Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei Trust v Attorney-General

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

FOR A COURT READY (FEE REQUIRED) VERSION PLEASE FOLLOW THIS LINK              

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI MANA NUI

 SC 135/2017
 [2018] NZSC 84
BETWEEN

NGĀTI WHĀTUA ŌRĀKEI TRUST
Appellant

AND

ATTORNEY‑GENERAL
First Respondent

NGĀTI PAOA IWI TRUST
Second Respondent

MARUTŪĀHU RŌPŪ LIMITED PARTNERSHIP
Third Respondent

Hearing:

14 and 15 May 2018

Court:

Elias CJ, William Young, O’Regan, Ellen France and Arnold JJ

Counsel:

J E Hodder QC, J W J Graham and R M A Jones for Appellant
D J Goddard QC and D A Ward for First Respondent
P F Majurey for Third Respondent
P A Joseph, T D Smith and R L Goss for Interveners

Judgment:

17 September 2018

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is allowed in part.  The claim is reinstated apart from paragraphs (e) and (f) of the declaratory relief sought. The proceeding is remitted to the High Court for hearing.

BThe first and third respondents must pay the appellant one set of costs of $25,000 plus usual disbursements.  We allow for second counsel.

CThe costs orders in the High Court and Court of Appeal are set aside.  If costs in those Courts cannot be agreed they should be set by the Court of Appeal and High Court respectively in light of this judgment.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS

Para No.
William Young, O’Regan, Ellen France and Arnold JJ [1]
Elias CJ [69]

WILLIAM YOUNG, O’REGAN, ELLEN FRANCE AND ARNOLD JJ
(Given by Ellen France J)


Table of Contents

Para No.
Introduction [1]
Background [5]
  Narrative of events [7]
  The claim [20]
  The judgments in the High Court and the Court of Appeal [30]
The appeal [34]
Discussion [35]
  Some principles [36]
Application of the principles to the present case [50]
Result [67]

Introduction

  1. Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei Trust challenges various decisions on the basis that the Crown breached or will breach its rights in relation to the central Auckland region.  The claim arises in the context of proposed settlements of historical Treaty of Waitangi (Treaty) claims between the Crown and Ngāti Paoa Iwi Trust and between the Crown and Marutūāhu Rōpū Limited Partnership.  It is intended the settlements will be implemented by legislation.

  2. Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei’s claim was struck out in the High Court.  Davison J considered, amongst other matters, that the relief sought directly related to the development of legislative proposals and granting the declarations sought would breach the principle of non-interference by courts in parliamentary proceedings.[1]  The decision to strike out was upheld in the Court of Appeal on the basis the relief sought would comprise an interference with parliamentary proceedings.[2]  Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei was given leave to appeal to this Court on the question of whether the Court of Appeal should have allowed the appeal.[3]  The principal issue for determination on the appeal is whether the claim should be permitted to proceed on the basis that it is properly characterised as a claim for the recognition of various rights rather than as a challenge to the decision to legislate.

    [1]

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei Trust v Attorney-General and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NZSC 84
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei Trust challenged various decisions on the basis that the Crown breached or will breach its rights in relation to the central Auckland region. The claim arose in the context of proposed settlements of historical Treaty of Waitangi claims between the Crown and Ngāti Paoa Iwi Trust and between the Crown and Marutūāhu Rōpū Limited Partnership. Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei’s claim was struck out in the High Court on the basis that the relief sought directly related to the development of legislative proposals and granting the declarations sought would breach the principle of non-interference by courts in parliamentary proceedings. The decision to strike out was upheld in the Court of Appeal on the basis that the relief sought would comprise an interference with parliamentary proceedings. The appeal to the Supreme Court was allowed in part, and the claim was reinstated apart from paragraphs (e) and (f) of the declaratory relief sought. The proceeding was remitted to the High Court for hearing. The Court held that Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei should be permitted to pursue its claim for declarations as to its rights, but it could not ask the Court to declare that the proposed decisions to legislate to implement the settlement with Ngāti Paoa and with Marutūāhu were invalid. The Court found that the claim was not an impermissible interference with parliamentary proceedings.

Background

Background to the litigation

Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei Trust is an entity representing the Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei iwi, asserting rights to land and interests in the central Auckland region of New Zealand. The Trust claims that the Crown (government) has breached its rights and obligations under the Treaty of Waitangi by proposing to transfer certain Crown-owned properties in central Auckland to other iwi (tribes) as part of Treaty settlements. Specifically, the Crown intended to transfer properties to Ngāti Paoa Iwi Trust and Marutūāhu Rōpū Limited Partnership. The Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei Trust filed a claim for judicial review and declaratory relief, asserting that the Crown's actions were inconsistent with its obligations under the Treaty and customary law (tikanga). The High Court struck out the claim, and the Court of Appeal upheld the strike-out on the basis that the claim amounted to an impermissible interference with parliamentary proceedings due to the proposed legislative implementation of the settlements.

The case began in the High Court, where Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei Trust filed an application for judicial review and declaratory relief against the Crown and other iwi. The High Court struck out the claim on the basis that it was not justiciable and amounted to an impermissible interference with parliamentary proceedings. The Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei Trust appealed to the Court of Appeal, which upheld the strike-out. The Trust then appealed to the Supreme Court of New Zealand, arguing that the Court of Appeal mischaracterised the claim and that the principle of non-interference with parliamentary proceedings did not bar the claim.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Court of Appeal should have allowed the appeal against the strike-out of the claim.
2. Whether the claim should be characterised as a challenge to the legislative proposals or as a claim for the recognition of various rights.
3. Whether the principle of non-interference with parliamentary proceedings bars the claim.
4. Whether the declaratory relief sought by Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei Trust is justiciable and should be permitted to proceed.

Held
1. The Court of Appeal should have allowed the appeal against the strike-out of the claim.
2. The claim should be characterised as a claim for the recognition of various rights rather than as a challenge to the legislative proposals.
3. The principle of non-interference with parliamentary proceedings does not bar the claim.
4. The declaratory relief sought by Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei Trust is justiciable and should be permitted to proceed, except for paragraphs (e) and (f) of the relief sought.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Supreme Court of New Zealand held that the Court of Appeal mischaracterised the claim by Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei Trust. The Court allowed the appeal in part, reinstating the claim for declaratory relief while striking out paragraphs (e) and (f) of the relief sought. The Court found that the claim was not barred by the principle of non-interference with parliamentary proceedings, as it did not seek to prevent parliamentary consideration but rather to determine existing legal rights. The Court emphasised that the courts must remain open to citizens who seek to have their existing legal interests and rights determined, provided they do not seek to preclude parliamentary consideration. The Court observed that the relief sought could have implications for the continuing Treaty relationship between the Crown and Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei Trust, and that the Crown's processes may have been in breach of obligations in law to observe tikanga, the Treaty of Waitangi, and consistently with the rights affirmed by the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. The Court allowed the appeal and permitted the claim to proceed with the exception of paragraphs (e) and (f) of the relief sought.