IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY
I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WHANGANUI-A-TARA ROHE
CIV 2021-485-341
[2022] NZHC 3064
UNDER the Judicial Review Procedure Act 2016 and Part 30 of the High Court Rules 2016 IN THE MATTER OF
an application for judicial review
BETWEEN
LAWYERS FOR CLIMATE ACTION NZ INCORPORATED
Applicant
AND
THE CLIMATE CHANGE COMMISSION
First Respondent
MINISTER FOR CLIMATE CHANGE
Second Respondent
Hearing: 28 February 2022 – 4 March 2022 (further submissions received
18, 19 and 22 August 2022)
Counsel:
J S Cooper KC, J D Every-Palmer KC and S T Coupe (via VMR) for Applicant
V E Casey KC, S A H Bishop (via VMR) and H M L Farquhar for First Respondent
A L Martin, P H Higbee (via VMR in part) and H T N Fong (via VMR) for Second Respondent
Judgment:
23 November 2022
JUDGMENT OF MALLON J
Table of contents
Introduction [1]
The parties [12]
The Commission [12]
The Minister [16]
LCANZ [17]
Context, and international and domestic framework [18]
LAWYERS FOR CLIMATE ACTION NZ INCORPORATED v THE CLIMATE CHANGE COMMISSION [2022] NZHC 3064 [23 November 2022]
Context [18]
International instruments [21]
Domestic legislation [37]
Preliminary issues [56]
Court’s jurisdiction to review the Commission’s advice [56]
Deference and intensity of review [69]
Evidence [77]
First ground of review: error of logic [81]
Introduction [81]
NDC Advice [87]
Commission’s reasoning [92]
The Commission’s calculations [100]
The alleged logical error and its impact [107]
Assessment [110]
Second ground of review: misapplication of statutory purpose and criteria [129]
Introduction [129]
The Budgets Advice [133]
The Minister’s decision [139]
Statutory provisions [141]
Statutory interpretation: two purposes? [148]
Statutory interpretation: what does “contribute to” mean? [155]
Statutory interpretation: a “bottom line” purpose? [167]
Did the Commission correctly interpret its task? [172]
Misinterpretation of criteria? [186]
Conclusion [191]
Third ground of review: was MAB accounting permissible? [192]
Introduction [192]
Climate change accounting and trees [196]
The Commission’s advice [199]
The Minister’s decision [216]
Statutory provisions [218]
The issue [229]
The New Zealand Greenhouse Gas Inventory [231]
Legislative history [242]
What is covered by “the rules”? [256]
Henry VIII clause [262]
Conclusion [274]
Fourth ground of review: unreasonable [275]
Introduction [275]
Preliminary issues [282]
What is the NDC in net:net terms using GHGI [284]
What are the budgets in net:net using GHGI [286]
Commission’s justification [291]
Is this consistent with contributing to the global 1.5˚C goal? [306]
Sufficiently ambitious? [308]
Unreasonable not to do more? [311]
Result [314]
Introduction
[1] In response to the climate change emergency, Parliament enacted legislation aimed at enabling Aotearoa New Zealand to develop and implement policies that would contribute to the global effort to limit the global average temperature increase to 1.5˚C above pre-industrial levels and meet its international obligations.1 Among other things, this legislation set greenhouse gas emissions targets for 2050 (the 2050 Target), including that New Zealand’s net emissions of greenhouse gases, other than biogenic methane, would be zero by 2050.2
[2] It also established the Climate…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Lawyers for Climate Action NZ Inc v Climate Change Commissio... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] NZHC 3064
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Commission had been established by statute to provide independent advice on mitigating climate change and adapting to its effects. The advice in question concerned the level of New Zealand's international commitment to reducing greenhouse gas emissions by 2030 and the budgets for domestic emissions of all greenhouse gases for consecutive periods from 2022 onwards. LCANZ argued that the Commission had made errors in its advice, which would result in emissions increasing over the next decade and be inconsistent with reductions necessary between 2010 and 2030 for the global 1.5°C effort.
The court found that the Commission's advice was not based on a logical error, as it had not intended to make a direct mathematical comparison between New Zealand's emissions and the global pathways. Instead, the Commission had used the global pathways as an indirect comparator, incorporating value judgments about New Zealand's contribution to the global 1.5°C effort. The court also found that the Commission had not misinterpreted the statutory purpose and criteria in preparing its advice, and that its recommended accounting methodology was permissible under the legislation.
Finally, the court concluded that the Commission's advice was not unreasonable, as it had considered a range of relevant factors, including New Zealand's particular circumstances as a developed country with significant commercial forestry. The court found that the Commission's reasoning and the material on which it was based justified its advice, and that the Commission had not acted irrationally or unreasonably in preparing its advice. The court dismissed the judicial review application and noted that challenge and debate can lead to better outcomes and provide legitimacy to the Commission's work.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi