANDREW JAMES O’NEIL

First Plaintiff

MOBY TRUSTEES LIMITED
Second Plaintiff

AND

ANDREW ROSS BEATTIE and LOUIS PETRUS DIRKZWAGER

Defendants

Hearing: 9 December 2022

Appearances:

M J Wallace for Plaintiffs

P J Shamy and S B Henry for Defendants

Judgment:

20 December 2022


JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE LESTER


O’NEIL v BEATTIE [2022] NZHC 3504 [20 December 2022]

[1]    This proceeding commenced in 2019. It has already been subject to several interlocutory applications, some of which have progressed to hearing with others withdrawn.

[2]    The judgments record substantial common ground. Notwithstanding that, Messrs Beattie and Dirkzwager seek further and better particulars of the first amended statement of claim seeking, at least in part, details of what in my view was apparently common ground.

[3]    Messrs Beattie and Dirkzwager issued a notice requiring further particulars on 3 June 2022. Many paragraphs of that notice read more as interrogatories than a notice for particulars. Nonetheless, Mr O’Neil provided answers to many of the particulars sought. The answers were not considered satisfactory hence Messrs Beattie and Dirkzwager’s present application. By the time of the hearing, the particulars sought had been narrowed to those in Messrs Beattie and Dirkzwager’s written submissions and it is those particulars only which are addressed in this Judgment.

The history between the parties

[4]    The parties entered into a joint venture, referred to in the amended statement of claim as a joint enterprise, in late 2013 to develop commercial units on what was then bare land. It is common ground the joint venture lasted to the end of 2017. At the heart of this proceeding is whose breach led to the end of joint venture.

[5]    In August 2014, Mr O’Neil made his required cash contribution to the joint venture. He sourced those funds from Moby Trustees Limited (Moby) and thereafter Mr O’Neil made monthly payments to the joint venture also sourced from Moby.     It seems reasonably clear the joint venture was intended to be undertaken through     a company called Hickory Ltd, as it was incorporated on 23 April 2015 with Moby, Mr Beattie and Mr Dirkzwager being directors and equal shareholders.

[6]    The land on which the development was to occur was at Hickory Place, Christchurch and owned by Hickory  Investments  (2013)  Limited  of  which  Messrs Beattie and Dirkzwager were directors and indirectly owners of its shares.

[7]Paragraph [10] of the amended of statement of claim reads:

The parties originally agreed that the Hickory Development would be completed within Hickory Investments (2013) Limited which owned the land but upon completion of the development the land and buildings on Unit numbers 3 to 11 and Lot 100 would be transferred to a new company: Hickory Limited.

[8]    This pleading also appears in the original statement of claim. In the original statement of defence, the pleading is admitted with Messrs Beattie and Dirkzwager going on to say the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read O'Neil v Beattie and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NZHC 3504
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of O'Neil v Beattie before the High Court of New Zealand involved a dispute between the plaintiffs, Andrew James O'Neil and Moby Trustees Limited, and the defendants, Andrew Ross Beattie and Louis Petrus Dirkzwager, over a joint venture to develop commercial units on land owned by Hickory Investments (2013) Limited. The defendants issued a notice requiring further particulars of the first amended statement of claim, arguing that the particulars provided by the plaintiffs were unsatisfactory. The court was required to decide whether the plaintiffs had provided sufficient particulars to inform the defendants of the case they had to meet, as required by High Court Rule 5.26. The court also needed to consider whether the particulars sought by the defendants were necessary to enable them to understand the claim they were facing and to prepare their defence. The court denied most of the requests for particulars, finding that the defendants had a clear understanding of the case they had to meet and that the particulars sought were either unnecessary or had already been addressed in previous pleadings. The court emphasised the importance of providing sufficiently detailed pleadings to inform the opposing party of the case to be met, but also warned against over-pleading that could obscure rather than clarify issues. The court ordered the plaintiffs to file an amended statement of claim by the end of February 2023 and noted that costs submissions could be filed if either party sought costs.