Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei Trust v Attorney-General

Link copied
Case Copied 55 min read

FOR A COURT READY (FEE REQUIRED) VERSION PLEASE FOLLOW THIS LINK

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA122/2017
[2017] NZCA 554

BETWEEN

NGĀTI WHĀTUA ŌRĀKEI TRUST
Appellant

AND

ATTORNEY-GENERAL
First Respondent

NGĀTI PAOA IWI TRUST
Second Respondent

MARUTŪĀHU RŌPŪ LIMITED PARTNERSHIP
Third Respondent

Hearing:

7 and 8 June 2017

Court:

Kós P, Cooper and Asher JJ

Counsel:

J E Hodder QC and JWJ Graham for Appellant
D A Ward and C C McKay for First Respondent
D J Goddard QC and L Theron for Second Respondent
P F Majurey for Third Respondent

Judgment:

4 December 2017 at 10.30 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe third respondent’s application to adduce further evidence is granted.

BThe appeal is dismissed.

CThe appellant must pay each of the respondents costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.  We certify for two counsel.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Cooper J)

Table of Contents

Para No
Introduction  [1]
Narrative  [5]
The challenged decisions  [36]
     The revised Ngāti Paoa decision  [37]
     The Marutūāhu decision  [43]
     The Minister’s approach  [49]
The claims in the High Court  [55]
The appeal  [65]
     Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei’s submissions  [65]
     The respondents’ submissions  [70]
Analysis  [75]
Approach  [75]
     Mana whenua  [77]
     Justiciability and comity  [85]
Result  [108]

Introduction

  1. The Minister for Treaty of Waitangi Negotiations has proposed that land in central Auckland be offered to Ngāti Paoa (represented in this proceeding by the Ngāti Paoa Iwi Trust) and Marutūāhu (represented in this proceeding by the Marutūāhu Rōpū limited partnership) in partial settlement of claims for historic breaches of the Treaty of Waitangi.  The proposals are in the course of documentation.  A deed of settlement with Ngāti Paoa has been initialled and is in the process of ratification.  A similar process is being followed with respect to Marutūāhu.  The land will not be transferred unless legislation is passed that authorises that to occur.

  2. The land is located in areas over which Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei claims to have mana whenua.  The Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei Trust commenced a proceeding in the High Court contending the transfer of the properties would breach obligations owed to it by the Crown and that it would unjustifiably erode its mana whenua.[1]  It sought extensive declaratory relief.

    [1]We refer to Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei to embrace both the iwi and the Trust or other entities associated with it. 

  3. The respondents, defendants in the High Court, applied to strike out the claim.  The application to strike out was advanced on two grounds: first, that the Crown had made policy decisions that the land should be offered as components of the settlement of Treaty claims, but does not intend to transfer the properties until the transfers are authorised by legislation; and second, that the policy decisions are not amenable to judicial review.  It was said that in these circumstances the claim disclosed no reasonable cause of action, could not succeed and was frivolous or vexatious.

  4. The High Court granted the strike out application.[2]  This is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei Trust v Attorney-General and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZCA 554
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei Trust v Attorney-General involves a dispute between Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei Trust and the Attorney-General regarding decisions made by the Minister for Treaty of Waitangi Negotiations. Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei Trust sought judicial review of two decisions made by the Minister: the first related to the offer of 136 Dominion Road and 71 Grafton Road landbank properties to Ngāti Paoa, and the second concerned the offer of properties as redress to the Marutūāhu Collective. The High Court of New Zealand was tasked with determining whether the Minister's decisions were legally sound and if the process followed was appropriate.

The primary legal issue was whether the Minister's decisions were irrational or unlawful, particularly in light of the principles of the Treaty of Waitangi and the process for negotiating Treaty settlement redress. The Court examined whether the Minister appropriately considered the interests of Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei and whether the decisions were made in accordance with the law. The Court also looked into whether the Minister had given proper weight to the submissions made by Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei and if the decisions were based on relevant and sufficient evidence.

The Court found that the Minister's decisions were not irrational or unlawful. The Court held that the Minister had considered the submissions made by Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei and had provided adequate reasons for his decisions. The Court also found that the process followed by the Minister was appropriate and that he had not breached any legal principles. The Court concluded that the decisions were based on relevant and sufficient evidence and that the Minister had acted within his powers.

The Court dismissed the application for judicial review, holding that the Minister's decisions were lawful and that the process followed was appropriate. The Court found that Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei had not established any grounds for the Court to intervene in the Minister's decisions. The Court emphasised that the decisions related to the offer of redress and that it was up to the iwi to decide whether to accept the offers. The Court found that the Minister had appropriately considered the interests of Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei and had acted in accordance with the law.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The letter of 8 July 2016, addressed to the Chair and Deputy Chair of Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei Trust was in the following terms:Final decision in regards to the offer of 136 Dominion Road and 71 Grafton Road landbank properties for Ngāti PaoaOn 17 August 2015 I wrote to you with my preliminary decision on overlapping claims between Ngāti Paoa and Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei in relation to the Crown’s redress offer of 136 Dominion Road and 71 Grafton Road landbank properties (the properties) to Ngāti Paoa.You raised several concerns with me and I provided you with two weeks up to 31 August 2015 to provide me with more information to consider for my final decision.On 26 August 2015 your counsel filed papers in the Auckland High Court in relation to the Crown’s process for negotiating Treaty settlement redress in Tāmaki in particular in relation to overlapping claims.On 21 May 2016 I revised my preliminary decision. I decided the Crown would not sell the properties. Rather, it would be for Parliament to authorise any transfer and proposed that settlement legislation would provide that Ngāti Paoa be given a right to purchase the properties at settlement date. Given the properties will not be alienated from the Crown prior to settlement date and unless Parliament permits it, I consider I am able to proceed to a final decision on the revised redress proposal. I note the final decision relates simply to the offer of redress: Ngāti Paoa may or may not accept.I have decided that there are no overlapping claims that prevent further work on reaching an agreement with Ngāti Paoa, to be implemented by legislation. I intend proposing that settlement legislation would constitute a right to purchase the properties at settlement date. I have instructed officials to continue negotiations with Ngāti Paoa and to continue parallel drafting of legislation. It should be emphasised that the revised decision communicated in the letter of 8 July 2016 meant that the properties would not be transferred to Ngāti Paoa unless and until legislation was passed. It was no longer a proposal to transfer the properties by means of what was effectively an agreement for sale and purchase. Instead, legislation would be introduced that, if passed, would confer a right to purchase. Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei commenced judicial review proceedings of the Minister’s preliminary decision in mid-2015, which was the genesis of the proceeding now before this Court. The second impugned decision was contained in a letter dated 13 May 2016, again addressed to the Chair and Deputy Chair of the Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei Trust. In that letter the Minister recorded a final decision to make offers in respect of named properties as redress to the Marutūāhu Collective. Once again, the decision was made following earlier discussions, and there was a preliminary decision by the Minister (communicated by letter dated 22 April 2016) to make a redress offer of one cultural redress property and the opportunity to purchase up to nine commercial properties in Tāmaki Makaurau for the Marutūāhu Collective. In the letter of 22 April 2016 to representatives of Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei the Minister wrote:You have raised several concerns with me and my officials in relation to the provision of redress for other iwi within your core area of interest. I understand your concerns to be primarily about the 2006 Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei Agreement in Principle exclusive Right of First Refusal Area (the “2006 proposed RFR area”) and the Crown’s application of the “layers of interest” concept as referenced in the 2007 Tāmaki Makaurau Settlement Process Report.The “2006 proposed RFR area” referred to was rescinded during the Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei settlement negotiations and after consideration of the Waitangi Tribunal’s 2007 Tāmaki Makaurau Settlement Process Report.The 2006 proposed RFR area was not included in the 2010 Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei refined Agreement in Principle[[12]] or the 2011 Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei Deed of Settlement.The crown has not recognised an exclusive area of interest for Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei and has never given undertakings that redress would not be provided to other iwi in this area. [12]We take the reference to the “2010 Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei refined Agreement in Principle” as being a reference to what we have referred to above as the Supplementary Agreement (footnote added).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established